Penn Station's Philly Cheese Steak: Ingredients And Toppings Explained

A Philly cheese steak from Penn Station is a mouthwatering sandwich that typically features thinly sliced, tender beefsteak, often grilled to perfection and seasoned with a blend of salt, pepper, and sometimes onions. The meat is then piled high on a soft, toasted hoagie roll and topped with melted cheese, traditionally Cheez Whiz, provolone, or American, depending on personal preference. Additional toppings like sautéed onions, bell peppers, and mushrooms are common, adding extra flavor and texture. This iconic sandwich is a staple of East Coast cuisine, known for its hearty, savory taste and satisfying combination of ingredients.

Explore related products

Hot Pockets Philly Steak and Cheese, Hot Pockets Frozen Sandwiches, Frozen Snacks, Air Fryer Snacks, 9g Protein, 4-Pack

$4.83

Steak-Umm, Sliced Steaks, Frozen, 9 oz

$3.99

Rayberns Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich -- 6 per case.

$84.7

Beef Skirt Steak Step 1

$19.99

Original Philly Cheesesteak Value Seasoned Beef Sandwich Slices, 4 Ounce -- 40 per case.

$112.83

Pre, Beef Ribeye Steak, Grass-Fed, Pasture-Raised | 0.625 lbs.

$13.12

Meat Options: Thinly sliced steak or chicken, grilled to perfection, forms the base

The heart of any Philly cheese steak lies in its meat, and Penn Station’s version is no exception. Here, the choice is clear: thinly sliced steak or chicken, both grilled to perfection. This simplicity is intentional, allowing the quality and preparation of the meat to shine. The thin slicing ensures even cooking and maximum flavor absorption, while grilling adds a smoky char that complements the other ingredients. Whether you opt for the classic steak or the lighter chicken, this foundation sets the stage for a sandwich that’s both hearty and balanced.

For those leaning toward steak, Penn Station uses ribeye, known for its marbling and tenderness. This cut, when thinly sliced, melts in your mouth and pairs seamlessly with the melted cheese. Chicken, on the other hand, offers a leaner alternative without sacrificing texture. Grilled until slightly crispy on the edges, it provides a satisfying contrast to the soft roll and gooey cheese. Both options are seasoned minimally, letting the natural flavors dominate while leaving room for customization with sauces or toppings.

When ordering, consider your preference for richness versus lightness. Steak delivers a more indulgent experience, ideal for those craving a classic Philly cheese steak. Chicken, however, appeals to health-conscious diners or those seeking a milder taste. Pro tip: ask for your meat to be grilled a bit longer if you prefer a crispier texture, or request it slightly less cooked for extra juiciness. This small adjustment can elevate your sandwich to match your exact preferences.

In practice, the meat’s role extends beyond flavor—it’s also about portion balance. Penn Station ensures the meat-to-bread ratio is spot-on, preventing the sandwich from becoming overly dense or dry. Each bite delivers a harmonious blend of protein, cheese, and roll, making it easy to see why this combination has stood the test of time. Whether you’re a steak purist or a chicken enthusiast, the grilled meat base is the cornerstone of Penn Station’s Philly cheese steak experience.

Cheese Varieties: Provolone, American, or Cheez Whiz are classic, melty choices

The choice of cheese on a Philly cheesesteak is as crucial as the meat itself, and Penn Station’s offerings—Provolone, American, and Cheez Whiz—each bring distinct textures and flavors to the table. Provolone, with its sharp, smoky edge, adds a mature complexity that pairs well with the richness of the steak. American cheese, smooth and creamy, melts effortlessly, creating a cohesive, velvety layer that binds the ingredients together. Cheez Whiz, a processed cheese sauce, introduces a tangy, almost nostalgic flavor that appeals to those who prefer a more indulgent, gooey experience. Each option caters to different palates, ensuring there’s a melt for every cheesesteak enthusiast.

When crafting your order, consider the melt factor—a critical element in cheesesteak satisfaction. Provolone requires a slightly higher heat to achieve optimal meltiness, so ensure your steak is piping hot to allow it to soften without burning. American cheese melts at a lower temperature, making it a foolproof choice for consistent creaminess. Cheez Whiz, already in sauce form, is best drizzled just before serving to maintain its signature texture. For maximum melt, ask for your cheesesteak to be grilled longer if you’re opting for Provolone or American, or request Cheez Whiz to be warmed separately and added at the last moment.

Flavor profiles play a significant role in cheese selection, and each variety complements the steak in unique ways. Provolone’s sharpness cuts through the meat’s richness, offering a balanced bite that appeals to those who enjoy a more pronounced cheese presence. American cheese, with its mild, buttery notes, enhances the steak’s natural flavors without overpowering them. Cheez Whiz, with its tangy, umami-rich profile, adds a bold, almost addictive quality that transforms the sandwich into a decadent treat. Pairing these cheeses with additional toppings—like sautéed onions or peppers—can further elevate the overall taste, so consider how your cheese choice will interact with other ingredients.

For those seeking a healthier twist, Provolone is the leanest option, offering a lower fat content compared to American or Cheez Whiz. However, if indulgence is the goal, Cheez Whiz delivers unmatched richness and flavor. American cheese strikes a middle ground, providing creaminess without overwhelming the palate. Regardless of choice, moderation is key—a Philly cheesesteak is already a hearty meal, so let the cheese enhance, not dominate, the experience. Experimenting with these varieties allows you to tailor the sandwich to your preferences, ensuring every bite is as satisfying as the last.

Bread Type: Soft hoagie roll, toasted for a crispy exterior and chewy interior

The foundation of any great Philly cheese steak from Penn Station lies in its bread. A soft hoagie roll, toasted to perfection, is the unsung hero that elevates the sandwich from good to unforgettable. This isn’t just any bread—it’s a carefully selected, slightly airy roll that strikes the perfect balance between structure and tenderness. When toasted, the exterior crisps up, providing a satisfying crunch that contrasts beautifully with the chewy, yielding interior. This duality ensures the bread holds up to the hearty fillings without becoming soggy, while still offering a comforting texture in every bite.

Toasting the hoagie roll is both an art and a science. Preheat your oven or toaster oven to 350°F (175°C) and place the roll inside for 3–5 minutes, or until the crust is golden brown. Avoid over-toasting, as it can make the bread too hard or dry. For an extra layer of flavor, lightly brush the roll with melted butter or olive oil before toasting. This not only enhances the crispiness but also adds a subtle richness that complements the savory steak and melted cheese. If you’re short on time, a quick toast on a skillet over medium heat works just as well—press the roll gently with a spatula to ensure even browning.

The choice of a soft hoagie roll isn’t arbitrary; it’s a deliberate decision rooted in tradition and practicality. Unlike denser breads, the hoagie roll’s light texture allows the flavors of the steak, cheese, and onions to shine without overwhelming them. Its size and shape are also ideal for containing the generous portions typical of a Penn Station cheese steak. For those with dietary restrictions, consider using a gluten-free hoagie roll, though achieving the same texture may require experimentation. Always opt for fresh bread—stale rolls will never toast properly, no matter the technique.

Finally, the toasted hoagie roll serves as the sandwich’s structural backbone. Its crispy exterior prevents the juices from the steak and melted cheese from seeping through, ensuring a mess-free eating experience. Meanwhile, the chewy interior acts as a sponge, soaking up just enough flavor to enhance each bite without becoming waterlogged. This interplay of textures is what makes the bread an integral part of the Philly cheese steak experience. Whether you’re enjoying it at Penn Station or recreating it at home, the right bread—toasted just right—is non-negotiable.

Explore related products

Philly Cheesesteak Seasoning

$6.99

Sargento Natural Provolone with Natural Smoke Flavor Sliced Cheese, 12 Slices

$2.17 $4.6

Amazon Grocery, Provolone Cheese with Natural Smoke Flavor, 8 Oz, 10 Slices (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary)

$0.98 $1.89

Vending 2 U Hamburger Helper Deluxe Philly Cheesesteak, 4.8 Ounces, Pack of 2, Bundled With One V2U Utensil Set

$10.48

FrigoCheese Heads, Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sticks and Beef Sticks, 8 ct

$5.99

Sargento Franks RedHot Natural Cheddar, Colby Jack, and American Shredded Cheese with Cayenne Pepper Seasoning, Traditional Cut, 7 oz

$2.99

Vegetable Add-ons: Onions, bell peppers, and mushrooms are popular, sautéed for flavor

Sautéed onions, bell peppers, and mushrooms are the holy trinity of vegetable add-ons for a Philly cheese steak from Penn Station. These aren’t just tossed on raw—they’re cooked until softened and slightly caramelized, adding a depth of flavor that raw veggies can’t match. The sautéing process melds their natural sugars with the savory notes of the steak and cheese, creating a harmonious blend that elevates the sandwich from good to unforgettable.

