Philly Cheese Steak: The Ultimate Cheese Choice Revealed

The iconic Philly Cheesesteak, a beloved sandwich originating from Philadelphia, is renowned for its mouthwatering combination of thinly sliced steak, sautéed onions, and melted cheese on a hoagie roll. While the debate over the best cheese to use in a Philly Cheesesteak continues among enthusiasts, traditionalists argue that provolone, American, or Cheez Whiz are the top contenders. Each cheese brings its unique flavor and texture to the sandwich, with provolone offering a sharp, smoky taste, American providing a creamy, mild flavor, and Cheez Whiz adding a tangy, processed twist. Understanding the role of cheese in a Philly Cheesesteak is essential to appreciating the nuances of this classic dish and the ongoing discussion surrounding its ideal composition.

Explore related products

Original Philly Cheesesteak Value Seasoned Beef Sandwich Slices, 4 Ounce -- 40 per case.

$111.74

Rayberns Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich -- 6 per case.

$76.78

Velveeta Skillets Creamy Beef Stroganoff One Pan Dinner Kit, 11.6 oz Box

$3.42 $4.19

Original Philly WOW Seasoned Beef Sandwich Slices (32-5oz) (10 Pounds of Beef)

$129.99

Vending 2 U Hamburger Helper Deluxe Philly Cheesesteak, 4.8 Ounces, Pack of 2, Bundled With One V2U Utensil Set

$9.5

Philly Cheesesteak Seasoning

$6.99

Provolone Cheese: Most common choice, mild flavor, melts well, complements steak without overpowering

Provolone cheese stands as the undisputed champion in the realm of Philly cheesesteaks, and its dominance is no accident. Its mild, slightly smoky flavor profile acts as the perfect foil to the rich, savory steak, enhancing the meat's natural taste without stealing the show. This delicate balance is crucial in a dish where every ingredient must play its part harmoniously.

Unlike sharper cheeses that can overwhelm the palate, provolone's subtlety allows the steak's essence to shine through, making it the go-to choice for cheesesteak aficionados.

The science behind provolone's success lies in its melting properties. With a moisture content of around 45-50%, it achieves the ideal melt at temperatures between 135-150°F (57-65°C), creating a gooey, stretchy texture that clings to the steak and bread without becoming greasy or separating. This is particularly important in a cheesesteak, where the cheese must act as a binding agent, holding the components together in every bite. For optimal results, grate the provolone finely (about 2-3 ounces per sandwich) and sprinkle it evenly over the steak while it's still on the griddle, allowing it to melt gradually under the residual heat.

From a practical standpoint, provolone's versatility extends beyond its flavor and melt. Its relatively low moisture content (compared to cheeses like mozzarella) means it’s less likely to sog the bread, a common pitfall in cheesesteak construction. Additionally, its mildness makes it a crowd-pleaser, appealing to a wide range of palates, from children to adults. When selecting provolone, opt for the aged variety (6-12 months), as it offers a slightly nuttier flavor and better melt compared to younger versions.

In the great cheese debate, provolone’s role in the Philly cheesesteak is not just traditional—it’s tactical. Its ability to complement without overpowering, melt without mess, and appeal to diverse tastes cements its status as the quintessential choice. While other cheeses may have their merits, provolone’s unique combination of qualities ensures it remains the gold standard, a testament to the adage that sometimes, the classics are classics for a reason.

American Cheese: Creamy texture, mild taste, popular alternative, melts smoothly, adds richness

American cheese, with its creamy texture and mild taste, has become a staple in the iconic Philly cheesesteak. Its popularity stems from its ability to melt smoothly, creating a cohesive and indulgent experience. When crafting a cheesesteak, consider American cheese as a reliable alternative to more assertive varieties. Its subtle flavor profile allows the savory notes of the steak and the tang of the onions to shine, while its richness binds the ingredients together. For optimal results, use two to three slices per sandwich, ensuring even coverage without overwhelming the other components.

