The Mystery Of Cheeses With Holes: Unraveling The Swiss Wonder

Swiss cheese is one of the most well-known varieties of cheese with holes, also known as eyes. The eyes in Swiss cheese are caused by bacteria that release carbon dioxide gas, which gets trapped in the cheese and slowly forms holes. The size of the holes can be controlled by changing the temperature of the milk, its acidity, or the aging time. Other types of cheese with eyes include Jarlsberg, Gouda, and Emmental.

The role of bacteria in creating holes

Swiss cheese is known for its distinctive holes, which are caused by bacteria, specifically a strain known as Propionibacterium. These bacteria are introduced into the cheese during the cheesemaking process and play a crucial role in creating the holes that give Swiss cheese its unique appearance and texture.

The process begins with the addition of Propionibacterium bacteria, which consume lactic acid in the cheese. As they feed on the lactic acid, these bacteria produce carbon dioxide gas. This gas accumulates in small pockets within the cheese, creating bubbles. As the cheese ages, these bubbles expand and gradually merge, forming larger and more visible holes. The size and distribution of the holes are influenced by various factors, including temperature, humidity, and fermentation times.

The type of bacteria used is essential to the hole-forming process. Propionibacterium freudenreichii, a specific strain of Propionibacterium, is responsible for creating the holes in Swiss cheese. This bacterial strain transforms the lactic acid in the cheese into carbon dioxide, a key step in the formation of the bubbles that become holes. The growth of these bacteria and the resulting hole formation can be influenced by factors such as temperature and milk composition.

The presence of holes in Swiss cheese is not just a cosmetic feature but also contributes to its characteristic flavour and texture. The holes provide an ideal environment for the growth of additional bacteria, further developing the cheese's distinctive nutty and slightly sweet flavour. Additionally, the holes create a light and airy texture, making Swiss cheese a versatile ingredient in various dishes, including sandwiches, salads, and fondue.

In conclusion, the role of bacteria in creating holes in Swiss cheese is significant. The introduction of specific bacterial strains, particularly Propionibacterium freudenreichii, initiates the process by producing carbon dioxide gas through the consumption of lactic acid. The subsequent formation and coalescence of bubbles, influenced by various factors, result in the distinctive holes that enhance both the sensory and culinary experience of Swiss cheese.

How temperature affects hole size

The holes in cheese, known as "eyes", are caused by the formation of gas due to microbial metabolism. This gas is carbon dioxide (CO2). The development of eyes in cheese can be a sought-after attribute or an unfortunate defect, depending on the type of cheese. Temperature plays a significant role in the size of these eyes.

The solubility of CO2 in cheese is temperature-dependent. As the temperature rises, CO2 becomes less soluble in water and more soluble in fat. This knowledge allows cheese producers to influence eye formation in their desired direction. For example, in Appenzeller-type semi-hard cheeses, decreasing fat content leads to an increase in water phase, resulting in more CO2 formation and larger eyes. Conversely, increasing the fat content leads to increased CO2 solubility, reducing eye volume. These effects are more pronounced at warmer temperatures, as observed during the ripening of Emmentaler cheese.

Temperature also affects the growth of microorganisms involved in fermentation, which produce the CO2 gas. If cheese is held at warm temperatures (>50°F), it can facilitate the growth of unwanted microorganisms, leading to defects such as small holes, undesirable flavours, and splits or cracks in the cheese. On the other hand, desired eye formation in cheeses like Swiss or Gouda can be achieved by taking certain precautions, such as removing most of the entrapped air from the curd to avoid producing too many holes.

Additionally, the flexibility of the cheese body during aging is crucial for eye development. If the cheese is too hard and brittle due to low temperature, the pressure from the gas will cause splits and cracks instead of spherical holes. Therefore, maintaining the appropriate temperature is essential to guide eye formation and prevent defects in the final cheese product.

The impact of milk collection methods on holes

The presence of holes in cheese, also known as "eyes", is caused by the formation of gas due to microbial metabolism. The gas, carbon dioxide, is produced by bacteria that consume lactic acid. These bacteria, called Propionibacterium freudenrichii subspecies shermanii, or P. shermanii for short, are added to the milk at the start of the cheesemaking process. As the bacteria grow, they emit gases that end up creating round openings in the cheese.

The impact of milk collection methods on the formation of holes in cheese has been recently studied by Agroscope, a Swiss agricultural institute. They found that the traditional use of open buckets during milking can cause tiny bits of hay to fall into the collected milk. These hay particles create weaknesses in the structure of the curd, allowing gas to form and expand, creating holes in the cheese. With modern methods of milk extraction, it is less likely for hay to contaminate the milk, which explains why Swiss cheese today has fewer holes than it did historically.

Cheesemakers can control the size of the holes by adjusting the temperature of the milk, its acidity, and the aging time of the cheese. Larger holes in the cheese correspond to a more intense and developed flavor, as the bacteria continue to act on the cheese during the aging process.

Overall, the milk collection methods can impact the formation of holes in cheese by influencing the presence of hay particles, which in turn affect the structure of the curd and the formation of gas pockets. Modern milk extraction techniques have reduced the occurrence of hay contamination, leading to a decrease in the size and number of holes in Swiss cheese over time.

Why some cheeses have holes and others don't

Cheeses with holes are called "'eyed' cheeses, while those without holes are known as "blind". The holes in cheese, or "eyes", are caused by the formation of gas due to microbial metabolism—specifically, carbon dioxide (CO2). This gas is released by bacteria during the cheese-making process as they consume lactic acid. The gas becomes trapped in the cheese, creating pockets that eventually form holes.

The presence or absence of holes depends on the specific bacteria used in the cheese-making process. For example, in Emmental cheese, a.k.a. Swiss cheese, the bacteria produce carbon dioxide gas and form holes. However, for most other cheese varieties, cheesemakers try to prevent gas formation as it can lead to undesired crevices, cracks, and splits in the final product.

The size and distribution of the holes are influenced by several factors, including the specific strains of bacteria, acidity, temperature, moisture content, and aging duration. For instance, Swiss cheese is made by adding bacteria to cow's milk, which causes chemical reactions and the formation of solid curds and liquid whey. At temperatures of around 22°C, these bacteria produce carbon dioxide gas, which creates bubbles. When the cheese is cooled to around 4°C, the bubbles remain in place and become a characteristic feature of Swiss cheese.

Additionally, the aging process plays a crucial role in developing the flavour and texture of Swiss cheese. During the aging process, bacteria and enzymes break down proteins and fats, further enhancing the flavour and texture of the cheese. The aging period typically lasts several months, and can even last up to centuries with secret recipes and skillsets.

While Swiss cheese is the most well-known example of an "eyed" cheese, other varieties may also contain holes. These include Gouda, Havarti, Tilsit, and Esrom, which usually have many tiny gas-formed holes. France has Gruyère français, Italy has Fontina, and the United States has a modified version called Baby Swiss. Maasdamer cheese from the Netherlands also has holes, and there is a variety of Gouda made with cultures that produce small gas bubbles and, thus, tiny holes.

The difference between mechanical and gas-formed holes

Cheeses with holes are known as "eyed" cheeses, and those without are known as "blind". The holes in cheese, or "eyes", are caused by the formation of gas due to microbial metabolism. This gas is carbon dioxide (CO2). The CO2 accumulates in any air pockets present in the cheese, and as more gas is produced, a bubble is formed.

Swiss-type and Dutch-type cheeses are known for their eyes, namely Emmentaler, Jarlsberg, Appenzell, and Gouda. Other varieties of cheese such as Havarti, Tilsit, and Esrom usually have many tiny gas-formed holes, but they are not typically referred to as "eyes".

Gas-formed holes, or "eyes", are the result of the addition of certain bacteria to the cheese. The bacteria produce carbon dioxide gas, which accumulates and forms bubbles or "eyes". Cheesemakers ensure that the cheese body remains flexible while aging to allow for the formation of nice round eyes. If the cheese body is too hard and brittle, the gas pressure will cause splits and cracks instead of eyes.

The presence of gas-formed holes in Swiss cheese is due to the breakdown of lactic acid by Propionibacterium. The lactic acid is produced by starter cultures that metabolize lactose (milk sugar) into lactic acid. The Propionibacterium then metabolizes the lactic acid into carbon dioxide, acetic acid, and propionic acid. These by-products also contribute to the overall flavour of Swiss cheese.

In Gouda cheese, gas-formed holes are caused by the breakdown of citric acid, which is naturally present in milk in small amounts. Bacterium such as Leuconostoc mesenteroides and Lactococcus lactis ssp. lactis biovar. diacetylactis metabolize the citric acid into carbon dioxide, diacetyl (which gives Gouda its butter flavour), and other compounds. The limited amount of citric acid in milk results in only a few small eyes in Gouda cheese.

Frequently asked questions