Blue Cheese Dressing: Which Brand Deserves The Crown?

Blue cheese is a popular salad dressing, but it can also be used on wings, wraps, steak, burgers, roasted Brussels sprouts, and as a dip for charcuterie boards. A good blue cheese dressing should be creamy, savoury, and funky, with a perfect blend of creamy richness and sharp blue cheese tang. So, which brand makes the best blue cheese dressing? There are many options available, including Whole Foods, Cindy's Kitchen, Kraft, Toby's, Marie's, Litehouse, and Jimmy's Extra Chunky Blue Cheese. While some people prefer a milder blue cheese flavour, others enjoy a strong and tangy taste with large chunks of blue cheese. Ultimately, the best brand of blue cheese dressing may come down to personal preference and specific criteria.

Explore related products

Royal Blue Stilton - 1 lb, Rich & Creamy, Traditional English Blue Cheese, Perfect for Gourmet Cooking & Wine Pairing

$27.99

Danish Blue Cheese - Approx. 6 Lb-Wheel or (3lb 2 wheels)

$34.06 $62.99

Royal Blue Stilton - Pound Cut

$27.99

English Cheese Blue Stilton - 1 lb / 454 g - OVERNIGHT GUARANTEED

$64.9

Saint Agur Blue Cheese Wheel – 5 lbs RW Creamy, Mild, and Uniquely Smooth Texture - Perfect for Charcuterie Boards from The Cheese Lover Shop

$110

Bleu D'Auvergne AOC French Blue Cheese - 1 lb / 454 g - GUARANTEED OVERNIGHT

$64.9

Chunky vs creamy

When it comes to blue cheese dressing, there are two distinct camps: those who prefer it chunky and those who prefer it creamy. Both have their merits, and the right choice ultimately depends on personal preference and the intended use of the dressing.

Chunky blue cheese dressing is characterised by its texture, with visible chunks of blue cheese interspersed throughout. This style is perfect for those who want a robust, tangy flavour and a satisfying bite. The chunks of cheese add a layer of depth and intensity to the dressing, making it a popular choice for those who crave a bold blue cheese experience. The chunkiness also provides a visual appeal, making it a favourite for those who enjoy seeing the bits of cheese in their dressing. However, it's important to ensure that the chunks are not too big, as they can become overwhelming and detract from the overall taste experience.

On the other hand, creamy blue cheese dressing offers a smoother, more decadent mouthfeel. It is often described as rich, savoury and funky, with a tangy flavour that packs a punch. The creaminess adds a level of indulgence and luxury to the dressing, making it a versatile choice for salads, dips and even sauces for meats. Creamy blue cheese dressing is known for its ability to coat ingredients evenly, enhancing the flavour of the dish without overpowering it. It is a popular option for those who want a well-balanced blend of creaminess and the sharp tang of blue cheese.

In terms of specific brands, there are several options available. For chunky blue cheese dressing, Whole Foods 365 Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing & Dip is a popular choice, offering a mild flavour and a texture that is neither too thick nor too thin. It is praised for its flavourfulness without being too intense, making it accessible to those who may be on the fence about blue cheese. Another well-known brand is Marie's, which is known for its thicker, chunkier consistency and stronger blue cheese flavour.

When it comes to creamy blue cheese dressing, Cindy's Kitchen stands out for its complex blend of ingredients, including Worcestershire sauce, garlic, white pepper, celery salt and honey. This dressing delivers on flavour, earning rave reviews from those who have tried it. Toby's is another excellent option, known for its creaminess and unique addition of dill, which adds a lovely, light flavour to the rich recipe.

Ultimately, the decision between chunky and creamy blue cheese dressing comes down to personal preference. Both styles have their unique qualities and can elevate a variety of dishes. Whether you're a fan of the robust chunkiness or the smooth creaminess, there is a blue cheese dressing out there that will tantalise your taste buds and take your culinary creations to the next level.

Mild vs strong flavour

When it comes to blue cheese dressing, there are a variety of options available, each with its own unique flavour profile and texture. Some people prefer a mild and creamy dressing, while others may favour a stronger, more pungent blue cheese taste.

For those who enjoy a milder flavour, Whole Foods 365 Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing & Dip is a great option. It offers a balanced flavour that is "flavoursome without being intense". This dressing has a thinner consistency compared to others and is perfect for those who want a light salad without being too decadent. Another mild option is the Marzetti brand, which is known for its extremely thick consistency and is a favourite among those who are new to blue cheese. Litehouse is another brand that falls under the mild flavour category, with a creamier and less chunky texture.

On the other hand, if you're a blue cheese enthusiast and prefer a stronger, more pungent flavour, Cindy's Kitchen Real Bleu Cheese Dressing is an excellent choice. This dressing has a complex blend of ingredients, including Worcestershire sauce, garlic, white pepper, celery salt, and honey, creating a unique and intense flavour. Toby's blue cheese dressing is another option for those seeking a stronger flavour. It is very creamy, thick, and packed with seasonings, making even a small amount feel like an indulgent treat. Marie's is another brand that delivers a stronger blue cheese flavour with larger chunks of cheese and a tangier taste due to the addition of buttermilk and vinegar.

