Why Reblochon Cheese Remains Banned In The United States

Reblochon cheese, a beloved French cheese from the Haute-Savoie region, is illegal in the United States due to strict FDA regulations regarding raw milk cheeses. The FDA mandates that cheeses made from unpasteurized milk must be aged for at least 60 days to reduce the risk of bacterial contamination, such as E. coli and Listeria. Reblochon, traditionally made from raw cow's milk and aged for only 3 to 4 weeks, does not meet this requirement. This ban reflects broader concerns about food safety in the U.S., despite the cheese's popularity and cultural significance in Europe. Efforts to import Reblochon have been unsuccessful, leaving American cheese enthusiasts to either seek alternatives or travel abroad to enjoy this creamy, nutty delicacy.

Explore related products

French Cheese (Eyewitness Companions)

$20.74

French Cheeses: The Visual Guide to More Than 350 Cheeses from Every Region of France

$32.09

igourmet French Cheeses for the Connoisseur Assortment - Includes Tomme de Savoie French Cheese, Nutty Comte, French Camembert and Gourmet Creamy Fourme d'Ambert From France

$109.95

French Cheese Epoisses AOC - 8.8 oz / 250 g - OVERNIGHT GUARANTEED

$64.9

French Cheese Prefere de Nos Montagnes Reblochon Style - 1.1 lb / 500 g

$64.9

Roquefort Papillon Cheese 2x3 LBS RW - French Blue Cheese - Creamy and Tangy Flavor Perfect for Charcuterie Boards Gift Set From The Cheese Lover Shop

$135

Unpasteurized milk regulations in the US and their impact on Reblochon cheese imports

Reblochon cheese, a creamy French delicacy, remains elusive to American consumers due to stringent U.S. regulations on unpasteurized milk products. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) mandates that all milk used in cheese production must be pasteurized unless the cheese is aged for at least 60 days, a process intended to eliminate harmful bacteria like *Salmonella* and *E. coli*. Reblochon, however, is traditionally made with raw milk and aged for only three weeks, falling short of this requirement. This regulatory barrier effectively bans its import, leaving enthusiasts to wonder why such a cherished cheese remains inaccessible.

To understand the impact of these regulations, consider the science behind pasteurization. Heating milk to 161°F (72°C) for 15 seconds kills pathogens but also alters the milk’s microbial flora, which can affect the cheese’s flavor and texture. Reblochon’s distinctive nutty, earthy profile relies on the natural enzymes and bacteria present in raw milk. Pasteurization, while safer, would strip the cheese of its unique character, rendering it a mere imitation of the original. For purists, this compromise is unacceptable, making the FDA’s rule a non-negotiable hurdle for Reblochon’s entry into the U.S. market.

Despite the ban, there are workarounds for those determined to taste authentic Reblochon. Some artisanal cheesemakers in the U.S. have begun producing raw-milk cheeses that comply with the 60-day aging rule, though these are not true Reblochon. Others travel to Canada or Mexico, where the cheese is available, to purchase it legally. However, importing it personally into the U.S. remains illegal, as customs officials strictly enforce the FDA’s regulations. For now, the only way to enjoy Reblochon in its traditional form is to visit France or other countries where raw-milk cheeses are embraced.

The debate over unpasteurized milk regulations highlights a broader clash between food safety and culinary tradition. While the FDA prioritizes public health, critics argue that the risks of raw-milk cheese are minimal when produced under strict hygienic conditions. In France, Reblochon has been safely consumed for centuries, with producers adhering to rigorous standards. This raises the question: could the U.S. adopt a more nuanced approach, allowing certain raw-milk cheeses with proven safety records? Until then, Reblochon remains a forbidden fruit, a symbol of the cultural divide between precaution and preservation of artisanal practices.

FDA restrictions on raw milk cheeses aged under 60 days

The FDA's restriction on raw milk cheeses aged under 60 days stems from a 1949 regulation aimed at reducing foodborne illness risks. This rule, codified in 21 CFR 133.149, mandates that raw milk cheeses must be aged at least 60 days at a minimum temperature of 35°F (1.7°C) to ensure the destruction of harmful pathogens like *Salmonella*, *E. coli*, and *Listeria*. The rationale is that prolonged aging in controlled conditions creates an environment inhospitable to these bacteria, significantly lowering the risk of contamination. This regulation applies uniformly to all raw milk cheeses, regardless of origin, making Reblochon—a French cheese typically aged for only 3–4 weeks—non-compliant for U.S. import.

From a practical standpoint, cheesemakers and importers face a dilemma when attempting to bring raw milk cheeses like Reblochon into the U.S. market. The 60-day aging requirement alters the cheese's texture, flavor, and overall character, often detracting from its traditional qualities. For example, Reblochon's soft, creamy texture and nutty flavor develop during its short aging period; extending this process would result in a harder, less characteristic product. This regulatory hurdle not only limits consumer access to authentic versions of such cheeses but also stifles the diversity of artisanal cheese offerings in the U.S.