If you’re customizing your order, consider the ratio of vegetables to meat. A balanced approach is key: too many veggies can overwhelm the steak, while too few leave the sandwich one-dimensional. Aim for a 1:2 ratio of vegetables to steak, ensuring each bite includes a mix of textures and flavors. Pro tip: ask for the veggies to be sautéed separately from the steak to maintain their distinct taste and prevent sogginess.

Bell peppers, in particular, bring a subtle sweetness and crunch that contrasts the richness of the cheese and meat. Red and green peppers are the most common, but don’t hesitate to request yellow or orange for a slightly fruitier note. Mushrooms, on the other hand, contribute an earthy, umami quality that pairs exceptionally well with provolone or American cheese. Onions, when caramelized, add a mild tang and a touch of sweetness that ties everything together.

For those watching their calorie intake, these vegetable add-ons are a smart choice. A standard portion of sautéed onions, bell peppers, and mushrooms adds roughly 50–70 calories to your sandwich, depending on the oil used. Compared to extra cheese or bacon, it’s a lighter way to enhance flavor. Plus, the fiber in these veggies aids digestion, making your meal feel more satisfying without weighing you down.

Finally, don’t underestimate the role of seasoning. While the veggies are sautéed, a pinch of salt, pepper, and garlic powder can amplify their natural flavors. If you’re feeling adventurous, ask for a sprinkle of paprika or red pepper flakes for a subtle kick. The goal is to complement, not overpower, the classic Philly cheese steak profile. When done right, these sautéed vegetables transform a simple sandwich into a layered, crave-worthy experience.

Sauce Options: Optional mayo, ketchup, or hot sauce for extra zest

A Philly cheese steak from Penn Station is a canvas for personalization, and the sauce options—mayo, ketchup, or hot sauce—are where you can truly make it your own. These condiments aren’t just afterthoughts; they’re transformative elements that can shift the sandwich’s flavor profile from classic to bold. Mayo adds a creamy richness, ketchup brings a tangy sweetness, and hot sauce injects fiery intensity. Each choice reflects your palate and mood, turning a standard order into a tailored experience.

Consider mayo the diplomat of sauces—smooth, versatile, and subtly enhancing. A light drizzle (about 1–2 teaspoons) complements the melted cheese without overpowering the steak’s savory notes. It’s ideal for those who prefer a milder, more cohesive flavor. However, use it sparingly; too much can make the sandwich greasy. Pro tip: Opt for full-fat mayo for maximum creaminess, or go for light mayo if you’re calorie-conscious but still crave that silky texture.

Ketchup, on the other hand, is the wildcard. Its tomato-based tang and sweetness can polarize opinions, but when applied judiciously (think 1 tablespoon or less), it adds a bright, nostalgic contrast to the rich meat and cheese. It’s particularly appealing to those who enjoy a hint of acidity. Caution: Overdoing it can turn your sandwich into a soggy mess, so spread thinly or request it on the side for controlled dipping.

Hot sauce is for the daring. A few dashes (2–3 shakes) of a vinegar-based variety like Frank’s RedHot or a thicker option like sriracha can elevate the sandwich with a spicy kick. It’s perfect for cutting through the heaviness of the cheese and steak, especially if you’ve ordered extra meat. Pair it with provolone for a smoky-spicy combo, or go with American cheese to balance the heat. Warning: Start small—hot sauce’s intensity can escalate quickly, and there’s no going back once it’s applied.

The key to mastering sauce options lies in balance and experimentation. Combine mayo and hot sauce for a creamy-spicy fusion, or mix ketchup and hot sauce for a sweet-heat twist. Always consider the sandwich’s other components—cheese type, onion presence, and bread freshness—when choosing your sauce. For first-timers, ask for sauces on the side to test ratios before committing. Remember, the goal is to enhance, not overwhelm, the Philly cheese steak’s signature flavors.

Frequently asked questions