Natural Cheeses: The American Clone

American cheese is a creamy, smooth cheese made from blending natural cheeses. It comes in several forms including individually wrapped cheese slices, small pre-sliced blocks and large blocks. American cheese melts well thanks to its specific formulation. It is made with butter so you get that nice, creamy melt. It is similar in taste and texture to cheddar cheese. The most similar to real cheese in both taste and texture of any of the deli-style slices we tasted, Organic Valley American Cheese Slices are an ideal option for people who say they don’t like American cheese.

Pasteurized process cheese

American cheese is a creamy, smooth cheese made from blending natural cheeses. It comes in several forms including individually wrapped cheese slices, small pre-sliced blocks and large blocks. American cheese melts well thanks to its specific formulation.

American cheese is made by a Swiss process of blending and melting down "real" cheeses like cheddar or Colby. It is made with milk, cheese culture, salt, enzymes, water, milk fat, sodium citrate, calcium phosphate, sodium phosphate, sorbic acid as a preservative, oleoresin paprika (for color, only in the yellow version), and annatto (for color, only in the yellow version).

American cheese can't be legally marketed as cheese because it contains additives such as whey, milk protein, and emulsifying salts. These mostly natural ingredients give American cheese the qualities that make it so special.

At the end of this process, there are two types of American cheese: pasteurized process cheese food and pasteurized process cheese. Pasteurized process cheese food is the individually wrapped singles you probably grew up with. Pasteurized process cheese is what you'd get sliced at the deli counter.

Organic Valley is a good option for people who want American cheese that’s actually cheese-like. It’s a lot like cheddar in taste and texture (minus any sharpness the aging process might contribute), but it still melts like American. Applegate Organics is another option that melted quickly and was nearly as wonderfully gooey as our top single from Trader Joe’s and our top deli-style slice from Kraft.

Additives in American cheese

American cheese is a creamy, smooth cheese made from blending natural cheeses like cheddar or Colby. It comes in several forms including individually wrapped cheese slices, small pre-sliced blocks, and large blocks.

The Swiss process of blending and melting down natural cheeses is what gives American cheese its unique qualities. However, it's important to note that American cheese can't be legally marketed as cheese because of the additives in its composition. These additives include whey, milk protein, and emulsifying salts.

The pasteurized process cheese food is the individually wrapped singles that you probably grew up with. The pasteurized process cheese is what you'd get sliced at the deli counter.

American cheese is known for its ability to melt well thanks to its specific formulation. It's this property that makes it a popular choice for grilled cheese sandwiches.

Some brands that offer American cheese that tastes similar to natural cheese include Organic Valley and Applegate Organics. These brands offer deli-style slices that are an ideal option for people who say they don’t like American cheese.

Natural ingredients in American cheese

American cheese is a creamy, smooth cheese that is made from blending natural cheeses like cheddar or Colby. It comes in several forms including individually wrapped cheese slices, small pre-sliced blocks and large blocks.

The ingredients in American cheese include milk, cheese culture, salt, enzymes, water, milk fat, sodium citrate, calcium phosphate, sodium phosphate, sorbic acid as a preservative, oleoresin paprika (for colour, only in the yellow version), annatto (for colour, only in the yellow version).

The most similar to real cheese in both taste and texture of any of the deli-style slices we tasted, Organic Valley American Cheese Slices are an ideal option for people who say they don’t like American cheese.

American cheese can't be legally marketed as cheese, even though it's made by a Swiss process of blending and melting down "real" cheeses. But this is only because there are additives in its composition that can include whey, milk protein, and emulsifying salts.

At the end of this process, though you end up with two types of American cheese: pasteurized process cheese food—the individually wrapped singles you probably grew up with—and pasteurized process cheese, which you'd get sliced at the deli counter.

Taste and texture of American cheese

American cheese is a creamy, smooth cheese that is made from blending natural cheeses like cheddar or Colby. It comes in several forms including individually wrapped cheese slices, small pre-sliced blocks, and large blocks. It is pasteurized and has additives like whey, milk protein, and emulsifying salts.

The most similar to real cheese in both taste and texture of any of the deli-style slices is the Organic Valley American Cheese Slices. It is made with butter and has a nice, creamy melt. It is like cheddar in taste and texture but without any sharpness.

When paired with deli meats like cured ham or mortadella, it reads more like a “real” cheese than any of the others we tested. Applegate Organics American Cheese melted quickly and was nearly as wonderfully gooey as our top single from Trader Joe’s and our top deli-style slice from Kraft.

American cheese is a mild cheddar cheese with less of that processed, plasticky texture many people dislike. It also has less silky drape than most American cheeses and takes longer to melt. The white version made without annatto is slightly creamier and softer than its yellow counterpart.

Meltability of American cheese

American cheese is a creamy, smooth cheese that is made from blending natural cheeses. It comes in several forms including individually wrapped cheese slices, small pre-sliced blocks and large blocks. American cheese melts well thanks to its specific formulation.

Organic Valley American Cheese Slices are an ideal option for people who say they don’t like American cheese. It is made with butter so you get that nice, creamy melt. Applegate Organics American Cheese melted quickly and was nearly as wonderfully gooey as our top single from Trader Joe’s and our top deli-style slice from Kraft.

Kraft Singles are a popular American cheese that is made with butter so you get that nice, creamy melt. It is a processed cheese that is made with water, milk fat, sodium citrate, calcium phosphate, salt, sodium phosphate, sorbic acid as a preservative, oleoresin paprika (for color, only in the yellow version), annatto (for color, only in the yellow version).

American cheese can't be legally marketed as cheese, even though it's made by a Swiss process of blending and melting down "real" cheeses like cheddar or Colby. But this is only because there are additives in its composition that can include whey, milk protein, and emulsifying salts. It's these mostly natural ingredients that give American cheese the qualities that make it so special.

Frequently asked questions