Cheez-It Battle: Nacho Cheeseburger Vs. Cheese Pizza

In 2017, Cheez-It launched a You Choose the Champion campaign, allowing fans to vote for their favourite flavour from three new options: Cheez-It Cheese Pizza, Cheez-It Cheeseburger, and Cheez-It Cheddar Nachos. While some reviews praised the novelty of the Cheeseburger flavour, others found it tasted more like a hot dog. The Cheddar Nachos flavour was also criticised for its familiarity and failure to capture the taste of nachos. The Cheese Pizza flavour was generally well-received, with some reviews praising its impressive replication of the pizza taste. However, others noted issues with uneven seasoning. Ultimately, the Cheese Pizza flavour was declared the winner of the competition, but it, along with the Cheeseburger flavour, was later discontinued.

Explore related products

Baked Snack Crackers, Lunch Snacks, Family Size, Hot and Spicy, 21oz Box (1 Box)

$5.97

Cheese Crackers, Baked Snack Crackers, Lunch Snacks, Hot and Spicy, 12.4oz Box (1 Box)

$3.48 $9.47

Baked Snack Crackers - Family Size Original - 21 oz

$7.99

Puff'd Double Cheese 3oz 6ct

$21.22

Baked Snack Cheese Crackers, Hot & Spicy, 7 oz Box

$10.5

Cheese Crackers, Baked Snack Crackers, Lunch Snacks, Original (6 Bags)

$23.76

Cheese Pizza Cheez-Its: a fan favourite

In 2017, Cheez-It introduced three new flavours as part of its "You Choose the Champion" campaign: Cheeseburger, Cheese Pizza, and Cheddar Nachos. While the Cheeseburger flavour was a fan favourite for some, the Cheese Pizza flavour was the overall winner of the campaign.

The Cheese Pizza flavour was well-received by snack enthusiasts, with many praising its accurate flavour profile. One reviewer noted that the crackers smelled like pizza and successfully replicated the taste of cheese pizza, with hints of tomato sauce, cheese, and oregano or parsley. The flavour was also considered impressive and yummy, although some found it to be a bit too familiar.

However, the Cheese Pizza Cheez-Its did face some criticism for their uneven seasoning. Some crackers were described as being underseasoned, while others were heavily seasoned, impacting the overall taste experience. Despite this, the flavour was popular enough to be crowned the winner of the campaign, with Cheez-It fans expressing their disappointment when it was discontinued in 2023.

The Cheese Pizza flavour was a fan favourite, sparking excitement and positive reviews from those who tried it. Its success in the "You Choose the Champion" campaign and the passionate responses to its discontinuation highlight the strong following it cultivated during its time on the market.

Cheeseburger Cheez-Its: tastes like McDonald's

Cheez-It launched a competition, "Cheez-It You Choose the Champion", where people could vote for their favourite flavour from three options: Cheeseburger, Cheese Pizza, and Cheddar Nachos. While the Cheddar Nachos flavour was deemed a failure by some, the Cheese Pizza and Cheeseburger flavours were more successful. However, the cheeseburger flavour stood out to many voters, with its uncanny resemblance to a McDonald's cheeseburger.

The Cheeseburger Cheez-It cracker has a strong mustard and relish flavour, with a hint of ketchup, pickles, and onions. The crackers also have a slight tanginess and a little bit of beef flavouring. One voter compared the flavour to a McDonald's cheeseburger, noting that both have hardly any meat and taste mostly of condiments and toppings. The voter gave the Cheez-It flavour a rating of 7 out of 10, the same rating they would give a McDonald's cheeseburger without fries.

Some voters were disappointed by the Cheese Pizza flavour, finding the crackers to be inconsistently seasoned, with most of them underseasoned. However, the few crackers that were well-seasoned were described as sufficiently tomatoey, with hints of oregano and onion powder. These well-seasoned crackers were likened to the last bite of a pizza with barely any sauce or cheese left. Despite the inconsistent seasoning, another voter found the crackers to be yummy, tasting like cheese pizza with a blend of tomato sauce, cheese, and herbs.

While the Cheddar Nachos flavour was deemed a failure by some voters, others found it to be quite enjoyable. These voters noted that the cheese flavour was more sophisticated than that of regular Cheez-Its, resembling spicy queso dip. The nacho flavour was also said to have a slight peppery element, possibly from jalapeños or chipotle. However, some voters felt that the flavour was too familiar and not complex enough to stand out.

Overall, the Cheeseburger Cheez-It flavour stood out to many voters, with its unique blend of flavours that replicated the taste of a McDonald's cheeseburger. While the Cheese Pizza and Cheddar Nachos flavours had their own merits, they did not achieve the same level of novelty and flavour accuracy as the Cheeseburger flavour.

