America's Favorite Cheese: Uncovering The Top Pick In Every State

When it comes to cheese, America has a diverse palate, but one variety consistently tops the charts in terms of popularity: mozzarella. Widely beloved for its versatility, mozzarella is a staple in countless American dishes, from pizza and lasagna to salads and sandwiches. Its mild, milky flavor and stretchy texture make it a favorite among both adults and children, while its affordability and widespread availability contribute to its dominance in the cheese market. Whether shredded, sliced, or fresh, mozzarella’s universal appeal ensures its place as the most popular cheese in America.

Explore related products

Kraft White American Cheese Singles, 72 Count

$28 $30

Kraft, American Cheese Slices, 16 Ounce

$29.98

Velveeta Original Pasteurized Recipe Cheese Product, 16 oz Block

$5.48

365 by Whole Foods Market Mozzarella String Cheese, 12 OZ

$4.99

Sargento Natural American Cheese Slices, 2 lbs.

$40 $42

Pace Medium Nacho Cheese Sauce, 10.5 oz Can

$1.82

Cheddar Dominance: Cheddar consistently tops U.S. cheese consumption charts, favored for versatility and flavor

Cheddar's reign as America's favorite cheese is no accident. Statistics paint a clear picture: it accounts for a staggering 26% of all cheese consumed in the U.S., dwarfing competitors like mozzarella (17%) and American cheese (10%). This dominance isn't just about numbers; it's a testament to cheddar's ability to seamlessly integrate into the American culinary landscape. From the classic grilled cheese sandwich to the sophisticated cheese board, cheddar's versatility knows no bounds.

Its appeal lies in its chameleon-like nature, adapting to both humble and haute cuisine.

Consider the humble macaroni and cheese, a dish synonymous with comfort food. While countless variations exist, cheddar remains the cornerstone, providing a sharp, tangy backbone that elevates the dish from mundane to magnificent. Its melting properties are equally impressive, creating a creamy, gooey texture that's both satisfying and indulgent. This adaptability extends beyond the kitchen. Cheddar's long shelf life and affordability make it a pantry staple, readily available in supermarkets across the country.

Whether shredded, sliced, or in block form, cheddar caters to diverse preferences and culinary needs.

However, cheddar's dominance isn't solely based on practicality. Its flavor profile is a key factor in its widespread appeal. The sharpness of cheddar, ranging from mild to extra sharp, offers a spectrum of taste experiences. This diversity allows individuals to personalize their cheese experience, catering to individual preferences. A mild cheddar might be the perfect complement to a delicate salad, while an extra sharp variety adds a bold punch to a hearty stew. This nuanced flavor profile ensures cheddar's relevance across a wide range of dishes and palates.

The cultural significance of cheddar cannot be overlooked. It's deeply ingrained in American food traditions, from backyard barbecues to holiday gatherings. Cheddar's presence on charcuterie boards, alongside crackers and fruits, is a testament to its ability to elevate any occasion. Its familiarity and accessibility make it a safe choice, a crowd-pleaser that transcends generational and regional divides. In a nation as diverse as the United States, cheddar's universal appeal is a rare and valuable asset.

Ultimately, cheddar's dominance in the American cheese market is a result of a perfect storm of factors: versatility, flavor diversity, affordability, and cultural significance. It's not just a cheese; it's a culinary chameleon, a comforting constant in a constantly evolving food landscape. Its ability to adapt, to please, and to inspire ensures its place at the top of the cheese hierarchy for years to come.

Mozzarella Rise: Mozzarella’s popularity soars due to pizza and Italian cuisine’s widespread appeal

Mozzarella's ascent to becoming one of America's most beloved cheeses is inextricably linked to the nation's love affair with pizza. Since the mid-20th century, when pizza transitioned from a niche Italian-American dish to a ubiquitous staple, mozzarella has been its undisputed star. Its meltability, stretchability, and mild flavor make it the perfect cheese for pizza, a food now consumed by over 90% of Americans monthly. This symbiotic relationship has propelled mozzarella to the top of cheese consumption charts, with the USDA reporting that Americans eat approximately 11 pounds of it per person annually.

The rise of mozzarella isn’t just about pizza, though. It’s also a testament to the broader appeal of Italian cuisine in the United States. From caprese salads to lasagna, mozzarella’s versatility has made it a cornerstone of Italian-inspired dishes that have become household favorites. Its ability to pair seamlessly with tomatoes, basil, and olive oil in a caprese salad or to add creamy texture to baked pasta dishes has cemented its place in American kitchens. As Italian cuisine continues to dominate restaurant menus and home cooking, mozzarella’s popularity shows no signs of waning.

