Best Cheeses For Sandwiches: Top Picks For Flavor And Texture

When it comes to crafting the perfect sandwich, selecting the right cheese can elevate the flavor and texture to new heights. A good sandwich cheese should complement the other ingredients while adding its own unique character, whether it’s creamy, sharp, or melty. Popular choices include cheddar for its versatility and sharp tang, Swiss for its nutty flavor and ability to melt smoothly, and provolone for its slightly smoky and firm texture. For a more indulgent option, brie or goat cheese can add a rich, creamy contrast, while mozzarella provides a classic, mild base for fresh ingredients. Ultimately, the best cheese for a sandwich depends on personal preference and the overall flavor profile you’re aiming to achieve.

Explore related products

Horizon Organic American Cheese Slices, 8 oz. Pack, 12 Slices

$5.79

Kraft White American Cheese Singles, 72 Count

$27.2 $30

Velveeta Original Pasteurized Recipe Cheese Product, 16 oz Block

$5.48

Kraft, American Cheese Slices, 16 Ounce

$29.98

Land O Lakes Sliced Yellow American Premium Deli Cheese, 3 lbs.

$46

Shullsburg Creamery - 120 Slice American Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf

$35.69

Mild & Melty: Cheddar, mozzarella, provolone, Swiss, Monterey Jack. Classic, crowd-pleasing choices for any sandwich

When it comes to crafting the perfect sandwich, selecting the right cheese can elevate your creation from ordinary to extraordinary. For those who prefer a Mild & Melty experience, cheeses like Cheddar, Mozzarella, Provolone, Swiss, and Monterey Jack are classic, crowd-pleasing choices that never disappoint. These cheeses are known for their smooth textures and subtle flavors, making them versatile additions to any sandwich. Whether you're building a grilled cheese, a deli sandwich, or a panini, these mild and melty cheeses will blend seamlessly with other ingredients while adding a creamy, satisfying element.

Cheddar is a timeless favorite for sandwiches due to its mild, slightly nutty flavor and excellent melting qualities. Its firmness when cold and gooey consistency when heated make it ideal for both cold cuts and hot sandwiches. Pair it with turkey, bacon, or even a simple tomato and lettuce combo for a comforting bite. For a twist, opt for a sharp cheddar to add a bit more depth without overwhelming the other flavors.

Mozzarella, often associated with pizza, is equally fantastic in sandwiches. Its mild, milky taste and stretchy texture make it a perfect match for hearty ingredients like pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, or grilled vegetables. Fresh mozzarella can add a luxurious touch to a caprese sandwich, while shredded low-moisture mozzarella melts beautifully in a hot pressed sandwich. Its neutrality allows it to complement rather than compete with bold flavors.

Provolone strikes a balance between mildness and a slightly smoky, tangy flavor, making it a versatile choice for sandwiches. Its semi-hard texture melts well, creating a creamy layer that pairs excellently with cured meats like salami or ham. Provolone is also a great option for adding a subtle richness to vegetarian sandwiches, such as those featuring roasted red peppers or artichoke hearts.

Swiss cheese, with its distinctive holes and mild, nutty flavor, is a staple in deli sandwiches like the classic turkey club or Reuben. Its low melting point ensures it becomes gooey and creamy when heated, making it perfect for grilled or toasted sandwiches. Swiss also pairs well with tangy condiments like mustard or sauerkraut, balancing their sharpness with its smooth, buttery texture.

Monterey Jack, often referred to as Jack cheese, is another excellent choice for those seeking a mild and melty option. Its buttery flavor and smooth melt make it a fantastic addition to sandwiches like grilled cheese or chicken melts. For an extra kick, try pepper Jack, which incorporates spicy jalapeños without overpowering the sandwich. Monterey Jack’s versatility allows it to work well with both cold and hot preparations, ensuring it’s a reliable go-to for any sandwich enthusiast.

Incorporating these Mild & Melty cheeses into your sandwiches guarantees a crowd-pleasing result. Their subtle flavors and excellent melting qualities make them ideal for enhancing the overall taste and texture of your sandwich without stealing the show. Whether you're catering to picky eaters or simply aiming for a classic, comforting bite, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Provolone, Swiss, and Monterey Jack are the perfect choices to keep your sandwiches delicious and satisfying.

Sharp & Tangy: Gouda, Gruyère, aged cheddar, pepper jack. Add bold flavor to hearty sandwiches

When crafting a hearty sandwich with a sharp and tangy profile, selecting the right cheese is crucial. Gouda, a Dutch cheese with a rich, nutty flavor, adds depth and a subtle tanginess that pairs well with robust ingredients like roasted meats or caramelized onions. Its semi-hard texture melts beautifully, creating a creamy layer that binds the sandwich together. For a more pronounced tang, opt for aged Gouda, which has a firmer texture and a more intense flavor profile.

