Parmesean Cheese: A Vegetarian's Dilemma

why is parmesean cheese not vegetarian

Parmesan cheese is not considered vegetarian because of the presence of rennet, an enzyme derived from the inner lining of the fourth stomach of calves, goats, or lambs, which are usually slaughtered for veal. While some cheeses are made with microbial rennet, which is harvested from the fermentation of a type of fungus, or vegetable rennet, made by boiling certain plants, traditional Parmesan cheese uses animal rennet. This has led to the creation of vegetarian alternatives to Parmesan, such as Gran Kinara cheese, which is made with vegetable rennet.

cycheese

Rennet, an enzyme derived from animal stomachs, is used in the production of Parmesan

The use of rennet, an enzyme derived from animal stomachs, is a key part of the Parmesan production process. Rennet is traditionally obtained from the inner lining of the fourth stomach of young, milk-fed ruminant grazing animals, such as calves, goats, or lambs. This stomach is particularly valued due to its high concentration of the enzyme chymosin, which is responsible for coagulating milk. The process of extracting rennet involves slicing these stomachs into small pieces, which are then soaked in a salt water or whey solution with an acidic component to draw out the enzymes. This production method, which has been used for centuries, renders Parmesan non-vegetarian by most standards.

The European Union's legal definition of Parmesan specifically mandates the use of calf rennet in the Reggiano region of Italy, where the cheese originates. This traditional production method, known as Parmigiano-Reggiano, is protected by a "Protected Designation of Origin" (PDO) status, ensuring that only cheeses produced in specific Italian regions using traditional methods can bear the name.

While Parmigiano-Reggiano always contains animal-derived rennet, some other varieties of Parmesan may be produced without it. Vegetarian alternatives to rennet include microbial enzymes that mimic chymosin, as well as vegetable rennet derived from various plants such as cardoon thistle, artichokes, nettles, and dried caper leaves. These plant-based sources can provide coagulating properties similar to those of animal rennet, allowing for the production of vegetarian-friendly Parmesan cheeses.

It is important to note that not all cheeses labelled as Parmesan are true Parmigiano-Reggiano, and some may be produced with vegetarian alternatives to rennet. However, for those seeking strictly vegetarian options, it is advisable to look for cheeses labelled as vegetarian or to check the ingredient list for enzymes instead of rennet.

cycheese

Rennet is not vegetarian, but there are vegetarian alternatives to it

Parmesan cheese is not vegetarian because it contains rennet, an enzyme derived from the inner lining of the fourth stomach of calves, goats, or lambs. While rennet is crucial to the traditional production of Parmigiano Reggiano, it is not vegetarian by most standards. However, there are alternatives to animal-derived rennet, and some companies produce vegetarian Parmesan cheese.

Rennet is a coagulant that separates curds from whey during the cheese-making process. Traditionally, it is obtained by slicing the stomachs of young calves and soaking them in an enzyme extraction solution. This practice has been used for centuries and is integral to producing many classic old-world cheeses, including Parmigiano Reggiano and English Cheddars. However, the use of animal rennet in cheese-making has become a concern for vegetarians and those wishing to avoid animal products.

To address this issue, vegetarian alternatives to rennet have been developed. These alternatives include vegetable rennet, which can be made by boiling plants such as cardoon thistle, artichokes, or nettles in water and straining the mixture with a cheesecloth. The resulting liquid contains enzymes that functionally mimic the coagulating properties of animal rennet. Various Iberian cheeses, such as Azeitão, have traditionally used plant rennet, making them good options for vegetarians.

In addition to vegetable rennet, microbial rennet is another vegetarian alternative. It is an enzyme harvested from the fermentation of a fungus called Rhizomucor miehei. Chymax, derived from yeast, is another non-animal rennet option. While it uses genetic material from animal stomach cells, the final product does not contain animal material, making it technically vegetarian. These alternatives allow cheese producers to create vegetarian-friendly versions of Parmesan and other cheeses.

Some grocery stores and specialty food companies offer vegetarian Parmesan cheese options. For example, Organic Valley offers a shredded Parmesan made with organic milk and vegetable-based enzymes, replicating the flavor of traditional Parmesan. BelGioioso and GOOD PLANeT Foods also produce vegetarian Parmesan. These options allow vegetarians to enjoy the complex flavors of Parmesan without compromising their dietary choices.

In conclusion, while traditional Parmesan cheese is not vegetarian due to the use of animal-derived rennet, there are viable alternatives. Vegetarian rennet sources, such as vegetable and microbial enzymes, have made it possible to produce vegetarian-friendly Parmesan cheese. With these alternatives, consumers can make informed choices that align with their dietary preferences and ethical considerations.

cycheese

Parmesan is often made with animal rennet, but some varieties are vegetarian

Parmesan cheese is often made with animal rennet, which is derived from the inner lining of the fourth stomach of calves, goats, or lambs. This makes the cheese unsuitable for vegetarians. However, it is important to note that not all Parmesan cheese is made with animal rennet, and some varieties are vegetarian-friendly.

