Shane's Legal Battle With Chuck E. Cheese

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson, in which he discussed the theory that Chuck E. Cheese recycled leftover pizza slices from customers to create new pizzas. Dawson's video sparked a lot of attention and caused Chuck E. Cheese to release an official statement denying the claims. Despite the franchise's denial, Dawson's video continued to circulate and gained traction online. So, did Chuck E. Cheese sue Shane Dawson? The answer is no. While there were rumours and speculation, Chuck E. Cheese did not take legal action against Dawson.

Shane Dawson's conspiracy theory about Chuck E. Cheese's pizza

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", in which he discussed the theory that Chuck E. Cheese's employees recycle leftover pizza slices from customers' unfinished pizzas to create new pizzas to serve. Dawson and his friends ordered several pizzas from the restaurant and were shocked to find that the pizzas looked misshapen, with the crusts misaligned and failing to form a perfect circle. They also noticed that the pepperonis were not aligned properly.

Dawson took one of the pizzas home and tried to figure out how it had been sliced. He claimed that he "definitely proven" that the pizza halves hadn't been originally together, as he couldn't get a rocker blade to line up with the slices' proportions. He also tried to line up the slices to form a perfect circle and questioned why a piece seemed to be missing.

While Dawson popularized this theory, he didn't create it. As far back as 2009, people were speculating on Yahoo! Answers that the franchise recycled pizzas. However, there was no evidence to support this claim, and the theory was largely forgotten until Dawson's video brought it back into the spotlight.

The conspiracy theory gained so much attention that Chuck E. Cheese was forced to respond. They released an official statement denying the claims and explaining that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough, which means that they're not always perfectly uniform in shape. Additionally, an ex-Chuck E. Cheese employee explained that uneven slices could also be the result of kitchen staff making mistakes during the cutting process. Despite the flaws in Dawson's theory, many people took it as fact, and the franchise received a lot of backlash.

Chuck E. Cheese's official statement denying the claims

Official Statement from Chuck E. Cheese's Regarding Recent Claims

We at Chuck E. Cheese's take the quality of our food and the trust of our customers very seriously. We pride ourselves on being a staple of childhoods and family entertainment for decades. Thus, we want to address the recent claims made by Shane Dawson and clarify that they are unequivocally false.

Our pizzas are made to order with fresh dough prepared in-house by our talented pizza pros. This means that while our pizzas may not always be perfectly uniform in shape, they are delicious and made with care. The variations in the amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings are a result of our handmade process and do not indicate any form of "recycling" as has been falsely claimed.

We understand that the appearance of our pizzas, particularly the crust and toppings, may have sparked questions and concerns. However, we assure you that there is no truth to the conspiracy theory that we take leftover slices from customers' pizzas and combine them to create new ones. This idea is simply preposterous and insulting to our dedicated pizza-making staff.

Furthermore, we would like to address Shane Dawson's video, "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane," which has contributed to the spread of these false claims. In the video, Shane presents "evidence" by showing pictures of our pizzas and pointing out mismatched slices and toppings. We would like to reiterate that the variations in our pizza's appearance are a natural result of our handmade process and do not indicate any improper practices.

We are disappointed that Shane Dawson chose to spread these baseless accusations without verifying the facts. We invite Shane and all our customers to visit our kitchens and see the pizza-making process first-hand. We have nothing to hide and are proud of the fresh, delicious pizzas we serve.

In conclusion, we at Chuck E. Cheese's strongly deny the claims made by Shane Dawson and want to reassure our customers that the quality and freshness of our food are of the utmost importance to us. We welcome you to continue creating memorable experiences and enjoying our unique brand of family entertainment and delicious pizza.

The franchise's $300 million investment in its restaurants

Chuck E. Cheese has been the world's premier family entertainment and dining brand for almost 50 years. The franchise has over 500 locations in 16 countries, including the US, Latin America, Africa, Australia, the Middle East, and Europe. CEC Entertainment, the parent company of Chuck E. Cheese, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2020. However, the company has since made a remarkable comeback, investing over $300 million to reinvent itself and attract a new generation of customers.

