Best Bread Types To Compliment Chopped Cheese

The chopped cheese sandwich is a New York City staple, with its roots in Harlem and the Bronx. The sandwich is typically made with ground beef, onions, and melted cheese, served on a hero roll. While the exact type of bread can vary, it is generally agreed that a soft roll is preferable to a crusty one. Some popular options include hoagie rolls, brioche buns, and potato buns. The roll is often toasted and buttered, and the sandwich is wrapped in foil to keep it warm and soft.

Hoagie or hero rolls

The hoagie or hero roll is said to be the classic choice of bread for a chopped cheese sandwich. Its long shape and soft texture make it ideal for holding the sandwich's fillings, which typically include ground beef, onions, and melted cheese. The roll's soft interior also allows for easier eating, as the sandwich can be wrapped in foil to keep it warm, which may cause the bread to steam and become softer.

While the hoagie or hero roll is a popular choice, other types of bread can also be used for chopped cheese sandwiches. Some people prefer to use a brioche bun or a potato bun, which offer a similar soft texture. It is recommended to toast the bread, regardless of the type chosen, to enhance the flavour and texture of the sandwich.

When making a chopped cheese sandwich, it is important to consider the size and shape of the bread. The hoagie or hero roll is typically wider and longer than a standard dinner roll or demi-baguette, providing more surface area for the fillings. The roll's soft interior also helps to absorb the juices from the meat and creates a more cohesive sandwich.

Overall, the hoagie or hero roll is a versatile and popular choice for chopped cheese sandwiches, offering a combination of convenience, taste, and texture that complements the sandwich's fillings.

Brioche or potato buns

Brioche buns have a classic light and savoury profile, with a soft and pillow-like interior. They are enriched dough, combining the sweetness of potato flour with the savouriness of brioche. Brioche buns are a good choice if you want a fancier or more substantial sandwich, as they can hold ingredients well. They are also a good option for thicker patties as they are firmer and can hold them better. However, some people find them too sweet and soft for burgers, especially as they can taste similar to cake.

Potato buns, on the other hand, are a good choice for smash burgers as they are softer and can complement the texture of the patty. They are crusty on the outside and soft on the inside, providing a nice contrast in textures. Potato buns are also a good option if you are grilling outdoors. However, they may not be sturdy enough for sandwiches with multiple toppings or fancy ingredients.

Ultimately, the choice between brioche and potato buns for your chopped cheese sandwich comes down to personal preference. Both types of buns have their unique characteristics and can enhance the flavour and texture of your sandwich in different ways.

Crustiness

The chopped cheese sandwich is a New York City staple, and the choice of bread is an important part of the dish's authenticity. While the filling is certainly key, the bread is what brings it all together.

The classic choice of bread for a chopped cheese sandwich is a long roll, such as a hoagie or hero roll. However, it is not set in stone, and the more important factor is that the bread is soft rather than crusty. A crusty exterior may detract from the soft, gooey texture of the filling, which includes melted cheese.

Some recipes suggest using a brioche bun or a potato bun, which are softer options. The bread should also be toasted, adding flavour and texture to the sandwich. Toasting the bread in butter in a frying pan over medium heat is a popular method.

Wrapping the sandwich in foil is another important step, as it keeps the sandwich warm and allows the buns to steam slightly, making them softer. This is especially important if a crustier bread is used, as the steaming process can help soften the exterior.

Overall, while a crusty exterior may work in certain variations of the sandwich, a softer bread is generally preferred for the classic chopped cheese sandwich. This ensures that the bread complements the texture and flavour of the filling without being too hard or dry.

Toasting

The bread for a chopped cheese sandwich should be toasted in a frying pan or on a griddle over medium heat. You can butter the bread first, which will add extra flavour and help it to toast evenly. It should be toasted until it is golden brown.

Once the bread is toasted, you can add condiments such as mayonnaise and ketchup. These condiments create a sauce that takes the sandwich to the next level.

Wrapping in foil

Wrapping your chopped cheese sandwich in foil is a common way to serve this New York City staple. Not only does it allow the sandwich to rest and the flavours to meld, but it also has a practical purpose.

Firstly, wrapping the sandwich in foil keeps it warm. From the time the sandwich is handed to you to when you actually eat it, there is usually a couple of minutes' wait. During this time, the buns steam slightly inside the foil, making them softer. This is especially nice for a sandwich like the chopped cheese, which has a soft roll, and it also makes it nicer to bite into.

Secondly, wrapping the sandwich in foil makes it easier to eat. The chopped cheese is both delicious and messy! Wrapping it in foil helps to contain the sandwich and prevent the ingredients from falling out.

Finally, wrapping the sandwich in foil is part of the chopped cheese's unique identity. Its association with New York City bodegas adds to its charm and makes it a nostalgic and familiar experience for those who have grown up enjoying it from their local corner stores.

So, if you want the authentic New York City experience, don't forget to wrap your chopped cheese sandwich in foil!

Frequently asked questions