Cheeseburger Cheese: Classic American Or Something Different?

The cheeseburger is an iconic American food, but what kind of cheese is normally used on a cheeseburger? The answer may depend on who you ask. Some sources claim that American cheese is the classic choice, while others suggest that cheddar, Swiss, or blue cheese are the standard options. Ultimately, the best cheese for a cheeseburger may come down to personal preference, with factors such as meltability and flavour complementarity also playing a role.

American cheese is the classic cheeseburger choice

American cheese is made by blending a cheese base (often Colby) with other ingredients such as cream, water, salt, spices, and an emulsifying agent. It is designed to melt well, and its buttery, lightly salty flavour complements the beefy taste of a burger. It is also affordable and easily accessible, making it a popular choice for a classic cheeseburger.

While some may argue that American cheese is not a "real cheese", it is a versatile option that can elevate the taste of a simple burger. It melts beautifully, creating a gooey texture that is essential to the cheeseburger experience. Its mild flavour enhances the savoury taste of the beef without overwhelming it, resulting in a well-balanced burger.

American cheese has earned its place as the classic cheeseburger choice due to its melting properties, flavour, and affordability. It has stood the test of time, remaining a favourite among cheeseburger enthusiasts across the nation.

Cheddar, Swiss, and blue cheese are also popular classic options

Cheddar, Swiss, and blue cheese are classic options for cheeseburgers. Starting with cheddar, this cheese is one of the most popular cheeseburger toppings, giving the burger a nice "tang" with its bold flavour. White or yellow cheddar varieties range from mild to sharp (or aged). Typically, younger cheddars will melt the best, so these are the best options for cheeseburgers.

Swiss cheese is another popular classic option for cheeseburgers. It is a super melting cheese and tastes extra special when paired with bacon or sautéed mushrooms. This nutty and buttery cheese has a very distinctive yet mellow taste, which makes it a great choice to add to a burger. Traditional Swiss, or Emmentaler, provides a stronger flavour profile than Baby Swiss, but it's recommended to use the younger, milder, and more buttery-flavoured Baby Swiss for cheeseburgers.

Blue cheese is another classic option for cheeseburgers. It can be melted on top or stuffed inside the burger patty. This pleasantly pungent and extremely creamy cheese makes a cheeseburger truly decadent. Blue cheese is often featured on burgers in upscale steak restaurants, along with high-end bacon. One classic example is the "Black and Blue" burger, where the ground beef patty is blackened with Cajun seasoning and topped with crumbled blue cheese. A little bit of blue cheese goes a long way, so adjust the amount to your preference!

Brie is a good choice for lamb or turkey burgers

Brie is also a good choice for turkey burgers, which tend to be on the blander side. Its creamy texture and mild flavour can add a delicious touch to turkey burgers without overpowering the meat. To enhance the creaminess, you can blend Brie with mayonnaise.

When using Brie on burgers, it's important to be careful with the melting process. Brie has a high-fat content, and if it's melted too much, the fats can start to split, affecting the overall dining experience.

For a unique twist on a Brie burger, you can experiment with different types of Brie, such as jalapeño Brie, which can add a spicy kick to your burger. However, be mindful of the other ingredients in your burger to avoid making it too sweet.

Gouda is a good pairing for filet mignon burgers

The cheeseburger is a classic American staple, but the type of cheese used can vary. The cheese you choose depends on the type of burger you're making. If you're using a high-quality meat, you might want to opt for a cheese that complements the meat without overpowering it. On the other hand, if you're using a cheaper meat, you might want a cheese with a stronger flavour to make the burger more interesting.

To make a filet mignon burger even more indulgent, you can top it with crispy onions and a gouda cheese sauce. To make the cheese sauce, simply mix butter, milk, and flour in a skillet over the coals, and then slowly add gouda until the sauce is thick and smooth. This gooey cheese sauce will melt beautifully over the burger, creating an epic backyard grilling experience.

If you're looking for a unique and delicious burger experience, a filet mignon burger with gouda cheese is an excellent choice. The sweetness of the meat and the nuttiness of the cheese will create a harmonious flavour profile that will leave you wanting more. So, fire up the grill and get ready to enjoy a mouthwatering treat!

Jack cheese is one of the best melting cheeses

Jack cheese is one of the best for melting, making it perfect for a classic, gooey cheeseburger. Its mild flavour makes it a versatile choice, pairing well with bold flavours. For example, Bobby Flay uses Jack cheese in his cheeseburger recipe, adding Mexican or Italian seasonings to the beef and topping it with Jack cheese. If you want to increase the heat, you could even opt for jalapeño, habanero, or pepper Jack cheese.

Jack cheese is not the only cheese that melts well, however. American cheese, for example, is known for its melting capabilities and is often used in cheeseburgers. It is made by blending a cheese base (usually Colby) with other ingredients such as cream, water, salt, spices, and an emulsifying agent. It typically takes about 45 seconds to melt evenly on a warm beef patty.

Mozzarella is another cheese that melts well and is a popular choice for cheeseburgers. It has excellent melting capabilities due to its elastic texture, resulting in a silky texture rather than a runny consistency. It pairs well with a beef patty as its mild, slightly sweet flavour adds contrast to the savoury meat without overwhelming it.

Brie is another cheese that melts beautifully and is an unexpected but excellent choice for a cheeseburger. It has a creamy, gooey texture and pairs well with toppings such as sautéed mushrooms. Its earthy notes of mushroom and cabbage complement the umami flavours of the beef patty.

Other cheeses that melt well on cheeseburgers include provolone, which has a buttery texture, and Swiss cheese or Emmental, which has a mild flavour.

Frequently asked questions