Critics argue that the FDA's one-size-fits-all approach overlooks advancements in modern cheese production and safety protocols. Many European countries, including France, have stringent regulations and testing standards that ensure raw milk cheeses are safe for consumption without requiring extended aging. For instance, Reblochon produced in France adheres to Appellation d'Origine Protégée (AOP) standards, which include rigorous hygiene practices and microbial testing. Advocates for raw milk cheeses suggest that the FDA could adopt a risk-based approach, allowing exceptions for cheeses produced under similarly strict safety protocols, rather than enforcing a blanket rule.

For consumers eager to experience raw milk cheeses like Reblochon, there are a few workarounds, though none are perfect. Some U.S. cheesemakers produce pasteurized versions of traditionally raw milk cheeses, which comply with FDA regulations but often lack the complexity of their raw counterparts. Others travel to countries where these cheeses are legal or purchase them during visits abroad. However, importing raw milk cheeses for personal use remains risky, as customs officials may confiscate them upon entry. The most effective long-term solution would involve advocacy for regulatory reform, encouraging the FDA to reconsider its aging requirements in light of modern food safety practices.

In conclusion, the FDA's 60-day aging restriction on raw milk cheeses, while rooted in public health concerns, creates barriers to enjoying traditional cheeses like Reblochon in the U.S. This regulation highlights the tension between food safety and culinary tradition, leaving consumers and producers to navigate a system that prioritizes caution over innovation. Until policy changes occur, the U.S. market will continue to miss out on the full spectrum of global cheese diversity.

Health risks associated with unpasteurized Reblochon cheese consumption

Unpasteurized Reblochon cheese, a French delicacy, poses significant health risks due to its raw milk content. Unlike pasteurized dairy products, raw milk can harbor harmful bacteria such as *Listeria monocytogenes*, *E. coli*, and *Salmonella*. These pathogens thrive in the cheese’s soft, creamy texture and can cause severe illnesses, particularly in vulnerable populations. For instance, *Listeria* infections, though rare, have a high mortality rate, especially among pregnant women, newborns, the elderly, and immunocompromised individuals. A single serving of contaminated Reblochon could introduce enough bacteria to trigger symptoms like fever, muscle pain, and gastrointestinal distress, escalating to life-threatening conditions like meningitis or septicemia.

Consider the process of Reblochon production: raw cow’s milk is minimally treated, preserving both beneficial and harmful microorganisms. While traditionalists argue this enhances flavor, it also increases the risk of bacterial contamination. Studies show that raw milk cheeses are 50 to 160 times more likely to cause outbreaks than their pasteurized counterparts. For example, a 2019 outbreak in France linked to Reblochon sickened over 100 people, primarily children under 5, with *E. coli* infections. Such incidents highlight the critical need for caution when consuming unpasteurized dairy products, especially for at-risk groups.

To minimize health risks, consumers should follow specific guidelines. Avoid unpasteurized Reblochon if you are pregnant, elderly, or have a weakened immune system. Always store the cheese at temperatures below 40°F (4°C) to slow bacterial growth, and consume it within a week of purchase. Pairing Reblochon with acidic foods or beverages, such as wine or vinegar-based dressings, can also help reduce bacterial viability. However, these measures are not foolproof, and the safest option remains choosing pasteurized alternatives.

Comparatively, countries like the U.S. have stricter regulations on raw milk cheeses, requiring a 60-day aging process to reduce pathogen levels. Yet, Reblochon’s shorter aging period often fails to meet these standards, leading to its prohibition in the U.S. market. This regulatory difference underscores a broader debate: balancing culinary tradition with public health. While Reblochon’s unique flavor profile is celebrated in France, its potential health risks cannot be ignored, particularly in a global context where food safety standards vary widely.

In conclusion, the health risks associated with unpasteurized Reblochon cheese are not theoretical but grounded in documented outbreaks and scientific evidence. Vulnerable individuals must exercise caution, and all consumers should weigh the sensory pleasures of this cheese against its potential dangers. Until production methods evolve to ensure safety, Reblochon’s illegality in the U.S. remains a protective measure rather than a culinary restriction.

Explore related products

Triple Creme Brie by Marin French (3 pack)

$59.94

French Cheese Camembert Le Bocage - 8.8 oz - Imported From France Cow Milk

$64.9

Papillon Roquefort Black Label A.O.C Blue Cheese - 1 lb.

$64.99

Fromager d'Affinois French Cheese - 4.4 lb Wheel - Luxurious Double Crème Cow's Milk Cheese, Brie-Style, Perfect for Gourmet Cooking and Entertaining

$143.51

French Cheese Chaumes - 1 pound

$59.75

French Cheese Saint André - 7 oz / 198 g

$54.9

Alternatives to Reblochon available in the US market

Reblochon cheese, a French delicacy, remains elusive to American consumers due to FDA regulations prohibiting the import of unpasteurized milk cheeses aged less than 60 days. This restriction stems from concerns over potential bacterial risks, leaving enthusiasts searching for suitable substitutes. Fortunately, the U.S. market offers several alternatives that mimic Reblochon’s creamy texture, nutty flavor, and meltability, ensuring your tartiflette or cheese board doesn’t suffer.

