Perfect Cheesesteak Cheese: Top Picks For Melty, Savory Philly Bliss

When it comes to crafting the perfect cheesesteak, selecting the right cheese is just as crucial as choosing the quality of the meat. Traditionally, Philadelphians swear by Cheez Whiz, a processed cheese sauce that melts seamlessly and adds a creamy, tangy flavor to the sandwich. However, purists often opt for provolone, either sharp or mild, for its slightly smoky and nutty profile that complements the beef without overpowering it. American cheese is another popular choice, prized for its smooth melt and mild taste that blends effortlessly with the other ingredients. Ultimately, the best cheese for a cheesesteak depends on personal preference, but each option brings its unique texture and flavor to this iconic dish.

Explore related products

Horizon Organic American Cheese Slices, 8 oz. Pack, 12 Slices

$6.79

Original Philly Cheesesteak Value Seasoned Beef Sandwich Slices, 6 Ounce -- 27 per case.

$125.91

Kraft, American Cheese Slices, 16 Ounce

$29.98

Organic Valley Alpine Style Organic Baby Swiss Cheese Slices

$7.69

Velveeta Original Pasteurized Recipe Cheese Product, 16 oz Block

$5.48

Shullsburg Creamery - 120 Slice American Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf

$35.69

Provolone vs. Cheez Whiz: Classic debate between traditional provolone and Philly's iconic Cheez Whiz preference

The cheesesteak, a Philadelphia icon, sparks fierce debate not just about its meat or roll, but its cheese. At the heart of this culinary clash: provolone, the traditional choice, versus Cheez Whiz, the city’s neon-hued darling. Both have their die-hard fans, but which reigns supreme?

Provolone: The Classic Contender

Provolone is the purist’s pick, favored for its sharp, smoky flavor and meltability. Aged for a minimum of 3-6 months, it adds a nuanced tang that complements the beef without overpowering it. To use, slice thin or grate finely—thick chunks won’t melt evenly. Pair with grilled onions and peppers for a balanced bite. Pro tip: Opt for provolone aged 4-6 months for optimal flavor and texture.

Cheez Whiz: Philly’s Unlikely Hero

Cheez Whiz, a processed cheese sauce, is the underdog turned legend. Its creamy texture and mild, salty profile act as a glue, binding the steak and onions into a cohesive, gooey masterpiece. Heat it gently—overcooking can make it oily. For maximum impact, drizzle it just before serving. Fun fact: Cheez Whiz gained popularity in the 1960s when Pat’s King of Steaks introduced it as a no-fuss alternative to sliced cheese.

The Meltdown: A Comparative Analysis

Provolone offers sophistication, while Cheez Whiz delivers comfort. The former appeals to those who savor complexity; the latter, to those who crave consistency. Texture-wise, provolone retains its integrity, whereas Cheez Whiz creates a seamless, velvety coating. Health-conscious eaters note: provolone has fewer additives, but Cheez Whiz’s lower fat content (when used sparingly) might sway some.

The Verdict: Tradition or Trend?

Choosing between provolone and Cheez Whiz isn’t just about taste—it’s about identity. Provolone honors the cheesesteak’s Italian-American roots, while Cheez Whiz embodies Philly’s blue-collar spirit. For first-timers, try provolone to experience the classic. For repeat visitors, embrace Cheez Whiz’s cult status. Ultimately, the best cheese is the one that makes your cheesesteak unforgettable.

American Cheese: Melty, mild, and popular choice for a creamy, classic cheesesteak texture

American Cheese is the unsung hero of the cheesesteak world, often overshadowed by fancier options but undeniably the backbone of the classic Philly experience. Its superpower lies in its meltability. Unlike harder cheeses that can clump or separate, American Cheese transforms into a silky, cohesive sauce that binds the steak, onions, and roll into a harmonious whole. This isn't about gourmet complexity; it's about reliable, comforting texture that elevates every bite.

Think of American Cheese as the ultimate cheesesteak glue. Its high moisture content and emulsifiers ensure a smooth, even melt that coats the thinly sliced steak without overwhelming its flavor. This is crucial in a sandwich where the meat should remain the star. The mild, slightly tangy profile of American Cheese complements rather than competes, adding a subtle richness without stealing the show.

For the purist, there's no substitute. While provolone or Cheez Whiz have their devotees, American Cheese delivers the textbook cheesesteak mouthfeel: stretchy, creamy, and indulgent. It's the difference between a good cheesesteak and one that feels like a nostalgic hug from South Philly. To achieve this, use thinly sliced American Cheese (not singles) and distribute it evenly over the hot steak on the griddle. Let it melt gently, then fold the steak and cheese together before piling it onto the roll.

Don't overthink it. American Cheese is forgiving, making it ideal for home cooks. Its consistent texture means you don't need precise temperature control or fancy techniques. Aim for a 2:1 ratio of steak to cheese by weight for a balanced bite. Too much cheese can make the sandwich greasy, while too little leaves it dry. Remember, this is comfort food—perfection is in the simplicity.

Pepper Jack: Spicy twist with pepper jack for those who like heat in their sandwich

For those seeking a fiery kick in their cheesesteak, Pepper Jack cheese emerges as a bold contender. Its inherent spiciness, derived from jalapeños and other peppers, transforms the classic sandwich into a flavor explosion. This isn't a subtle heat; it's a vibrant, tongue-tingling experience that elevates the savory richness of the steak and onions.

Imagine the sizzle of thinly sliced steak on the griddle, the aroma of caramelized onions mingling with the sharp tang of Pepper Jack. Each bite becomes a dance of flavors, the creamy cheese melting into the meat, its spicy notes cutting through the richness, leaving a satisfying warmth that lingers.