From a culinary perspective, American cheese’s smooth melt is a game-changer. Unlike harder cheeses that can clump or separate, it forms a velvety layer that coats the steak and bread evenly. This consistency is particularly important in a dish where texture is as crucial as taste. To enhance its performance, allow the cheese to come to room temperature before adding it to the sandwich. This simple step ensures it melts faster and more uniformly, reducing the risk of overcooking the steak or burning the bread.

Persuasively, American cheese’s versatility makes it a smart choice for both traditionalists and innovators. While purists might argue for provolone or Cheez Whiz, American cheese offers a middle ground that appeals to a broader audience. Its mildness accommodates additional toppings like peppers or mushrooms without clashing, while its richness elevates the overall flavor profile. For those experimenting with variations, try layering American cheese with a sharper cheese for added depth, but keep the ratio 2:1 in favor of American to maintain balance.

Descriptively, imagine biting into a Philly cheesesteak where the American cheese has melded seamlessly with the thinly sliced steak, its creamy texture contrasting the crispness of the roll. The cheese’s mild taste acts as a harmonious backdrop, enhancing the umami of the meat and the sweetness of caramelized onions. This sensory experience is why American cheese remains a go-to option for cheesesteak enthusiasts. To replicate this at home, toast the roll lightly before assembling the sandwich to prevent sogginess, ensuring every bite is as satisfying as the last.

Instructively, mastering the use of American cheese in a Philly cheesesteak involves timing and technique. Place the cheese on top of the steak while it’s still on the griddle, allowing the residual heat to melt it gradually. Once it begins to soften, fold the steak and cheese together before transferring the mixture to the roll. This method ensures maximum integration without overcooking. For a finishing touch, press the sandwich gently to seal the layers, creating a cohesive bite that showcases American cheese’s role in achieving richness and unity.

Cheese Whiz: Processed cheese, iconic in Philly, gooey texture, tangy flavor, divisive choice

Cheese Whiz, a processed cheese product, has become an iconic, if controversial, topping for the classic Philly cheesesteak. Its gooey texture and tangy flavor profile offer a distinct sensory experience that sets it apart from traditional cheeses like provolone or American. For those seeking authenticity in their cheesesteak, understanding Cheese Whiz’s role is essential—it’s not just a cheese; it’s a cultural marker.

To use Cheese Whiz effectively, heat it gently in a microwave or double boiler until it reaches a smooth, pourable consistency. Avoid overheating, as it can cause the cheese to separate or become rubbery. Apply it generously but strategically—too much can overwhelm the steak and onions, while too little may leave the sandwich dry. For best results, pair Cheese Whiz with thinly sliced ribeye and caramelized onions, allowing its tanginess to balance the richness of the meat.

The choice of Cheese Whiz is deeply divisive, even among Philadelphians. Purists argue it’s the only true option, citing its ability to meld seamlessly with the other ingredients. Critics, however, dismiss it as artificial and inferior to natural cheeses. This debate highlights a broader question: Is authenticity in food about tradition or personal preference? Cheese Whiz’s enduring popularity suggests that, for many, it’s not just about taste—it’s about identity.

For those hesitant to try Cheese Whiz, start with a small portion to gauge its impact on the sandwich. Pair it with a side of crispy fries or a pickle to cut through its richness. If you’re making cheesesteaks at home, experiment with different cheeses to find your preferred balance of flavor and texture. Ultimately, Cheese Whiz isn’t just a topping—it’s a statement, a nod to Philly’s culinary heritage, and a bold choice that demands attention.

Explore related products

Original Philly Cheesesteak Value Seasoned Beef Sandwich Slices, 6 Ounce -- 27 per case.

$122.64

Hot Pockets Philly Steak & Cheese with Reduced Fat Mozzarella Cheese, Peppers, Onions and Sauce in a Seasoned Crust - Ready Set Gourmet Donate a Meal Program - 4 Pack (12ct. 4.5 oz Each)

$181.52

Betty Crocker PHILLY CHEESESTEAK Hamburger Helper 6.5oz (2 Pack)

$14.97

Original Philly Ribeye Seasoned Beef Sandwich Slices, 4 Ounce -- 40 per case.

$153.16

Philly Sensations Minute Ready Raw Philly Beef Steak, 4 Ounce Slices -- 40 per case.

$193.67

Tallarico's "Philly Style" Steak Sandwich Sauce 2 Jars

$19.55 $21.25

Cheddar Cheese: Sharp or mild, adds depth, melts well, less traditional but used occasionally

Cheddar cheese, whether sharp or mild, offers a versatile twist to the classic Philly cheesesteak. Its robust flavor profile adds depth to the sandwich, complementing the savory beef and sautéed onions without overpowering them. Sharp cheddar brings a tangy, bold edge, ideal for those seeking a more pronounced cheese presence, while mild cheddar provides a creamy, subtle richness that lets the meat shine. Both varieties melt exceptionally well, ensuring a cohesive, gooey texture that’s essential for a satisfying bite.

When incorporating cheddar into your cheesesteak, consider the balance of flavors. Sharp cheddar pairs best with seasoned beef and peppers, as its intensity can stand up to stronger ingredients. Mild cheddar, on the other hand, works seamlessly with simpler combinations, like beef and onions, enhancing without competing. Use approximately 2-3 ounces of shredded cheddar per sandwich to achieve optimal coverage and melt without overwhelming the other components.

While cheddar is less traditional than provolone or American cheese, its occasional use in Philly cheesesteaks highlights its adaptability. For a modern twist, try a 50/50 blend of sharp cheddar and provolone to marry tradition with innovation. This combination retains the familiar tang of provolone while introducing cheddar’s distinctive character. Experimentation is key—start with small amounts to gauge how cheddar’s sharpness or mildness interacts with your chosen ingredients.

Practical tip: Grate the cheddar finely to ensure even melting and distribution. Pre-shredded cheese often contains anti-caking agents that can affect texture, so opt for freshly grated for the best results. Serve the cheesesteak immediately after assembling to enjoy the cheese at its melted peak. While cheddar may not be the first choice for purists, its ability to add depth and melt beautifully makes it a worthy contender for those looking to explore beyond the classics.

Mozzarella Cheese: Mild, stretchy, melts evenly, sometimes used for a unique twist

Mozzarella cheese, with its mild flavor and signature stretch, offers a unique twist to the traditional Philly cheese steak. While not the classic choice, its even melt and subtle taste make it an intriguing alternative for those seeking a departure from the usual suspects like provolone or Cheez Whiz. This Italian staple, traditionally paired with tomatoes and basil, brings a surprising versatility to the hearty, meat-centric sandwich.

Imagine the contrast: the savory, thinly sliced steak, the caramelized onions, and the soft, slightly elastic mozzarella, creating a textural interplay that’s both comforting and novel. For those who prefer a cheese that doesn’t overpower the other ingredients, mozzarella’s mildness allows the flavors of the steak and peppers to shine through.

When incorporating mozzarella into your Philly cheese steak, consider the type of mozzarella you’re using. Fresh mozzarella, while delicious, tends to release more moisture, which can make the sandwich soggy. Opt for low-moisture mozzarella, often labeled as "pizza cheese," as it melts evenly without compromising the sandwich’s structure. Shred the cheese finely to ensure it distributes evenly across the steak and bread.

The key to mastering this twist lies in temperature control. Mozzarella melts best at a consistent heat, so cook your steak and vegetables first, then add the cheese just before assembling the sandwich. This ensures the mozzarella melts smoothly without burning. For an extra layer of flavor, sprinkle a pinch of dried oregano or garlic powder over the cheese before closing the sandwich.

While mozzarella may not be the traditional choice, its unique qualities—mildness, stretchiness, and even melt—make it a worthy contender for those looking to experiment. It’s particularly appealing to younger palates or those who find sharper cheeses like provolone too overpowering. Pair it with a crusty roll and a side of marinara for dipping, and you’ve got a Philly cheese steak that’s both familiar and refreshingly different.

Frequently asked questions