Cheese Whiz In Cheesesteaks: Philly's Iconic Debate Explained

The iconic Philadelphia cheesesteak is a subject of much debate, particularly when it comes to the choice of cheese. One of the most controversial options is Cheese Whiz, a processed cheese sauce that has become synonymous with the city's famous sandwich. While traditionalists argue that provolone or American cheese are the only acceptable choices, many Philadelphians swear by the creamy, tangy flavor that Cheese Whiz adds to the classic combination of thinly sliced steak and sautéed onions on a hoagie roll. The use of Cheese Whiz has sparked passionate discussions among locals and visitors alike, with some considering it an essential component of an authentic cheesesteak experience, while others view it as a sacrilegious deviation from the original recipe. As the debate rages on, one thing is certain: the question of whether cheesesteaks should have Cheese Whiz remains a defining aspect of Philadelphia's culinary identity.

Explore related products

Kraft Cheez Whiz Original Cheese Dip, 15 oz Jar (Pack of 2)

$18.98

Kraft Cheez Whiz Original, 450g/15.9 oz.,Made with Real Cheese (Imported from Canada)

$14.99

Kraft Cheez Whiz 450g - 2 Pack - Original - Made with Real Cheese - Imported from Canada

$26.89

Kraft Cheez Whiz Original Cheese Dip, 15 oz Jar

$31.99

Whiz Original Cheese Dip, 15 oz Jar (Pack of 6) L8

$44.99

Original Philly Cheesesteak Value Seasoned Beef Sandwich Slices, 4 Ounce -- 40 per case.

$112.83

Origin of Cheese Whiz: Introduced in 1952, Cheese Whiz became a Philly cheesesteak staple

Cheese Whiz, a processed cheese product introduced in 1952 by Kraft, quickly found its way into the hearts—and sandwiches—of Philadelphians. Its smooth, spreadable texture and tangy flavor made it an ideal companion to the thinly sliced steak and soft rolls that define the Philly cheesesteak. While purists might argue for provolone or American cheese, Cheese Whiz’s convenience and unique taste cemented its status as a staple in many cheesesteak shops. This section explores how a mid-century innovation became inseparable from one of America’s most iconic sandwiches.

To understand Cheese Whiz’s role in the cheesesteak, consider its practical advantages. Unlike sliced cheese, which requires melting, Cheese Whiz comes pre-emulsified, allowing it to blend seamlessly with hot steak and onions. This efficiency made it a favorite among fast-paced sandwich shops like Pat’s King of Steaks and Geno’s Steaks, where speed is as crucial as flavor. For home cooks, using Cheese Whiz simplifies the process: heat ½ cup in a microwave for 30 seconds, then drizzle over the steak for an authentic Philly experience.

From a cultural standpoint, Cheese Whiz’s adoption reflects Philadelphia’s embrace of innovation in its culinary traditions. The 1950s were a time of experimentation with convenience foods, and Cheese Whiz fit the era’s spirit. Its association with the cheesesteak grew as tourists and locals alike sought the “Whiz wit” option—a cheesesteak with Cheese Whiz and onions. This pairing became a badge of authenticity, distinguishing Philly’s sandwich from imitators in other cities.

However, the use of Cheese Whiz isn’t without controversy. Critics argue it’s too processed for a dish rooted in simplicity. Yet, its enduring popularity suggests that for many, the cheesesteak’s soul lies in its ability to adapt. When ordering, specify “Whiz wit” or “Whiz wit-out” depending on your onion preference, and don’t be afraid to ask for extra—most shops are generous with the portion. For a DIY version, pair Cheese Whiz with thinly sliced ribeye and a soft Amoroso roll for maximum authenticity.

In conclusion, Cheese Whiz’s journey from 1952 novelty to cheesesteak essential is a testament to its versatility and Philadelphia’s culinary pragmatism. Whether you view it as a shortcut or a tradition, its role in the cheesesteak’s evolution is undeniable. Next time you debate the cheese choice, remember: in Philly, Whiz isn’t just an option—it’s history on a roll.

