Provel Vs. Provolone: Unraveling The Distinct Cheese Differences

Provel and provolone cheese, though often confused due to their similar names, are distinct in origin, composition, and flavor. Provel cheese is a processed blend of Swiss, provolone, and cheddar cheeses, primarily used in St. Louis-style pizza, known for its low melting point and mild, smoky taste. In contrast, provolone is a traditional Italian cheese made from cow’s milk, available in two varieties—sweet (mild and creamy) and sharp (aged and tangy)—and is widely used in sandwiches, charcuterie boards, and pasta dishes. While provolone is a standalone, natural cheese, Provel is a regional, processed blend, highlighting their key differences in both production and culinary application.

Explore related products

BelGioioso, Sharp Provolone, 8 oz

$8.59

365 by Whole Foods Market Sliced Provolone, 8 OZ

$3.79

365 by Whole Foods Market Provolone Cheese

$9.99

Auricchio Provolone Imported From Italy Sold by the pound

$32.98

Generic Auricchio Provolone Imported Cheese from Italy 2 LB

$49

Auricchio Stravecchio Provolone- From Italy

$27.98

Origin and History: Provel is St. Louis-created, while provolone has Italian roots dating back centuries

Provel cheese, a staple in St. Louis-style pizza, is a relatively modern creation with roots firmly planted in the American Midwest. Developed in the 1940s by Italian immigrants in St. Louis, Provel was designed as a blend of Swiss, provolone, and white cheddar cheeses. This hybrid cheese was crafted to melt smoothly and evenly, making it ideal for the thin-crust, cracker-like pizzas that define St. Louis pizza culture. Its creation was a practical solution to the challenges of using traditional Italian cheeses in a fast-paced, high-volume pizzeria setting. Unlike provolone, Provel’s history is short but impactful, tied directly to the culinary identity of a single city.

In contrast, provolone cheese boasts a rich history that stretches back centuries, deeply embedded in Italian culinary tradition. Originating in the southern regions of Italy, particularly Campania and Puglia, provolone was first documented in the 16th century. Traditionally made from buffalo or cow’s milk, this semi-hard cheese was a product of rural craftsmanship, aged in caves or cellars to develop its distinctive sharp, tangy flavor. Provolone’s name is believed to derive from the Italian word *provola*, a type of cheese pulled and shaped by hand. Its enduring popularity in Italy and beyond is a testament to its versatility, used in everything from sandwiches to pasta dishes.

The divergence in origins between Provel and provolone highlights their distinct cultural significance. Provel’s creation was driven by the practical needs of St. Louis pizzerias, reflecting the ingenuity of immigrant communities adapting traditional flavors to new environments. Provolone, on the other hand, is a product of centuries-old artisanal techniques, shaped by regional Italian traditions and agricultural practices. While Provel’s history is localized and utilitarian, provolone’s is global and deeply rooted in heritage, showcasing how cheese can embody both innovation and tradition.

For those looking to appreciate these cheeses in context, consider their intended uses. Provel is best experienced atop a St. Louis-style pizza, where its meltability and mild flavor complement the crisp crust. Provolone, however, shines in its aged form, sliced thinly for antipasto platters or grated over baked dishes. Understanding their origins not only enriches the tasting experience but also highlights the ways in which cheese can reflect cultural exchange and historical evolution. Whether you’re a cheese enthusiast or a culinary historian, the stories of Provel and provolone offer a fascinating lens into the intersection of food and identity.

Ingredients and Composition: Provel blends Swiss, provolone, and cheddar; provolone is a single, aged cheese

Provel cheese, a staple in St. Louis-style pizza, is a unique blend of three distinct cheeses: Swiss, provolone, and cheddar. This combination creates a cheese with a melting profile that’s both creamy and stretchy, ideal for achieving that signature thin, crispy crust. The proportions of each cheese in Provel are carefully balanced—typically 50% Swiss for its mild, nutty flavor, 30% provolone for a sharp tang, and 20% cheddar for added richness. This blend not only enhances flavor but also improves meltability, making it a practical choice for high-heat cooking.

In contrast, provolone stands alone as a single, aged cheese with a history rooted in Italy. Made from cow’s milk, provolone undergoes a longer aging process, often 4 to 12 months, which develops its firm texture and pronounced flavor. The aging time directly impacts its taste: younger provolone is mild and slightly sweet, while older varieties become sharper and more complex. This cheese is often sliced for sandwiches or grated over pasta, showcasing its versatility in both raw and melted forms.

