Shane Dawson's Chuck E. Cheese Controversy: Lawsuit Looming?

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson, in which he discussed the theory that Chuck E. Cheese recycled leftover pizza slices to create new pizzas. Dawson's video sparked widespread online discussion and led to an official response from Chuck E. Cheese, who denied the claims. Despite the franchise's denial and the lack of evidence, Dawson's theory gained traction, with many social media users taking it as fact. While Chuck E. Cheese did not sue Dawson, the YouTuber faced backlash and was banned from the establishment.

Shane Dawson's conspiracy theory about Chuck E. Cheese's pizza

YouTuber Shane Dawson has popularised a conspiracy theory about Chuck E. Cheese's pizza. In a 2019 video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", Dawson and his friends discuss the theory that Chuck E. Cheese employees take leftover pizza slices, bring them back to the kitchen, and plate them to be re-served to new customers. Dawson then visits a Chuck E. Cheese restaurant and orders several pizzas. He notices that the pizzas are misshapen, with the crust misaligned and the pepperonis not lining up. He also points out that some slices are longer than others.

Dawson claims that he has "definitely proven" that the pizza halves weren't originally together and that there is a reason for the misshapen pizzas, but he can't say it "legally". He implies that the reason is related to his earlier conspiracy theory.

Chuck E. Cheese responded to Dawson's video, stating that the claims made are "unequivocally false" and that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough, which is why they are not always perfectly uniform in shape. They also denied that they recycle pizzas. Additionally, some former employees have stated that the conspiracy theory is not true, and that the uneven slices are due to mistakes made during the cutting process.

Chuck E. Cheese's denial of the conspiracy theory

Chuck E. Cheese's denial of Shane Dawson's conspiracy theory was swift and emphatic. The pizza chain released an official statement to several news outlets, including E! News, refuting the claims made in Dawson's video. The statement read:

> "The claims made in this video about Chuck E. Cheese's and our pizza are unequivocally false. No conspiracies here—our pizzas are made to order, and we prepare our dough fresh in our restaurant, which means that they're not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious."

The company also took to Twitter to address the conspiracy directly, tweeting:

> "Nope, all our pizzas are made fresh by our team of talented pizza pros. Each 'za is handmade which means the amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings might vary – but it still tastes great."

Trisha York, the senior manager of Knoxville's Chuck E. Cheese, also strongly denied the claims, asserting that "we've never 'recycled' pizzas – never! – and I've been here 10 years."

Despite the strong denial from Chuck E. Cheese, the conspiracy theory gained traction on social media, with many users taking it as fact and demanding an explanation from the company. However, as one source points out, Dawson's theory had several flaws, including the fact that a misaligned crust doesn't prove much, and that it's unlikely that enough untouched pizza slices would be left behind by customers to create entirely new pizzas.

The evidence Dawson used to support his theory

In a 2019 video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", YouTuber Shane Dawson shared a conspiracy theory about the pizza chain Chuck E. Cheese. The theory, which Dawson claimed to have believed since childhood, alleged that Chuck E. Cheese would take slices from leftover pizzas and combine them to create new pizzas.

• Visual Evidence: Dawson presented visual evidence in the form of pictures from the internet and his own personal observations. He showed images of pizzas from Chuck E. Cheese where the slices did not seem to match up to form a perfect circle, and toppings such as pepperoni were misaligned. This irregularity in shape and topping distribution led Dawson to believe that the pizzas were made from recycled slices rather than freshly made dough.
• Hands-on Investigation: Dawson and his friends conducted their own investigation by visiting a local Chuck E. Cheese and ordering multiple pizzas, including a pepperoni, a half-and-half, and a margarita. Upon receiving their order, they noticed that the pepperoni and half-and-half pizzas appeared mismatched, as if they were not originally from the same pizza. This seemed to support Dawson's theory that the pizzas were made from different slices.
• Personal Testimony: Dawson shared his personal experiences with Chuck E. Cheese pizzas, claiming that when he ordered pizza from them as a child, it often looked like a collection of randomly placed slices rather than a freshly made pizza.
• Public Speculation: Dawson was not the first to propose this conspiracy theory. As early as 2009, internet users on platforms like Yahoo! Answers had speculated about the possibility of Chuck E. Cheese recycling pizza slices. This pre-existing speculation added fuel to Dawson's theory and suggested that the practice may have been going on for years.

While Dawson's theory gained traction and sparked intense online discussions, it was not without its flaws. Chuck E. Cheese denied the allegations, releasing an official statement to several news outlets, including E! News, refuting the claims and asserting that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough, which can result in slight variations in shape and toppings. Additionally, former Chuck E. Cheese employees offered alternative explanations for the mismatched slices, attributing them to errors in the cutting process rather than intentional recycling.

The response from Chuck E. Cheese employees

Chuck E. Cheese employees were quick to deny the conspiracy theory. The senior manager of Knoxville's Chuck E. Cheese, Trisha York, strongly denied the claims, asserting that the restaurant had never recycled pizzas in her ten years of working there. Other employees also came forward, explaining that the handmade dough and giant cutter used to prepare the pizzas contributed to their uneven shape and mismatched slices.

In addition to employee responses, Chuck E. Cheese released an official statement to several news outlets, addressing the conspiracy:

> "The claims made in this video about Chuck E. Cheese's and our pizza are unequivocally false. No conspiracies here—our pizzas are made to order, and we prepare our dough fresh in our restaurant, which means that they're not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious."

The franchise also took to Twitter to address the allegations directly, stating:

> "Nope, all our pizzas are made freshly by our team of talented pizza pros. Each 'za is handmade which means the amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings might vary – but it still tastes great."

Despite the strong denial from Chuck E. Cheese and its employees, the conspiracy theory sparked widespread online discussion and attracted significant attention. Some social media users were shocked that many people took the theory as fact, while others speculated about the actual conditions within the restaurant chain that may have contributed to the appearance of mismatched pizza slices.

While Chuck E. Cheese did not sue Shane Dawson over the conspiracy theory, the incident highlighted the power of online platforms in shaping public perception and the potential impact of such allegations on a business's reputation.

Whether Chuck E. Cheese can sue Shane Dawson

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", in which he discussed the theory that Chuck E. Cheese recycled its pizza slices. In the video, Dawson and his friends ordered several pizzas at a Chuck E. Cheese restaurant and observed that the pizzas were misshapen, with misaligned crusts and toppings. Dawson claimed that this was evidence that the pizza chain recycled leftover slices from customers to create new pizzas.

The conspiracy theory gained a lot of attention, and Chuck E. Cheese released an official statement denying the claims and explaining that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough, which can result in uneven shapes. Despite the denial, some social media users continued to spread the theory, and Chuck E. Cheese faced accusations of lying.

As for whether Chuck E. Cheese can sue Shane Dawson, it is important to note that while Dawson's video presented his observations and theories, he did not explicitly state that his claims were facts. He framed his content as a conspiracy theory and included disclaimers in his videos. Additionally, the theory had been circulating on the internet as early as 2009, and Dawson was not the one who originally created it. These factors make it challenging to pursue legal action against him for defamation or slander.

Furthermore, Chuck E. Cheese's response to the situation was focused on denying the allegations and clarifying their pizza-making process. They did not indicate any intention to take legal action against Dawson. In fact, they may have more to lose by suing Dawson, as it could bring negative publicity and potentially validate the conspiracy theory in the eyes of some people.

Therefore, while Chuck E. Cheese has denied the claims made by Shane Dawson, it is unlikely that they will sue him. The company has already issued a strong denial and provided explanations for the uneven pizza slices, which should be sufficient to address the situation.

Frequently asked questions