Cheddar Nachos Cheez-Its: inconsistent seasoning

In 2017, Cheez-It launched a "You Choose the Champion" campaign, inviting people to vote for their favourite flavour from three new options: Cheez-It Cheese Pizza, Cheez-It Cheeseburger, and Cheez-It Cheddar Nachos.

While some reviews of Cheddar Nachos were positive, with one reviewer awarding it a rating of 7.5 out of 10, the flavour was criticised for its inconsistent seasoning. Some crackers were blasted with seasoning, while others had so little that they tasted like regular Cheez-Its. One reviewer noted that this issue could be solved by eating handfuls of crackers at a time, rather than just one at a time.

The Cheddar Nachos flavour was also criticised for tasting too familiar. One reviewer compared it to Taco Bell's nacho cheese sauce, while another likened it to the Cheez-It Grooves Hot & Spicy Cheddar flavour, but less bold.

Despite these criticisms, the Cheddar Nachos flavour was a popular choice, with some reviewers stating that it tied with Cheez-It Cheeseburger for first place. Ultimately, however, the Cheez-It Cheese Pizza flavour was declared the winner of the "You Choose the Champion" campaign by several reviewers.

Explore related products

Original Crackers (3 Pounds)

$14.78

Cheez-It Cracker Throw Pillow

$19.99

Puff'd Cheesy Baked Snacks, Puffed Crackers, Lunch Snacks, Cheese Pizza, 5.75oz Bag (1 Bag)

$11.6

Cheese Crackers, Baked Snack Crackers, Office and Kids Snacks, Hot and Spicy, 5.25lb Case (12 Boxes)

$39.48

Puff'd Cheesy Baked Snacks, Puffed Crackers, Lunch Snacks, Cheese Pizza (6 Bags)

$32.99

Old El Paso Taco Sauce - Creamy Queso Dip, 9 oz.

$4.69

Extra Toasty Cheez-Its: the true champion?

In the battle of the Cheez-It flavours, the true champion may be none of the above. While the nacho cheeseburger and cheese pizza flavours have their fans, it seems that the extra toasty flavour is the real winner.

The "You Choose the Champion" campaign saw Cheez-It release three new flavours: nacho cheeseburger, cheese pizza, and cheddar nachos. The idea was that consumers would vote for their favourite, with the losing flavours being discontinued. However, it seems that none of these flavours were truly able to dethrone the extra toasty Cheez-It.

One reviewer declared that the "true champion" or "King" was Extra Toasty Cheez-It, describing them as "perfectly salted and burnt a little extra". Another agreed, stating that the extra toasty flavour is "saltier and more refined".

While the extra toasty flavour may be the fan favourite, the other flavours in the "You Choose the Champion" campaign had their merits. The cheese pizza flavour was described as "yummy and impressive", although it suffered from uneven seasoning. The nacho cheeseburger flavour was also well-received, with some reviewers praising its ability to replicate the flavour of a McDonald's cheeseburger. However, one reviewer felt that it tasted more like a hot dog.

Ultimately, the cheese pizza flavour was the official winner of the "You Choose the Champion" campaign, although it has since been discontinued. So, while the extra toasty flavour may be the fan-favourite, it seems that none of these flavours have truly stood the test of time.

Cheez-It You Choose the Champion: a competition

Cheez-It launched its "You Choose the Champion" campaign in 2017, inviting fans to vote for their favourite flavour from three new options: Cheeseburger, Cheese Pizza, and Cheddar Nachos. The competition was inspired by Lay's "Do Us A Flavor" campaign, and Cheez-It fans were encouraged to sample all three flavours before casting their vote.

The Cheese Pizza flavour was ultimately declared the winner, with many reviewers praising its strong tomato sauce and cheese flavours, and its similarity to popular frozen pizzas. However, some reviewers noted issues with uneven seasoning, with many crackers tasting like pizza crust rather than the full pizza experience.

The Cheeseburger flavour was also well-received, with some reviewers noting the tanginess of the pickles and the mustard, and the smell of steak sauce. However, others felt that it tasted more like a hot dog than a cheeseburger.

The Cheddar Nachos flavour received mixed reviews, with some enjoying the spicy queso dip flavour and the hint of jalapeño, while others found it too similar to the regular Cheez-It flavour, with an inconsistent level of seasoning.

Despite the success of the Cheese Pizza flavour in the competition, it was discontinued in 2023, along with the Cheeseburger flavour. Fans were disappointed by this decision and took to social media to express their desire for the flavours to return.

Frequently asked questions