America's Favorite Cheese: Uncovering The Most Popular Variety In The Us

When it comes to cheese, the United States has a diverse palate, but one variety consistently stands out as the most popular: mozzarella. Widely used in pizzas, pasta dishes, and salads, mozzarella’s mild, creamy texture and versatile nature make it a staple in American households and restaurants alike. Its dominance is further solidified by the country’s love for Italian-American cuisine, where mozzarella plays a central role. While other cheeses like cheddar and American cheese also hold significant popularity, mozzarella’s widespread use and cultural integration make it the undisputed favorite in the U.S. cheese market.

Explore related products

Andrew & Everett White American Cheese

$9.49

Andrew & Everett Yellow American Cheese

$9.49

Horizon Organic American Cheese Slices, 8 oz. Pack, 12 Slices

$7.49

Amazon Grocery, Pasteurized Process American Cheese, 16 Oz, 24 Ct (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary)

$2.48

Kraft Deli Deluxe American Cheese Slices, 16 oz Pack, 24 Slices

$3.97

Kraft Singles American Slices, 16 ct Pack

$3.28

Mozzarella Dominance: Widely used in pizzas and pasta, mozzarella consistently tops U.S. cheese consumption charts

Mozzarella reigns supreme in American cheese consumption, and its dominance is no accident. This mild, stretchy cheese is the backbone of two of the most beloved foods in the U.S.: pizza and pasta. According to the USDA, Americans consume over 11 pounds of mozzarella per capita annually, dwarfing the consumption of cheddar, the next most popular cheese. This statistic alone underscores mozzarella’s unparalleled role in the American diet. Its versatility—melting perfectly on pizzas, blending seamlessly into lasagna, or adding a creamy texture to caprese salads—makes it indispensable in both home kitchens and restaurants.

To understand mozzarella’s dominance, consider its functional properties. Its high moisture content and ability to melt smoothly without burning make it ideal for cooking. For example, when making pizza, mozzarella’s stretchiness creates the iconic "cheese pull" that consumers crave. In pasta dishes like baked ziti or stuffed shells, it provides a gooey, comforting texture that elevates the dish. Even in cold applications, such as caprese salads, its soft consistency and mild flavor complement fresh tomatoes and basil without overpowering them. These qualities explain why mozzarella is a go-to choice for chefs and home cooks alike.

From a practical standpoint, incorporating mozzarella into your cooking is straightforward. For pizzas, opt for low-moisture mozzarella (often labeled "pizza cheese") to prevent a soggy crust. When layering in pasta dishes, shred the cheese evenly to ensure consistent melting. For a healthier twist, use part-skim mozzarella, which reduces fat content without sacrificing flavor. Pro tip: pair mozzarella with acidic ingredients like tomato sauce or balsamic glaze to balance its richness. This simple trick enhances the overall taste profile of your dish.

Mozzarella’s dominance also reflects broader culinary trends in the U.S. The rise of fast-casual Italian-American chains and the enduring popularity of comfort foods have cemented its place in the national palate. Unlike more polarizing cheeses, mozzarella’s mildness appeals to a wide range of tastes, including children and those with less adventurous palates. Its affordability and widespread availability further contribute to its ubiquity. Whether you’re crafting a homemade pizza or grabbing a slice on the go, mozzarella is the silent hero that ties it all together.

In conclusion, mozzarella’s reign as America’s favorite cheese is a testament to its adaptability, functionality, and universal appeal. Its role in iconic dishes ensures its continued dominance in U.S. cheese consumption charts. By understanding its properties and incorporating it thoughtfully into your cooking, you can harness its full potential and elevate your meals. Mozzarella isn’t just a cheese—it’s a culinary cornerstone.

Cheddar's Versatility: A staple in households, cheddar is loved for its sharpness and melting qualities

Cheddar cheese reigns as the undisputed champion of American refrigerators, with a staggering 26% of U.S. cheese sales attributed to this versatile dairy delight. Its dominance isn't merely a matter of taste; it's a testament to its adaptability in the kitchen. From the moment it's shredded over a steaming bowl of macaroni to its role as the star of a sophisticated cheese board, cheddar's sharpness and melting prowess make it a household essential.

The Science Behind the Melt: Cheddar's melting qualities stem from its low moisture content and pH levels, typically ranging between 5.0 and 5.5. This unique composition allows it to melt smoothly without becoming greasy, making it ideal for sauces, sandwiches, and casseroles. For optimal melting, aim for a temperature range of 120°F to 150°F, ensuring a creamy texture without burning.