Traditional Cheese Options: Provolone and American cheese are classic alternatives to Cheese Whiz

While Cheese Whiz is a popular and iconic choice for cheesesteaks, particularly in Philadelphia, traditionalists often opt for provolone or American cheese. These two cheeses offer distinct flavors and textures that complement the steak without overwhelming it. Provolone, with its sharp and slightly smoky taste, adds a sophisticated edge to the sandwich, especially when melted to a gooey consistency. American cheese, on the other hand, provides a creamy, mild flavor that blends seamlessly with the meat, ensuring every bite is smooth and cohesive. Both options are deeply rooted in the history of the cheesesteak, predating the rise of Cheese Whiz as a go-to topping.

Choosing between provolone and American cheese depends on personal preference and the desired outcome. For a bolder, more complex flavor profile, provolone is the way to go. It pairs exceptionally well with additional toppings like sautéed onions or peppers, enhancing the overall depth of the sandwich. American cheese, however, is ideal for those who prefer a simpler, more straightforward taste. Its meltability is unmatched, ensuring even distribution throughout the sandwich. To achieve the perfect melt, add the cheese to the steak while it’s still on the griddle, allowing it to blend with the meat’s juices for maximum flavor integration.

Incorporating these traditional cheeses into your cheesesteak requires attention to technique. Provolone should be thinly sliced or grated to ensure even melting, as thicker pieces may remain rubbery. American cheese, typically sold in singles, should be torn into smaller pieces and scattered over the steak for uniform coverage. Both cheeses benefit from being added toward the end of the cooking process to prevent overcooking or burning. For a crispy exterior, consider toasting the roll separately before assembling the sandwich.

While Cheese Whiz has its place in cheesesteak culture, provolone and American cheese offer a nod to tradition and a chance to customize the sandwich to individual tastes. Provolone appeals to those seeking a sharper, more pronounced cheese flavor, while American cheese caters to lovers of classic, comforting simplicity. Experimenting with these options allows you to appreciate the versatility of the cheesesteak and discover which cheese truly elevates the experience for you. Whether you’re a purist or a newcomer, these traditional choices are worth exploring.

Regional Preferences: Cheese Whiz is more popular in tourist areas than among locals

Cheese Whiz on a cheesesteak is a polarizing choice, and its popularity varies dramatically depending on who you ask and where you are. In Philadelphia, the birthplace of the cheesesteak, locals often scoff at the idea of using Cheese Whiz, favoring provolone or American cheese instead. Yet, in tourist-heavy areas like South Street or near Pat’s and Geno’s, Cheese Whiz is a common order. This discrepancy isn’t just anecdotal—it’s a trend rooted in cultural expectations and marketing strategies. Tourists, unfamiliar with local preferences, often default to Cheese Whiz because it’s prominently advertised and associated with the "classic" cheesesteak experience they’ve seen in media or guides.

To understand this divide, consider the role of visual appeal. Cheese Whiz, with its bright yellow color and smooth texture, photographs well, making it a favorite for social media posts and food blogs. For tourists seeking Instagram-worthy meals, Cheese Whiz checks the box. Locals, however, prioritize flavor and tradition. Provolone, for instance, offers a sharper taste that complements the meat, while American cheese melts seamlessly, creating a cohesive bite. Cheese Whiz, while creamy, can overpower the steak’s flavor, which is why it’s often viewed as a novelty rather than a staple.

If you’re a tourist looking to order like a local, skip the Cheese Whiz and ask for provolone or American. For a practical tip, specify “provolone with” or “American without” to indicate whether you want onions on your sandwich—a shorthand locals use. If you’re a business owner in a tourist area, consider offering Cheese Whiz as an option but educate your customers on regional preferences. A simple menu note like “Locals prefer provolone or American” can guide visitors toward a more authentic experience while still catering to their expectations.

The takeaway here is that Cheese Whiz isn’t inherently wrong—it’s just context-dependent. In tourist areas, it’s a crowd-pleaser that aligns with outsiders’ perceptions of a cheesesteak. Among locals, it’s often seen as a gimmick. By understanding this dynamic, both visitors and businesses can navigate the cheesesteak landscape more thoughtfully, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied—whether they’re snapping a photo or savoring a bite of tradition.

Explore related products

Cheez Whiz - Pasteurized Process Cheese Spread, 6.5 lb Pouch

$64.19

American Cheese Snack Easy Cheese 8 oz Can- Yellow American Cheese

$6.99

EASY CHEESE Cheddar Cheese Snack, 12 - 8 oz Cans

$66.36

EASY CHEESE American Cheese Snack, 12 - 8 oz Cans

$62.88

Brick - Limburger Cheese 8 oz.

