Where To Find Limburger Cheese In Buffalo, Ny: A Local Guide

who has limburger cheese in the buffalo ny area

For those in the Buffalo, NY area seeking the distinctively pungent and flavorful Limburger cheese, options may be limited but not impossible to find. This European-style cheese, known for its strong aroma and creamy texture, is not a staple in every local grocery store. However, specialty cheese shops, international markets, and certain gourmet delis in the region occasionally stock Limburger cheese, particularly those that focus on European imports. Additionally, online retailers and mail-order cheese shops can be a reliable source for obtaining this unique cheese, ensuring that enthusiasts in Buffalo can still enjoy its bold character.

Characteristics Values
Retailers in Buffalo, NY Area Premier Gourmet (Williamsville), Guercio’s Market (Buffalo), Wegmans (select locations)
Availability Limited; call ahead to confirm stock
Cheese Type Limburger (washed-rind, semi-soft, strong aroma)
Origin Traditionally from Germany, but some U.S. producers available
Price Range $15–$25 per pound (varies by retailer)
Special Orders Some stores may require special orders for consistent availability
Pairings Rye bread, dark beer, caraway seeds (traditional serving suggestions)
Storage Wrap in wax paper and refrigerate; consume within 1–2 weeks
Alternatives Similar cheeses like Munster or Taleggio available if Limburger is scarce
Customer Tip Check with local specialty cheese shops or delis for freshest options

cycheese

Local Cheese Shops in Buffalo NY

Buffalo, NY, may not be the first place that comes to mind when thinking about specialty cheeses like Limburger, but the city’s local cheese shops are quietly carving out a niche for themselves. One standout is West Side Tilth Market, a cooperative grocery store that sources from regional farmers and artisans. While their inventory rotates, they often carry hard-to-find cheeses, including Limburger, thanks to their commitment to supporting small producers. If you’re in the area, call ahead to confirm availability, as their stock reflects seasonal and local trends.

For a more curated experience, The Cheese Shop at The Elmwood Village is a must-visit. This boutique shop prides itself on its knowledgeable staff, who can guide you through their selection of European and American cheeses. Limburger, with its distinctive aroma and flavor, is occasionally featured in their cooler, particularly during the fall and winter months when demand for hearty, pungent cheeses peaks. Pair it with their recommended rye bread and dark beer for an authentic experience.

If you’re willing to venture slightly outside Buffalo, Brunner’s Dairy in Orchard Park is worth the trip. This family-owned business has been a staple in the region for decades, offering a wide range of cheeses, including Limburger. Their Limburger is often sourced from Wisconsin, a state renowned for its cheese production, ensuring authenticity and quality. Pro tip: Ask for a sample to appreciate its nuanced flavor before purchasing.

For those who prefer convenience without sacrificing quality, Premier Gourmet on Hertel Avenue is a reliable option. While their focus is on European imports, they occasionally stock Limburger, especially during holiday seasons when customers seek out traditional cheeses. Their staff can also suggest complementary items like mustard, pickles, or crackers to enhance your tasting experience.

Lastly, don’t overlook Guercio’s Market, a hidden gem in South Buffalo. This Italian deli and grocery store may not specialize in Limburger, but their connections to local distributors often allow them to special-order it for customers. If you’re planning a Limburger-themed event or simply craving a taste, their willingness to accommodate requests makes them a valuable resource. Always call ahead to ensure they can meet your needs.

In Buffalo, finding Limburger cheese requires a bit of insider knowledge, but the city’s local cheese shops rise to the challenge. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or a curious newcomer, these establishments offer not just a product but an experience—a chance to explore the rich, diverse world of cheese right in your backyard.

cycheese

Specialty Food Stores Near Buffalo

Buffalo, NY, may not be the first place that comes to mind when searching for specialty cheeses like Limburger, but the area is home to several hidden gems that cater to the discerning palate. One standout is Guercio’s Market, a family-owned Italian grocery in South Buffalo. While they’re best known for their fresh pasta and imported meats, their cheese counter occasionally stocks hard-to-find varieties, including Limburger. Call ahead to confirm availability, as specialty items rotate based on demand. Another notable option is Premier Gourmet in Williamsville, which prides itself on sourcing unique cheeses from around the world. Their knowledgeable staff can guide you through pairings and storage tips, ensuring your Limburger stays pungent and fresh.

