
Middlefield Cheese, a beloved artisanal cheese known for its rich flavor and quality, is a sought-after product in New Castle, PA. For those wondering where to purchase it locally, several specialty shops and grocery stores in the area carry this popular cheese. Establishments such as local farmers' markets, gourmet food stores, and select supermarkets often stock Middlefield Cheese, ensuring residents and visitors alike can enjoy its distinctive taste. Checking with stores like Giant Eagle, local delis, or contacting nearby distributors can help locate this cheese, making it easier to add to your culinary repertoire.
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Local grocery stores selling Middlefield Cheese in New Castle, PA
- Specialty cheese shops in New Castle, PA, offering Middlefield Cheese
- Farmers markets in New Castle, PA, with Middlefield Cheese
- Online retailers delivering Middlefield Cheese to New Castle, PA
- Restaurants in New Castle, PA, featuring Middlefield Cheese on menus

Local grocery stores selling Middlefield Cheese in New Castle, PA
Middlefield Cheese, a beloved staple for cheese enthusiasts, can be found in select local grocery stores in New Castle, PA. One such store is Giant Eagle, a regional supermarket chain known for its diverse product offerings. Located at 4222 Wilmington Road, Giant Eagle stocks Middlefield Cheese in its specialty cheese section, often featuring varieties like Swiss, Baby Swiss, and Pepper Jack. For those seeking convenience, the store’s online shopping platform allows customers to check availability and order for pickup or delivery, ensuring you don’t miss out on this artisanal delight.
Another reliable option is Walmart Supercenter on 4331 New Castle Road. While primarily known for its affordability, Walmart carries Middlefield Cheese in its dairy aisle, typically offering block and shredded options. Keep an eye on their weekly ads, as Middlefield products occasionally go on sale, making it an economical choice for families or bulk buyers. Pro tip: Walmart’s app lets you scan items in-store to check prices and availability, streamlining your shopping experience.
For a more personalized shopping experience, consider visiting B&B Grocery, a local market at 1201 Mill Street. This family-owned store prides itself on supporting regional brands, including Middlefield Cheese. Here, you’ll find a curated selection of Middlefield’s premium cheeses, such as their aged cheddar and smoked varieties. The staff is knowledgeable and often shares pairing suggestions, like pairing the smoked cheese with local crackers or charcuterie. B&B also offers custom slicing, ideal for entertaining or specific recipe needs.
Lastly, Shop 'n Save on 2429 Wilmington Road is another local favorite. Their cheese counter frequently includes Middlefield’s popular marbled cheeses, perfect for adding a unique twist to sandwiches or cheese boards. Shop 'n Save’s loyalty program provides additional savings on dairy products, making it a budget-friendly option. If you’re unsure which Middlefield variety to choose, their in-store samples (available on weekends) allow you to taste before you buy.
In summary, New Castle residents have several options for purchasing Middlefield Cheese, each catering to different preferences. Whether you prioritize convenience, affordability, personalization, or loyalty rewards, these local grocery stores ensure you can enjoy this high-quality cheese without venturing far from home. Always call ahead or check online for availability, as stock may vary.
Does a Sausage Egg McMuffin Include Cheese? The Full Breakdown
You may want to see also

Specialty cheese shops in New Castle, PA, offering Middlefield Cheese
New Castle, PA, may not be the first place that comes to mind when thinking about specialty cheese shops, but it’s home to a few hidden gems that cater to cheese enthusiasts. Among the varieties they offer, Middlefield Cheese stands out for its rich, creamy texture and distinct flavors. This artisanal cheese, crafted with care, has found its way into the hearts (and refrigerators) of locals. If you’re on the hunt for Middlefield Cheese in New Castle, here’s where to look and what to expect.
One standout shop is The Cheese Corner, a family-owned establishment that prides itself on sourcing high-quality, locally made cheeses. Their selection of Middlefield Cheese includes popular varieties like the aged cheddar and smoked gouda, perfect for pairing with crackers or melting into a gourmet grilled cheese. The staff is knowledgeable and eager to offer pairing suggestions, making it a go-to spot for both seasoned cheese lovers and curious newcomers. Pro tip: Call ahead to check availability, as their inventory rotates seasonally.
Another notable destination is Farmhouse Pantry, a charming shop that combines a love for cheese with a passion for supporting local farmers. Here, Middlefield Cheese is showcased alongside other regional products, creating a one-stop shop for artisanal goods. Their Middlefield offerings often include limited-edition flavors, such as dill havarti or pepper jack, which are worth trying for their unique twists. For those planning a cheese board, Farmhouse Pantry also stocks honey, jams, and charcuterie items that complement Middlefield Cheese beautifully.
If you’re looking for a more interactive experience, The Dairy Nook offers cheese-tasting sessions where you can sample Middlefield Cheese before purchasing. This is particularly helpful if you’re unfamiliar with the brand or want to explore new flavors. Their aged Swiss and marble cheddar are customer favorites, and the shop frequently hosts events featuring local cheesemakers, giving you a deeper appreciation for the craft. Be sure to sign up for their newsletter to stay updated on tasting schedules.
For those who prefer convenience, Market Fresh Grocers carries a selection of Middlefield Cheese in their specialty cheese section. While it’s not a dedicated cheese shop, the quality and variety are impressive, making it a reliable option for last-minute purchases. Look for their pre-packaged cheese platters, which often include Middlefield varieties, ideal for entertaining or gifting.
In New Castle, PA, finding Middlefield Cheese isn’t just about the purchase—it’s about the experience. Whether you’re browsing a family-owned shop, attending a tasting, or picking up a quick selection at the grocery store, these specialty cheese shops ensure that Middlefield Cheese remains accessible and enjoyable. So, the next time you’re in the area, make it a point to explore these local treasures and savor the flavors of Middlefield Cheese.
Chuck E. Cheese in Fort Wayne, IN: Fact or Fiction?
You may want to see also