To capitalize on mozzarella’s appeal, consider these practical tips. For pizza enthusiasts, opt for fresh mozzarella (preferably low-moisture for better melt) and shred it yourself for optimal texture. When making caprese salad, use high-quality olive oil and balsamic glaze to elevate the dish. For a healthier twist, substitute traditional mozzarella with part-skim varieties, which reduce calorie intake without sacrificing flavor. Parents can also involve kids in mozzarella-based recipes like homemade pizza or cheese sticks, fostering both culinary skills and an appreciation for Italian cuisine.

Comparatively, while cheddar remains a strong contender for America’s favorite cheese, mozzarella’s growth trajectory is unmatched. Cheddar’s popularity is rooted in tradition and versatility, but mozzarella’s rise is fueled by cultural trends and the global dominance of pizza. This distinction highlights how mozzarella’s appeal transcends mere taste—it’s a symbol of shared culinary experiences, from family pizza nights to trendy Italian eateries. As long as pizza and Italian cuisine remain staples of American dining, mozzarella’s reign is likely to continue.

Finally, the story of mozzarella’s popularity is also one of innovation. From pre-shredded bags to dairy-free alternatives, the cheese industry has adapted to meet consumer demands. For those with lactose intolerance or dietary restrictions, vegan mozzarella made from nut or soy bases offers a way to enjoy Italian favorites without compromise. Whether in its traditional form or modern iterations, mozzarella’s adaptability ensures its place at the heart of American cheese culture, proving that its rise is as much about evolution as it is about tradition.

American Cheese Usage: Processed American cheese remains a staple in burgers, sandwiches, and snacks

Processed American cheese, often simply called "American cheese," holds a unique position in the culinary landscape of the United States. Despite its reputation as a highly processed product, it remains a staple in American kitchens, particularly in the realm of burgers, sandwiches, and snacks. Its popularity stems from its meltability, consistency, and affordability, making it a go-to choice for both home cooks and fast-food chains alike. Unlike artisanal cheeses that boast complex flavors and textures, American cheese is engineered for convenience and uniformity, ensuring it performs reliably in a variety of applications.

One of the most iconic uses of American cheese is in the classic cheeseburger. Its ability to melt into a smooth, creamy layer that perfectly adheres to the patty and bun is unmatched. For optimal results, place a slice of American cheese on the burger patty while it’s still on the grill, allowing the heat to melt it slightly before transferring it to the bun. This technique ensures even coverage and enhances the overall flavor profile. Similarly, in grilled cheese sandwiches, American cheese’s low melting point and consistent texture create a golden, crispy exterior with a gooey interior, making it a favorite among both children and adults.

Beyond burgers and sandwiches, American cheese plays a significant role in snack foods. It is a key ingredient in cheese crackers, nachos, and cheese dips, where its mild flavor and smooth consistency complement rather than overpower other ingredients. For homemade snacks, consider melting American cheese with a small amount of milk (approximately 1 tablespoon per slice) to create a creamy dip that pairs well with pretzels or vegetables. Its versatility extends to party platters, where it can be cubed and served alongside cured meats and crackers for a crowd-pleasing appetizer.

While American cheese is undeniably convenient, it’s important to approach its usage with awareness of its nutritional content. A single slice typically contains around 60–80 calories, 4–6 grams of fat, and 200–300 milligrams of sodium. For those monitoring their intake, consider using it sparingly or pairing it with lighter ingredients, such as fresh vegetables or whole-grain bread. Despite its processed nature, American cheese can still be enjoyed as part of a balanced diet when consumed in moderation.

In conclusion, processed American cheese’s enduring popularity in burgers, sandwiches, and snacks is a testament to its practicality and reliability. Its unique properties make it an indispensable ingredient in American cuisine, offering both convenience and consistency. By understanding its strengths and limitations, home cooks can harness its potential to elevate everyday meals while making informed choices about its role in their diet. Whether in a classic cheeseburger or a homemade snack, American cheese continues to prove its value as a culinary staple.

Explore related products

Shullsburg Creamery - 120 Slice American Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf

$35.69

Cooper Cheese, White

$9.75

Organic Valley® Premium American Cheese — Organic, Pasture Raised, Non Gmo — 11 Ounce

$18.66

Kraft American Sliced Cheese, 5 Pound -- 4 per case.

$140.97 $157.89

BORDEN CHEESE SLICES GRILLED CHEESE MELTS SINGLES 12 OZ PACK OF 4

$49

Velveeta Original Pasteurized Recipe Cheese Product Classic Size, 32 oz Block

$6.98 $7.48

Regional Preferences: Cheese popularity varies by region, with Midwest favoring Colby and Jack

The Midwest's love affair with Colby and Jack cheeses is a testament to the region's dairy heritage and its residents' preference for mild, versatile cheeses. These two varieties dominate the cheese boards and sandwiches of Midwesterners, offering a creamy texture and subtle flavor that pairs well with the heartier dishes typical of the region. Colby, with its slightly open texture and pale yellow hue, is often enjoyed on its own or melted into casseroles, while Jack, known for its smooth consistency and mild taste, is a favorite in snacks and appetizers.

To understand this regional preference, consider the Midwest's agricultural roots. The region's fertile soil and temperate climate have long supported dairy farming, making cheese a staple in local diets. Colby and Jack cheeses, being relatively easy to produce and store, became popular among farmers and, subsequently, the general population. This historical context explains why these cheeses remain a beloved choice in the Midwest, even as other regions develop distinct tastes.

When exploring the Midwest's cheese landscape, it's essential to note the variations within the region. For instance, Wisconsin, often dubbed "America's Dairyland," boasts a strong tradition of cheese production, with Colby and Jack being among the most celebrated. However, neighboring states like Minnesota and Illinois also contribute to this preference, each adding its unique twist. In Minnesota, for example, the influence of Scandinavian cuisine might lead to a slightly different approach to using these cheeses, incorporating them into dishes like hotdishes or serving them alongside rye bread.

For those looking to embrace the Midwest's cheese culture, here’s a practical tip: when hosting a gathering, consider a cheese board featuring Colby and Jack as the stars. Pair them with local crackers, fresh fruits, and a selection of cured meats for an authentic Midwestern experience. To elevate the presentation, add a touch of regional pride by including a small flag or a map of the Midwest, highlighting the cheese's origins. This not only showcases the region's favorites but also sparks conversations about the unique culinary identity of the Midwest.

In contrast to other regions where sharper or more exotic cheeses might reign supreme, the Midwest's preference for Colby and Jack reflects a broader appreciation for simplicity and tradition. These cheeses are not just food items; they are a connection to the region's history and a symbol of its agricultural prowess. As such, understanding this preference offers a window into the cultural and culinary values of the Midwest, making it a fascinating aspect of America's diverse cheese landscape.

Gouda and Swiss Growth: Specialty cheeses like Gouda and Swiss gain traction in gourmet markets

While cheddar and mozzarella dominate American cheese sales, a quieter revolution is brewing in gourmet markets. Specialty cheeses like Gouda and Swiss are experiencing a surge in popularity, driven by a growing appetite for unique flavors, artisanal craftsmanship, and culinary exploration.

This shift reflects a maturing palate among consumers, who are increasingly seeking out cheeses that offer more than just meltability or familiarity.

Consider the rise of Gouda. Once relegated to the "fancy cheese" section, Gouda is now finding its way into mainstream consciousness. Its versatility is a key factor: from young, creamy Goudas perfect for snacking to aged varieties with complex, nutty flavors ideal for pairing with robust wines, there’s a Gouda for every taste and occasion. Look for smoked Goudas adding depth to grilled cheese sandwiches or aged Goudas gracing charcuterie boards, showcasing their ability to elevate everyday dishes.

Swiss cheese, with its distinctive eye formation and slightly sweet, nutty flavor, is also experiencing a renaissance. Beyond its classic role in sandwiches and fondue, Swiss is finding new life in gourmet applications. Shaved over salads, melted into sophisticated macaroni and cheese, or paired with fresh fruit and nuts, Swiss is proving its versatility and appeal to discerning palates.

This growth isn't just about taste. Consumers are increasingly drawn to the stories behind these cheeses. The artisanal production methods, often involving small-scale dairies and traditional techniques, resonate with a desire for authenticity and connection to food origins. Look for labels highlighting pasture-raised cows, specific regions, and aging processes – these details add a layer of narrative and value to the cheese-buying experience.

For those looking to explore this trend, start with small portions from local cheese shops or specialty grocers. Experiment with pairings – try a young Gouda with a crisp apple cider or an aged Swiss with a full-bodied red wine. Don't be afraid to ask for recommendations; cheesemongers are a wealth of knowledge and can guide you towards new favorites.

As Gouda and Swiss continue to gain traction, they're not just challenging the dominance of cheddar and mozzarella; they're expanding the American cheese landscape, offering a world of flavor and experience beyond the ordinary.

Frequently asked questions