Maggot-Ridden Cheeses: A Delicacy Or Disaster?

Casu marzu, also known as casu martzu, is a traditional Sardinian sheep milk cheese that contains live insect larvae, or maggots. The cheese is made by leaving whole pecorino cheeses outside with part of the rind removed, allowing female cheese flies to lay their eggs in the cheese. When the eggs hatch, the resulting larvae break down the cheese's fats through their digestive action, creating a very soft texture. While casu marzu is considered a delicacy by some, it has been banned from commercial sale due to health concerns.

Casu marzu, or 'maggot cheese', is made with sheep's milk and is a Sardinian delicacy

Casu marzu, or maggot cheese, is a Sardinian delicacy made with sheep's milk. The process of making this cheese involves leaving out whole pecorino cheeses with part of the rind removed, allowing female cheese flies (Piophila casei) to enter and lay their eggs. These flies can lay up to 500 eggs at a time, and the resulting larvae break down the cheese's fats through their digestive action, creating a very soft texture. This takes the cheese beyond typical fermentation to a stage of decomposition. The larvae appear as translucent white worms, about 8mm long.

The cheese is considered unsafe to eat if the maggots are dead, so it is usually consumed with live maggots. However, some people choose to kill the maggots before ingestion by placing the cheese in a sealed paper bag, where they suffocate and jump around until they die. The traditional way of consuming casu marzu involves cutting it into thin strips and spreading it on moistened Sardinian flatbread (pane carasau), often served with a strong red wine like cannonau.

Casu marzu has a strong flavour and a very strong, persistent smell. It is considered by some to be an aphrodisiac and is revered as a cultural symbol in Sardinia. However, it has also been deemed dangerous and banned from commercial sale due to the potential health risks associated with ingesting live maggots. These maggots can survive the gastric juices and cause pseudomyiasis, leading to serious lesions in the intestines. Despite the ban, the cheese is still produced and sold on the black market, with some Sardinians organising to make it available despite facing heavy fines.

The cheese is banned from commercial sale, but Sardinians have been consuming it for centuries

Casu marzu, also known as casu martzu, is a traditional Sardinian sheep milk cheese that contains live insect larvae or maggots. The cheese is made by leaving whole pecorino cheeses outside with part of the rind removed, allowing female cheese flies to lay their eggs in the cheese. The eggs hatch, and the resulting larvae break down the cheese's fats through their digestive action, creating a very soft texture. While the idea of eating cheese with live maggots may seem unappetizing or dangerous to some, the people of Sardinia have a long history of consuming this unique delicacy.

The practice of making and consuming casu marzu dates back to ancient times, possibly even to the days when Sardinia was a province of the Roman Empire. Local gastronome Giovanni Fancello traces the history of this cheese to that period, noting that even Pliny the Elder and Aristotle wrote about the consumption of worms. For Sardinians, casu marzu is more than just a cheese; it is an important part of their cultural and culinary heritage. It is believed to be an aphrodisiac and is deeply rooted in the island's superstition and mysticism.

Despite its cultural significance, casu marzu has faced legal challenges and is currently banned from commercial sale. Italian authorities have prohibited its sale under laws against the consumption of food infected by parasites, and offenders face hefty fines. The European Union has also outlawed the cheese due to food hygiene and health regulations. However, this has not stopped the production and consumption of casu marzu entirely. Some Sardinians continue to make and consume the cheese, either obtaining it through the black market or producing it themselves.

The process of making casu marzu is quite fascinating. It begins with leaving the pecorino cheese outside, allowing the female cheese flies to lay their eggs. Once the eggs hatch, the larvae begin to eat through the cheese, breaking down its fats and creating a soft texture. The cheesemaking process typically takes about three months, and the resulting cheese is said to have a strong flavor with reminders of Mediterranean pastures and a spicy aftertaste.

While some Sardinians cringe at the thought of consuming casu marzu, others unabashedly love its strong flavors and consider it a unique pleasure. The cheese is typically served on moistened Sardinian flatbread (pane carasau) and paired with a strong red wine like cannonau. When consuming the cheese, diners hold their hands above it to prevent the maggots from leaping, as they are capable of jumping up to 15 centimeters when disturbed.