Consider the age of your cheddar when planning its use. Younger cheddars, aged 2-3 months, offer a milder flavor and are perfect for dishes where you want the cheese to complement, not overpower, other ingredients. In contrast, a 2-year-old sharp cheddar, with its pronounced tang and firmer texture, can elevate a simple grilled cheese sandwich to gourmet status. For the boldest flavor, reach for a 5-year-old extra sharp cheddar, best reserved for standalone enjoyment or as a finishing touch on soups and salads.

Pairing Perfection: Cheddar's versatility extends beyond the kitchen. When crafting a cheese board, consider the age and sharpness of your cheddar to guide your pairings. A young, mild cheddar pairs beautifully with crisp apples and honey, while a sharp, aged variety stands up to robust accompaniments like dark chocolate and hearty crackers. For wine enthusiasts, a full-bodied Cabernet Sauvignon complements the richness of aged cheddar, whereas a lighter Pinot Grigio balances the creaminess of younger varieties.

In the realm of comfort food, cheddar's role is unparalleled. Its ability to meld seamlessly into dishes like macaroni and cheese or broccoli casserole makes it a go-to for family meals. For a twist on tradition, experiment with blending cheddar with other cheeses, such as Gruyère or Monterey Jack, to create a complex flavor profile. When baking, incorporate shredded cheddar into biscuit dough or sprinkle it over the top of a savory pie for a golden, crispy finish.

Practical Tips for Cheddar Enthusiasts: To maintain cheddar's quality, store it in the refrigerator at 35°F to 40°F, wrapped in wax paper to allow it to breathe. For longer storage, consider vacuum sealing. When grating cheddar, chill it first to prevent sticking, and always use the finest grater setting for even melting. For those with lactose intolerance, aged cheddars are a better option due to their lower lactose content, typically below 2 grams per ounce.

Cheddar's versatility is not just a matter of convenience; it's a culinary asset that transforms ordinary meals into extraordinary experiences. Whether you're a seasoned chef or a home cook, understanding the nuances of cheddar's sharpness and melting qualities unlocks a world of possibilities in the kitchen and beyond.

American Cheese Appeal: Processed American cheese remains popular for its convenience and classic flavor

Processed American cheese, often simply called "American cheese," holds a unique and enduring place in the hearts—and refrigerators—of many Americans. Despite the rise of artisanal and specialty cheeses, this processed variety remains a staple, thanks to its unmatched convenience and familiar, comforting flavor. Its popularity isn’t just nostalgia; it’s a practical choice for busy households, school lunches, and quick meals. The individually wrapped singles are a grab-and-go solution, melting effortlessly onto burgers, sandwiches, or grilled cheese without the fuss of slicing or grating. For parents, it’s a reliable way to sneak protein into kids’ diets, as its mild, slightly salty taste appeals to younger palates.

From a culinary perspective, processed American cheese’s appeal lies in its consistency and functionality. Unlike natural cheeses, which can vary in texture and meltability, American cheese is engineered to perform predictably. Its emulsified structure ensures smooth, even melting, making it ideal for dishes like cheesesteaks or macaroni and cheese. Chefs and home cooks alike appreciate this reliability, especially in high-volume settings or when precision is key. While food purists may scoff, the cheese’s ability to maintain its flavor and texture under heat sets it apart from many of its unprocessed counterparts.

Critics often dismiss processed American cheese as inferior due to its additives and lower cheese content, but this overlooks its role as a democratizing food. At an average price of $4–$6 per 12-ounce pack, it’s significantly more affordable than premium cheeses like cheddar or Swiss. For families on a budget, this accessibility makes it a practical choice without sacrificing taste. Additionally, its long shelf life—up to six months when unopened—reduces food waste, a growing concern in modern households. These factors combine to make it a smart, economical option for everyday use.

To maximize the appeal of processed American cheese, consider these practical tips: pair it with acidic ingredients like pickles or tomatoes to balance its richness, or use it as a base layer in casseroles for a creamy, binding effect. For a healthier twist, opt for low-sodium versions or limit portion sizes to 1–2 slices per serving. While it may not be the star of a gourmet cheese board, its versatility and affordability ensure it remains a go-to for quick, satisfying meals. In a culture that values both tradition and efficiency, processed American cheese’s classic flavor and convenience are a recipe for continued popularity.

Explore related products

Amazon Saver, American Singles, Pasteurized Prepared Cheese Product, 24 Slices, 16 Oz (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary)

$2.48

Dietz & Watson White American Cheese

$7.99

Kraft Deli Deluxe White American Cheese Slices (24 ct Bag)

$3.97

Kraft Singles American Slices, 24 ct Pack

$3.97

Dietz & Watson Yellow American Cheese

$7.99

Dietz & Watson Pre-Sliced American White Cheese, 8 oz

$4.99

Parmesan's Ubiquity: Grated Parmesan is a go-to for adding savory depth to dishes nationwide

Grated Parmesan's dominance in American kitchens isn't just a trend; it's a testament to its unparalleled ability to elevate everyday dishes. A sprinkle of this umami-rich cheese transforms mundane meals into savory experiences. From pasta to popcorn, its granular texture and complex flavor profile add depth without overwhelming other ingredients. This versatility explains why Parmesan consistently ranks among the most consumed cheeses in the U.S., with annual per capita consumption hovering around 2.5 pounds. Its convenience—pre-grated and shelf-stable—further cements its status as a pantry staple.

To maximize Parmesan's impact, consider dosage and application. For pasta dishes, aim for 1-2 tablespoons per serving, adjusting based on the dish's richness. A lighter hand works best for salads or soups, where a teaspoon can enhance without overpowering. Pro tip: store grated Parmesan in an airtight container in the fridge to maintain freshness, and let it come to room temperature before using to release its full aroma. For a bolder flavor, opt for aged varieties, which offer a nuttier, more concentrated taste.

Comparatively, while cheeses like mozzarella and cheddar dominate volume sales, Parmesan's role is uniquely transformative. Unlike mozzarella's melt or cheddar's sharpness, Parmesan's granular form and savory punch make it a finishing touch rather than a base ingredient. This distinction positions it as a flavor enhancer across cuisines, from Italian classics to modern fusion dishes. Its ability to bridge culinary traditions underscores its ubiquity and enduring appeal.

Persuasively, Parmesan's popularity isn't just about taste—it's about efficiency. Busy home cooks and professional chefs alike rely on its ability to deliver complexity with minimal effort. A single container of grated Parmesan can last weeks, offering consistent quality without the need for grating or refrigeration (in the case of shelf-stable varieties). This practicality, combined with its culinary versatility, ensures Parmesan remains a go-to for adding savory depth to dishes nationwide. Whether you're crafting a gourmet meal or elevating a weeknight dinner, grated Parmesan is the unsung hero of American kitchens.

Regional Favorites: Local cheeses like pepper jack and Colby-Jack thrive in specific U.S. regions

While cheddar and mozzarella dominate national sales, the U.S. cheese landscape is far from monolithic. Regional preferences paint a more nuanced picture, with local favorites like pepper jack and Colby-Jack carving out dedicated followings in specific areas. These cheeses, often overlooked in broader discussions of popularity, thrive due to cultural traditions, historical production hubs, and unique flavor profiles that resonate with local palates.

Taking a closer look at these regional stars reveals a fascinating interplay between geography and taste.

Consider the Southwest, where pepper jack reigns supreme. This spicy, Monterey Jack-based cheese, infused with fiery peppers, perfectly complements the region's love for bold, flavorful dishes like nachos, tacos, and chili. Its popularity extends beyond mere taste; it's a cultural touchstone, reflecting the Southwest's vibrant culinary heritage and its embrace of heat. Similarly, the Midwest proudly claims Colby-Jack as its own. This marbled blend of mild Colby and Monterey Jack offers a creamy texture and subtle tang that pairs beautifully with the region's comfort food staples like burgers, grilled cheese sandwiches, and hearty casseroles. Its versatility and approachable flavor profile make it a pantry staple for families across the heartland.

These regional favorites aren't just about taste; they're about identity. They tell stories of local history, culinary traditions, and shared experiences.

Understanding these regional preferences isn't just academic; it's practical. For food producers and retailers, recognizing these localized trends allows for targeted marketing and product development. A restaurant in Texas might highlight pepper jack-stuffed jalapenos, while a Wisconsin deli could showcase Colby-Jack in their signature cheese curds. For consumers, exploring these regional cheeses offers a delicious way to connect with different parts of the country, expanding culinary horizons and appreciating the diversity of American food culture.

Frequently asked questions