Goat Cheddar Cheese: Where To Buy The Best

where to buy goat cheddar cheese

If you're looking to buy goat cheddar cheese, there are several options available to you. Goat cheddar is a type of cheese made from goat's milk that has a distinct flavour and texture compared to traditional cow's milk cheddar. It tends to be sweeter and smoother, with a mild goat milk flavour and a soft, creamy body. Some varieties have a semi-firm, buttery texture with hints of fresh yeast and sourdough bread. You can find goat cheddar cheese at specialty cheese shops, such as Wisconsin Cheese Mart, Central Coast Creamery, LaClare Creamery, and Murray's Cheese. These shops offer a range of goat cheddar options, including vacuum-sealed cheeses with a long shelf life and cheese and sausage gift boxes.

Characteristics Values
Texture Soft, creamy, pliable, semi-firm, buttery
Flavour Mild goat milk, mild yeast, fresh baked sourdough bread, fresh grass, fruity, light, nutty, sweet
Weight 6 oz. chunk
Colour White
Pairings Roasted nuts (pistachios, marcona almonds), maple syrup
Ingredients Pasteurized goat milk, cheese cultures, vegetarian enzymes, calcium chloride, salt
Storage Vacuum-sealed, lasts for up to 6 months when refrigerated

cycheese

Goat Cheddar from Wisconsin Cheese Mart

Goat's milk cheese has been made for thousands of years and is still extremely popular in countries where dairy cows are not commonly found. Goat cheese typically has a slightly earthier taste than cow's milk cheese and comes in a variety of forms. One such variety is the Goat Cheddar offered by Wisconsin Cheese Mart.

Wisconsin Cheese Mart's Goat Cheddar is a cheddar-style cheese formulated for goat milk cheese lovers. It is crafted by their master cheesemaker to have a soft, creamy, and pliable body with a mild goat milk flavor. The cheese is available both in its standard variety and an aged version, which is matured for a minimum of 6 months to develop a more complex flavor profile.

Wisconsin Cheese Mart offers a range of cheese and sausage gift boxes that are perfect for any occasion. These boxes can include their Goat Cheddar, providing a unique and tasty experience for those who enjoy goat milk cheese. The gift boxes are ideal for special events or holidays, such as Christmas or Thanksgiving, or even as a corporate gift idea.

The Goat Cheddar from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a versatile product that can be enjoyed in multiple ways. It can be served as part of a cheese platter, paired with wines or other beverages, or used as an ingredient in recipes that call for a mild and creamy goat cheese. The cheese's soft and pliable texture makes it easy to work with in the kitchen, and its mild flavor ensures it can complement a variety of dishes without overwhelming other ingredients.

With a rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars from 11 total reviews, the Goat Cheddar from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a well-received product. Customers have praised its creamy texture and mild flavor, noting that it is a delightful option for those who appreciate goat milk cheese. The aged version of the cheese has also been well-received, with reviewers commenting on its complex flavor and smooth finish.

cycheese

Central Coast Creamery's Goat Cheddar

This cheese is a unique offering in the marketplace, as it is made in a wheel form instead of a standard cheddar block. The cheese is cut into wedges and vacuum-sealed, ensuring a six-month shelf life when refrigerated. Central Coast Creamery's Goat Cheddar is an excellent option for a charcuterie board and can be ordered online with free shipping on qualified orders.

The cheese is priced at $10.00 and can be purchased from the CCC Deli and Cheese Shop in SLO, which is open from 11 am to 6:30 pm, or from the Paso Robles store. The Central Coast Creamery website also offers a collection of other cheeses, including Ewenique, Dream Weaver, and Big Rock Blue, which can be filtered and sorted by price.

cycheese

Cypress Grove Goat Cheddar

Cypress Grove's goat cheddar is a white cheddar made from goat's milk. It is sweeter and smoother than cow's milk cheddar, with a slightly sharp, complex, and luxurious texture. The cheese is aged for two months or more, during which it develops a nutty and savoury flavour. It is produced by Cypress Grove, a California-based company that uses goat's milk to make soft-ripened cheeses with bold flavours. The company was founded in 1983 by cheesemaker Mary Keehn, who sought to create healthy food for her family.