The $300 million investment has been used to address the challenges of entertaining children and their parents in an age dominated by technology. CEO Dave McKillips, who joined the company in January 2020, recognised that the brand needed a dramatic makeover. The investment has been used to renovate stores, eliminate animatronics, introduce trampolines, and upgrade the menu with scratch-made pizzas. Additionally, the company has developed a mobile app and invested in marketing and entertainment partnerships with well-known children's brands.

Under McKillips' leadership, the company has focused on active play, introducing kid-sized trampolines to 450 locations, for which customers pay an additional fee. The company has also introduced a subscription program with unlimited visits and discounts, encouraging more frequent visits from families. This program has been well-received, with a significant increase in the number of passes sold in 2024 compared to the previous year.

The investments seem to be paying off, with CEC Entertainment, which includes Pasqually's Pizza & Wings and Peter Piper Pizza, reporting eight consecutive months of same-store sales growth. The company's annual revenue increased from $912 million in 2019 to $1.2 billion in 2023, despite having fewer open locations. Chuck E. Cheese's commitment to innovation and its willingness to invest in its stores have contributed to its success and ability to adapt to the changing preferences of its customers.

The chain's response to the pandemic

The COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns in 2020 posed a challenge to Chuck E. Cheese's business model, which relies on in-person entertainment and dining. In response, the company launched a social media campaign called the "Afternoon Fun Break", featuring special daily videos on its official YouTube channel. Each Friday, Chuck E. Cheese himself hosted a livestream, sometimes joined by his friends. This strategy aimed to maintain engagement with their audience even when physical locations were temporarily closed.

As the pandemic continued, Chuck E. Cheese's parent company, CEC Entertainment, faced financial difficulties. In June 2020, CEC Entertainment filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. The company emerged from bankruptcy months later with new leadership and significantly reduced debt.

The pandemic also accelerated the company's efforts to modernise and adapt to changing consumer preferences. Recognising that children were consuming entertainment in new ways, growing up with screens and bite-sized entertainment, CEO Dave McKillips led an aggressive transformation of the chain. This included phasing out the iconic animatronic band, adding more screens and interactive games, and introducing kid-sized trampolines. These changes aimed to revitalise the brand and appeal to a new generation of children and their parents.

The pandemic also impacted the company's birthday business, one of its best marketing tools. However, as of 2025, this aspect of the business has recovered to pre-pandemic levels.

Overall, the pandemic presented both challenges and opportunities for Chuck E. Cheese. The company responded with creative digital strategies, financial restructuring, and a commitment to modernisation, ultimately emerging from the pandemic with a refreshed brand and increased sales.

The possibility of legal action against Shane Dawson

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", in which he discussed and provided "evidence" for the long-standing conspiracy theory that Chuck E. Cheese recycled leftover pizza slices from customers to create new pizzas. Dawson's video sparked widespread attention and concern, with many social media users taking his theory as fact.

In response to the video, Chuck E. Cheese released an official statement refuting Dawson's claims: "The claims made in this video about Chuck E. Cheese and our pizza are unequivocally false. No conspiracies here—our pizzas are made to order, and we prepare our dough fresh in our restaurant, which means that they're not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious." Additionally, ex-employees of the franchise came forward to explain that the uneven pizza slices could be attributed to mistakes made during the cutting process.

Despite the backlash and refutations, Chuck E. Cheese did not sue Shane Dawson over his conspiracy theory. While there were rumours and speculations about potential legal action, it appears that none was taken. Dawson's video may have been viewed as slanderous and damaging to the reputation of the restaurant chain, but it also brought attention to the restaurant's actual conditions, which may have influenced any decision regarding legal action.

Furthermore, Dawson's video and the subsequent response from Chuck E. Cheese occurred in 2019, and there have been no recent updates or developments indicating that legal action was pursued or is currently underway. Therefore, it is highly unlikely that Chuck E. Cheese will initiate legal proceedings against Shane Dawson at this late stage.

Frequently asked questions