Ultimately, the preference for mild or strong blue cheese dressing comes down to individual taste. Some people may enjoy the subtle creaminess of a mild dressing, while others may crave the sharp and tangy flavour of a stronger variety. It's worth experimenting with different brands and textures to find the one that suits your palate.

Cheap vs expensive

When it comes to blue cheese dressing, there are a variety of options available, from cheap to expensive. While some people may be tempted to opt for the least expensive option, it is important to consider the trade-offs in terms of quality and taste.

Starting with the cheaper options, we have brands like Signature Select, which is one of the cheapest options on the market. However, its low price is reflected in its lack of flavour and watery texture. The first ingredient in this product is water, which contributes to its thin and runny consistency. It also has a slightly sweet taste due to the addition of sugar, which is not typically found in blue cheese dressing recipes. Another affordable option is Kraft, which can be purchased for $2.89 at Walmart. This dressing does the job and is priced right, but it may not stand out in terms of flavour or texture.

Moving on to the more expensive options, we have brands like Cindy's Kitchen, which is known for its real bleu cheese dressing and dip. This brand uses a long list of recognisable ingredients, including Worcestershire sauce, garlic, white pepper, celery salt, and honey, creating a complex and flavourful dressing. Toby's is another premium option, known for its thick and creamy texture, making even a small amount feel like a decadent treat. This dressing is herbier than most, with a light flavour of dill that complements the richness of the blue cheese.

For those looking for a middle ground between cheap and expensive, Whole Foods offers its own brand of blue cheese dressing for $3.99. This option is slightly lower in calories than some of its competitors, but it may also lack flavour. If you're looking for a mild blue cheese dressing that's not too thick or thin, Whole Foods 365 Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing & Dip is a great option. It's flavourful without being overwhelming, making it a perfect choice for those who want a light and delicious salad. Another option in this price range is Wegmans' store brand, which costs $2.50 and is beloved by shoppers. However, it may not live up to the brand's usual standards in terms of appearance and texture.

In conclusion, when it comes to cheap vs. expensive blue cheese dressing, there are trade-offs to consider. Cheaper options may sacrifice flavour and texture, while more expensive brands offer unique and complex flavours with a creamier and thicker consistency. Ultimately, the best blue cheese dressing depends on individual preferences, budget, and specific requirements.

Explore related products

Rogue Creamery - Rogue River Blue Cheese, approx 18 oz, Seasonal Award-Winning Cheese For Cheese Platters and Charcuterie Boards

$110

ROGUE CREAMERY Organic Oregon Blue Cheese, 4.2 OZ

$15.53

California Blue Cheese 5.3 oz

$14.99

Danish Blue Cheese, Sold by the pound

$59.99

DaneKo Danish Blue Cheese (Wheel of approx. 5.5 pounds)

$111.86

Point Reyes Original Blue Cheese 1 lb, 2 Pack

$73.96

Popular brands

Marie's and Litehouse are popular brands for blue cheese lovers. Marie's is thicker and chunkier with larger chunks of blue cheese, resulting in a stronger and more bitter flavour. On the other hand, Litehouse is creamier and has a milder blue cheese flavour with more emphasis on spices. If you're looking for a dressing with a strong blue cheese flavour and lots of chunks, Jimmy's Extra Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing is a great option. It's made with Amablu Blue Cheese from the Caves of Faribault in Minnesota, known for its rich, creamy, and full-bodied flavour.

Creative uses

As a Sauce

Blue cheese dressing can be used as a sauce for steak, burgers, or roasted vegetables like Brussels sprouts. The creaminess of the dressing pairs well with meat and adds a tangy twist to your dish.

Dip

Blue cheese dressing can be used as a dip for a charcuterie board or even as a veggie dip. Its thick and creamy texture makes it perfect for dipping, and the blue cheese flavour adds a sophisticated touch.

Sandwiches and Wraps

Add a generous spread of blue cheese dressing to your sandwiches or wraps. It can elevate a simple turkey or chicken sandwich to something extraordinary. For an extra indulgent treat, pair it with a club sandwich or a BLT.

Creative Combinations

For those who are feeling adventurous, try using blue cheese dressing as a topping for unique dishes like buffalo wings with a side of celery sticks, or even as a sauce for grilled shrimp. It can also be used as a base for a pasta salad or as a secret ingredient in your next mac and cheese recipe.

Customised Creations

Create your own signature dishes by using blue cheese dressing as a base and adding your favourite herbs and spices. For example, mix in some chopped chives, garlic, or even a dash of hot sauce to create a customised blue cheese dip or sauce that's perfect for game day or your next barbecue.

The possibilities are endless, so don't be afraid to experiment and find new ways to enjoy this delicious and versatile condiment.

Frequently asked questions