Unveiling The Mystery Of Pink Cheese: A Colorful Curiosity

Have you ever wondered why some cheeses turn pink? This phenomenon, known as 'pinking', is often seen in aged cheddars, Swiss alpine cheese, and some Italian cheeses. While it may be aesthetically unappealing to some, it is important to know that pinking is harmless to consumers. The cause of this colour change has been a mystery, with various hypotheses proposed, including the impact of fluorescent lighting and oxidation. However, researchers from University College Cork, Ireland, have recently identified the chemical and microbial culprits behind this curious transformation.

The science behind pink cheese

Cheese is often associated with a bright orange colour, but in most cases, it doesn't develop that shade on its own. Before dyeing cheese became a common practice, the rich golden colour occurred naturally in cheese made from milk from cows with beta-carotene-rich diets. In the 17th century, English cheesemakers discovered that they could increase their profits by skimming the cream from the milk to make butter or to sell separately. However, this cream also contained most of the orange pigment, so its removal left the cheese with a less desirable colour. To remedy this, cheesemakers began adding colouring to their low-fat cheeses. One popular dye they used was annatto, an additive derived from the seeds of a tropical plant that is still used in cheese today.

While the additive annatto has been used for hundreds of years, the issue of pink discolouration is a more recent phenomenon. Most cheese sold today is displayed under fluorescent lights in grocery stores for long periods. This light bleaches out the yellow component of annatto, leaving the cheese with an unappetising pink tinge. Oxidation has a similar effect, which is why cheddar cheese can turn pink after being exposed to air in the refrigerator for too long.

The pink hue is usually found just under the rind of aged cheddars but can also appear in Swiss alpine cheese and some Italian cheeses, such as Parmigiano Reggiano and Fontina Val d’Aosta. This discolouration, known as 'pinking', is considered a defect by the cheesemaking industry, and affected wheels are discarded or repurposed, resulting in financial losses. Although pinking is aesthetically undesirable, it poses no danger to consumers.

The cause of pinking has been the subject of various hypotheses but has never been conclusively explained until recently. Researchers from University College Cork, Ireland, identified the microbial culprit and the chemical causing the discolouration. They discovered that the presence of the microbe Thermus thermophilus, a thermophile that thrives in environments above 65 °C, was linked to the production of the carotenoid lycopene, resulting in the pink discolouration. This microbe was traced back to the hot water supply pipes in cheesemaking facilities, likely contaminating the cheese during the production process.

While the presence of Thermus thermophilus is a significant contributor to pinking, it is important to note that there may be other causes of pink pigments in cheese. Interactions between bacteria and fungi growing on cheese rinds, for example, have also been implicated in the development of pink or red colours in cheese pastes.

Is pink cheese safe to eat?

There are several reasons why cheese may turn pink. One of the most common causes is microbial processes during cheese production, which can lead to colourful defects. In particular, the presence of the microbe Thermus thermophilus, a thermophile that thrives in environments above 65°C, has been linked to the development of a pinkish hue in cheese, often just under the rind. This microbe was found to be present in the hot water supply pipes of cheesemaking facilities, which can contaminate the cheese and lead to the production of the carotenoid lycopene, resulting in a pinkish appearance.

Another possible explanation for pink cheese is the growth of bacteria called Brevibacterium linens, which is commonly found on the skin and is responsible for the unpleasant odour of sweaty gym socks and shoes. This bacterium also grows on washed rind cheeses, contributing to their strong smell. The growth of B. linens indicates that the acidity level of the cheese has decreased, creating favourable conditions for other bacteria to proliferate. While B. linens itself is likely safe to consume, the presence of pink bacteria on sliced or exposed cheese suggests that other undesirable microorganisms may also be present, increasing the risk of the cheese becoming unsafe for consumption.

In general, the appearance of pink cheese, especially if it is unexpected, can be concerning. While in some cases, the pink hue may be harmless, it could also indicate the presence of undesirable bacteria or other microorganisms that could compromise food safety. Therefore, it is generally recommended to err on the side of caution and discard pink cheese, especially if it has been exposed to the environment or if there are other signs of spoilage, such as an unpleasant odour or a slimy texture.

To prevent cheese from turning pink, proper storage conditions are crucial. For example, storing mozzarella cheese in brine can help extend its shelf life, but the acidity, salt, and calcium levels of the brine must be carefully matched to those of the cheese to avoid adverse effects. Additionally, maintaining proper sanitation and hygiene practices during cheese production and handling can help minimise the risk of microbial contamination and subsequent discolouration.

In summary, while the presence of pink cheese may not always indicate a safety hazard, it is often advisable to discard it to minimise the risk of consuming potentially unsafe food. The appearance of pink cheese can result from various factors, including microbial activity, bacterial growth, and storage conditions. Proper handling, storage, and sanitation practices can help reduce the likelihood of cheese discolouration and potential food safety issues.

The financial impact of pink cheese on cheesemakers

Pink cheese, often referred to as "pinking", is considered a defect in the cheesemaking industry. This phenomenon is characterised by a pinkish hue, typically found around or just under the rind of aged cheddars, Swiss alpine cheeses, and some Italian varieties such as Parmigiano Reggiano and Fontina Val d’Aosta. While the root cause of pinking has been a subject of debate, recent studies have identified the presence of the microbe Thermus thermophilus, which is likely responsible for the colour change. This microbe, originally isolated from a hot spring in Japan, has been found in the hot water supply pipes of cheesemaking facilities, suggesting its inadvertent introduction during the cheesemaking process.

The occurrence of pinking has significant financial implications for cheesemakers. When detected before shipment, affected batches must be discarded or repurposed, resulting in monetary losses. This is purely an aesthetic decision, as the pink hue is not harmful to consumers. However, the presence of unwanted bacteria and the potential for quality defects can damage a cheesemaker's reputation and erode consumer trust.