The use of rennet is a traditional method of cheese-making, dating back to the Middle Ages. It is an enzyme that coagulates and separates milk into curds and whey. While animal rennet is derived from the stomachs of young, milk-fed ruminant animals, there are now vegetarian alternatives available. These alternatives include vegetable-based enzymes, obtained by soaking plants like artichokes, cardoon thistle, nettles, or thistles, and microbial-based enzymes, which are made from mold enzymes extracted in a lab.

Some grocery stores sell clearly labeled vegetarian Parmesan cheese alternatives made with these vegetarian enzymes. For example, Organic Valley Shredded Parmesan offers a vegetarian-friendly version, and producers like BelGioioso also have their own vegetarian versions. Additionally, some soft cheeses like cottage cheese, cream cheese, or paneer are reliably vegetarian because they are made with an acid, such as lemon juice or vinegar, as their coagulant instead of rennet.

When in doubt, vegetarians can look for kosher labels on cheese products, which signify that the product did not interact with meat. Checking the ingredient list is also essential, as some cheeses will be labeled as suitable for vegetarians or list \"microbial enzyme\" or \"vegetarian enzyme\" instead of rennet. However, it is important to note that traditional cheeses, such as Parmigiano-Reggiano, are unlikely to be made with non-animal rennet.

While the availability of vegetarian Parmesan cheese is positive, some people argue that the obsession with finding vegetarian cheeses misses the point. They suggest that the focus should be on the broader issue of animal slaughter in the dairy industry, as male dairy calves, which are typically used for rennet, have no value on dairy farms and are often sold for veal.

Is Parmesan Romano Cheese Pasteurized?

You may want to see also

cycheese

Rennet is used in most cheeses, not just Parmesan

Rennet is a crucial ingredient in the Parmigiano Reggiano production process, which is the style of cheese that Parmesan is modelled after. Rennet is derived from the inner lining of the fourth stomach of young, grazing animals like calves, goats, or lambs. This stomach is prized for its concentration of the enzyme chymosin, which is responsible for curdling milk as part of the animal's digestion.

While rennet is essential to Parmesan, it is also used in most other cheeses, including cheddar, feta, Manchego, and Swiss, as well as Italian cheeses like Pecorino Romano, Grana Padano, and Gorgonzola, and French and Swiss cheeses like Camembert, Vacherin, Emmenthaler, and Gruyère. Rennet is used to coagulate milk, separating the solid milk particles from the water to form curds, which are essential for the formation of cheese.

The use of rennet in cheese is not a new discovery. Since at least Roman times, cheese makers have been using rennet to coagulate milk, and alternatives to animal rennet have been sought and found. These alternatives include microbial enzymes that mimic the effects of chymosin, as well as various plants such as cardoon thistle, artichokes, and nettles, and even fig juice. These non-animal sources of rennet are suitable for vegetarians and are used in some cheeses, making them vegetarian-friendly.

Today, most cheese is made using chymosin derived from bacterial sources, and fermentation-produced chymosin (FPC) is widely used in industrial cheesemaking due to its lower cost and commercial viability. FPC has been available since 1990 and has become the preferred choice for many cheese producers, taking up to 90% of the global market share for rennet by 2017.

In summary, while the discovery that Parmesan contains rennet may be disappointing to vegetarians, it is important to note that rennet is used in most cheeses, not just Parmesan. However, alternatives to animal-derived rennet exist, and some cheeses are made with these vegetarian sources, providing options for those who wish to avoid animal rennet.

cycheese

Rennet-free cheeses are often labelled as vegetarian or list microbial enzymes

Rennet is a crucial ingredient in the Parmigiano Reggiano production process. It is an enzyme used to coagulate and thicken milk, forming curds and separating them from whey. Rennet is usually derived from the stomach of a young grazing animal, such as calves, goats, or lambs. This makes it unsuitable for vegetarians.

Parmesan cheese is modelled after Parmigiano-Reggiano, and while all cheeses labelled Parmigiano-Reggiano contain animal-derived rennet, Parmesan can be either vegetarian or non-vegetarian. Rennet-free Parmesan cheeses are often labelled as vegetarian or list microbial enzymes. Some brands that sell vegetarian Parmesan include Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, Bel Gioioso, and Cabot.

Vegetarian alternatives to Parmesan and other European cheeses bypass the use of rennet and instead use microbial enzymes that mimic the effects of chymosin. These enzymes are derived from various plants, such as cardoon thistle, artichokes, or nettles, which are boiled in water and strained to leave behind a thickening enzyme similar to chymosin. While these non-animal alternatives are less popular due to their unpredictable nature and potential to produce unwanted flavours, they are viable options for vegetarians.

It is important to note that cheesemakers are not required to specify on their packaging whether they use animal or vegetable rennet. Therefore, it is advisable to consult resources such as the Vegetarian Resource Group or lists provided by specialty stores like Trader Joe's to identify vegetarian-friendly cheeses.

Frequently asked questions

Parmesan cheese is not vegetarian because it contains rennet, which is derived from the inner lining of a calf's fourth stomach. Calves are usually slaughtered for veal.

Rennet is an enzyme used to clot milk. It is a coagulant that forms curds and separates them from whey.

Yes, there are some vegetarian alternatives to Parmesan cheese available in the market. Some brands include Follow Your Heart, Whole Foods, Trader Joe's, Organic Valley, BelGioioso, and GOOD PLANeT Foods.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment