Manchego And Gruyere: Similar Cheeses, Different Origins

Manchego, a Spanish cheese, is one of the most unique cheeses in the world, made from the milk of Manchega sheep. It is adored for its distinct flavour and texture, but there are several other delicious cheeses that can be used as substitutes. One of them is Gruyere, a Swiss-style cheese that is known for its melting properties. So, is Manchego cheese like Gruyere?

Explore related products

El Trigal 6 Month Aged Manchego

$20.99

El Trigal 12 Month Old Manchego

$21.99

Corcuera 3 Month Old Manchego

$18.99

El Trigal 8 Month Manchego

$22.99 $24.99

Emmi Roth, Le Gruyère from Switzerland, 6 oz

$10.99

Manchego Cheese Wheel – Approx. 2 lbs – Spanish Sheep’s Milk Cheese Aged 3 Months – Authentic D.O.P. Product of Spain

$59.99

Taste and texture differences

Gruyere, a Swiss-style cheese, is often suggested as a substitute for Manchego, indicating that the two cheeses share similar characteristics. Both are semi-hard cheeses with a distinctive flavour and texture. However, there are some taste and texture differences between the two.

Manchego is a Spanish cheese made from sheep's milk. It has a Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) status, meaning it must be produced in a specific region of central Spain, using traditional methods. The cheese is aged for varying lengths of time, resulting in different flavour profiles. Young Manchego has a mild, slightly tangy taste, while aged Manchego is richer and more robust, with hints of caramel and nuts. It has a crumbly, granular texture that becomes harder and more crystalline as it ages. The flavours of Manchego sharpen with age, taking on more rounded, toasty nuances.

Gruyere, on the other hand, is an Alpine-style cheese, meaning it is cooked and pressed, resulting in a firm yet pliable texture. It is known for its sweet and nutty flavour, which becomes more pronounced as it melts. Gruyere is a good melting cheese, with younger varieties outperforming aged ones in terms of meltability. It has a smooth, creamy texture that lends itself well to dishes like French onion soup and sandwiches.

While both cheeses share some similarities, such as their semi-hard texture and nutty flavour notes, there are distinct differences. Manchego has a stronger sheep's milk taste, while Gruyere is milder and sweeter. Manchego's texture is more crumbly and granular, especially as it ages, while Gruyere maintains its smooth, creamy mouthfeel.

In summary, while Gruyere can be a suitable substitute for Manchego in certain dishes, they are not exactly the same. The taste and texture differences between the two cheeses are subtle but distinct, with Manchego offering a stronger, more complex flavour and a crumbly, crystalline texture, while Gruyere provides a milder, sweeter flavour and a smooth, creamy melt.

Substitutes for Manchego

Manchego, a Spanish cheese made from sheep's milk, is known for its creamy, buttery texture and slightly tangy and nutty flavour. It is a versatile cheese that can be grated, melted, or sliced. While Manchego is a unique cheese, there are several substitutes that can be used in its place, depending on the desired taste and texture.

Parmesan

Parmesan

Parmigiano-Reggiano, is an Italian cheese made from cow's milk. It has a granular texture and a strong umami flavour. While it has a saltier and more pungent taste than Manchego, it can still be a suitable substitute, especially when grated over pasta dishes.

Iberico

Iberico is a Spanish cheese with a rich, slightly sweet, and nutty flavour. It has a firm and dense texture, similar to Manchego, making it easy to slice or grate. However, Iberico may be more challenging to find and is often pricier than Manchego.

Gruyere

Gruyere is a Swiss cheese with a nutty and savoury taste, similar to Manchego. It melts well, making it a good choice for dishes like grilled cheese sandwiches. While it has a slightly more robust flavour than Manchego, it can still be an excellent substitute in many recipes.

Meseta

Meseta is another Spanish cheese with a similar flavour profile to Manchego. It is typically regarded as a milder version, making it a good option for those who prefer a more subtle taste. However, Meseta may be harder to find depending on your location.

Pecorino

Pecorino is an Italian sheep's milk cheese with a firm texture and a distinct, slightly salty flavour. It is commonly used for grating over pasta dishes or enjoyed on a cheese platter. Pecorino has a more pronounced tangy taste compared to Manchego, adding an Italian twist to your recipe.

Gouda

Gouda is a mild and slightly nutty cheese that can be used interchangeably with Manchego in certain recipes. It works well on its own or melted in various dishes.

Asiago

Asiago has a similar firm, dense texture and tangy flavour to Manchego. It becomes more crumbly with age, making it a good substitute for both young and aged Manchego. Asiago is suitable for various dishes, including pastas, pizzas, salads, and sandwiches.

Cheddar

Cheddar has a creamy texture with crystalline dots, giving it a mouthfeel similar to Manchego. It has a nutty and complex flavour and is a cow's milk cheese. Cheddar is a good substitute for Manchego in dishes like quiches, grilled cheese, casseroles, and quesadillas.

