American Cheese Vs. Kraft Singles: Unraveling The Melty Mystery

The question of whether American cheese and Kraft Singles are the same often sparks curiosity among cheese enthusiasts and casual consumers alike. American cheese, a processed cheese variety, is known for its mild flavor, smooth texture, and melting properties, commonly used in sandwiches and burgers. Kraft Singles, on the other hand, is a specific brand of individually wrapped processed cheese slices, often associated with American cheese due to its similar characteristics. While both share a comparable taste and consistency, Kraft Singles is a branded product, whereas American cheese is a broader category. This distinction raises the question: are they interchangeable, or do subtle differences set them apart in terms of ingredients, production, and culinary use?

Explore related products

Horizon Organic American Cheese Slices, 8 oz. Pack, 12 Slices

$6.65

Amazon Grocery, Pasteurized Process American Cheese, 16 Oz, 24 Ct (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary)

$2.48

Kraft Deli Deluxe American Cheese Slices, 16 oz Pack, 24 Slices

$4.68

Land O Lakes® Sliced White Deli American Cheese Product, 8 oz

$3.96

Land O Lakes Yellow Deli American Cheese, Packaged Sliced Cheese, 8oz, 10 Slices

$3.96

Dietz & Watson Deli-Sliced White American Cheese, 12 oz

$6.99

Ingredients Comparison: American cheese vs. Kraft Singles' processed cheese food ingredients

American cheese and Kraft Singles may seem interchangeable, but their ingredient lists reveal stark differences. American cheese, traditionally a blend of cheeses like Cheddar and Colby, relies on a simple base: milk, cheese culture, salt, and enzymes. Kraft Singles, labeled as "pasteurized prepared cheese product," contains a more complex mix: milk, whey, milk protein concentrate, and a slew of additives like sodium citrate, sodium phosphate, and sorbic acid. This distinction highlights Kraft Singles’ engineered nature, designed for meltability and shelf stability, versus American cheese’s closer ties to natural cheese-making processes.

Consider the role of milk in both products. American cheese typically uses fresh, whole milk as its primary ingredient, contributing to its creamy texture and richer flavor. Kraft Singles, however, lists milk as its first ingredient but also includes whey and milk protein concentrate, which are byproducts of cheese production. These additions serve as cost-effective protein sources and emulsifiers, ensuring the product’s smooth, uniform consistency. For those prioritizing whole-food ingredients, American cheese’s reliance on fresh milk may be more appealing.

Additives are where the two diverge most dramatically. Kraft Singles contains preservatives like sorbic acid to extend shelf life, artificial colorings for uniformity, and emulsifiers like sodium phosphate to prevent separation when melted. American cheese, while sometimes containing minimal stabilizers, generally avoids such additives. This makes American cheese a better option for those sensitive to preservatives or seeking a product closer to traditional cheese. However, Kraft Singles’ additives are FDA-approved and safe in moderation, making it a convenient choice for specific applications like grilled cheese sandwiches.

Fat content is another key difference. American cheese typically contains around 25-30% milk fat, contributing to its richness. Kraft Singles, labeled as "reduced-fat," contains approximately 16% milk fat, with added water and stabilizers to maintain texture. While this makes Kraft Singles lower in calories, it also dilutes the cheese flavor, often requiring more product to achieve the same taste impact. For calorie-conscious consumers, Kraft Singles may be preferable, but flavor purists will likely favor American cheese’s higher fat content.

Finally, consider the intended use. Kraft Singles’ engineered ingredients make it ideal for consistent melting and convenience, perfect for sandwiches or quick snacks. American cheese, with its simpler composition, offers a more authentic cheese experience, better suited for dishes where flavor and texture take precedence. Understanding these ingredient differences allows consumers to choose the product that best aligns with their culinary needs and health preferences.

Melting Properties: How Kraft Singles differ in meltability from traditional American cheese

Kraft Singles and traditional American cheese may look similar, but their melting properties reveal stark differences. Kraft Singles, engineered for consistency, contain emulsifiers like sodium citrate and sodium phosphate, which ensure a smooth, even melt without separating into oil and solids. Traditional American cheese, while also processed, lacks these additives in the same concentration, leading to a slightly grainier texture when melted and a higher likelihood of oil pooling. This distinction makes Kraft Singles a go-to for dishes requiring a flawless, uniform melt, like grilled cheese sandwiches or cheeseburgers.

