
Ordering different cheeses online at Jersey Mike's is a convenient way to customize your favorite subs with ease. Whether you prefer the sharpness of provolone, the creaminess of American, or the boldness of pepper jack, Jersey Mike's offers a variety of cheese options to suit your taste. To order, simply visit their website or mobile app, select your desired sub, and navigate to the customization section where you can choose your preferred cheese. This flexibility ensures that every bite is tailored to your liking, making your Jersey Mike's experience even more enjoyable.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Ordering Platform | Jersey Mike's website or mobile app |
| Customization Option | Cheese selection available during sandwich customization |
| Cheese Options | American, Provolone, Swiss, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Mozzarella, and more |
| Specialty Cheese | Some locations offer premium or seasonal cheese options |
| Substitute Cheese | Can replace default cheese with preferred choice during customization |
| Extra Cheese Option | Available for an additional charge |
| Dietary Restrictions | Vegetarian cheese options available; check for specific dietary needs |
| Online Order Confirmation | Review cheese selection in order summary before checkout |
| In-Store Availability | Cheese options may vary by location; confirm with specific store |
| Delivery/Pickup | Cheese preferences are maintained for both delivery and pickup orders |
| Customer Support | Contact Jersey Mike's support for assistance with cheese customization |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Jersey Mike's Cheese Options: Explore available cheese varieties for subs
- Online Ordering Process: Steps to customize cheese choices on the website
- Popular Cheese Combinations: Best cheese pairings for signature subs
- Special Requests for Cheese: How to add or substitute cheese online
- Cheese Availability by Location: Check if specific cheeses are offered at your store

Jersey Mike's Cheese Options: Explore available cheese varieties for subs
Jersey Mike's offers a surprisingly diverse cheese selection, allowing you to customize your sub beyond the standard American or provolone. While their menu might not explicitly list every option, knowing what's available empowers you to craft a truly personalized sandwich.
Let's delve into the world of Jersey Mike's cheese, exploring varieties, flavor profiles, and pairing suggestions.
Understanding the Basics: Core Cheese Options
Jersey Mike's foundation lies in classic sub cheeses: American, Provolone, and Swiss. American, with its mild, creamy texture, melts beautifully and complements most meats and veggies. Provolone, slightly sharper and firmer, adds a nutty depth to hearty subs like the Italian or Philly Cheesesteak. Swiss, with its distinctive holes and mild, slightly sweet flavor, pairs well with ham, turkey, and lighter toppings.
These core options provide a solid starting point, but the real fun begins when you venture beyond the familiar.
Exploring the Beyond: Specialty Cheeses and Customization
Jersey Mike's often features rotating specialty cheeses, offering seasonal or regional variations. Keep an eye out for options like pepper jack, adding a spicy kick, or cheddar, bringing a sharper, tangier element. Don't be afraid to inquire about current offerings – your local Jersey Mike's might have hidden gems waiting to be discovered. Remember, customization is key. You can request extra cheese, a specific cheese blend, or even a half-and-half combination for a truly unique flavor experience.
For example, try a Philly Cheesesteak with half provolone and half pepper jack for a fiery twist on a classic.
Pairing Cheese with Sub Styles: A Flavor Symphony
The beauty of Jersey Mike's cheese selection lies in its ability to enhance different sub styles. For cold subs like the Turkey and Provolone, a classic pairing like Swiss or American works wonders. For hot subs like the Meatball and Cheese, melted provolone or a blend with mozzarella creates a gooey, satisfying texture. Experiment with bold flavors – pepper jack on a spicy Italian sub or cheddar on a roast beef sub for a richer taste.
Consider the overall flavor profile of your sub and choose a cheese that complements or contrasts it for a harmonious bite.
Pro Tips for Cheese Enthusiasts:
- Don't be shy to ask: Jersey Mike's staff are usually happy to guide you through cheese options and suggest pairings.
- Think beyond the menu: While the menu might not list every cheese, don't hesitate to inquire about availability.
- Experiment with combinations: Don't be afraid to mix and match cheeses for a truly personalized sub.
- Consider melting properties: Some cheeses melt better than others. For a gooey experience, opt for American, provolone, or mozzarella.
By understanding Jersey Mike's cheese options and embracing customization, you can elevate your sub experience from ordinary to extraordinary. So, next time you're craving a Jersey Mike's sub, remember – the cheese is not just a topping, it's an opportunity to create a flavor masterpiece.
Spam, Peas, and Cheese: A Unique Recipe Worth Trying?
You may want to see also

Online Ordering Process: Steps to customize cheese choices on the website
Jersey Mike's online ordering system is designed with customization in mind, allowing you to tailor your sandwich down to the cheese. While their menu highlights classic combinations, the true magic lies in the ability to substitute or add cheeses to suit your taste. This flexibility is a key differentiator, catering to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike.
Understanding this customization process empowers you to craft the perfect sandwich, ensuring every bite is a reflection of your personal preferences.
The process begins with selecting your sandwich base. Whether you're craving a classic Philly cheesesteak or a hearty Italian sub, each option presents a starting point for your cheese customization journey. Once you've chosen your foundation, the "Customize" button becomes your gateway to cheesy possibilities. Here, you'll find a dedicated section for cheese selection, often pre-filled with the standard option for that particular sandwich. This is where your creativity takes center stage.
A simple dropdown menu reveals a variety of cheese options, typically including provolone, American, Swiss, and cheddar. Selecting your desired cheese is as straightforward as clicking on your preferred choice. For those seeking a more decadent experience, the "Extra Cheese" option allows you to double down on your favorite variety.
While the online ordering system is user-friendly, a few considerations can enhance your cheese customization experience. Firstly, be mindful of flavor profiles. Some cheeses, like sharp cheddar, can overpower more delicate ingredients, while others, like Swiss, offer a milder complement. Consider the overall balance of your sandwich when making your selection. Secondly, don't be afraid to experiment. Jersey Mike's encourages customization, so feel free to try unique combinations. Perhaps a provolone and American blend on your turkey sub, or a bold cheddar addition to your veggie delight. Finally, remember that cheese is a key component in binding your sandwich together. Opting for a meltier cheese like American can ensure a cohesive and satisfying bite.
Uncovering the Slice Count: Kraft Singles Cheese Mystery Explained
You may want to see also

Popular Cheese Combinations: Best cheese pairings for signature subs
Jersey Mike's offers a wide array of cheeses, but the magic lies in pairing them to elevate your sub. For instance, combining provolone and American cheese creates a classic, melt-in-your-mouth texture that complements hearty meats like ham or turkey. Provolone adds a sharp, tangy kick, while American contributes creamy richness, balancing the flavors without overpowering the other ingredients. This duo is a go-to for traditionalists seeking a familiar yet satisfying bite.
If you're craving something bolder, try pairing pepper jack with cheddar. Pepper jack’s spicy jalapeño notes and cheddar’s sharp, nutty profile create a dynamic contrast that pairs well with subs like the Italian or Chipotle Cheesesteak. The heat from the pepper jack cuts through the richness of the meats, while the cheddar adds depth. Pro tip: Request this combo on a hot sub to fully melt the cheeses and meld the flavors.
For a more sophisticated twist, consider Swiss and muenster. Swiss brings a mild, nutty flavor and distinctive holes, while muenster adds a buttery, creamy texture. This pairing works exceptionally well on turkey or roast beef subs, enhancing the meats without overwhelming them. It’s a subtle yet elegant choice for those who prefer a lighter cheese profile.
Lastly, don’t overlook the simplicity of a single cheese done right. Sharp provolone, when ordered as the sole cheese, can stand out on subs like the Famous Philly or #7 Turkey and Provolone. Its robust flavor and excellent meltability make it a powerhouse on its own. When ordering, specify “extra provolone” to ensure a generous portion that dominates the flavor profile.
Experimenting with cheese pairings at Jersey Mike's isn't just about taste—it's about enhancing the overall sub experience. Whether you’re mixing or sticking to one, the key is to match the cheese’s intensity with the sub’s ingredients. Next time you order, think beyond your usual and let the cheese be the star.
Cheetos Timeline: Original Cheese vs. Hot Cheetos – Which Came First?
You may want to see also
Explore related products

Special Requests for Cheese: How to add or substitute cheese online
Jersey Mike's online ordering system is designed for efficiency, but it doesn't always explicitly accommodate cheese substitutions or additions. To navigate this, you'll need to leverage the "Special Instructions" field, a powerful tool for communicating your preferences directly to the sandwich artists. Think of it as your direct line to the kitchen, where clarity and specificity reign supreme.
Vague requests like "extra cheese" leave room for interpretation. Instead, be precise: "Please add double provolone to my #7." If you're substituting, clearly state both the cheese to omit and its replacement: "Hold the American cheese on my #13 and add pepper jack instead."
The key to success lies in understanding Jersey Mike's cheese offerings. Their standard options typically include Provolone, American, and Swiss. Some locations may offer specialty cheeses like Pepper Jack or Cheddar, but availability varies. Before placing your order, check the online menu or call your local store to confirm their cheese selection. This ensures your request is feasible and avoids disappointment.
Remember, the "Special Instructions" field is for reasonable requests. Asking for a cheese not typically offered or demanding complex layering techniques might not be possible. Keep it realistic and respectful of the staff's time and resources.
While online ordering streamlines the process, don't hesitate to call the store directly if you have complex cheese requests or want to confirm they can accommodate your preferences. A quick phone call can save time and ensure your sandwich is crafted exactly as you envision it. Ultimately, clear communication is key to getting the cheesy masterpiece you crave.
Substituting Grated Cheese for Block Cheese: Tips and Tricks for Perfect Results
You may want to see also

Cheese Availability by Location: Check if specific cheeses are offered at your store
Jersey Mike's offers a variety of cheeses across its locations, but availability can vary based on regional preferences, supply chain logistics, and store-specific decisions. Before placing an online order, it’s crucial to verify if your desired cheese is offered at your local store. For instance, while provolone is a staple nationwide, options like pepper jack or Swiss may be limited to certain areas. Start by visiting Jersey Mike's official website or app, where the menu often reflects location-specific offerings. Alternatively, a quick call to the store can confirm availability, ensuring your order isn’t delayed or substituted.
Analyzing the discrepancy in cheese availability reveals a strategic approach to catering to local tastes. In the Midwest, for example, cheddar and American cheeses are more prevalent due to their popularity in regional cuisine. Conversely, stores in the Northeast might prioritize provolone and mozzarella to align with the area’s preference for classic Italian-style subs. This localization ensures freshness and customer satisfaction but requires customers to be proactive in checking options. Ignoring this step could lead to disappointment if your chosen cheese isn’t available, forcing you to settle for a less desirable alternative.
To streamline the process, follow these steps: First, enter your location on Jersey Mike's website or app to access the menu for your nearest store. Second, scroll through the cheese options listed under sandwich customizations. If the cheese you want isn’t visible, contact the store directly. Third, consider having a backup choice in mind, especially if you’re ordering during peak hours when substitutions are more likely. For example, if pepper jack isn’t available, smoked cheddar could offer a similar flavor profile.
A practical tip is to use the “special instructions” field during online ordering to specify your cheese preference and indicate flexibility. For instance, write, “Pepper jack if available, otherwise Swiss.” This approach communicates your priorities while giving the store leeway to fulfill your order efficiently. Additionally, signing up for Jersey Mike's email updates can keep you informed about new menu additions or changes in cheese availability at your local store.
In conclusion, while Jersey Mike's strives to offer a consistent experience, cheese availability ultimately depends on your location. By verifying options beforehand and planning alternatives, you can ensure a seamless ordering process. This small step not only saves time but also enhances your overall experience, allowing you to enjoy your sandwich exactly as you envisioned.
Add Applebee's Beer Cheese to Your Grubhub Order: A Tasty Guide
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Yes, you can customize your sub with different cheese options when ordering online. Simply select your desired sub, choose the "Customize" option, and replace or add cheese from the available choices like Provolone, American, Swiss, or others.
To add multiple cheeses, select the "Customize" option for your sub, then choose "Add Extra" under the cheese section. You can select additional cheese types and adjust quantities as needed before finalizing your order.
While most cheese options are available online, some specialty or seasonal cheeses may not be listed. However, the standard options like Provolone, American, Swiss, and others are typically available for customization. Always check the menu for the most up-to-date choices.

























