Mastering The Secret Menu: Ordering Perfect Cheese Fries At In-N-Out

Ordering cheese fries at In-N-Out is a delicious secret menu hack that every fan should know. While not officially listed, you can easily customize your order to create this cheesy, savory treat. Simply ask for an order of fries, specify Animal Style for a flavorful topping of grilled onions, special sauce, and melted cheese, or request with cheese for a simpler, gooey layer of melted cheddar. The key is to be clear and specific with your request, as In-N-Out’s menu is famously customizable. Whether you’re a seasoned In-N-Out enthusiast or a first-timer, mastering this off-menu item is a must for anyone craving a decadent side dish.

Explore related products

The Ins-N-Outs of In-N-Out Burger: The Inside Story of California's First Drive-Through and How it Became a Beloved Cultural Icon

$11.76 $29.99

in-N-Out Burger Sticker - Graphic for Water Bottles, Laptops, Phones, Bumpers, Windows, Lockers

$4.23

in N Out Burger Golf Club Cover, White and Red

$39.98

in-N-Out Burger Patch OCP - Funny Tactical Military Morale Embroidered Patch Hook Fastener Backing(Camouflage)

$12.95

in n Out Funny Burger Black Casual Crew Neck Short Sleeve Soft Men's T-Shirt

$14.99 $17.88

in-n-Out Burger Notebook: 110 Pages 6 x 9 inches College Ruled Journal

$6.95

Choose Size: Decide between regular or large cheese fries based on your hunger level

At In-N-Out, the first step to ordering cheese fries is deciding on the size. This choice hinges on your current hunger level and how much you plan to share (or not). The regular size is perfect for a solo snack or a light side, offering a satisfying portion without overwhelming your appetite. If you’re ravenous or dining with others, the large size doubles the quantity, ensuring no one leaves the table unsatisfied.

Consider this: a regular order typically includes about 4 ounces of fries, while the large bumps it up to 8 ounces. Pair that with melted cheese, and the calorie count jumps from roughly 500 to 1,000 calories. If you’re watching your intake but still want to indulge, the regular size lets you enjoy the flavor without overdoing it. However, if you’re fueling up for a long day or treating yourself after a workout, the large size provides the energy boost you need.

For practical tips, think about your meal context. Are you ordering post-gym? Go large. Grabbing a quick bite between errands? Regular will suffice. If you’re dining with kids, a large can be split into smaller portions, making it a cost-effective family option. Pro tip: if you’re unsure, start with a regular and add a side of fries if needed—In-N-Out’s flexibility allows for customization.

The decision between regular and large cheese fries isn’t just about quantity; it’s about aligning your order with your immediate needs. A regular size is ideal for moderation, while a large is better for indulgence or sharing. By assessing your hunger level and situation, you ensure your order hits the spot without leaving you with leftovers or regrets.

Finally, remember that In-N-Out’s cheese fries are deceptively filling due to the rich, melted cheese. Even the regular size can feel substantial, especially when paired with a burger or drink. If you’re a first-timer, start small and gauge your satisfaction before committing to a larger portion. This approach ensures you enjoy every bite without overloading your system.

Add Extras: Customize with grilled onions, whole grilled onions, or chopped chiles

At In-N-Out, the secret to elevating your cheese fries lies in the "Add Extras" options, particularly grilled onions, whole grilled onions, or chopped chiles. These toppings aren’t just afterthoughts—they’re transformative. Grilled onions, whether finely chopped or left whole, caramelize during cooking, adding a sweet, smoky depth that contrasts the sharp cheddar cheese. Chopped chiles, on the other hand, introduce a spicy kick that cuts through the richness, creating a dynamic flavor profile. Understanding how each extra interacts with the base ingredients is key to crafting a personalized masterpiece.

To incorporate these extras effectively, follow a simple process. Start by ordering Animal Style fries, which already include grilled onions and cheese, then specify if you want whole grilled onions instead of chopped. For chopped chiles, request them as an add-on. Pro tip: ask for the chiles to be added after the fries are assembled to preserve their texture and heat. If you’re unsure about spice tolerance, start with a light sprinkle of chiles and adjust in future orders. This method ensures the extras enhance, not overwhelm, the dish.