To understand why Kraft Singles outperform in meltability, consider their composition. They are formulated with a higher ratio of moisture and stabilizers, which lower the cheese’s melting point and create a more fluid consistency. Traditional American cheese, though still processed, retains more of the natural cheese proteins, resulting in a firmer melt that holds its shape better. For example, in a cheese sauce, Kraft Singles will blend seamlessly, while traditional American cheese may require additional stirring to achieve uniformity. This makes Kraft Singles ideal for applications where a quick, even melt is critical.

If you’re experimenting with melting cheese, temperature control is key. Kraft Singles begin to melt at around 150°F (65°C), while traditional American cheese typically requires 160°F (71°C) or higher. To test this, place both cheeses on a skillet over medium heat. Kraft Singles will liquefy rapidly and spread evenly, whereas traditional American cheese will soften more gradually and retain some texture. For best results, use Kraft Singles in recipes where a smooth, cohesive melt is desired, and reserve traditional American cheese for dishes where a slightly firmer, more distinct texture is preferred, such as cheese plates or layered casseroles.

Practical tip: When substituting one for the other, adjust your expectations. If using traditional American cheese in place of Kraft Singles, add a small amount of milk or cream to improve meltability. Conversely, if using Kraft Singles in a recipe calling for traditional American cheese, reduce the heat slightly to prevent over-melting. Understanding these differences allows you to leverage each cheese’s unique properties for optimal results in cooking and baking.

Nutritional Differences: Calories, fat, and sodium content comparison between the two

American cheese and Kraft Singles, while often used interchangeably, are not identical in their nutritional profiles. A single slice of American cheese (28g) typically contains around 100 calories, 8g of fat, and 350mg of sodium. In contrast, a slice of Kraft Singles (21g) averages 60 calories, 4g of fat, and 280mg of sodium. This immediate comparison reveals that Kraft Singles are slightly lower in calories, fat, and sodium per slice, primarily due to their smaller serving size. However, when adjusted for weight, the differences become less pronounced, with Kraft Singles still maintaining a slight edge in sodium content.

For those monitoring their sodium intake, the disparity in sodium levels is particularly noteworthy. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend limiting daily sodium intake to less than 2,300mg, with an ideal limit of 1,500mg for most adults, especially those with hypertension. A single slice of American cheese contributes roughly 15% of the daily sodium limit, while Kraft Singles account for about 12%. Over the course of a day, these differences can add up, especially in recipes like grilled cheese sandwiches or burgers, where multiple slices are often used.

Fat content is another critical factor, particularly for individuals following low-fat diets. American cheese’s higher fat content (8g per slice) includes approximately 5g of saturated fat, which exceeds the recommended daily limit of 13g for a 2,000-calorie diet. Kraft Singles, with 4g of fat (2.5g saturated), offer a slightly leaner option. However, it’s essential to note that both products contain processed fats, which should be consumed in moderation regardless of quantity.

Caloric differences, though modest, can be significant for calorie-conscious consumers. Kraft Singles’ lower calorie count (60 vs. 100) makes it a marginally better option for those tracking daily intake. However, the trade-off lies in portion size: Kraft Singles are smaller, so achieving the same volume of cheese in a dish would require more slices, potentially negating the caloric advantage. For example, using three slices of Kraft Singles to match the volume of two slices of American cheese would result in 180 calories, compared to 200 calories for American cheese.

In practical terms, the choice between American cheese and Kraft Singles should align with specific dietary goals. For sodium reduction, Kraft Singles offer a slight advantage, but portion control remains key. For fat and calorie management, Kraft Singles are marginally better, though the differences are minimal. Ultimately, both products are processed cheeses with similar nutritional drawbacks, so moderation is advised. Pairing either with fiber-rich foods like whole-grain bread or vegetables can help balance their impact on overall health.

