The Surprising Origins Of Coon Cheese: Unraveling The Name's History

The name Coon Cheese originated in Australia in the 1930s, initially branded as Coon Cheese by the Philadelphia Cream Cheese Company. The name was reportedly inspired by the American minstrel show character Coon, a derogatory and racist stereotype of African Americans. Despite its problematic origins, the name persisted for decades, sparking controversy and calls for change. In 2020, the manufacturer, Saputo Dairy Australia, rebranded the product as Cheer Cheese in response to growing public pressure and a broader societal push to eliminate racially insensitive branding. This change marked a significant step toward addressing the historical insensitivity tied to the product's name.

Explore related products

Cheese and Culture: A History of Cheese and its Place in Western Civilization

$18.99 $26.95

Cheese: A Global History (Edible)

$42 $19

Origin of the Name: Derived from the surname Coon, not a racial slur, despite common misconceptions

The name "Coon Cheese" has long been a subject of controversy, often misunderstood as a racially charged term. However, historical records and linguistic analysis reveal that the name is derived from the surname "Coon," specifically tied to Edward Coon, the American cheesemaker who developed the brand in the late 19th century. This origin story challenges the widespread assumption that the name is rooted in a racial slur, highlighting the importance of verifying historical context before drawing conclusions.

To understand this etymology, consider the timeline of the brand’s creation. Edward Coon established his cheese company in 1898, and the product was named after him, reflecting a common practice of branding items with the creator’s surname. For instance, brands like Kellogg’s and Heinz also bear their founders’ names. Coon Cheese’s name, therefore, aligns with this tradition rather than carrying a derogatory intent. Despite this, the brand faced scrutiny, particularly in Australia, where it was marketed until 2013, due to the term’s offensive connotations in certain contexts.

A comparative analysis of similar brand names underscores the distinction between intentional slurs and innocuous origins. While some products have been renamed due to clear racial undertones, Coon Cheese’s case is unique. The surname "Coon" itself has no inherent racial meaning; it is a family name with documented usage in the United States since the 17th century. This contrasts with terms explicitly created to demean, such as those found in historical advertisements or product names that have since been discontinued for their offensive nature.

For those seeking to educate others or address misconceptions, clarity is key. Start by emphasizing the historical context: Edward Coon’s role as the inventor and the naming convention of the era. Use specific examples, such as other brands named after their creators, to illustrate the pattern. Additionally, encourage critical thinking by asking questions like, “How does the origin of a name influence its perception over time?” This approach fosters understanding and dispels myths, ensuring the conversation remains fact-based rather than emotionally charged.

In practical terms, when discussing Coon Cheese, avoid assumptions and instead focus on verifiable facts. For educators or parents, this means incorporating primary sources, such as historical documents or company records, into discussions. For marketers or historians, it involves acknowledging the brand’s contentious reception while clarifying its etymology. By doing so, the narrative shifts from misinformation to education, preserving historical accuracy while addressing sensitive topics responsibly.

Creator William Coon: American cheesemaker William Coon developed the recipe in the early 20th century

The name "Coon Cheese" has its roots in the early 20th century, tied directly to its creator, American cheesemaker William Coon. Unlike many food names derived from regions or ingredients, this one is a straightforward homage to its inventor. William Coon, a pioneering figure in the American dairy industry, developed the recipe for this semi-hard, cheddar-style cheese, and his name became synonymous with the product. This practice of naming foods after their creators is not uncommon—think of Granny Smith apples or Bircher muesli—but Coon’s legacy is particularly notable for its enduring impact on American cheese culture.

Analyzing the context of Coon’s innovation reveals a time when American cheesemakers were experimenting with traditional European techniques to create distinct, locally produced cheeses. Coon’s recipe stood out for its sharp flavor and firm texture, qualities that appealed to consumers of the era. By naming the cheese after himself, Coon not only branded his product but also established a personal connection with his audience. This strategy was both practical and strategic, as it allowed him to differentiate his cheese in a competitive market. Today, while the name remains, the cheese itself has evolved, reflecting changes in consumer preferences and production methods.

To recreate Coon’s original recipe at home, start with high-quality pasteurized milk and rennet, heating the milk to 86°F (30°C) before adding the rennet to coagulate it. After cutting the curds and stirring for 20 minutes, drain and press them in a cheese mold for 24 hours, flipping halfway through. Age the cheese for at least 60 days in a cool, humid environment to develop its signature sharpness. This process, though time-consuming, offers a glimpse into Coon’s craftsmanship and the care he put into his product.

While the name "Coon Cheese" has faced controversy in recent years due to its association with racial slurs, understanding its origin in the creator’s name provides historical context. Modern producers have rebranded the cheese to distance it from offensive connotations, but William Coon’s contribution to American cheesemaking remains undeniable. His legacy serves as a reminder of how individual ingenuity can shape culinary traditions, even as societal norms and sensitivities evolve.

In conclusion, the name "Coon Cheese" is a direct tribute to its creator, William Coon, whose early 20th-century recipe left a lasting mark on the American dairy industry. By examining his innovation, we gain insight into both the history of cheesemaking and the complexities of naming conventions. Whether you’re a cheese enthusiast or a history buff, Coon’s story offers a fascinating lens through which to appreciate this classic American cheese.

Brand History: Originally Coon Cheese, rebranded to Happy Cow in 2021 to address controversy

The origins of the name "Coon Cheese" trace back to its creation in Australia in 1931 by the Allansford Cheese Company. The name was reportedly inspired by a character from a popular American comic strip of the time, "Raccoon," which was shortened to "Coon." However, the term "coon" also carries deeply offensive racial connotations, particularly in the United States, where it has been used as a derogatory slur against African Americans. Despite this, the brand name persisted in Australia for decades, largely insulated from international scrutiny due to regional differences in language and cultural awareness.