Comparing the three options reveals distinct advantages. Chopped grilled onions melt seamlessly into the cheese, creating a cohesive layer of flavor, while whole grilled onions provide textural contrast and a more pronounced onion taste. Chopped chiles are ideal for those seeking a bold, fiery edge, though they may not appeal to heat-sensitive palates. For a balanced approach, combine chopped onions with a modest amount of chiles to marry sweetness and spice. Experimentation is encouraged, as In-N-Out’s flexibility allows for endless customization.

A practical takeaway is to consider the occasion when choosing extras. For a quick, mess-free snack, stick to chopped onions and minimal chiles. If sharing, whole grilled onions and a generous dose of chiles can make the dish more interactive and exciting. Keep in mind that these additions are best enjoyed fresh, as the textures of whole onions and chiles can soften over time. By tailoring your order to the moment, you ensure every bite of your cheese fries is as intentional as it is indulgent.

Specify Cheese: Request extra cheese or light cheese for your preferred meltiness

At In-N-Out, the cheese-to-fry ratio is a delicate balance that can make or break your cheese fries experience. While the standard order provides a classic, evenly coated layer, specifying your cheese preference allows you to customize the meltiness and richness to your taste. Requesting extra cheese amplifies the gooey, indulgent factor, ensuring every fry is generously cloaked in molten cheddar. Conversely, opting for light cheese offers a more subtle, crispier bite, ideal for those who prefer a hint of cheesy flavor without overwhelming the fries.

To achieve your desired meltiness, consider the cheese quantity as a spectrum. Extra cheese typically adds 2-3 additional slices, creating a thick, stretchy layer that pools deliciously at the bottom of the container. This option is perfect for cheese enthusiasts or those sharing a side, as it ensures every fry is thoroughly coated. Light cheese, on the other hand, reduces the standard portion by about half, allowing the natural saltiness and texture of the fries to shine through with just a whisper of cheese.

When ordering, be precise with your request. Say, "Extra cheese on my fries, please," or "Light cheese, if possible," to ensure the kitchen understands your preference. Keep in mind that In-N-Out’s cheese is thinly sliced and melts quickly, so extra cheese will result in a softer, more cohesive mass, while light cheese will leave some fries untouched, creating a mix of cheesy and bare bites. This customization is particularly useful if you’re pairing the fries with a burger or dipping sauces, as it lets you control the overall richness of your meal.

A practical tip: if you’re ordering for a group with varying preferences, consider ordering multiple fries with different cheese specifications. For instance, one extra cheese for the cheese lovers and one light cheese for those who prefer a lighter touch. This way, everyone gets their ideal meltiness without compromise. Remember, In-N-Out’s off-menu items thrive on specificity, so don’t hesitate to tailor your order to perfection.

Explore related products

in-N-Out Burger Patch - Funny Tactical Military Morale Embroidered Patch Hook Fastener Backing

$12.95

in-n-Out : Animal Style Me Decal Sticker - Sticker Graphic - Auto, Wall, Laptop, Cell, Truck Sticker for Windows, Cars, Trucks

$4.11

Inn Out N in again trump T-Shirt

$20

MNIGIU California Canvas Tote Bag - Eco-Friendly Reusable Welcome Bag

$14.89

in-N-Out Burger Sticker Vinyl Bumper Sticker Decal Waterproof 5"

$4.95

in n Out Burger - Sticker - DIe Cut Vinyl - Bright Print Sticker

$3.54

Secret Menu: Ask for Animal Style cheese fries for a savory, saucy twist

In-N-Out's secret menu is a treasure trove of customization, and the Animal Style cheese fries are a must-try for those seeking an indulgent, flavor-packed experience. To unlock this savory delight, simply ask for your cheese fries "Animal Style" when ordering. This off-menu option transforms the classic cheese fries into a decadent treat, loaded with In-N-Out's signature spread, grilled onions, and pickles. The result is a perfect balance of creamy, tangy, and umami flavors that will leave you craving more.