Farmers markets in New Castle, PA, with Middlefield Cheese
New Castle, PA, boasts a vibrant farmers market scene, and for cheese enthusiasts, the star attraction is undoubtedly Middlefield Cheese. This artisanal cheese, known for its rich flavors and local heritage, is a staple at several markets in the area. Here’s how to find it and make the most of your visit.
Locating Middlefield Cheese at Farmers Markets
Start your search at the New Castle Farmers Market, held weekly in downtown New Castle. Vendors here often feature Middlefield Cheese alongside fresh produce, baked goods, and handmade crafts. Another reliable spot is the Shenango Valley Farmers Market, where local dairy producers frequently showcase their wares. For a more intimate experience, visit the Lawrence County Farmers Market, which highlights small-batch cheeses, including Middlefield’s signature varieties like cheddar and Swiss. Pro tip: Arrive early, as popular cheeses tend to sell out quickly, especially during peak seasons.
Why Middlefield Cheese Stands Out
Middlefield Cheese isn’t just another dairy product—it’s a testament to Pennsylvania’s agricultural legacy. Produced by the Amish community in nearby Middlefield, Ohio, this cheese is crafted using traditional methods passed down through generations. Its distinct flavor profile, a result of grass-fed cows and slow aging, sets it apart from mass-produced alternatives. At farmers markets, you’ll often find samples, allowing you to taste the difference firsthand. Pair it with local honey or freshly baked bread for a truly authentic experience.
Maximizing Your Farmers Market Visit
To fully enjoy your trip, plan ahead. Check market schedules online, as hours and locations can vary seasonally. Bring cash, as some vendors may not accept cards. Engage with the vendors—they’re a wealth of knowledge about their products and can offer pairing suggestions or storage tips. For families, many markets include kid-friendly activities, such as petting zoos or cooking demonstrations, making it a fun outing for all ages. Don’t forget reusable bags to carry your purchases sustainably.
Supporting Local Economy Through Cheese
Buying Middlefield Cheese at farmers markets isn’t just about indulging in delicious food—it’s a way to support local farmers and artisans. By purchasing directly from vendors, you’re contributing to the economic vitality of New Castle and its surrounding communities. Plus, you’re reducing your carbon footprint by choosing products that don’t travel long distances. It’s a win-win: you get premium cheese, and local producers thrive. So next time you’re at a market, make Middlefield Cheese your go-to choice for flavor and impact.
Sargento Colby-Jack Stick Cheese Recall: What You Need to Know
You may want to see also
Explore related products
$4.99 $9.9

Online retailers delivering Middlefield Cheese to New Castle, PA
For those in New Castle, PA, seeking the rich, creamy flavor of Middlefield Cheese, online retailers offer a convenient solution. While local stores may carry limited selections, e-commerce platforms provide access to a broader range of Middlefield’s artisanal cheeses, from sharp cheddar to pepper jack. These retailers often include detailed product descriptions, customer reviews, and shipping options tailored to preserve freshness during transit.
One standout option is Amish Country Foods, an online marketplace specializing in authentic Amish products. They stock Middlefield Cheese in various sizes and flavors, with shipping options that ensure the cheese arrives in optimal condition. Their website features a user-friendly interface, allowing customers to filter by type, weight, and price. For New Castle residents, standard shipping typically takes 3–5 business days, with expedited options available for last-minute needs.
Another reliable source is Yoder’s Homestead, which offers Middlefield Cheese alongside other Amish-made goods. Their website includes a "Cheese of the Month" club, ideal for enthusiasts looking to explore new varieties regularly. Yoder’s provides detailed care instructions, such as storing cheese in a cool, humid environment to maintain its texture and flavor. They also offer flat-rate shipping for orders over $50, making it cost-effective for bulk purchases.
For those prioritizing sustainability, The Cheese Guy stands out. This retailer partners with Middlefield Cheese to deliver products in eco-friendly packaging, reducing environmental impact. Their website includes a "Cheese Pairing Guide," offering suggestions for crackers, wines, and fruits that complement Middlefield’s offerings. Shipping to New Castle is handled via refrigerated trucks to ensure freshness, with delivery times ranging from 2–4 days.
When ordering online, consider these practical tips: check for seasonal discounts, especially during holidays; verify the retailer’s return policy for damaged or spoiled items; and opt for insulated packaging if ordering during warmer months. By leveraging these online retailers, New Castle residents can enjoy Middlefield Cheese without leaving home, making it easier than ever to savor this artisanal delight.
Stop Complaining: Turn Your Whine into a Productive Mindset with Cheese
You may want to see also

Restaurants in New Castle, PA, featuring Middlefield Cheese on menus
New Castle, PA, may not be the first place that comes to mind when thinking about gourmet cheese, but local restaurants are quietly elevating their menus with Middlefield Cheese, a regional gem. This artisanal cheese, known for its rich flavors and handcrafted quality, is making appearances in unexpected ways, from appetizers to main courses. For food enthusiasts, discovering which eateries feature Middlefield Cheese is like uncovering a hidden treasure, offering a taste of local pride and culinary creativity.
One standout is The Almond Tree, a cozy bistro that pairs Middlefield’s sharp cheddar with house-made apple chutney in their grilled cheese sandwich. The dish is a masterclass in simplicity, letting the cheese’s nutty, tangy notes shine. Another notable mention is Cascata, where the chef incorporates Middlefield’s smoked gouda into a creamy risotto, adding depth and a subtle smoky finish. These examples illustrate how restaurants are using the cheese not just as an ingredient, but as a focal point to celebrate local craftsmanship.
For those looking to explore further, The Cooper’s Brick Oven Winery offers a charcuterie board featuring Middlefield’s herb-infused cheeses, paired with their own wines for a truly regional experience. Meanwhile, The Tavern on the Square takes a bold approach by incorporating Middlefield’s blue cheese into a decadent burger, balancing richness with a tangy kick. Each restaurant’s treatment of the cheese highlights its versatility, proving it’s more than just a snack—it’s a culinary chameleon.
To make the most of this local specialty, consider timing your visit during seasonal menus, as chefs often experiment with limited-edition Middlefield varieties. For instance, autumn might bring a pumpkin-spiced cheese paired with roasted vegetables, while spring could feature fresh herb-infused options. Calling ahead to confirm availability is also a practical tip, as artisanal cheeses can sell out quickly. By seeking out these dishes, you’re not just enjoying a meal—you’re supporting local farmers and chefs who are passionate about showcasing Pennsylvania’s best.
In a town where chain restaurants often dominate, these establishments stand out by embracing Middlefield Cheese as a symbol of authenticity and quality. Whether you’re a resident or a visitor, exploring these menus offers a unique way to connect with New Castle’s culinary identity. So, the next time you’re in the area, skip the ordinary and opt for a dish that tells a story—one that begins in a local creamery and ends on your plate.
Gordon Ramsay's Honest Take on The Cheesecake Factory
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Middlefield Cheese is available at local grocery stores, specialty shops, and farmers' markets in New Castle, PA. Check stores like Giant Eagle, Walmart, or local delis for availability.
Yes, stores like Giant Eagle, Walmart Supercenter, and local specialty shops like Deluca’s Market often carry Middlefield Cheese products.
Middlefield Cheese is typically distributed through retail stores. However, you can contact local distributors or check the Middlefield Cheese website for direct purchase options.
Yes, Middlefield Cheese is often sold at local farmers' markets in New Castle, PA. Check the Lawrence County Farmers' Market or similar venues for availability.





![Artisan Cheese Making at Home: Techniques & Recipes for Mastering World-Class Cheeses [A Cookbook]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/81eH1+cYeZL._AC_UL320_.jpg)










![QUESO!: Regional Recipes for the World's Favorite Chile-Cheese Dip [A Cookbook]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/91YLsuAZ1xL._AC_UL320_.jpg)








