Bushra Griffith
In Season 6, Episode 3 of MasterChef, titled 'Apple of My Eye', the top 22 contestants faced their first mystery box challenge, with apple pie as the main dish. One of the contestants, Olivia, made an apple pie with goat cheese and blueberries. The judges thought everything in her pie tasted nice and balanced except for the goat cheese, which tasted out of place. In another episode, contestant Michael made an apple pie with cheddar cheese on top of the crust.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Name of the episode | You're the Apple of My Eye |
| Season | 6 |
| Episode Number | 3 |
| Air Date | May 27, 2015 |
| Channel | FOX |
| Contestants who made apple pie with cheese | Olivia, Michael, Christine Ha |
| Winner of the episode | Christopher |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
Michael's apple pie with cheddar cheese
Michael's story and motivation for appearing on MasterChef were also noteworthy. He wanted to share his experiences and become a role model for young gay Christians struggling with their faith. Despite his early exit from the show, Michael has pursued internships at respected restaurants in Austin, working hard to learn and grow as a chef.
The episode featuring Michael's apple pie with cheddar cheese was "You're the Apple of My Eye," the third episode of Season 6 of MasterChef. It aired on May 27, 2015, on FOX. In this episode, the top 22 contestants faced their first Mystery Box Challenge, with apple pie as the main dish. The contestants had to create their apple pies in just 60 minutes, adding their unique twists.
The judges for this episode included Gordon Ramsay, Christina Tosi, and Graham Elliot. They had varying reactions to the pies presented to them. While some pies received praise for their flavours and presentation, others fell short due to issues with taste, texture, or balance of ingredients.
Overall, Michael's apple pie with cheddar cheese stood out for its creative use of cheese, even though it did not impress the judges. His pie and story continue to be remembered by viewers, showcasing his impact on the competition.
The Making of Pawlet Cheese: A Vermont Original
You may want to see also
Olivia's apple pie with goat cheese and blueberries
In the third episode of Season 6 of MasterChef, Olivia made an apple pie with goat cheese and blueberries. The episode, titled "You're the Apple of My Eye", featured a Mystery Box Challenge where the top 22 contestants had to prepare dishes using ingredients they had left behind in their own kitchens. Olivia's pie was one of the three worst pies of the night, along with Brianna's and Mateo's. Brianna was sent home, while Olivia was spared.
The judges thought that everything in Olivia's pie tasted nice and balanced, except for the goat cheese, which tasted out of place. Graham described the goat cheese as "weird", saying that it gave the pie a "farm flavor". Olivia herself hated her pie so much that she said she would rather shave her head than serve it to the judges.
Despite the negative feedback on her pie, Olivia's creative use of goat cheese and blueberries in an apple pie showcased her unique approach to flavour and ingredient combinations. It takes courage to experiment with unconventional ingredients, and although the judges did not favour her choice of goat cheese, it is commendable that she took a risk and put her own twist on a classic dessert.
Overall, while Olivia's pie may not have been a success, her willingness to take risks and step outside the box is an important aspect of culinary innovation and can often lead to delicious surprises. It is also a reminder that even when things don't turn out as expected, there is still value in the attempt and the opportunity to learn and grow as a chef.
Big Cheese Chews: Barkworthies' Manufacturing Secrets Revealed
You may want to see also
Brianna's apple pie with ginger and mint
The episode, titled "'Apple of My Eye'", was the third episode of Season 6 of MasterChef, aired on May 27, 2015, on FOX. In this episode, the top 22 contestants faced their first Mystery Box Challenge, with the main dish being apple pie. The contestants had 60 minutes to prepare their dishes.
The inclusion of cheese in apple pie was a talking point in this episode. Contestant Olivia's apple pie with goat cheese and blueberries was criticised for the cheese's incongruity with the other flavours. Another contestant, Michael, scattered cheddar cheese on top of his crust, which the judges were unsure about. However, it is worth noting that this approach to apple pie has precedent, with Martha Stewart and several online recipes incorporating cheddar cheese crusts.
Ultimately, the winner of the elimination challenge was Christopher, whose apple pie with maple syrup and bourbon filling impressed the judges with its beautiful pastry and amazing colour.
Goat Cheese: A Historical Culinary Delight
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Mateo's ginger apple pie with cardamom and salted caramel
In Season 6, Episode 3 of MasterChef, titled "You're the Apple of My Eye", the top 22 contestants faced their first mystery box challenge, with apple pie as the main dish. The contestants had 60 minutes to prepare their dishes using a unique set of ingredients left behind in their own kitchens.
Mateo, a high school teacher with a distinctive large bow tie, presented a ginger apple pie with cardamom and salted caramel. Unfortunately, his creation received negative reviews from the judges due to several technical issues. The apples in the pie were too thick, and the pastry was too thin to hold the weight of the filling, resulting in the pie disintegrating when cut. Additionally, the judges found the ginger to be overpowering, throwing off the balance of flavours in the pie.
Mateo's pie was ultimately ranked among the three worst pies of the night, along with Brianna's and Olivia's. As a result, Mateo became the first contestant to be eliminated from the competition.
It is worth noting that while Mateo's pie did not impress the judges, other contestants incorporated cheese into their apple pie creations. For instance, Olivia used goat cheese and blueberries, and Michael, from Season 3, opted for a cheddar cheese crust. However, the judges were not entirely convinced by the addition of cheese to the traditional apple pie.
President Cheese: Where is it Made?
You may want to see also
Sarah's pecan apple pie with cinnamon and caramel
In the third episode of Season 6 of MasterChef, the top 22 contestants competed in their first two challenges, with apple pie as the main dish. One of the contestants, Sarah, made a pecan apple pie with cinnamon and caramel sauce. The pie was deemed delicious by the judges, with Graham describing it as "a slice of autumn" and "textbook".
The challenge was particularly intense as the contestants only had 60 minutes to prepare their dishes. This was not the only time apple pie was featured as a challenge on the show. In another episode, titled 'Marines and Apple Pie', the pressure test challenge was to bake an apple pie in just 75 minutes.
Some contestants took a more unconventional approach to the classic apple pie, such as Michael, who scattered cheddar cheese on top of his crust for a crunchy cheesy top. However, the judges were not entirely convinced by this addition, despite its presence in dozens of recipes online and Martha Stewart's own recipe.
Ultimately, it was Christopher who won the elimination challenge for his apple pie with maple syrup and bourbon filling, despite his initial nerves about never having made an apple pie before.
Babybel Cheese Wax: What's the Mystery Ingredient?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Olivia made an apple pie with goat cheese and blueberries on MasterChef.
The judges thought everything in Olivia's pie tasted nice and balanced except for the goat cheese, which tasted out of place.
Yes, Michael made an apple pie with cheddar cheese on top of the crust on MasterChef.
The judges were not entirely sure about the cheddar cheese in Michael's pie, but they did not think it was a bad idea as there are dozens of recipes for apple pie with cheddar cheese crust.
Yes, many other contestants made apple pies on MasterChef, including Christopher, Brianna, Mateo, Steven/Stephen, Charlie, and Sara/Sarah.
