Feta Cheese: Ethical Or Not?

Feta cheese is a popular ingredient in many dishes, but is the process of making it inhumane? Feta is a soft, white, brined cheese with a tangy flavour and crumbly texture. Traditionally, it is made from a combination of sheep's milk (70%) and goat's milk (30%), although some producers may use cow's milk in varying proportions. The milk is coagulated using enzymes from rennet or lactic acid bacteria, and then cut into cubes, salted, and placed in barrels or containers to age in brine. While feta provides nutritional benefits such as protein, calcium, and B vitamins, the production of dairy products has been criticised for its treatment of animals. Some argue that animals cannot consent to the use of their milk, and that the dairy industry contributes to environmental, health, and economic issues. However, others suggest that cheese can be made in a more humane and sustainable way, such as by rescuing cows from slaughter or dairy farms, or using human breast milk.

Explore related products

CREDO FOODS Oatmilk Queso Blanco, 11 OZ

$6.1 $6.89

Dairyland soft Feta Cheese 1kg

$29.25

Tahsildaroglu 1 Cow's Milk 1 Goat Milk's 1 Sheep's Milk Ezine Feta Cheese (3 pack total 1050gr)

$34.95

NOOCH IT Cashew Parmesan Cheese – 4oz | Dairy-Free, Organic, Fair Trade, Non-GMO, Gluten-Free | Plant-Based Cashew Cheese Topping & Parmesan Substitute for Pasta, Pizza & Popcorn

$11.99

Mizithra Cheese, (1 lb)

$19.99

KRINOS Kefalotyri Cheese 200G Wedge

$38.15

Feta is made from sheep and goat's milk

Feta cheese is a Greek staple, renowned for its tangy flavour and crumbly texture. It is a versatile ingredient that can be used in a variety of dishes, from salads to pastries. But what is it made from?

Feta is traditionally made from a combination of sheep's milk and goat's milk (70% sheep's milk and 30% goat's milk). This blend is considered the standard, and feta made from this blend can bear the Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) label within the European Union. In fact, according to EU legislation, only feta cheese produced in specific areas of Greece using this blend or sheep's milk alone can be labelled as feta. The unique environment and breeds of sheep and goats used for milk give feta its specific aroma and flavour.

The process of making feta involves coagulating the milk, separating the whey from the curds, and then cutting the curds into cubes, salting them, and placing them in barrels or containers. The blocks of cheese are then placed in a salted solution and refrigerated for two months.

While the traditional blend of sheep and goat milk remains the standard, some producers may incorporate cow's milk or use different ratios of sheep and goat milk. However, this variation in production may affect the taste of the cheese.

In summary, feta cheese is traditionally made from a blend of sheep's milk and goat's milk, with a rich history and a distinct flavour profile that has made it a beloved ingredient worldwide.

Animals cannot consent to giving milk

Feta cheese is a soft, white, and brined cheese that originated in Greece. It is traditionally made from sheep's milk (70%) and goat's milk (30%). While some producers may use cow's milk in varying proportions, only feta cheese made from sheep's and goat's milk can be labelled as such in the European Union.

The process of making feta cheese involves pasteurizing the milk, adding lactic acid starter cultures to separate the whey from the curds, and then adding rennet to set the casein. The curd is then cut into cubes, salted, and placed in barrels or containers for a few days. Finally, the cheese is placed in a salted solution and refrigerated for two months before being packaged for distribution.

Now, addressing the topic of animal consent in the context of milk production, it is essential to recognize that animals, including cows, cannot provide verbal or written consent for their milk to be used. While they may exhibit expressive body language and physical cues, the ability to consent implies a level of agency and understanding that is not within the realm of animal communication.

The concept of consent implies a voluntary agreement or permission granted by an individual with full comprehension of the situation at hand. Animals, such as cows, do not possess the cognitive capacity to understand the complexities of the dairy industry or the implications of their milk being consumed by humans. They cannot consent to the use of their milk any more than they can consent to being photographed or having their image captured.

Additionally, it is important to consider the ethical implications of the dairy industry. Dairy cattle are often bred to overproduce milk, and the industry has been associated with environmental, health, and economic concerns. While some may argue for the health benefits of cheese or the expressiveness of animal body language, the fundamental issue of animal consent remains unresolved.

In conclusion, the argument that "animals cannot consent to giving milk" holds weight. The production and consumption of animal milk, including that used in feta cheese, without their consent raises ethical questions about the treatment of animals and the complexities of consent in human-animal interactions.

Dairy contributes to environmental issues

Secondly, dairy farms generate substantial greenhouse gas emissions, primarily through enteric fermentation and manure storage. Methane, a potent greenhouse gas, is released during the digestive process of cows and other dairy animals. In addition, dairy farms produce large amounts of manure, which releases methane and nitrous oxide when stored and managed improperly. These gases have a much higher global warming potential than carbon dioxide, exacerbating climate change.

Moreover, dairy farms consume vast quantities of water, contributing to water scarcity and environmental pollution. Water is used not only for animal drinking but also for cleaning, cooling, and processing milk and other dairy products. The wastewater generated can contain high levels of organic matter, nutrients, and pathogens, leading to water pollution if not properly treated.

The transportation and refrigeration of dairy products also contribute to environmental issues. Dairy products, including cheese, need to be transported and stored under refrigerated conditions, requiring significant energy consumption and contributing to greenhouse gas emissions. Furthermore, the use of fossil fuels in transportation and the release of refrigerant gases from cooling systems further impact climate change and air quality.

Lastly, dairy farms often use intensive farming practices that can have detrimental effects on the environment. The overuse of pesticides and fertilizers in feed crop production can lead to soil degradation, water pollution, and the decline of pollinator populations. In addition, the concentrated animal feeding operations in some dairy farms generate large amounts of waste, increasing the risk of water and soil contamination.

Explore related products

Feta Cheese Culture 5-pack

$13.99

Deli Fresh Barrel-Aged Greek Feta Cheese, approx. 16oz (1lb)

$14.94

Deli Fresh Cream Feta Cheese, approx. 1 lb

$9.19

KRINOS Myzithra 1.3Lb ~

$34.75

Deli Fresh Greek Myzithra Cheese, GRATED, approx. 12 oz (0.75lb)

$22.99

Deli Fresh Greek Myzithra Cheese, approx. 1.1-1.4 lb

$31.99

Ethical cheese would include consent

Feta cheese is a popular ingredient in many dishes, but is it ethical? Feta is traditionally made from sheep's milk or a mixture of sheep and goat's milk, and the process of making this cheese has been a topic of debate among those concerned about animal welfare.

The issue of consent has been raised in the context of cheese production, with some arguing that ethical cheese would include obtaining consent from the animals involved. While animals cannot give verbal or written consent, they can express their desires through body language and physical cues. For example, if a cow does not want something to happen, it will make its discomfort apparent. Unfortunately, some farmers use inhumane methods like electric prodders to force cows to comply with their wishes.

The idea of consent in cheese production highlights the importance of treating animals with respect and ensuring their welfare. It raises questions about the ethics of the dairy industry, where cows are bred to overproduce milk, and the potential for exploitation even in rescue scenarios. However, obtaining consent from animals is not a straightforward concept and may lead to complex issues, especially when considering the potential for human exploitation.

To ensure ethical cheese production, some suggest obtaining milk from consenting individuals. While this could be a solution, it raises concerns about exploitation, especially if it involves individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds. Additionally, the amount of milk produced through such means might not be sufficient for commercial purposes, limiting its feasibility on a large scale.

Ultimately, the concept of "ethical cheese" involving consent is complex and multifaceted. It invites reflection on the treatment of animals in the dairy industry and the potential for exploitation in various contexts. While obtaining consent from animals is challenging, the discussion underscores the importance of exploring alternative solutions that prioritize the well-being of all involved.

Human-made cheese exists

The notion of humane or inhumane cheese production is a topic of discussion among vegans and vegetarians. The argument is centred on the idea of consent, with some arguing that animals cannot consent to giving their milk for cheese production.

While most feta cheese is made from sheep's milk or a blend of sheep and goat's milk, human-made cheese does exist. In 2021, a post on Reddit asked if anyone would consider consuming cheese again if it were made in an ethical manner and was good for one's health. One response mentioned that human-made cheese had been done, linking to an article on the PETA website about breastmilk cheese.

The same Reddit thread also discusses the possibility of obtaining a cow in an ethical way, such as by rescuing one from slaughter or a dairy farm, and using its milk for cheese. However, the commenter points out that such a cow likely wouldn't produce enough milk to make a profit.

Another commenter argues that even ethical dairy production contributes to environmental, health, and economic issues associated with animal agriculture. They suggest that delicious cheese alternatives are available, made with ingredients like chickpeas.

While the idea of human-made cheese may be intriguing or even amusing to some, it is important to note that the practice of making cheese from human breast milk is not widely accepted or practiced. The discussion on Reddit highlights the complexities and varying perspectives surrounding the topic of humane cheese production.

Frequently asked questions