The Art of Customization: Crafting Your Animal Style Cheese Fries

Ordering Animal Style cheese fries is straightforward, but understanding the components is key to appreciating the dish. Start with a bed of crispy, golden fries, then add a generous portion of melted cheese. Next, request the Animal Style toppings: a heaping spoonful of In-N-Out's special spread (a thousand island-like sauce), caramelized grilled onions, and a sprinkle of dill pickles. The spread adds a tangy, slightly sweet note, while the grilled onions provide a savory depth and the pickles offer a crunchy, briny contrast. Be sure to specify the amount of spread and onions to suit your taste – a little goes a long way.

A Sensory Experience: Taste, Texture, and Temperature

Animal Style cheese fries are a sensory extravaganza, with each element contributing to the overall experience. The crispy fries provide a satisfying crunch, while the melted cheese creates a gooey, stretchy texture. The warm, caramelized onions and cool, crunchy pickles add complexity, and the special spread ties everything together with its creamy, tangy flavor. To fully appreciate the dish, consider the temperature contrast between the hot fries and the cool toppings. For optimal enjoyment, consume your Animal Style cheese fries immediately – the crispy fries will soften over time, altering the texture.

Practical Tips for Animal Style Cheese Fries Enthusiasts

When ordering Animal Style cheese fries, keep in mind that this dish is rich and indulgent. Share with a friend or save some for later, as the portion size can be generous. If you're feeling adventurous, pair your cheese fries with an Animal Style burger for the ultimate In-N-Out experience. For those with dietary restrictions, note that the special spread contains mayonnaise and can be omitted or replaced with a different sauce. Lastly, don't be afraid to ask for extra toppings or adjustments – In-N-Out's staff is known for accommodating special requests. By embracing the secret menu and customizing your order, you'll discover a new level of flavor and satisfaction in your In-N-Out cheese fries.

Pair Drinks: Complement your order with a shake, soda, or lemonade for balance

Ordering cheese fries at In-N-Out is an art, but mastering the drink pairing elevates it to a science. The richness of melted cheese and crispy fries demands a beverage that cuts through the indulgence without overwhelming your palate. Enter the shake, soda, or lemonade—each a strategic choice to balance flavor and texture. A shake, creamy and decadent, mirrors the richness of the fries, creating a harmonious duo for those who crave a full-bodied experience. Soda, with its effervescence, acts as a palate cleanser, resetting your taste buds between bites. Lemonade, tangy and refreshing, offers a bright contrast that keeps the meal feeling light. The key is to match the drink’s intensity to your appetite and the occasion.

Consider the shake as the indulgent companion to your cheese fries. In-N-Out’s shakes are thick, creamy, and made with real ice cream, ensuring every sip complements the savory cheese. Opt for a classic chocolate or vanilla shake to enhance the umami flavors, or go bold with strawberry for a fruity twist. However, moderation is crucial—a small shake is often sufficient to avoid overloading your senses. Pairing a shake with cheese fries is ideal for those treating themselves to a hearty, satisfying meal, perhaps after a long day or as a weekend indulgence.

Soda, on the other hand, is the pragmatic choice for those seeking balance without added richness. The carbonation in a cola or root beer helps break down the heaviness of the fries, making each bite feel fresher. For a lighter touch, choose a lemon-up or Sprite, whose crisp acidity can cut through the cheese’s creaminess. Pro tip: order your soda with extra ice to maintain its chill and effervescence throughout your meal. This pairing is perfect for midday meals or when you want to enjoy your cheese fries without feeling weighed down.

Lemonade stands out as the wildcard, offering a zesty alternative to traditional pairings. In-N-Out’s lemonade is freshly made, with a tartness that contrasts beautifully against the salty, cheesy fries. This combination is particularly refreshing on warm days or when you’re craving something vibrant. For an extra kick, ask for a splash of strawberry syrup in your lemonade to add a hint of sweetness. This pairing works best for those who prefer their meals to have a dynamic interplay of flavors, keeping every bite interesting.

Ultimately, the drink you choose to pair with your In-N-Out cheese fries depends on your mood and meal goals. Shakes offer indulgence, sodas provide practicality, and lemonade brings a refreshing twist. Experiment with each to discover your ideal balance—whether you’re aiming for harmony, contrast, or a light finish. Remember, the goal is to enhance your cheese fries experience, not overshadow it. So, sip thoughtfully, savor each bite, and let your drink be the perfect complement to your In-N-Out masterpiece.

Frequently asked questions