How Manchego is made

Manchego is a hard, buttery Spanish cheese with a silky texture and creamy richness. It is traditionally made from the milk of sheep that graze on the central plateau of Spain, although it can also be made from a mix of goat and ewe's milk, or even from cow's milk. The milk can be pasteurized or unpasteurized, with the raw milk produced on small farms considered artisanal.

To make Manchego, the milk is first allowed to ripen. In the meantime, the moulds and draining surfaces can be sanitized in preparation for the final stages. Once the milk has ripened, liquid rennet is added, and the milk is slowly stirred for 1-2 minutes. The milk then sits quietly for 30 minutes while the culture works and the rennet coagulates the curd. After 15 minutes, the milk should start to thicken, but it is important to wait the full 30 minutes before testing the curd set. The curds are then cut into small pieces, about the size of small maize or barley grains. This is to accommodate the varying degrees of ageing, as Manchego is a very compact cheese. The curds are cut first into 3/4 to 1" sections and allowed to rest for 5 minutes, then reduced to 3/8-1/4". This process is common when working with higher-fat milk to control the loss of butterfat. All stirring should be slow and gentle, just enough to keep the curds separate and moving.

The final stages involve placing the curds into moulds. Traditionally, this would be a plaited strap of 'Esparto' grass, which can be coiled into a round form and tied off for cheeses of varying sizes, leaving the traditional zig-zag pattern on the cheese. More commonly today, plastic moulds are used, designed to imprint this traditional pattern.

The ageing process for Manchego takes place in high-humidity natural caves, for a minimum of 60 days. The cheese can be aged for varying lengths of time, resulting in different flavour profiles. Young Manchego has a mild, slightly tangy taste, while aged Manchego is richer and more robust, with hints of caramel and nuts.

Explore related products

Don Juan, Cheese Manchego 6 Month, 5.3 Ounce

$12.5

Emmi, Raw Kaltbach Cave Aged Gruyere

$29.99

Manchego Cheese Gran Reserva – Aged 18 Months – 2 Wedge Pack (8 oz Each) – Total 1 lb – Spanish Sheep’s Milk Cheese

$33.99

Manchego Aged 6 Months Spanish Cheese - 1 pound

$39

Kaasaggio Robusto Gouda

$19.99

Manchego - Pound Cut (1 pound)

$40.99

How to serve Manchego

Manchego is a popular Spanish cheese with a unique flavour and texture. It is adored for its rich, buttery flavour and crumbly texture. It is typically made from sheep's milk and has a Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) status, meaning it must be produced in a specific region following traditional methods.

When serving Manchego, it is important to note that it has an inedible rind that should be removed before consumption. The best way to store leftover Manchego is to wrap it in parchment paper and seal it with a rubber band or tape, which will keep it fresh for up to two months.

• On a cheese or charcuterie board: Manchego is a perfect addition to any cheese plate or charcuterie board. It pairs well with quince paste, chutney, Marcona almonds, fresh figs, Spanish crackers, green olives, pistachios, and other typical charcuterie ingredients.
• With wine: Manchego and wine make an excellent pairing. Try pairing it with a robust red or dry white wine, or a crisp and fruity sparkling wine like Cava, Trento, or Prosecco.
• In a sandwich: Manchego can be used in sandwiches, such as grilled cheese or a bocadillo. For a unique combination, pair it with crusty sourdough, mayo instead of butter, sliced Granny Smith apples, and a drizzle of honey.
• In quesadillas: Manchego melts well and is commonly used in quesadillas, adding a creamy, salty flavour.
• On bread: Manchego can be enjoyed on bread, especially French bread or sourdough.
• In omelettes: Manchego can be melted and used in omelettes.
• With meat: Manchego pairs well with meat, such as chorizo or jamon iberico.
• In tapas: In Spain, Manchego is often served as tapas in thinly sliced triangles.
• In baked goods: Manchego can be baked into goods such as focaccia bread, adding a salty savour.
• In pasta: Melted Manchego provides a rich, indulgent flavour in baked pasta dishes.

Other unique cheeses

Manchego cheese is adored for its unique flavour and texture, and while it is a Spanish favourite, there are several other unique cheeses to explore.

One of the more popular cheeses, Pecorino, is a famous Italian cheese made from sheep's milk. It has a firm texture and a distinct, slightly salty flavour, similar to Manchego. Another substitute for Manchego, Gouda, has a mild and nutty taste and can be enjoyed on its own or melted. Parmesan, or Parmigiano-Reggiano, is another well-known cheese that can stand in for Manchego in many recipes, although it has a more pungent and granular texture.

For those looking for something a little more unusual, there are several options to explore. Halloumi, a Greek cheese, is unique in its ability to handle high temperatures without melting, allowing it to be grilled like a steak. Drunken Goat and Comté are two other lesser-known cheeses that can add an unusual twist to your next cheese board. For a unique, sweet treat, try a block of "yay-toast", a famous Norwegian après-ski cheese made from cow and goat milk. It looks like chocolate but tastes like caramel fudge, providing a truly distinctive cheese experience.

Frequently asked questions