For Tartiflette Enthusiasts: Raclette Cheese

If you’re craving the gooey, indulgent experience of Reblochon in a tartiflette, raclette cheese is your best bet. Both cheeses hail from the Alps and share a similar meltability. Opt for French or Swiss raclette, which has a comparable mild, nutty profile. When preparing tartiflette, layer thinly sliced raclette over potatoes and bacon, then bake until bubbling. Pro tip: Use a dedicated raclette grill for an authentic, interactive dining experience, especially when entertaining guests.

For Cheese Boards: Saint-Nectaire

Saint-Nectaire, another French AOC cheese, is a worthy addition to cheese boards in place of Reblochon. Its semi-soft texture and earthy, slightly fruity flavor profile align closely with Reblochon’s characteristics. Pair it with crusty bread, fresh figs, or a glass of Pinot Noir to elevate the experience. Look for pasteurized versions available in specialty cheese shops or online retailers like Murray’s Cheese or Igourmet.

For Fondue Lovers: Gruyère and Comté Blend

While Reblochon is traditionally used in Savoyard fondue, a blend of Gruyère and Comté can achieve a similar richness and depth. Combine equal parts of these two cheeses, both readily available in the U.S., for a fondue that’s creamy, nutty, and slightly sweet. Add a splash of dry white wine and a clove of garlic to enhance the flavor. This combination melts smoothly and provides a luxurious texture akin to Reblochon-based fondues.

For the Adventurous: American Artisan Cheeses

Domestic cheesemakers have stepped up to fill the Reblochon void with innovative alternatives. Cheeses like Vermont Creamery’s Bijou or Cypress Grove’s Humboldt Fog offer unique twists while maintaining a creamy, spreadable texture. Bijou, aged for 60 days to comply with FDA regulations, has a buttery, tangy flavor that pairs well with charcuterie. Humboldt Fog, with its ash-veined center, adds a dramatic touch to any cheese board. These options not only satisfy Reblochon cravings but also support local artisans.

By exploring these alternatives, Reblochon enthusiasts can still enjoy the essence of this French classic without crossing legal or safety boundaries. Whether you’re crafting a tartiflette, assembling a cheese board, or experimenting with fondue, these substitutes ensure no culinary tradition is left behind.

Efforts to legalize Reblochon cheese through regulatory changes or modifications

Reblochon cheese, a French delicacy with a rich, creamy texture and a history dating back to the 13th century, remains illegal in the United States due to its production methods, which involve raw, unpasteurized milk. The FDA’s strict regulations prohibit the sale of cheeses made from raw milk unless they have been aged for at least 60 days, a process Reblochon does not undergo. This ban has sparked efforts from cheese enthusiasts, importers, and lawmakers to legalize Reblochon through targeted regulatory changes or modifications. These initiatives aim to reconcile the cheese’s traditional production methods with U.S. safety standards, ensuring consumers can enjoy this cultural staple without compromising public health.

One key strategy involves petitioning the FDA to amend the 60-day aging rule for specific cheeses like Reblochon. Advocates argue that the rule, designed to reduce pathogens in raw milk cheeses, does not account for the unique microbial environment of traditional French cheeses. Scientific studies could be commissioned to demonstrate that Reblochon’s production process, including its specific bacterial cultures and low moisture content, naturally inhibits harmful pathogens. Such evidence could form the basis of a targeted exemption, allowing Reblochon to bypass the aging requirement while meeting safety benchmarks. Importers and cheese guilds are already collaborating with food scientists to build this case, emphasizing the importance of data-driven advocacy in regulatory reform.

Another approach focuses on modifying Reblochon’s production methods to comply with U.S. regulations without sacrificing its distinctive flavor. Some European producers have experimented with thermalization, a gentler alternative to pasteurization that heats milk to lower temperatures, preserving more of its original characteristics. If Reblochon could be produced using thermalized milk, it might meet FDA standards while retaining its traditional taste. However, this method faces resistance from purists who argue it would alter the cheese’s authenticity. Balancing tradition with compliance requires careful negotiation, potentially involving protected designation of origin (PDO) status to ensure any modifications do not dilute Reblochon’s cultural identity.

Legislative action also plays a role in these efforts. Bills have been introduced in Congress to grant waivers for cheeses with PDO status, recognizing their cultural and economic significance. Such legislation would allow Reblochon and other traditional cheeses to enter the U.S. market under specific conditions, such as stringent testing for pathogens. Lobbying efforts by cheese importers and culinary organizations are crucial to advancing these bills, highlighting the economic benefits of legalizing Reblochon, including increased tourism and trade opportunities. Public awareness campaigns, such as social media movements and cheese festivals, further amplify these efforts, rallying consumer support for regulatory change.

Ultimately, legalizing Reblochon in the U.S. requires a multi-faceted approach combining scientific research, production innovation, and legislative advocacy. While challenges remain, the growing demand for artisanal cheeses and appreciation for global culinary traditions provide momentum for change. By addressing regulatory barriers with practical solutions, stakeholders can pave the way for Reblochon’s legalization, allowing Americans to savor this French treasure while upholding food safety standards. The journey is complex, but the reward—a slice of Reblochon on a charcuterie board—makes the effort worthwhile.

Frequently asked questions