Cypress Grove's Humboldt Fog is one of the most famous American cheeses, with its line of ash being one of the most-copied styles. It has earned recognition both domestically and internationally and has won numerous awards, including Best of Class, American Cheese Society in 1998, 2002, 2005, and 2019, and Best of California in multiple years.

You can order Cypress Grove's goat cheddar online through their website, which offers nationwide shipping. They have also partnered with Goldbelly to provide an improved ordering experience, allowing you to order directly from the creamery.

In addition to their goat cheddar, Cypress Grove offers a range of recipes on their website, from appetisers to desserts, utilising their cheeses.

cycheese

LaClare Creamery's Goat Cheddar

LaClare Creamery is a family-owned business that takes pride in its goat cheese, pursuing perfection in flavour and quality. Their goat cheddar is made from whole pasteurized goat milk, which has a different casein protein composition from cow's milk. This gives the cheese a distinct, memorable flavour that customers love. The cheese has a fresh, fruity, and light flavour with a creamy texture. As it ages, it develops a rich, nutty, and complex taste.

LaClare's goat cheddar is available in 6 oz chunks, perfect for snacking or cooking. The cheese can be shredded, sliced, or melted, making it a versatile ingredient for various recipes. It is an excellent choice for salads, sandwiches, burgers, omelettes, or grilled cheese sandwiches. The raw milk variety also offers nutritional benefits, providing a sharp cheddar experience.

You can purchase LaClare Creamery's goat cheddar directly from their website or find it on Amazon.com. The creamery also invites visitors to come and see their goats, learn about their cheesemaking operations, and enjoy a sandwich in their cafe.

cycheese

Local cheese shops/deli counters

If you're looking to buy goat cheddar cheese from a local cheese shop or deli counter, there are a few options to consider. These specialty stores offer a variety of artisanal cheeses, including goat cheddar, and can provide expert advice and recommendations.

One option is to visit a local cheese shop that specializes in cheeses from small-batch producers and local farms. These shops often source their cheeses directly from nearby dairy farms, ensuring a fresh and unique selection. You can inquire about their goat cheddar options, which may include cheeses from local goat dairies. The staff at these shops are usually very knowledgeable about the origin and characteristics of each cheese, so they can guide you towards the perfect goat cheddar for your taste preferences.

Deli counters in gourmet grocery stores are another great option. These delis often carry a diverse range of cheeses, including goat cheddar, and can provide convenient access to other specialty food items. The staff at these counters can assist you in selecting the right cheese and may even offer recommendations for complementary foods, such as crackers or wines, to enhance your overall dining experience.

Additionally, some areas have dedicated cheese shops that focus on international or domestic cheeses. These shops may carry goat cheddars from various regions, allowing you to explore the differences in flavor and texture across different producers. For example, you might find a creamy and mild goat cheddar from Wisconsin or a semi-firm, buttery variety with hints of sourdough and fresh grass from Central Coast Creamery. These shops often pride themselves on educating their customers about the unique attributes of each cheese.

Lastly, don't underestimate the value of local farmers' markets. Many artisan cheesemakers sell their products directly to customers at these markets, and you may be able to find a local producer of goat cheddar. This option provides the added benefit of connecting directly with the cheesemaker, allowing you to learn about their specific goat herd, cheese-making process, and the distinct characteristics of their goat cheddar.

Cheddar Cheese Drying: What to Do?

You may want to see also

Frequently asked questions

There are several online retailers that sell goat cheddar cheese, including Wisconsin Cheese Mart, Central Coast Creamery, LaClare Creamery, and Murray's Cheese.

Goat cheddar cheese is typically made with pasteurized goat milk and has a mild, creamy, and fruity flavor. As it ages, it can develop a rich, nutty, and complex flavor profile. The texture is semi-firm and buttery, and it pairs well with roasted nuts and sweet flavors like maple syrup.

Goat cheddar cheese is made with goat's milk instead of cow's milk, resulting in a sweeter and smoother flavor profile compared to traditional cow's milk cheddar.

Vacuum-sealed goat cheddar cheese can last up to six months when refrigerated.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment