Perfect Pairing: Simple Cheese Options For Your Steak And Cheese Sub

When crafting the perfect steak and cheese sub, selecting the right cheese is crucial for achieving that ideal balance of meltiness and flavor. An easy and popular choice is provolone, known for its mild, smoky taste and excellent melting qualities. Its versatility complements the richness of the steak without overpowering it. Another simple option is American cheese, which melts effortlessly and adds a creamy texture, making it a classic go-to for sandwiches. For those seeking a sharper profile, cheddar slices offer a tangy contrast to the savory steak. Whichever cheese you choose, ensuring it melts evenly and blends seamlessly with the other ingredients is key to elevating your steak and cheese sub to perfection.

Explore related products

Easy Cheese American Cheese Snack, 8 oz

$5.53

American Cheese Snack Easy Cheese 8 oz Can- Yellow American Cheese

$6.99

Original Queso-Melt Cheese Loaf 5 lbs

$54.98

BORDEN CHEESE SLICES GRILLED CHEESE MELTS SINGLES 12 OZ PACK OF 4

$19.04

Land O Lakes American Extra Melt Yellow Process Cheese Loaf, 5 Pound -- 6 per case.

$192.21 $210.62

EASY CHEESE Cheddar Cheese Snack, 12 - 8 oz Cans

$66.36

Provolone Cheese: Mild, melts well, classic choice for steak subs, complements beef flavor perfectly

Provolone cheese stands out as a top contender for steak and cheese subs due to its mild flavor profile and exceptional melting qualities. Its subtle nuttiness enhances the rich, savory taste of beef without overpowering it, making it a classic pairing in this iconic sandwich. Unlike sharper cheeses that can clash with the meat’s natural flavors, provolone acts as a harmonious complement, allowing the steak to remain the star while adding a creamy, gooey texture that ties the sub together.

When selecting provolone for your steak sub, opt for low-moisture varieties, as they melt more evenly and resist turning rubbery under heat. Thinly slice or grate the cheese to ensure it melts quickly and coats the steak uniformly. For optimal results, layer the provolone directly on top of the hot steak while it’s still on the griddle or in the pan, allowing the residual heat to melt it before transferring the mixture to the sub roll. This method prevents the bread from becoming soggy and ensures every bite is perfectly cheesy.

A key advantage of provolone is its versatility in both hot and cold applications, though it truly shines when melted. For a twist, try mixing provolone with a small amount of sharp cheddar or pepper jack to add complexity without losing the cheese’s signature mildness. However, purists will argue that provolone alone is sufficient, as its clean flavor and meltability make it a no-fuss, reliable choice for busy kitchens or quick meal prep.

In terms of portioning, aim for a 1:2 ratio of cheese to steak by weight, ensuring enough provolone to coat the meat generously without overwhelming it. For a standard 6-inch sub, 2–3 ounces of provolone is ideal. If using pre-sliced cheese, 3–4 slices will suffice. This balance ensures the cheese enhances the steak’s flavor without dominating the sandwich, creating a cohesive, satisfying bite every time.

Finally, provolone’s mildness makes it a crowd-pleaser, appealing to a wide range of palates, from kids to adults. Its meltability and ability to complement beef without competing flavors have cemented its status as a go-to cheese for steak subs. Whether you’re crafting a classic Philly-style sandwich or experimenting with variations, provolone’s reliability and simplicity make it an easy, winning choice for any steak and cheese sub.

American Cheese: Creamy, melts smoothly, adds richness, popular for its gooey texture in subs

American Cheese is the unsung hero of the steak and cheese sub, delivering a trifecta of texture, flavor, and meltability that elevates the sandwich from good to iconic. Its creamy consistency isn’t just a coincidence—it’s engineered through emulsification, a process that blends cheese with stabilizers like sodium citrate, ensuring it melts smoothly without breaking or clumping. This makes it ideal for layering over thinly sliced steak, where it clings to the meat and bread without pooling or hardening. For maximum gooeyness, aim for a 2:1 ratio of steak to cheese, allowing the richness of the cheese to complement the savory beef without overwhelming it.

The richness American Cheese adds isn’t just about fat content—it’s about flavor balance. Its mild, slightly tangy profile acts as a bridge between the hearty steak and the soft sub roll, rounding out the sandwich’s overall taste. To enhance this effect, toast the roll lightly before assembling the sub; the warmth will encourage the cheese to melt faster and adhere better, creating a cohesive bite. Pro tip: if using deli-sliced American Cheese, layer it directly over the hot steak to expedite melting, ensuring every corner of the sub gets its fair share of cheesy goodness.

What sets American Cheese apart in subs is its ability to maintain a gooey texture even as it cools. Unlike cheddar or provolone, which can stiffen or separate, American Cheese retains its stretch and creaminess, making it a reliable choice for eat-as-you-go meals. For a next-level experience, pair it with a sharp, tangy sauce like horseradish or pepperoncini brine—the contrast will highlight the cheese’s mild richness without overshadowing it. Just remember: less is more with condiments; a light drizzle is enough to enhance, not dominate.

Critics often dismiss American Cheese as basic, but its simplicity is its strength. It’s accessible, affordable, and consistent, making it a go-to for home cooks and sandwich shops alike. For a DIY twist, experiment with stacking two layers of cheese—one under the steak for melt-into-the-meat magic, and one on top for that signature pull-apart effect. The result? A sub that’s not just easy to make, but impossible to forget. American Cheese isn’t just a choice here—it’s the secret weapon.

Pepper Jack Cheese: Spicy kick, melts easily, pairs well with steak for bold flavor

Pepper Jack cheese brings a fiery twist to the classic steak and cheese sub, making it an ideal choice for those who crave bold flavors. Its signature blend of jalapeños and serrano peppers infuses each bite with a controlled heat that complements, rather than overwhelms, the richness of the steak. This cheese isn’t just about spice—its creamy texture and excellent meltability ensure it binds the sandwich together, creating a cohesive, mouthwatering experience. For a sub that stands out, Pepper Jack is a game-changer.

When pairing Pepper Jack with steak, consider the cut and seasoning of the meat. A well-marbled ribeye or strip steak holds up to the cheese’s intensity, while simpler seasoning—salt, pepper, and garlic—lets the peppery notes shine. To balance the heat, add cool, crisp toppings like shredded lettuce or a drizzle of ranch dressing. Pro tip: Toast the sub roll before assembling to prevent sogginess and enhance the texture contrast.

The melting properties of Pepper Jack are another reason it’s perfect for this application. Unlike harder cheeses that can clump or separate, Pepper Jack melts smoothly, evenly coating the steak and bread. For best results, shred the cheese finely or slice it thinly to ensure even distribution. If using pre-shredded cheese, avoid varieties with anti-caking agents, as they can hinder melting. Heat the sandwich in a skillet or oven until the cheese is fully melted and bubbly for maximum flavor integration.

For those wary of spice, start with a 50/50 mix of Pepper Jack and a milder cheese like provolone or mozzarella. This tones down the heat while retaining the peppery undertones. Kids or heat-sensitive palates can enjoy a milder version, while spice enthusiasts can amp it up with extra jalapeño slices or a dash of hot sauce. The versatility of Pepper Jack makes it a crowd-pleaser, adaptable to various taste preferences.

In the realm of steak and cheese subs, Pepper Jack cheese is more than just an ingredient—it’s a statement. Its spicy kick, meltability, and bold flavor profile elevate the sandwich from ordinary to extraordinary. Whether you’re crafting a quick weeknight meal or impressing guests, Pepper Jack ensures your sub leaves a lasting impression. Experiment with ratios and pairings to find your perfect balance, and let this cheese transform your next sandwich into a fiery, flavorful masterpiece.

Explore related products

Original Queso-Melt Cheese, 8 oz, 10 Pack

$64.98

EASY CHEESE American Cheese Snack, 12 - 8 oz Cans

$61.07

Carr's - Melts - Cheese - 150g (Case of 12)

$59 $72.41

Land O Lakes American Extra Melt White Process Cheese Loaf, 5 Pound -- 6 per case.

$260.62

Queso-Melt Jalapeno Cheese, 8 oz, 10 Pack

$64.98

Walnut Creek Meltz Cheese 2 Pound bar

$29.99

Cheddar Cheese: Sharp, melts well, adds tanginess, enhances steak’s natural taste in subs

Cheddar cheese, particularly the sharp variety, stands out as an ideal choice for steak and cheese subs due to its unique blend of flavor and functionality. Its sharp tanginess cuts through the richness of the steak, creating a balanced bite that elevates the overall taste experience. Unlike milder cheeses, sharp cheddar adds a depth that complements rather than overwhelms the meat’s natural flavors. This dynamic interplay ensures the steak remains the star while the cheese enhances its savory profile.

Melting properties are critical in a steak and cheese sub, and sharp cheddar excels in this area. Its high fat content and moisture levels allow it to melt smoothly, creating a creamy texture that binds the sandwich together. For optimal results, shred the cheddar finely or slice it thinly to ensure even melting. Avoid overheating, as cheddar can become oily or separate; instead, melt it over medium heat or under a broiler for a few minutes until just softened.

The tanginess of sharp cheddar serves as a counterpoint to the umami richness of the steak, preventing the sub from becoming monotonous. This contrast is particularly effective when paired with caramelized onions or sautéed peppers, which add sweetness to balance the cheese’s acidity. For a more pronounced tang, opt for a cheddar aged over 12 months, as longer aging intensifies its flavor profile. Younger cheddars, while still meltable, lack the complexity needed to stand up to robust steak flavors.

Incorporating sharp cheddar into a steak and cheese sub is straightforward but requires attention to detail. Layer the cheese directly on top of the hot steak to allow residual heat to initiate melting. Add a sprinkle of Worcestershire sauce or a dash of hot sauce to amplify the cheese’s tanginess. For a heartier sub, mix shredded cheddar with a small amount of mayonnaise or cream cheese to create a spreadable mixture that ensures even distribution. This technique also prevents the cheese from clumping or sliding off the steak.

Ultimately, sharp cheddar’s ability to melt seamlessly, its tangy flavor profile, and its enhancement of the steak’s natural taste make it a superior choice for steak and cheese subs. Its versatility allows for experimentation—whether grated, sliced, or blended into a sauce—ensuring every bite is cohesive and satisfying. By prioritizing quality cheddar and mindful preparation, even novice cooks can craft a sub that rivals those from specialty shops.

Mozzarella Cheese: Mild, stretchy, melts evenly, provides a simple, creamy texture for subs

Mozzarella cheese, with its mild flavor and stretchy texture, is an unsung hero in the world of steak and cheese subs. Its ability to melt evenly without overpowering the meat makes it a versatile choice for those seeking simplicity and creaminess. Unlike sharper cheeses that can dominate the sandwich, mozzarella complements the steak, allowing its natural flavors to shine while adding a smooth, cohesive element to each bite.

When crafting a steak and cheese sub with mozzarella, consider the cheese-to-steak ratio carefully. Aim for a 1:2 ratio (one part cheese to two parts steak) to ensure the mozzarella enhances rather than overshadows the meat. Shredded low-moisture mozzarella is ideal for this purpose, as it melts seamlessly without making the sub soggy. For best results, layer the cheese directly on top of the hot steak, allowing the residual heat to melt it naturally before assembling the sandwich.

One of the standout qualities of mozzarella in this context is its stretchiness, which adds a satisfying textural contrast to the tender steak. This characteristic is particularly appealing in a hot sub, where the cheese can be pulled apart slightly, creating a visually enticing and enjoyable eating experience. To maximize this effect, use fresh mozzarella and heat the sub briefly in a panini press or oven, ensuring the cheese reaches its optimal melt without burning.

For those seeking a practical tip, pair mozzarella with a simple seasoning blend for the steak, such as salt, pepper, and a touch of garlic powder. This minimal approach allows the mild cheese to act as a creamy binder, tying the flavors together without complicating the profile. Additionally, consider adding a thin layer of marinara sauce for a subtle Italian twist, though this is optional and depends on personal preference.

In conclusion, mozzarella’s mildness, stretchiness, and even melt make it an excellent, easy-to-use cheese for steak and cheese subs. Its ability to enhance without overwhelming, coupled with its textural appeal, positions it as a smart choice for both novice and experienced sandwich makers. By focusing on quality ingredients and mindful assembly, mozzarella can elevate this classic sub into a creamy, cohesive delight.

Frequently asked questions