The financial impact of pinking can be substantial, especially for smaller cheesemakers with limited production batches. The need to discard entire wheels of cheese due to superficial discolouration can result in lost revenue and decreased profitability. Additionally, the time and resources invested in producing the cheese are wasted, impacting the overall efficiency of the cheesemaking operation.

To mitigate these financial losses, cheesemakers have explored strategies to prevent pinking. This includes implementing measures to eliminate the presence of Thermus thermophilus in their facilities, such as improving sanitation practices and regularly testing for the presence of unwanted microbes. By addressing the root cause of the issue, cheesemakers can reduce the occurrence of pinking and minimise its financial consequences.

Furthermore, some cheesemakers have recognised the potential for pink cheese to be a unique and desirable product. By embracing the unexpected colour, they have created limited-edition batches of pink cheese, marketed as a novelty item. This approach not only reduces waste but also generates additional revenue and attracts consumers seeking unusual culinary experiences.

In conclusion, pink cheese, or pinking, presents a financial challenge for cheesemakers, requiring them to balance quality control, consumer expectations, and profitability. While the presence of Thermus thermophilus can lead to unwanted discolouration, innovative solutions and marketing strategies can help transform this defect into an opportunity, minimising financial losses and potentially creating new sources of revenue.

The role of lighting in the discoloration of cheese

Lighting plays a significant role in the discoloration of cheese, specifically in the development of a pink hue. This phenomenon, known as "pinking", is often observed in aged cheddars and occasionally in Swiss alpine and some Italian cheeses. While the exact cause of pinking has been a subject of debate, recent studies have provided insights into the underlying factors.

One factor attributed to pinking is the use of artificial lighting, particularly fluorescent lights, in grocery store display cases. The prolonged exposure to fluorescent lighting can cause the bleaching of annatto, a common dye used in cheese, resulting in an unappealing pinkish tinge. This effect is similar to the oxidation process, which can also turn cheese pink over time when exposed to air in the refrigerator. The intensity and type of lighting can influence the rate and extent of discoloration, with certain wavelengths of light having a more pronounced impact on the cheese's appearance.

In addition to lighting conditions, microbial activity has also been implicated in the development of pink cheese. Researchers from University College Cork, Ireland, identified a specific microbe, Thermus thermophilus, as the primary culprit behind pinking. This microbe, found in the hot water supply pipes of cheesemaking facilities, produces the carotenoid lycopene, which imparts a pink colour to the cheese. The presence of this microbe, along with specific genes involved in carotenoid synthesis, strongly suggests a link between microbial activity and the pink discoloration of cheese.

Furthermore, the interaction between different microbes can also influence the development of pink hues. For example, the presence of propionic acid bacteria alongside Thermus thermophilus resulted in increased carotenoid production and more pronounced pinking. This interplay between microbes highlights the complex nature of cheese discoloration and the need for further research to fully understand all the contributing factors.

To mitigate the issue of pinking, cheesemakers can employ strategies such as using alternative lighting options with different wavelength compositions or adjusting lighting intensities to minimise the bleaching effect on annatto. Additionally, implementing measures to prevent the contamination of cheese with specific microbes, such as Thermus thermophilus, can help reduce the occurrence of pink discoloration. By understanding the role of lighting and microbial activity in cheese discoloration, cheesemakers can develop effective strategies to maintain the desired appearance and quality of their products.

The effect of oxidation on cheese color

The effect of oxidation on cheese colour is a pertinent issue in the cheese industry, as the oxidation process can cause cheese to turn pink, which is often considered a defect. This phenomenon, known as "pinking", occurs when the cheese is exposed to oxygen, resulting in a chemical reaction that alters the cheese's colour. While the exact cause of pinking is not fully understood, it is believed to be due to a combination of factors, including the presence of certain bacteria and the oxidation of annatto, a natural colourant added to cheese.

Annatto, derived from the seed of a tropical plant, has been used for centuries to colour cheese, giving it a rich, golden hue. However, when exposed to oxygen, the annatto undergoes a chemical change, causing the cheese to turn pink. This process is similar to the way iron oxidises and rusts when exposed to air. The oxidation of annatto is particularly noticeable in cheeses that are left open in the refrigerator or under fluorescent lights in grocery store display cases, as the light can also bleach out the yellow component of annatto, enhancing the pink hue.

The presence of certain bacteria can also contribute to the pinking effect. In a study by researchers at University College Cork, Ireland, a specific microbe, Thermus thermophilus, was identified as a culprit in the pink discolouration of cheese. This thermophilic (heat-loving) bacterium was found in the hot water supply pipes of cheesemaking facilities, and its presence in the cheese-making process resulted in increased carotenoid production, leading to the pink hue. Additionally, interactions between bacteria and fungi on cheese rinds have also been implicated in the development of pink or red colours in cheese pastes.

While pinking is considered a defect by cheesemakers and can result in financial losses, it is important to note that it is purely an aesthetic issue and does not pose any danger to consumers. However, the presence of certain bacteria and the oxidation of annatto can still affect the quality and marketability of the cheese. To prevent pinking, cheesemakers can employ strategies such as improving sanitation practices, using alternative colourants, or developing new packaging and storage methods that minimise oxygen exposure.

In conclusion, the effect of oxidation on cheese colour, particularly the development of a pink hue, is a complex issue influenced by various factors, including the oxidation of annatto and the presence of specific bacteria. While pinking may be undesirable from a commercial perspective, it is not a cause for safety concerns. By understanding the underlying causes of pinking, cheesemakers can implement effective strategies to minimise its occurrence and maintain the desired colour and quality of their cheese products.

Frequently asked questions