
Papa John's cheese sticks are a popular menu item, but what is the best sauce to pair them with? Papa Johns offers a variety of dipping sauces to accompany their cheese sticks, including garlic sauce, pizza sauce, and cheese sauce. While some customers rave about the garlic sauce, others find it underwhelming and prefer the cheese dipping sauce. Ultimately, the best sauce comes down to individual taste preferences.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Number of sauces | Three (Special Garlic, Cheese, and Pizza) |
| Garlic Sauce ingredients | Garlic, mozzarella cheese |
| Cheese Sauce ingredients | Cornstarch, milk, Cheez Whiz, and jalapeno juice |
| Pizza Sauce ingredients | Tomato |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce is a popular choice for cheese stix
- The sauce is creamy and smooth with a mild garlic kick
- The sauce is made with soybean oil, water, salt, and garlic
- You can make a copycat recipe at home with margarine and garlic powder
- Other Papa John's dipping sauces include Cheese and Pizza Sauce

Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce is a popular choice for cheese stix
The Special Garlic Sauce has a strong following, with some customers ordering extra cups to dip their crusts in or to save for later with frozen pizzas. It is a signature offering from Papa John's and is often mentioned as a highlight of the menu. The sauce is also versatile, as it can be used as a topping for the dough before baking to make garlic cheese stix or as a dip for the finished product.
The garlic sauce has a mild garlic flavour that is not overpowering, with the garlic taste growing steadily in the aftertaste. This subtle yet lingering garlic kick sets it apart from other garlic sauces and makes it a unique and memorable part of the Papa John's experience. The sauce is also noted for its goopy, spreadable consistency, which adds to its appeal as a dip.
While some may prefer the butter-garlic sauce or cheese sauce, the Special Garlic Sauce stands out as a favourite among Papa John's customers. Its creamy texture, savoury taste, and subtle garlic kick make it an ideal pairing for the cheese stix, enhancing the flavour and providing a satisfying dipping experience.
Overall, Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce is a popular and well-loved choice for cheese stix. Its unique flavour and texture combination have made it a signature offering that keeps customers coming back for more. The mild garlic kick and savoury silkiness create a delicious dip that perfectly complements the cheese stix.
Mozzarella or Provolone: The Best Italian Beef Cheese?
You may want to see also

The sauce is creamy and smooth with a mild garlic kick
Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce is a great choice for dipping cheese stix. The sauce is creamy and smooth with a mild garlic kick, making it a perfect pairing for the cheesy snack.
The sauce is made with soybean oil, water, salt, and a small amount of garlic, with other natural flavors and ingredients to enhance its texture and taste. The exact ratio is hard to pinpoint, but it's a small percentage of garlic, creating a subtle garlic flavor that grows in the aftertaste. The sauce is designed to be dippable, with a soft, squeezable consistency.
The Special Garlic Sauce is a popular choice for Papa John's customers, with some even ordering extra cups to dip their crusts into or save for later. The sauce is also versatile, as it can be used with frozen pizzas from other brands.
To make a similar sauce at home, you can combine garlic powder and margarine, aiming for a 1% garlic-to-margarine ratio. For a softer, squeezable texture, Parkay margarine is a good option. Alternatively, you can use butter for a more natural taste.
The Special Garlic Sauce is a unique offering from Papa John's, providing a savory and silky dip that perfectly complements the cheese stix. Its mild garlic flavor ensures that it doesn't overpower the cheese, creating a well-balanced and enjoyable snack experience.
Best Cheeses to Start Your Day
You may want to see also

The sauce is made with soybean oil, water, salt, and garlic
Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce is a popular choice for dipping cheese stix, with some customers ordering extra cups to dip their crusts into. The sauce is made with soybean oil, water, salt, and garlic, and here is a breakdown of these ingredients:
Soybean Oil
Soybean oil is a vegetable oil extracted from soybeans, and it is often used in food products due to its neutral flavour and high smoke point. In the Special Garlic Sauce, soybean oil acts as the base ingredient, providing a smooth and creamy texture.
Water
Water is added to the sauce to thin it out and create a dipping consistency. It also helps to distribute the other ingredients evenly throughout the sauce.
Salt
Salt is included as a seasoning to enhance the flavour of the sauce. It brings out the savoury notes and balances the other ingredients, ensuring the sauce is neither too bland nor too overpowering.
Garlic
The garlic in Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce is dehydrated garlic, also known as garlic powder. It contributes a mild garlic flavour that builds steadily in the aftertaste, leaving a lingering garlicky note on the palate. The use of dehydrated garlic ensures a consistent flavour profile and a smooth texture in the sauce.
The combination of these ingredients creates a savoury, silky, and mildly garlicky sauce that has become a favourite among Papa John's customers, complementing their cheese stix and pizza crusts perfectly.
Best Cheeses for Babies: A Quick Guide
You may want to see also
Explore related products

You can make a copycat recipe at home with margarine and garlic powder
Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce is a well-loved dip for its cheese stix. The garlic sauce is creamy and smooth with a mild kick of garlic, making it a perfect dip for the crusts or cheese stix.
The garlic sauce can be recreated at home with a simple copycat recipe using two ingredients: margarine and garlic powder. Margarine is an emulsion of water and vegetable oil, which makes it easily spreadable and dippable at room temperature. The benefit of using margarine over butter is that it provides an unnaturally savory taste. The Papa John's website also clarifies that the garlic in the ingredients list is dehydrated, so it is garlic powder that is used in the sauce.
To make the copycat recipe, you can use Country Crock or Parkay margarine, as these have a similar squeezable consistency to the original sauce. The garlic powder-to-margarine ratio should be close to 1:100, as the Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce contains less than 2% garlic. Mix the ingredients and let the flavors meld for about 30 minutes before tasting.
You can also use the Special Garlic Sauce to make Papa John's cheesesticks at home. Simply brush the garlic sauce onto pizza dough, sprinkle with mozzarella cheese, and bake.
Cheese Benefits for Osteoporosis: Best Types to Eat
You may want to see also

Other Papa John's dipping sauces include Cheese and Pizza Sauce
Papa John's cheese stix are a great snack, and choosing the right dipping sauce can elevate the whole experience. While Papa John's Special Garlic Sauce is a popular choice, some other options are also available, including Cheese and Pizza Sauce.
The Cheese Sauce is a simple yet indulgent dip, perfect for those who want a double dose of cheese with their cheese stix. It is made with cornstarch, milk, and Cheez Whiz, with a kick of jalapeno juice added for a little extra flavour. This sauce is ideal for those who want a smooth and creamy dip with a hint of spice.
The Pizza Sauce is a classic choice, offering a more traditional tomato-based dip. It is made with a blend of tomatoes, spices, and herbs, simmered to perfection, creating a rich and flavourful sauce. This option is great for those who want a more robust and hearty dipping experience.
In addition to these sauces, Papa John's also offers a range of other extras, including various types of cheese, such as Provolone, Asiago, Fontina, Parmesan, and Romano. These cheeses can be used as toppings or enjoyed on the side, providing a variety of flavours and textures to enhance your cheese stix.
With these dipping sauces and extras, Papa John's cheese stix can be customised to your taste preferences, ensuring a delicious and satisfying snack experience.
Lamb Burger and Cheese: The Perfect Match
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Papa John's cheese stix are made from the same pizza dough recipe. They are a small pizza rolled out, covered in a layer of garlic sauce, then topped with mozzarella cheese.
The best sauce for Papa John's cheese stix is the Special Garlic Sauce. This sauce comes with the cheese stix as a dipping sauce.
To make the Special Garlic Sauce, combine the ingredients in a small bowl and microwave on half power for 20 seconds, stirring afterward.
Yes, Papa John's offers two other dipping sauces for their breadsticks and cheesesticks: Cheese Sauce and Pizza Sauce.

