Explore related products

Dietz & Watson Deli-Sliced Yellow American Cheese, 12 oz

$6.99

Andrew & Everett White American Cheese

$8.99

Organic Valley® Premium American Cheese — Organic, Pasture Raised, Non Gmo — 11 Ounce

$18.66

Organic Valley Premium Organic American Cheese Slices — Pasture Raised, No Added Hormones — 8 Slices ​(6 Oz)

$7.69

Andrew & Everett Yellow American Cheese

$8.99

Sargento Natural American Sliced Cheese, 24 Slices

$9.89

Texture and Flavor: Kraft Singles' consistency vs. American cheese's taste and mouthfeel

Kraft Singles and American cheese may share a similar color and shape, but their textures and flavors diverge significantly. Kraft Singles, a processed cheese product, boasts a remarkably uniform consistency—smooth, slightly rubbery, and melt-resistant. This is achieved through the addition of emulsifiers and stabilizers, which create a texture that remains intact even when heated. In contrast, American cheese, whether deli-sliced or block-form, has a more natural give. It’s softer, creamier, and melts into a gooey, stretchy consistency ideal for sandwiches or burgers. This difference in mouthfeel is immediately noticeable: Kraft Singles retain their structure, while American cheese transforms into a rich, velvety layer.

Flavor-wise, Kraft Singles deliver a bold, salty punch with a hint of tanginess, designed to appeal to a broad audience. Their taste is consistent, almost artificial, and lacks the complexity of natural cheese. American cheese, however, offers a milder, buttery flavor with subtle nutty or sweet undertones, depending on the brand or variety. This is because American cheese is made from a blend of cheeses (often Cheddar and Colby) and aged minimally, preserving its smooth, approachable taste. While Kraft Singles dominate with their assertive saltiness, American cheese complements other ingredients without overpowering them.

For those seeking a practical comparison, consider this: Kraft Singles are ideal for grilled cheese sandwiches where a stable, non-greasy melt is desired. Their uniformity ensures even coverage and minimal mess. American cheese, on the other hand, shines in burgers or cheesesteaks, where its creamy melt and subtle flavor enhance the dish without stealing the show. To elevate the taste of Kraft Singles, pair them with strongly flavored ingredients like jalapeños or bacon, which balance their saltiness. For American cheese, opt for simpler pairings like tomato or lettuce to let its natural flavor shine.

A sensory experiment can illustrate these differences: place a slice of Kraft Singles and American cheese on your tongue. The former will remain firm, its saltiness dominating, while the latter will dissolve more quickly, leaving a buttery, mild aftertaste. This highlights the trade-off between Kraft Singles’ engineered consistency and American cheese’s natural, dynamic qualities. Ultimately, the choice depends on the desired texture and flavor profile—whether you prioritize uniformity or a more authentic, melt-in-your-mouth experience.

FDA Classification: Why Kraft Singles are labeled as pasteurized prepared cheese product

Kraft Singles, those individually wrapped slices of yellow delight, are a staple in many American households. But have you ever wondered why they’re labeled as a "pasteurized prepared cheese product" instead of just "cheese"? The answer lies in the FDA’s strict classification system, which hinges on the product’s ingredients and manufacturing process. Unlike traditional American cheese, Kraft Singles contain additives like whey, milk protein concentrate, and emulsifiers to enhance meltability and extend shelf life. These additions disqualify them from being labeled simply as "cheese," which must meet specific standards for milk fat, moisture, and cheese solids.

To understand the FDA’s role, consider the agency’s definition of cheese. According to the Standards of Identity for Dairy Products, cheese must be made from milk, cream, or a combination of both, with specific percentages of milk fat and moisture. Kraft Singles, while primarily dairy-based, include ingredients like sodium citrate and sorbic acid, which are not permitted in standard cheese production. These additives improve texture and preservation but push the product into the "pasteurized prepared cheese product" category, a classification for cheese-like items that don’t meet the traditional cheese criteria.

From a practical standpoint, this classification isn’t just bureaucratic red tape—it informs consumers about what they’re eating. For instance, individuals with dietary restrictions or allergies need to know if a product contains additives like whey or emulsifiers. Parents might also prefer traditional cheese for their children due to its simpler ingredient list. Kraft Singles, while convenient and versatile, are engineered for specific qualities like uniform melting, making them ideal for grilled cheese sandwiches or burgers but distinct from natural cheese in both composition and nutritional profile.

If you’re comparing Kraft Singles to American cheese, the key takeaway is that they’re not the same. American cheese, whether sliced or block form, typically adheres to the FDA’s cheese standards, whereas Kraft Singles are a processed variant. For those seeking a closer alternative, look for brands labeled as "American cheese" rather than "pasteurized prepared cheese product." However, if convenience and consistency are priorities, Kraft Singles remain a reliable choice—just be aware of their processed nature and ingredient differences. Always check labels to make informed decisions, especially if you’re mindful of additives or seeking a more natural option.

Frequently asked questions