Choosing Pepper Jack isn't just about heat tolerance; it's about embracing a unique flavor profile. The cheese's peppery punch complements the umami depth of the steak, creating a complex and memorable taste sensation. It's a choice for those who crave adventure in their sandwiches, who want their cheesesteak to be more than just a meal, but an experience.

However, wielding Pepper Jack requires consideration. Its potency can overwhelm milder ingredients, so balance is key. Opt for a moderate amount, allowing the cheese to enhance, not dominate, the other flavors. Consider pairing it with a slightly sweeter roll to temper the heat, or adding a cool, crisp topping like shredded lettuce or a drizzle of ranch dressing for contrast.

For the heat-seekers, Pepper Jack is a game-changer. It's not just a cheese; it's a statement, a declaration of your love for bold flavors and culinary adventure. So, embrace the spice, experiment with pairings, and let your cheesesteak become a testament to your taste buds' daring spirit.

Explore related products

Adam's Reserve New York Extra Sharp Cheddar Slices

$5

Rumiano Organic Havarti Cheese, Sliced, 6 oz

$5.79 $6.79

Kraft White American Cheese Singles, 72 Count

$28

Sargento Natural American Cheese Slices, 2 lbs.

$37 $40

Singles American Cheese Slices 3 lbs., Made with real dairy and no artificial flavors or preservatives, our sliced cheese has a mild, savory flavor and smooth, creamy texture that’s perfectly melty , 72 ct.

$30

Land O Lakes Sliced Yellow American Premium Deli Cheese, 3 lbs.

$44.5

Mozzarella: Stretchy, mild mozzarella as a less traditional but gooey alternative

Mozzarella, with its signature stretch and mild flavor, offers a gooey, indulgent twist to the classic cheesesteak. While not a traditional choice, it’s gaining popularity for its meltability and ability to complement the savory beef without overpowering it. For best results, use fresh mozzarella (not the low-moisture variety used for pizza) and shred it finely to ensure even distribution. Aim for a 3:1 ratio of meat to cheese, as too much mozzarella can make the sandwich greasy.

Consider the texture contrast mozzarella brings to the table. When melted, it creates a luscious, stringy pull that pairs well with the thinly sliced steak and sautéed onions. However, its mildness means it won’t add the sharp tang of provolone or the funk of Cheez Whiz. To enhance flavor, sprinkle a pinch of garlic powder or dried oregano over the cheese before assembling the sandwich. This simple step bridges the gap between mozzarella’s neutrality and the boldness typically expected in a cheesesteak.

One practical tip: allow the mozzarella to come to room temperature before adding it to the sandwich. Cold cheese won’t melt evenly, resulting in clumps rather than a smooth, gooey layer. If you’re using a griddle or skillet, add the cheese just as the steak finishes cooking, letting the residual heat do the work. For oven-broiled cheesesteaks, place the assembled sandwich under the broiler for 1–2 minutes, watching closely to avoid burning.

Mozzarella’s versatility extends to dietary preferences. It’s naturally lower in sodium than aged cheeses, making it a better option for those monitoring their intake. For a lighter twist, pair it with chicken or portobello mushrooms instead of beef. While purists may argue against its use, mozzarella’s stretchy, melt-in-your-mouth quality offers a satisfying alternative that appeals to a broader audience, especially those who prioritize texture over sharpness.

In the end, mozzarella’s role in a cheesesteak is about experimentation and personalization. It may not be the first cheese that comes to mind, but its gooey, mild nature can elevate the sandwich in unexpected ways. Whether you’re a traditionalist looking to mix things up or a newcomer to cheesesteaks, mozzarella invites you to rethink what this iconic dish can be. Just remember: balance is key—let the cheese enhance, not dominate, the flavors of the steak and toppings.

Cheese Combinations: Mixing cheeses like provolone and American for enhanced flavor and texture

The classic cheesesteak debate often hinges on cheese choice, with purists swearing by provolone and others championing American. But why limit yourself to one when combining the two can elevate your sandwich to new heights? A 50/50 mix of provolone and American cheese creates a harmonious balance: the sharp, slightly smoky flavor of provolone complements the creamy, melt-y richness of American. This combination not only enhances the overall taste but also ensures a smooth, stretchy texture that clings perfectly to the steak and bread.

To achieve this ideal blend, start by grating equal parts provolone and American cheese. Use approximately 2 ounces of each cheese per 8-inch cheesesteak to avoid overwhelming the meat while still delivering robust flavor. Layer the cheeses evenly over the cooked steak on the griddle, allowing them to melt together before placing the mixture on the roll. This method ensures the cheeses meld seamlessly, creating a cohesive, indulgent bite.

While provolone and American are a winning duo, the ratio can be adjusted to suit personal preference. For a bolder flavor, increase the provolone to 60% and reduce the American to 40%. Conversely, if you prefer a milder, creamier profile, flip the ratio. Experimentation is key—don’t be afraid to tweak the proportions until you find your perfect match. Just remember: too much American can make the sandwich greasy, while excessive provolone might overpower the steak’s natural taste.

One practical tip is to use low-moisture provolone for better meltability and to avoid excess liquid. Pair this combination with a toasted Amoroso roll and thinly sliced ribeye for a textbook cheesesteak experience. For an extra layer of complexity, add a drizzle of melted cheese wiz—a Philadelphia staple—to the mix. This trio of cheeses creates a decadent, multi-dimensional flavor profile that’s hard to resist.

In the end, the beauty of mixing provolone and American lies in its versatility and ability to enhance both flavor and texture. It’s a simple yet transformative technique that turns a good cheesesteak into a great one. Whether you’re a home cook or a seasoned chef, mastering this cheese combination will set your sandwich apart, proving that sometimes, the whole is truly greater than the sum of its parts.

Frequently asked questions