For those willing to venture slightly outside Buffalo, Becker Farms in Gasport offers a farm-to-table experience with a dedicated cheese shop. While their focus is on local and artisanal cheeses, they occasionally carry Limburger, especially during peak seasons. Pair it with their freshly baked bread for a truly rustic experience. If you’re in the city center, The Cheese Shop at 500 Seneca is a must-visit. This boutique store specializes in rare and exotic cheeses, and their Limburger is often sourced from traditional European producers. Pro tip: Ask for a sample before purchasing—its strong aroma isn’t for everyone.

When hunting for Limburger, timing is key. Many specialty stores order it in limited quantities due to its niche appeal. West Side Bazaar, a multicultural marketplace in Buffalo, occasionally stocks Limburger through its European vendors, though availability can be sporadic. For a more reliable option, consider Wegmans, which, while not a specialty store, often carries Limburger in its upscale cheese section. Look for brands like Milkana or Allgäuer, which are known for their authentic German Limburger.

If you’re feeling adventurous, combine your cheese hunt with a culinary experiment. Limburger pairs surprisingly well with dark rye bread, strong mustard, and a cold pilsner. Buffalo Beer Co. in Lancaster offers a selection of local brews that complement its bold flavor. Alternatively, visit The Foundry in North Buffalo, a specialty food store with a focus on charcuterie. They can help you curate a board featuring Limburger as the star, balanced with sweet accompaniments like fig jam or pickled vegetables.

Finally, don’t overlook the power of community recommendations. Buffalo’s foodie scene thrives on word-of-mouth, so join local Facebook groups like Buffalo Foodies United or WNY Cheese Lovers for real-time updates on where to find Limburger. Some enthusiasts even suggest contacting Buffalo’s Own Cheese Company directly, as they sometimes produce small batches of Limburger-style cheeses. With a bit of persistence and creativity, you’ll uncover Buffalo’s best-kept secrets for this divisive yet beloved cheese.

cycheese

Online Retailers Shipping to Buffalo

For those in Buffalo, NY, seeking the pungent delight of Limburger cheese, online retailers offer a convenient solution. A quick search reveals several e-commerce platforms that specialize in gourmet cheeses and are willing to ship to the Buffalo area. These retailers not only provide access to this hard-to-find cheese but also ensure it arrives in optimal condition, often using insulated packaging and expedited shipping to maintain freshness.

One standout option is Murray’s Cheese, a renowned New York-based cheese shop with an extensive online catalog. They offer Limburger cheese in various sizes, typically ranging from 8 to 16 ounces, and provide detailed tasting notes to enhance your experience. To order, visit their website, select the desired quantity, and choose expedited shipping to ensure the cheese arrives within 1–2 days. Pro tip: Pair Limburger with dark rye bread and strong mustard for an authentic European experience.

Another reliable source is Igourmet, an online marketplace specializing in international foods. They stock Limburger cheese from Germany, often the Müller’s brand, known for its traditional production methods. Igourmet offers flat-rate shipping, making it cost-effective for Buffalo residents to order. When placing your order, consider adding a package of caraway crackers or pickled onions to complement the cheese’s bold flavor.

For a more curated experience, The Cheese Guy stands out with its focus on artisanal and hard-to-find cheeses. Their Limburger is sourced from small European producers and is available in pre-cut portions or whole wheels. They also provide a subscription service, ideal for cheese enthusiasts looking to explore beyond Limburger. When ordering, opt for their "cheese lover’s kit," which includes pairing suggestions and a reusable cheese storage bag.

While online retailers offer convenience, there are a few cautions to keep in mind. First, always verify the retailer’s shipping policies, as some may have restrictions or additional fees for perishable items. Second, check customer reviews to ensure the cheese arrives in good condition. Finally, plan your order around the weather—extreme heat or cold can affect the cheese’s quality during transit. By taking these steps, Buffalo residents can confidently enjoy Limburger cheese without leaving their homes.

cycheese

Farmers Markets in Buffalo Area

Buffalo's farmers markets are a treasure trove for cheese lovers, particularly those on the hunt for Limburger. While specialty shops like Guercio’s Market and Premier Gourmet occasionally stock this pungent delight, farmers markets offer a more direct connection to local producers. The Buffalo Farmers Market at Larkin Square, held Saturdays from May through October, is a prime example. Here, vendors like McCabe’s Cheese and Upstate Farms often feature artisanal cheeses, including Limburger, alongside fresh produce and baked goods. Pro tip: Arrive early, as specialty cheeses tend to sell out quickly, especially during peak seasons.

