Discover The Unique Flavor And History Of American Brick Cheese

American Brick Cheese is a distinctive, semi-soft cheese with a rich history rooted in Wisconsin, particularly in the town of Plymouth. Known for its rectangular brick-like shape, from which it derives its name, this cheese has a mild, slightly tangy flavor and a creamy texture that becomes more pronounced as it ages. Traditionally made from cow’s milk, it is surface-ripened and often smeared with bacteria to develop its characteristic rind and complex flavor profile. Brick cheese is versatile, used in cooking, melting, or enjoyed on its own, and holds a cherished place in Midwestern culinary traditions, especially as a key ingredient in the iconic Detroit-style pizza. Its unique production process and regional significance make it a standout in the world of American cheeses.

Explore related products

Horizon Organic American Cheese Slices, 8 oz. Pack, 12 Slices

$5.5 $5.99

Andrew & Everett White American Cheese

$9.99

Brick- Wisconsin Cheese - Mild Brick Cheese (2lb)

$15.75

Cooper Brand: Sharp American Cheese 5 Lb.

$49.99

Organic Valley American Cheese Slices, 6 Oz

$5.82 $6.99

Brick - Wisconsin Cheese - Mild Brick Cheese (16oz)

$10.5

Origins: American brick cheese originated in Wisconsin, developed by immigrant cheesemakers in the 19th century

American brick cheese, a staple in the Midwest, owes its existence to the ingenuity of 19th-century immigrant cheesemakers in Wisconsin. These pioneers, primarily from Germany and Scandinavia, brought with them traditional cheesemaking techniques but adapted them to the local resources and climate. The result was a cheese that was both practical and distinctive, shaped literally and figuratively by its environment. Unlike the soft, spreadable cheeses of their homelands, American brick cheese emerged as a semi-soft variety with a mild, tangy flavor and a firm yet pliable texture, ideal for melting and slicing.

The term "brick" in its name is no coincidence. Early cheesemakers lacked sophisticated equipment, so they pressed the curds using bricks, which gave the cheese its characteristic rectangular shape and dense consistency. This improvisational method not only solved a practical problem but also became a defining feature of the cheese. Wisconsin’s abundant dairy farms provided the high-quality milk necessary for production, while the cool, humid climate ensured optimal aging conditions. These factors, combined with the immigrants’ craftsmanship, cemented Wisconsin as the birthplace of American brick cheese.

To understand the cheese’s origins, consider the historical context of Wisconsin in the 1800s. As dairy farming expanded, cheesemaking became a vital means of preserving surplus milk. Immigrant families, often isolated in rural areas, relied on their traditional skills to create cheeses that could sustain them through harsh winters. American brick cheese was one such innovation, a testament to their resourcefulness. Its development was not just a culinary achievement but also a cultural one, reflecting the fusion of Old World techniques with New World materials.

For those interested in recreating this historical cheese, the process begins with raw cow’s milk, which is heated and curdled using rennet. After cutting and stirring the curds, they are pressed under weights (traditionally bricks) for several hours to expel whey. The cheese is then brined and aged for 1–3 months, during which it develops its signature flavor and texture. Modern cheesemakers often use food-grade bricks or presses, but the essence of the method remains unchanged. This hands-on approach ensures that each batch retains the authenticity of its 19th-century origins.

In conclusion, American brick cheese is more than just a dairy product; it’s a piece of Wisconsin’s history, shaped by the creativity and resilience of immigrant cheesemakers. Its origins highlight the intersection of necessity, tradition, and innovation, making it a unique contribution to American culinary heritage. Whether enjoyed on a sandwich, melted over a burger, or savored on its own, this cheese carries with it the story of those who crafted it over a century ago.

Texture & Flavor: Semi-soft, mild, and slightly tangy, with a firm yet creamy texture

American brick cheese, a semi-soft variety, strikes a balance between firmness and creaminess, making it a versatile choice for both cooking and snacking. Its texture is akin to a young cheddar but with a more yielding bite, allowing it to melt smoothly without losing its structure entirely. This duality is key for dishes like grilled cheese sandwiches or cheese sauces, where a cheese that can both hold its shape and blend seamlessly is ideal. For optimal melting, shred or slice the cheese thinly and heat it gradually over medium heat to preserve its creamy mouthfeel.

The flavor profile of American brick cheese is a study in subtlety—mild yet with a faint tang that lingers on the palate. This slight acidity, often described as "lactic," comes from its specific culturing process and aging, which is shorter than harder cheeses. The mildness makes it a crowd-pleaser, especially for those who find sharper cheeses overpowering. Pair it with bold flavors like spicy peppers or tangy preserves to highlight its gentle tang without overwhelming its natural notes. For a simple appetizer, serve thin slices with a drizzle of honey and a sprinkle of sea salt to enhance its creamy texture and subtle zest.

Comparatively, American brick cheese sits between mozzarella and cheddar in both texture and flavor, offering a unique middle ground. While mozzarella is softer and milder, and cheddar is firmer and sharper, brick cheese provides a creamy density and a hint of tang that sets it apart. This makes it an excellent substitute in recipes where a softer cheese might become too runny or a harder cheese might dominate the dish. For instance, use it in place of mozzarella on pizza for a richer, slightly tangy twist, or swap it for cheddar in macaroni and cheese for a creamier, less sharp result.

To fully appreciate the texture and flavor of American brick cheese, consider its role in both cold and heated applications. When served cold, its firm yet creamy texture shines, making it a satisfying snack or addition to a cheese board. When heated, its semi-soft nature allows it to melt into a luscious, cohesive mass, ideal for topping burgers or blending into dips. For a practical tip, store it in the refrigerator wrapped in wax paper to maintain moisture, and let it come to room temperature before serving to enhance its creamy qualities. This cheese’s versatility and nuanced profile make it a staple worth exploring in any kitchen.

Production Process: Made from pasteurized cow’s milk, pressed into bricks, and aged for 1-3 months

American Brick Cheese begins with a foundational ingredient: pasteurized cow’s milk. This choice is deliberate, as pasteurization eliminates harmful bacteria while preserving the milk’s natural enzymes and proteins, which are crucial for proper curdling and flavor development. Unlike raw milk, pasteurized milk ensures consistency and safety, making it ideal for large-scale production. The process starts by heating the milk to a specific temperature—typically around 160°F (71°C) for 15 seconds—before cooling it to the optimal range of 88–90°F (31–32°C) for bacterial cultures and rennet to work effectively. This step is non-negotiable; without pasteurization, the cheese risks spoilage or uneven texture.

Once the milk is prepared, bacterial cultures are added to acidify it, a critical step for coagulation. After 30–45 minutes, rennet is introduced to form a firm curd. The curd is then cut into small pieces to release whey, a process that determines the cheese’s final moisture content. Unlike softer cheeses, Brick Cheese requires a drier curd, achieved by stirring and heating the mixture to 100–102°F (38–39°C). The curds are then pressed into bricks, a signature step that gives the cheese its name and shape. This pressing removes excess whey and creates a dense, compact structure, essential for the aging process.

Aging is where Brick Cheese develops its distinctive flavor and texture. The pressed bricks are salted, either by brining or dry-salting, to enhance taste and preserve the cheese. They are then aged for 1–3 months in a controlled environment with temperatures around 50–55°F (10–13°C) and 85–90% humidity. During this time, the cheese undergoes a transformation: its flavor deepens from mild and buttery to tangy and slightly nutty, while its texture becomes semi-soft yet sliceable. The aging duration is flexible, allowing producers to tailor the cheese to specific preferences—shorter aging yields a milder taste, while longer aging intensifies complexity.

The production process of American Brick Cheese is a balance of precision and patience. Each step—from pasteurization to pressing to aging—serves a distinct purpose, contributing to the cheese’s unique characteristics. For home cheesemakers, replicating this process requires attention to detail, particularly in temperature control and aging conditions. Commercial producers often use specialized equipment to ensure consistency, but the principles remain the same. Whether enjoyed on a sandwich, melted into a dish, or savored on its own, Brick Cheese’s production process is a testament to the artistry of cheesemaking.

Finally, the versatility of Brick Cheese lies in its production method. Its semi-soft texture makes it ideal for melting, while its tangy flavor pairs well with robust ingredients like dark bread or cured meats. For those experimenting with aging, consider starting with a 1-month batch for a milder profile and extending to 3 months for a bolder experience. Proper storage—wrapped in wax or parchment paper and refrigerated—ensures the cheese retains its quality. Understanding the production process not only deepens appreciation for this American original but also empowers enthusiasts to explore its potential in their kitchens.

Explore related products

365 by Whole Foods Market, Medium Cheddar Bar, 8 oz

$3.49

Widmer’s Brick Cheese – 2.25 lb Half Loaf | Buttery & Creamy Authentic Wisconsin Brick Cheese | Perfect for Detroit Style Pizza & More

$47.95

Andrew & Everett Yellow American Cheese

$9.99

Shullsburg Creamery - 120 Slice American Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf

$35.69

Cooper Cheese CV Sharp Yellow American Cheese - 5 lb. Solid Block

$47.75

New Bridge Brick Cheese (Loaf approx. 6 pounds)

$64.98

Culinary Uses: Ideal for sandwiches, pizza, or melting due to its excellent meltability

American brick cheese, with its semi-soft texture and mild, tangy flavor, is a melting marvel in the culinary world. Its high moisture content and pH levels allow it to melt smoothly and evenly, making it a top choice for dishes where cheese is the star. Unlike harder cheeses that can become stringy or oily, brick cheese achieves a creamy, cohesive melt that enhances both texture and taste. This quality is particularly evident when used in sandwiches, where it binds ingredients together without overwhelming them.

For sandwich enthusiasts, American brick cheese is a game-changer. Its mild flavor complements rather than competes with other ingredients, making it ideal for grilled cheese sandwiches or hearty subs. To maximize its meltability, start by grating the cheese instead of slicing it—this increases surface area and promotes even melting. Layer it generously but not excessively; a ratio of 2-3 ounces of cheese per sandwich ensures a rich, gooey interior without making the bread soggy. For a crisp exterior and perfectly melted interior, cook the sandwich on medium-low heat, allowing the cheese to warm gradually.

Pizza lovers will find American brick cheese to be a versatile alternative to mozzarella or provolone. Its tangy undertones add depth to the classic tomato-and-cheese combination, while its meltability ensures a consistent, bubbly crust. When using brick cheese on pizza, shred it finely and distribute it evenly across the dough. Pair it with toppings like pepperoni, mushrooms, or caramelized onions to create a harmonious flavor profile. Bake at 450°F for 12-15 minutes, monitoring closely to achieve a golden, slightly charred crust without burning the cheese.

Beyond sandwiches and pizza, American brick cheese shines in any recipe requiring melted cheese. Think cheese sauces, fondue, or stuffed dishes like jalapeño poppers. Its ability to melt smoothly without separating makes it a reliable choice for sauces, where a grainy texture can ruin the dish. For a simple yet decadent cheese sauce, melt 4 ounces of brick cheese into 1 cup of warm béchamel, stirring constantly until fully incorporated. This sauce pairs beautifully with vegetables, pasta, or as a dip for crusty bread.

Incorporating American brick cheese into your cooking repertoire opens up a world of possibilities. Its excellent meltability, combined with its unique flavor, elevates everyday dishes into something special. Whether you’re crafting the ultimate grilled cheese, perfecting your pizza recipe, or experimenting with cheese-based sauces, brick cheese delivers consistency and richness. Keep it refrigerated until use, and allow it to come to room temperature for 15-20 minutes before cooking to ensure optimal melting. With this cheese in your kitchen, the only limit is your creativity.

Popularity: A Midwest staple, especially in Wisconsin, often used in local cuisine

American brick cheese, a Midwest culinary treasure, owes much of its enduring popularity to its deep roots in Wisconsin’s dairy heritage. Unlike its milder counterparts, brick cheese boasts a robust, slightly tangy flavor and a semi-soft texture that melts beautifully, making it a favorite in local kitchens. Its name derives from the traditional brick-shaped weights used during the cheese-making process, a nod to its artisanal origins. In Wisconsin, where cheese is practically a way of life, brick cheese is more than just an ingredient—it’s a symbol of regional pride and a testament to the state’s dairy dominance.

To truly appreciate brick cheese’s role in Midwest cuisine, consider its versatility. It’s the star of the iconic Wisconsin beer brat, where it’s melted over grilled sausages and served on a buttery bun. For a heartier dish, try it in a creamy casserole or as a topping for tavern-style pizza, where its rich flavor complements the crisp crust. Home cooks often use it in place of cheddar for a bolder macaroni and cheese, or slice it thin for a standout grilled cheese sandwich. Pro tip: pair it with a local craft beer or a sweet, tangy preserves for a flavor combination that’s distinctly Wisconsin.

What sets brick cheese apart in the Midwest isn’t just its taste—it’s its cultural significance. At state fairs, cheese curds made from brick cheese are a must-have, their squeaky texture and warm, salty flavor drawing lines of eager locals and tourists alike. In Wisconsin, cheese boards aren’t complete without a wedge of brick cheese, often served alongside rye bread and mustard for a traditional touch. Its presence at family gatherings, tailgates, and holiday tables underscores its status as a unifying element in Midwest food culture.

For those outside the Midwest looking to incorporate brick cheese into their cooking, start small. Its assertive flavor can overpower delicate dishes, so use it judiciously. A sprinkle of shredded brick cheese on a salad or soup adds depth without overwhelming other ingredients. If you’re feeling adventurous, experiment with it in recipes like stuffed mushrooms or as a filling for homemade ravioli. Remember, brick cheese is best enjoyed fresh, so seek out local producers or specialty shops to ensure you’re getting the authentic Midwest experience.

In a region where cheese is king, brick cheese reigns supreme, its popularity a testament to its unique flavor and cultural resonance. Whether you’re a Wisconsin native or a curious food enthusiast, exploring brick cheese is more than a culinary adventure—it’s a journey into the heart of Midwest tradition. So, the next time you’re in the dairy aisle, reach for a block of brick cheese and discover why it’s a staple worth savoring.

Frequently asked questions