Maggots are deliberately introduced to the cheese to promote an advanced level of fermentation

Casu marzu, also known as the 'maggot cheese' or 'grub cheese', is a traditional Sardinian sheep milk cheese that contains live insect larvae or maggots. The process of making this cheese involves deliberately introducing maggots to promote an advanced level of fermentation.

Casu marzu is derived from pecorino, a traditional Sardinian sheep milk cheese. To make casu marzu, whole pecorino cheeses are left outside with part of the rind removed, allowing female cheese flies (Piophila casei) to lay their eggs in the cheese. These flies can lay more than 500 eggs at a time. The eggs hatch, and the resulting larvae begin to eat through the cheese, breaking down its fats with their digestive acids and transforming the texture into a very soft, creamy consistency. This process takes the cheese beyond typical fermentation to a stage of decomposition, an advanced level of fermentation.

The introduction of maggots is a deliberate step in the production of casu marzu. The cheesemaking process is carefully timed to coincide with the reproductive cycle of sheep and the warm sirocco wind, which is believed to further soften the cheese and encourage maggot activity. The overall fermentation process, including the introduction of maggots, takes a total of three months.

The presence of maggots in casu marzu is not accidental but a key aspect of its production. The digestive action of the larvae brings the cheese to the final stage of fermentation, giving it a soft texture and a strong flavour. While some may find the idea of maggot-infested cheese unappetizing or even dangerous, it is a delicacy that is deeply rooted in Sardinian culture and history.

Maggots can survive the stomach acid and remain in the intestine, leading to a condition called pseudomyiasis

Casu martzu, also known as the 'maggot cheese' or 'grub cheese', is a traditional Sardinian sheep milk cheese that contains live insect larvae (maggots). The larvae are deliberately introduced to the cheese to promote an advanced level of fermentation and break down the cheese's fats. The digestive action of the larvae, which are from the cheese fly of the Piophilidae family, brings the cheese to a stage of decomposition beyond typical fermentation.

When consumed, the larvae can survive in the intestine, leading to a condition called pseudomyiasis. However, it is important to note that no cases of pseudomyiasis have been linked to the consumption of casu martzu. The risk arises from the possibility of the larvae surviving the stomach acid and remaining in the intestine. There have been documented cases of pseudomyiasis with P. casei, the cheese fly responsible for the larvae in casu martzu.

Pseudomyiasis is a condition where fly larvae survive in the gastrointestinal tract. It is a form of intestinal myiasis, which is the infestation of live human and vertebrate animals with fly larvae that feed on dead or living tissue or ingested food of the host. Intestinal myiasis occurs when fly eggs or larvae previously deposited in food are ingested and survive. Some people with intestinal myiasis have been asymptomatic, while others have experienced abdominal pain, vomiting, and diarrhoea.

The potential health risks associated with the consumption of casu martzu have led to its ban in Italy and the European Union. The sale of this cheese is prohibited as it is considered dangerous, and offenders face heavy fines. Despite the legal restrictions, casu martzu continues to be produced and sold on the black market, where it commands a high price.

The cheese is deemed dangerous by Italian authorities and is prohibited across the EU

Casu marzu, also known as the 'maggot cheese' or 'grub cheese', is a traditional Sardinian sheep milk cheese that contains live insect larvae. The cheese is made by leaving whole pecorino cheeses outside with part of the rind removed, allowing the eggs of the cheese fly Piophila casei to be laid in the cheese. The eggs hatch and the resulting larvae eat through the cheese, breaking down its fats and creating a very soft texture.

The Italian authorities have deemed casu marzu dangerous and banned its sale, and this ban is enforced across the European Union. The cheese is considered potentially dangerous to human health as the ingested maggots may not be destroyed by gastric juices and can cause intestinal lesions. The larvae can also carry harmful microorganisms that may lead to infections. If the maggots survive in the intestine, they can cause enteric pseudomyiasis, although no cases have been linked to the consumption of casu marzu.

Despite the ban, casu marzu is still produced and sold on the black market, sometimes for double the price of an ordinary block of pecorino cheese. It is also available in some local restaurants in Sardinia. The process of making casu marzu is considered an important cultural symbol in Sardinia, and it is believed to be an aphrodisiac.

The European Union has recently begun to study the notion of eating grubs as part of the concept of novel food, where insects are raised to be consumed. This is due to research indicating that insect consumption could help reduce carbon dioxide emissions associated with animal farming and alleviate the climate crisis.

Frequently asked questions