To understand the difference in composition, consider the fat and moisture content. Provel’s blend results in a lower moisture level compared to fresh provolone, which is why it melts evenly without pooling oil. Provolone, being a natural cheese, retains more moisture and fat, contributing to its creamy mouthfeel when melted. For home cooks, this means Provel is better suited for dishes requiring consistent texture, while provolone excels in recipes where a richer, more distinct flavor is desired.

When substituting one for the other, keep in mind their structural differences. Provel’s blended nature makes it less likely to burn or separate, whereas provolone’s higher moisture content requires careful monitoring during cooking. For instance, if using provolone in place of Provel on a pizza, reduce the oven temperature slightly to prevent scorching. Conversely, adding a touch of Swiss or cheddar to provolone can mimic Provel’s meltability in a pinch.

In summary, Provel’s engineered composition prioritizes functionality, combining the best traits of three cheeses for specific culinary applications. Provolone, with its aged, singular character, offers depth and tradition. Choosing between them depends on whether you’re aiming for consistency (Provel) or complexity (provolone). Both have their place in the kitchen, but understanding their ingredients and composition ensures you use each to its fullest potential.

Texture and Melt: Provel melts smoothly for pizzas; provolone is firmer, ideal for sandwiches

Provel cheese, a blend of Swiss, provolone, and white cheddar, boasts a texture that transforms when heated. Unlike its constituent cheeses, Provel melts into a smooth, creamy consistency, making it a favorite for St. Louis-style pizzas. This meltability ensures even coverage and a rich, gooey mouthfeel that complements the thin, crispy crust typical of this pizza style. In contrast, provolone, a semi-hard Italian cheese, retains more of its structure when heated. It softens but doesn’t liquefy, maintaining a slight chewiness that pairs well with sandwiches, where texture contrast is desirable.

For pizza makers, the choice between Provel and provolone hinges on the desired end result. Provel’s smooth melt creates a uniform layer of cheese that blends seamlessly with toppings, ideal for pizzas where a cohesive, creamy texture is key. Provolone, however, offers a firmer melt that holds its shape better, making it suitable for sandwiches where the cheese should add substance without overwhelming other ingredients. For instance, a classic Italian sub benefits from provolone’s ability to melt slightly while still providing a satisfying bite.

When experimenting with these cheeses, consider the cooking method and temperature. Provel melts optimally at 350°F to 400°F, achieving its signature smoothness within 8–10 minutes in a standard oven. Provolone, being firmer, requires slightly higher heat (400°F to 425°F) to soften without burning, and it’s best used in thinner slices to ensure even melting. For sandwiches, toast provolone under a broiler for 2–3 minutes to achieve a golden, slightly crispy exterior while maintaining its interior firmness.

The texture and melt characteristics of these cheeses also influence their pairing with other ingredients. Provel’s creamy melt works well with bold, savory toppings like pepperoni or mushrooms, as its smoothness balances their richness. Provolone’s firmer texture, on the other hand, stands up to hearty sandwich fillings like cured meats, roasted vegetables, or spreads, adding depth without losing its identity. For a practical tip, use Provel for pizzas where a uniform cheese layer is desired, and reserve provolone for sandwiches where texture variety enhances the overall experience.

Ultimately, the choice between Provel and provolone comes down to the culinary context. Provel’s smooth melt is tailor-made for pizzas, where its creamy texture elevates the dish without overpowering it. Provolone’s firmer melt, ideal for sandwiches, ensures it remains a distinct, complementary component rather than a dominant one. Understanding these differences allows chefs and home cooks alike to leverage each cheese’s unique properties, enhancing the dishes they create.

Explore related products

Provolone Cheese Premium (Sharp) One Pound. Frank and Sal Imported Cut Fresh and Vacuum Sealed Daily To Order

$28.98

Sharp Provolone Cheese--Imported from Italy

$39

Strong Provolone Valpadana DOP 2.2 lbs (1kg) - EMILIA FOOD LOVE Selected with love in Italy (Strong, Slice 2.2 lbs (1 KG))

$49.9

Dietz & Watson Pre-Sliced Provolone Cheese, 8 oz

$4.99

Organic Valley Gourmet Organic Provolone Cheese Block — Pasteurized, No Added Hormones — 8 Oz

$5.53

IGOR Mini Provolone Dolce

$19.99

Flavor Profile: Provel is mild and smoky; provolone is sharp, nutty, and more complex

Provel cheese, a blend of Swiss, provolone, and cheddar, offers a flavor profile that is distinctly mild and smoky. This combination creates a subtle, almost understated taste that pairs well with hearty dishes like St. Louis-style pizza. The smokiness, often attributed to the cheddar component, adds a gentle depth without overwhelming the palate. In contrast, provolone stands alone with its sharp, nutty, and complex character. Aged provolone, for instance, develops a more pronounced tang and a harder texture, making it a favorite for grating over pasta or slicing onto charcuterie boards. The difference in flavor intensity means provel acts as a complementary ingredient, while provolone can be the star of the dish.

To appreciate the flavor profiles, consider their applications in cooking. Provel’s mildness makes it ideal for dishes where cheese should enhance, not dominate, such as in a creamy pasta bake or a grilled cheese sandwich. Its smokiness adds a subtle layer that complements other ingredients without clashing. Provolone, on the other hand, shines in recipes where its sharpness and nuttiness can take center stage. For example, a provolone-topped bruschetta or a melted provolone dip benefits from its bold flavor. Pairing provolone with sweet or acidic ingredients, like honey or balsamic glaze, can balance its complexity and highlight its unique taste.

For those experimenting with these cheeses, a side-by-side tasting can reveal their distinct personalities. Start with a small portion of each, noting how provel’s smoothness contrasts with provolone’s bite. Add a slice of cured meat or a piece of fruit to the tasting to observe how each cheese interacts with different flavors. Provel’s mildness allows it to blend seamlessly, while provolone’s complexity stands out, creating a dynamic pairing. This exercise not only educates the palate but also inspires creative uses in cooking.

In practical terms, understanding these flavor profiles can guide better ingredient choices. If a recipe calls for a melting cheese but you want a hint of smoke, provel is the way to go. If you’re crafting a dish that needs a cheese with character, provolone delivers. For instance, a smoked chicken and provel panini offers comfort with a twist, while a provolone and fig flatbread showcases the cheese’s versatility. Knowing when to use one over the other ensures the intended flavor balance is achieved, elevating the final dish.

Finally, consider the role of aging in shaping these cheeses’ flavors. Provolone’s complexity deepens with age, becoming sharper and more crumbly, while provel’s blend maintains its consistent mildness. This makes provolone a cheese that evolves over time, offering different experiences depending on its maturity. Provel, however, remains reliably subtle, making it a safe choice for consistent results. Whether you’re a home cook or a professional chef, recognizing these nuances allows you to harness each cheese’s unique qualities to perfection.

Culinary Uses: Provel is iconic on St. Louis-style pizza; provolone is versatile in Italian dishes

St. Louis-style pizza is instantly recognizable by its thin, cracker-like crust and generous topping of Provel cheese. This processed blend of Swiss, provolone, and cheddar melts into a gooey, buttery layer that contrasts sharply with the crisp base. Provel’s mild, smoky flavor and low moisture content make it ideal for this style, as it doesn’t weigh down the dough. For authenticity, use 4–5 ounces of Provel per 12-inch pizza, distributing it evenly to ensure every slice has that signature creamy texture. Avoid overloading, as the cheese’s richness can overpower the delicate crust.

In contrast, provolone shines in Italian cuisine through its versatility and distinct character. Its semi-hard texture and sharp, tangy flavor make it a staple in dishes like lasagna, grilled cheese sandwiches, and antipasto platters. When using provolone, consider its aging: younger versions are milder and melt better, while aged provolone adds a nutty, robust kick ideal for grating over pasta or salads. For melting applications, such as in a panini, slice provolone thinly (1/8-inch) to ensure even distribution and avoid clumping.

The culinary divide between Provel and provolone reflects their origins and intended uses. Provel, a mid-20th-century invention, was designed specifically for St. Louis pizza, while provolone’s roots in southern Italy tie it to traditional Mediterranean cooking. To experiment with Provel beyond pizza, try it in a cheese dip with hot sauce or as a topping for garlic bread. Provolone, however, pairs beautifully with cured meats, olives, and crusty bread for a classic Italian appetizer.

For home cooks, understanding these cheeses’ strengths is key. Provel’s processed nature means it won’t work in recipes requiring natural cheese, like fondue or cheese boards. Provolone, on the other hand, can elevate both hot and cold dishes, from stuffed peppers to caprese skewers. When substituting, remember: Provel lacks provolone’s complexity, and provolone’s moisture content can alter the texture of St. Louis-style pizza. Stick to their iconic roles for best results, but don’t hesitate to explore creative applications within their respective domains.

Frequently asked questions