$34.99

Cheese Heads String Cheese, Low-moisture part-skim mozzarella cheese Sticks 1 Pack (1 oz, 48 ct)

$34

Texture and Flavor: Cheese Whiz adds creamy texture and tangy flavor to cheesesteaks

Cheese Whiz, a processed cheese product, has become a divisive yet iconic topping for the classic Philadelphia cheesesteak. Its role in this beloved sandwich goes beyond mere tradition; it’s a textural and flavor powerhouse. When melted over thinly sliced steak and nestled into a soft hoagie roll, Cheese Whiz transforms the sandwich with its signature creamy consistency and tangy, slightly salty kick. This combination not only complements the richness of the meat but also binds the ingredients together, creating a cohesive bite that’s both indulgent and satisfying.

To achieve the perfect balance, consider the application technique. A thin, even layer of Cheese Whiz is ideal—enough to coat the steak without overwhelming it. Overdoing it can lead to a greasy texture, while too little may leave the sandwich dry. For best results, warm the Cheese Whiz slightly before adding it to the sandwich. This ensures it melts smoothly and adheres to the steak, enhancing both texture and flavor. Pro tip: Use approximately 2–3 tablespoons per sandwich, adjusting based on personal preference.

Comparatively, Cheese Whiz stands out from other cheese options like provolone or American cheese. While provolone offers a sharper, more pronounced flavor, and American cheese adds a mild, melty quality, Cheese Whiz brings a unique tanginess and velvety mouthfeel. This makes it a favorite among purists and adventurers alike. Its processed nature also ensures consistency, making it a reliable choice for both home cooks and busy sandwich shops.

For those experimenting with Cheese Whiz, pair it with traditional cheesesteak toppings like sautéed onions and bell peppers to enhance its tangy profile. Avoid adding acidic condiments like ketchup or hot sauce, as they can clash with the cheese’s flavor. Instead, opt for a neutral base, such as a plain hoagie roll, to let the Cheese Whiz shine. This approach highlights its role as both a flavor enhancer and a textural agent, elevating the cheesesteak experience.

In conclusion, Cheese Whiz isn’t just a topping—it’s a game-changer for cheesesteaks. Its creamy texture and tangy flavor create a harmonious blend with the steak, making each bite memorable. By mastering its application and pairing it thoughtfully, you can craft a cheesesteak that’s not only authentic but also uniquely satisfying. Whether you’re a traditionalist or a newcomer, Cheese Whiz proves that sometimes, the boldest choices yield the best results.

Health Considerations: Cheese Whiz is high in sodium and preservatives, raising health concerns

Cheese Whiz, a staple in many cheesesteaks, contains a staggering 420 mg of sodium per 2-tablespoon serving—nearly 18% of the daily recommended intake for adults. This figure escalates quickly when paired with the already sodium-rich components of a cheesesteak, such as cured meats and bread. For individuals with hypertension or those over 50, whose sodium limits are often capped at 1,500 mg daily, a single cheesesteak with Cheese Whiz can push them dangerously close to, or even beyond, this threshold.

Beyond sodium, Cheese Whiz relies on preservatives like sorbic acid and sodium phosphate to extend its shelf life. While these additives are FDA-approved, their long-term effects remain debated. Studies suggest that frequent consumption of phosphates may impair kidney function and accelerate bone density loss, particularly in postmenopausal women and older adults. For those with pre-existing renal conditions, the combination of high sodium and phosphates in Cheese Whiz could exacerbate health risks, making it a less-than-ideal choice for regular consumption.

To mitigate these risks, consider substituting Cheese Whiz with lower-sodium alternatives like provolone or American cheese, which contain roughly 170–200 mg of sodium per ounce. If Cheese Whiz is non-negotiable, limit the portion to 1 tablespoon (210 mg sodium) and pair the sandwich with potassium-rich sides like spinach or sweet potato fries to help balance sodium levels. For children, whose sodium limits range from 1,000–1,500 mg daily depending on age, Cheese Whiz should be reserved for rare treats rather than a regular menu item.

Ultimately, while Cheese Whiz adds unmistakable creaminess to a cheesesteak, its health implications cannot be ignored. Moderation is key—enjoy it sparingly and balance it with mindful dietary choices. For those with specific health concerns, consulting a dietitian to tailor cheese alternatives can ensure the indulgence doesn’t come at the expense of well-being.

Frequently asked questions