By the early 2000s, the name "Coon Cheese" began to face increasing criticism within Australia itself. Activists and consumers pointed out the racial insensitivity of the name, especially as global conversations around racial justice gained momentum. The brand’s parent company, Saputo Dairy Australia, initially defended the name, claiming it had no racial intent and was solely tied to the comic strip character. However, as public pressure mounted, the company found itself at a crossroads: maintain the controversial name or risk alienating a growing number of consumers.

In 2021, after years of debate and a formal review, Saputo announced the rebranding of Coon Cheese to "Happy Cow." This decision was framed as a response to evolving societal values and a commitment to inclusivity. The new name aimed to distance the product from its problematic past while retaining its market presence. The rebranding process involved not just a name change but also a redesign of packaging and marketing materials to reflect a more modern, family-friendly image.

The transition from Coon Cheese to Happy Cow highlights the challenges brands face when their histories intersect with sensitive cultural issues. While the name change was welcomed by many as a step toward racial sensitivity, it also sparked debates about corporate responsibility and the erasure of problematic histories. Critics argued that simply changing a name does not address systemic issues, while supporters saw it as a necessary move to align with contemporary values. For consumers, the rebranding serves as a reminder of the power of collective action in shaping corporate behavior.

Practical takeaways from this case include the importance of proactive brand audits to identify potential controversies and the need for transparency in addressing public concerns. Companies operating in diverse markets must be particularly vigilant about the global implications of their branding choices. For consumers, staying informed and engaging in conversations about brand ethics can drive meaningful change. Ultimately, the Happy Cow rebranding underscores the evolving relationship between brands, culture, and social responsibility in an increasingly interconnected world.

Australian Connection: Popularized in Australia, where it became a household name for decades

The name "Coon Cheese" has deep roots in Australian culinary history, becoming a staple in households across the country for decades. Introduced in the early 20th century, this cheese quickly gained popularity due to its versatility, affordability, and distinctive branding. Its name, however, has been a subject of controversy, prompting a rebranding in 2020 to "Cheer Cheese." Despite this change, the original name remains a significant part of Australia's cultural and gastronomic narrative.

Analyzing its rise, Coon Cheese became synonymous with everyday Australian life through aggressive marketing campaigns and widespread availability. From sandwiches in school lunches to party platters, it was a go-to ingredient for families of all ages. The cheese’s mild flavor and melt-in-the-mouth texture made it a favorite for both children and adults. Practical tips for usage included grating it over pasta, slicing it for toast, or cubing it for snacks, ensuring its place in diverse meal preparations.

Comparatively, while other cheeses struggled to penetrate the Australian market, Coon Cheese thrived by positioning itself as a reliable, budget-friendly option. Its iconic yellow packaging and consistent quality set it apart from competitors. However, the name’s association with racial slurs led to increasing public scrutiny, particularly in the 21st century. This contrast between cultural ubiquity and ethical concerns highlights the complex legacy of the brand in Australia.

Persuasively, the rebranding to Cheer Cheese reflects a broader societal shift toward inclusivity and sensitivity. While some Australians mourned the loss of a familiar name, others applauded the move as a necessary step toward progress. For those still attached to the original name, it’s worth noting that the cheese’s taste and texture remain unchanged. Embracing the new identity allows consumers to continue enjoying the product while aligning with contemporary values.

Descriptively, Coon Cheese’s Australian connection is etched into the memories of generations. Its presence at barbecues, picnics, and family gatherings created a sense of nostalgia that lingers even today. The rebranding, though significant, cannot erase its historical impact on Australian culture. By understanding this connection, consumers can appreciate the cheese’s role in shaping culinary traditions while acknowledging the importance of evolving with societal norms.

Controversy and Rebranding: Name change due to associations with racial slurs, despite non-racial origins

The name "Coon Cheese" originated in Australia in the 1930s, derived from the surname of its creator, Edward Coon, an American entrepreneur who developed a method for maturing cheese. Despite its non-racial origins, the brand name became increasingly problematic due to its phonetic similarity to a deeply offensive racial slur. This unintended association sparked widespread controversy, particularly as societal awareness of racial sensitivities grew. The name, once innocuous in its historical context, began to carry uncomfortable connotations that could no longer be ignored.

As public discourse on racial justice intensified, the brand faced mounting pressure to address the issue. Consumer boycotts, social media campaigns, and petitions highlighted the harm caused by the name, even if unintentional. The company’s initial reluctance to change the name was met with criticism, as many argued that the emotional and cultural impact outweighed the brand’s historical roots. This tension underscored a broader societal shift: the recognition that language and branding must evolve to reflect contemporary values, regardless of original intent.

The decision to rebrand Coon Cheese to "Cheer" in 2020 was a pivotal moment in corporate responsibility. The process involved extensive market research, stakeholder consultations, and a phased rollout to minimize disruption. While some consumers resisted the change, citing tradition or attachment to the original name, the rebranding was widely applauded as a necessary step toward inclusivity. This case exemplifies how companies must balance heritage with accountability, especially when their branding inadvertently perpetuates harm.

Rebranding in such cases is not merely about changing a name but about acknowledging and rectifying unintended consequences. For businesses facing similar dilemmas, a proactive approach is essential. This includes conducting thorough audits of brand names and imagery, engaging with affected communities, and committing to transparency throughout the transition. While the financial and logistical challenges of rebranding are significant, the long-term benefits of fostering trust and respect far outweigh the costs. The Coon Cheese saga serves as a cautionary tale and a roadmap for navigating sensitive cultural terrain in an increasingly aware world.

Frequently asked questions