Gruyère, a Swiss cheese known for its slightly salty and earthy taste, is another excellent choice for adding boldness to sandwiches. Its exceptional melting qualities make it ideal for grilled cheese or panini, where it forms a gooey, flavorful interior. Gruyère’s complexity complements ingredients like ham, mushrooms, or spinach, elevating the overall taste experience. Its sharp, tangy notes cut through richer components, ensuring a balanced bite.

Aged Cheddar brings a sharp, pungent flavor that stands out in any sandwich. Its crumbly yet meltable texture works well in both hot and cold sandwiches. Pair it with apple slices, bacon, or pickles to enhance its tanginess. Aged Cheddar’s robust character makes it a perfect match for hearty breads like rye or sourdough, creating a sandwich that’s both satisfying and memorable.

For those who enjoy a spicy kick, Pepper Jack is an ideal sharp and tangy cheese. Infused with chili peppers and spices, it adds heat and flavor to sandwiches like Cuban sandwiches, turkey subs, or veggie melts. Its semi-soft texture melts easily, distributing its fiery tang throughout the sandwich. Pepper Jack’s boldness makes it a standout choice for those seeking an extra punch in their meal.

Incorporating these cheeses into your sandwiches ensures a sharp and tangy flavor profile that enhances the overall experience. Whether you’re building a grilled cheese, a club sandwich, or a wrap, Gouda, Gruyère, aged Cheddar, and Pepper Jack bring boldness and depth. Experiment with combinations—like layering Gruyère with aged Cheddar for a double hit of sharpness—to create sandwiches that are as flavorful as they are satisfying. These cheeses are not just ingredients; they’re the stars that transform a simple sandwich into a culinary delight.

Creamy & Spreadable: Cream cheese, goat cheese, Brie, Boursin. Perfect for soft, rich sandwich layers

When it comes to crafting a sandwich with a luxurious, velvety texture, creamy and spreadable cheeses are the ultimate choice. This category includes cream cheese, goat cheese, Brie, and Boursin, each offering a unique flavor profile and consistency that can elevate your sandwich from ordinary to extraordinary. These cheeses are perfect for creating soft, rich layers that meld beautifully with other ingredients, ensuring every bite is a delight.

Cream Cheese is a versatile staple in the creamy cheese category. Its mild, slightly tangy flavor and smooth texture make it an excellent base for both sweet and savory sandwiches. Spread it generously on bagels with smoked salmon and dill, or layer it in a turkey and avocado sandwich for added creaminess. For a creative twist, mix cream cheese with herbs or spices like chives, garlic, or everything bagel seasoning to customize its flavor to your sandwich’s theme.

Goat Cheese brings a tangy, slightly earthy flavor and a crumbly yet spreadable texture to sandwiches. Its distinct taste pairs wonderfully with fresh vegetables, grilled chicken, or roasted beets. Try spreading goat cheese on multigrain bread, then layering it with arugula, sliced pears, and a drizzle of honey for a sweet and savory combination. Its richness also balances well with lean proteins like grilled shrimp or turkey, adding depth to lighter sandwiches.

Brie, with its buttery texture and mild, nutty flavor, is a decadent choice for sandwiches. Its soft, edible rind adds a subtle complexity, making it ideal for grilled cheese sandwiches or paired with fruits like apples or figs. For a sophisticated option, layer Brie with prosciutto and arugula on a crusty baguette, or pair it with jam and turkey for a modern take on a classic tea sandwich. Brie’s melt-in-your-mouth quality ensures it blends seamlessly into any sandwich.

Boursin, a French herb-and-garlic-infused cheese, is a flavor powerhouse that requires minimal additional ingredients. Its creamy, spreadable consistency and bold taste make it a standout choice for simple yet elegant sandwiches. Spread Boursin on sourdough bread, add sliced cucumber and smoked turkey, and you have a refreshing, flavorful meal. It also works beautifully in vegetarian sandwiches, paired with roasted vegetables or grilled portobello mushrooms, adding a rich, herby dimension.

Incorporating creamy and spreadable cheeses like cream cheese, goat cheese, Brie, and Boursin into your sandwiches guarantees a soft, rich experience. These cheeses not only add texture but also enhance the overall flavor profile, making them perfect for both classic and innovative sandwich creations. Whether you’re aiming for simplicity or sophistication, these cheeses are sure to make your sandwich memorable.

Explore related products

Wisconsin Cheese Company – 100% Wisconsin Specialty Cheese Block Sampler Holiday Gift Pack (7 Blocks) – Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Swiss, Gouda, Salami, Smoked Cheddar & Tomato Basil | Perfect for Parties, Charcuterie Boards, and Holiday Gifts

$39.99

Adam's Reserve New York Extra Sharp Cheddar Slices

$5

BORDEN CHEESE SLICES GRILLED CHEESE MELTS SINGLES 12 OZ PACK OF 4

$49

Arla Dofino Havarti Cheese Slices, 24 oz.

$39.5

Tillamook Sharp Cheddar Thick Slices, 12 Ounce

$24.98

MILLERS CHEESE Sliced Muenster, 6 OZ

$9.99

Smoky & Savory: Smoked Gouda, cheddar, provolone, mozzarella. Enhance sandwiches with a smoky twist

When it comes to crafting a sandwich with a smoky and savory profile, the right cheese can make all the difference. Smoked Gouda is a standout choice for adding depth and a subtle smoky flavor. Its rich, nutty undertones complement both hearty meats like turkey or ham and vegetarian options like grilled vegetables. To enhance its smoky essence, pair it with ingredients like crispy bacon, caramelized onions, or a drizzle of barbecue sauce. Smoked Gouda melts beautifully, making it ideal for grilled sandwiches or paninis.

Cheddar is another excellent option for a smoky and savory sandwich, especially when opting for a smoked cheddar variety. Its sharp, tangy flavor pairs well with bold ingredients like roasted chicken, apple slices, or jalapeños. For a classic combination, layer smoked cheddar with thinly sliced roast beef and horseradish sauce on rye bread. Its firm texture also holds up well in cold sandwiches, ensuring every bite is packed with flavor.

Provolone brings a mild, smoky flavor and a satisfying chewiness to sandwiches. Its versatility shines in both hot and cold applications, making it perfect for Italian subs, grilled cheese, or even a simple turkey and avocado sandwich. Pair provolone with cured meats like salami or pepperoni, or use it to balance the sweetness of roasted red peppers and pesto. Its meltability ensures it blends seamlessly with other ingredients, creating a cohesive and flavorful bite.

Mozzarella, while traditionally mild, can be elevated with a smoky twist by opting for a smoked variety or pairing it with smoky ingredients. Its creamy texture and mild flavor make it an excellent base for more assertive components like smoked turkey, arugula, or sun-dried tomatoes. For a hot sandwich, smoked mozzarella melts into a gooey, stretchy delight, especially when paired with grilled eggplant or zucchini. Its freshness also balances heavier, smokier elements, ensuring the sandwich doesn’t become overwhelming.

To truly enhance your sandwich with a smoky twist, consider combining these cheeses for a layered flavor profile. For instance, a blend of smoked gouda and provolone can elevate a grilled chicken sandwich, while a mix of smoked cheddar and mozzarella adds complexity to a veggie melt. Don’t forget the importance of bread and condiments—a crusty baguette or multigrain bread pairs well with smoky cheeses, and spreads like Dijon mustard or garlic aioli can amplify the savory notes. With these cheeses, your sandwich will be a smoky, savory masterpiece.

Unique & Bold: Blue cheese, feta, halloumi, havarti. Elevate sandwiches with distinct, adventurous flavors

When it comes to crafting a sandwich that stands out, opting for unique and bold cheeses like blue cheese, feta, halloumi, and havarti can transform a mundane meal into an extraordinary experience. These cheeses bring distinct flavors and textures that cater to adventurous palates. Blue cheese, with its pungent, earthy aroma and creamy yet crumbly texture, pairs exceptionally well with sweet elements like honey, apples, or caramelized onions. Try a blue cheese and pear sandwich on multigrain bread for a balance of sharp and sweet flavors. Its boldness makes it a centerpiece, so use it sparingly to avoid overpowering other ingredients.

Feta cheese offers a tangy, salty kick that adds brightness to any sandwich. Its crumbly texture works beautifully in Mediterranean-inspired creations, such as a spinach, tomato, and olive sandwich with a drizzle of olive oil. For a bolder twist, combine feta with roasted red peppers and arugula on ciabatta. Feta’s versatility allows it to complement both hearty and light ingredients, making it a go-to for those seeking a zesty edge.

Halloumi, known for its firm texture and ability to grill or fry without melting, brings a unique chewiness to sandwiches. Its mild, slightly salty flavor pairs well with fresh vegetables like cucumbers, tomatoes, and mint. Create a halloumi and hummus sandwich with a sprinkle of za’atar for a Middle Eastern flair. Alternatively, grill halloumi slices and serve them in a baguette with pesto and arugula for a warm, satisfying bite.

Havarti, a Danish cheese with a buttery, nutty flavor and smooth meltability, is perfect for adding richness to sandwiches. Its mild yet distinctive taste complements both cold cuts and grilled vegetables. Use havarti in a grilled vegetable panini with zucchini, eggplant, and sun-dried tomatoes, or pair it with smoked turkey and cranberry sauce for a bold, seasonal twist. Its creamy texture ensures every bite is indulgent.

Incorporating these unique and bold cheeses into your sandwiches not only elevates the flavor profile but also encourages experimentation. Whether you’re crafting a quick lunch or a gourmet meal, blue cheese, feta, halloumi, and havarti offer adventurous flavors that cater to those seeking something beyond the ordinary. Don’t be afraid to mix and match these cheeses with unexpected ingredients to create sandwiches that are as memorable as they are delicious.

Frequently asked questions