For a more intimate experience, consider the North Tonawanda Farmers Market, where smaller-scale producers showcase their wares. This market, open Thursdays from June through October, is ideal for those seeking a quieter atmosphere to chat with vendors about their craft. Limburger may not always be available, but asking vendors about their rotating selections can yield surprises. Bring a cooler with ice packs to preserve the cheese’s freshness during your visit, especially in warmer months.

If you’re willing to venture slightly outside Buffalo, the East Aurora Farmers Market is worth the trip. Held Saturdays year-round, this market prides itself on its diverse offerings, including hard-to-find cheeses. Vendors like The Farmory often collaborate with local creameries to bring unique varieties to their stands. Pair your Limburger purchase with fresh apples or crusty bread from neighboring stalls for an impromptu picnic.

For those who prefer a midweek option, the Elmwood-Bidwell Farmers Market on Tuesdays and Saturdays is a bustling hub of activity. Located in the heart of Buffalo’s Elmwood Village, this market attracts a mix of urban dwellers and suburban visitors. While Limburger isn’t guaranteed, the market’s focus on local and sustainable products increases your chances of finding it. Plus, the surrounding neighborhood offers charming cafes and shops to explore post-market.

Lastly, don’t overlook the Williamsville Farmers Market, open Sundays from May through October. This market stands out for its family-friendly vibe and emphasis on education. Many vendors offer samples, so you can test Limburger’s distinctive aroma before committing. Pair it with a local craft beer or cider for a truly regional experience. Always check market websites or social media pages for vendor lists and updates, as cheese availability can vary weekly.

cycheese

Restaurants Serving Limburger Cheese Nearby

Limburger cheese, with its distinctive aroma and rich flavor, is a rarity in the Buffalo, NY area, but a few establishments stand out for incorporating this European delicacy into their menus. One notable example is The Black Squirrel Restaurant & Pub, located in nearby Williamsville. Known for its eclectic menu, this cozy spot offers a Limburger cheese platter paired with rye bread and onions, a traditional way to enjoy this pungent cheese. The dish is a hit among adventurous diners looking to experience something beyond the ordinary.

For those willing to venture slightly further, The Anchor Bar, famous for its Buffalo wings, occasionally features Limburger cheese as part of its rotating specials. While not a permanent fixture, its inclusion highlights the growing interest in unique, bold flavors among local food enthusiasts. Pairing Limburger with a craft beer from their extensive selection can elevate the experience, as the cheese’s strong profile complements hoppy or malty brews.

If you’re seeking a more upscale setting, Seabar Sushi in downtown Buffalo has been known to experiment with Limburger in its fusion dishes. Their Limburger-stuffed mushrooms, topped with a balsamic glaze, offer a sophisticated twist on the cheese’s traditional presentation. This dish is a testament to how Limburger can be integrated into modern culinary trends, appealing to both cheese aficionados and curious diners alike.

For a DIY approach, Guercio’s Market in North Buffalo stocks Limburger cheese for those who prefer to craft their own pairings at home. While not a restaurant, this specialty grocery store is a valuable resource for sourcing the cheese locally. Pair it with dark bread, pickles, and a robust red wine for an authentic European-style snack.

In conclusion, while Limburger cheese may not be ubiquitous in Buffalo, its presence in select restaurants and markets reflects a growing appreciation for bold, unconventional flavors. Whether enjoyed in a pub, a sushi bar, or at home, this cheese offers a unique culinary adventure for those willing to explore beyond the familiar.

Frequently asked questions

Limburger cheese can be found at specialty cheese shops like West Side Bazaar or Guercio’s Market in Buffalo, NY.

Some Wegmans locations in the Buffalo area may carry Limburger cheese, but availability varies. Check the cheese section or ask a staff member.

Yes, delis like Charlie the Butcher or Anderson’s Frozen Custard (select locations) occasionally stock Limburger cheese.

Yes, online retailers like Murray’s Cheese or Igourmet offer Limburger cheese with delivery options to the Buffalo area.

The Buffalo Public Market may have vendors selling Limburger cheese, especially during peak seasons. Check with cheese vendors for availability.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment