The Uneven Chucky Cheese Pizza Mystery: Why The Difference?

Chuck E. Cheese's pizza has been the topic of much discussion and speculation, with some people even going so far as to suggest that the restaurant chain recycles old, uneaten slices to create new pizzas. This theory has gained traction due to the perceived abnormalities in the shape and size of the pizza slices. However, Chuck E. Cheese's has denied these claims, stating that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough prepared in-restaurant, resulting in slight variations in shape. Employees have also offered alternative explanations, such as the use of a bulky pizza slicer that is difficult to handle, causing slices to move and create uneven shapes. While the true reason behind the unevenness of Chuck E. Cheese's pizzas remains a mystery, it has sparked interesting discussions and reactions from the public.

Explore related products

KITCH 24/7 Personal Cheese Pizza 7 inch – 20 per case

$89.72

Annie's Frozen Mini Pizza Bagels, Three Cheese, Snacks, 9 Ct, 6.65 oz

$6.79

365 By Whole Foods Market, Pizza Blend Cheese, Shredded, 8 Ounce

$3.19

Annie's Frozen Pizza Poppers, Three Cheese, Snacks, 6.8 oz, 15 ct

$6.29

Amy's Frozen Snacks, Cheese Pizza Snacks, Made With Organic Flour and Tomatoes, Microwave Meals, 6.0 Oz

$6.39

365 By Whole Foods Market, Pizza, Thin Crust Four Cheese, 12.5 Ounce

$4.59

Shane Dawson's conspiracy theory

In a 2019 YouTube video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", YouTuber Shane Dawson, with over 20 million subscribers, discussed several theories about Chuck E. Cheese's pizza. The theory that caught the most attention was that Chuck E. Cheese employees recycle leftover pizza slices to create new pizzas to serve. Dawson and his companions ordered several pizzas at a Chuck E. Cheese restaurant and were shocked to see that the pizza was misshapen, with the crust misaligned and failing to form a perfect circle.

In the video, Dawson suggests that the franchise's pizzas look weird because they are assembled from old, uneaten slices. This idea has gained traction as people have noticed the uneven slices, toppings, and crust on Chuck E. Cheese pizzas. Dawson's theory is not entirely new, as similar claims about the pizza chain can be found on the internet as far back as 2009. However, Dawson's large platform and influence brought the theory back into the spotlight, leading to a wave of reactions from the public and responses from former and current Chuck E. Cheese employees.

Some alleged employees of Chuck E. Cheese's took to Twitter and Reddit to refute Dawson's theory. One Reddit user, identified as Jade, wrote, "I'm a cashier and hate my job anyway, but [Dawson’s] theory is just grasping at straws." Additionally, YouTuber Payden, an ex-Chuck E. Cheese employee, explained that the uneven slices could be attributed to kitchen staff errors during the cutting process. For example, they might cut an extra slice to make up for a previous mistake, resulting in "funky" and misaligned pizzas.

Chuck E. Cheese's also denied Dawson's claims, releasing an official statement to several news outlets: "The claims made in this video about Chuck E. Cheese’s and our pizza are unequivocally false. No conspiracies here—our pizzas are made to order, and we prepare our dough fresh in our restaurant, which means that they’re not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious." The company attributed any abnormalities in the shape of their pizzas to their made-to-order process, claiming that their dough is always freshly prepared in-house. Despite the backlash and refutations, Chuck E. Cheese's did not sue Dawson over the conspiracy theory.

Chuck E. Cheese's response

Chuck E. Cheese has denied the claims made in Shane Dawson's video, stating that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough prepared in-restaurant, which may result in slight variations in shape but does not compromise taste. They have refuted any conspiracies suggesting that they recycle or reuse leftover pizza slices.

The company has addressed the issue by emphasising the made-to-order nature of their pizzas and the use of fresh dough, which can result in slight variations in shape. They have denied any intentional uneven distribution or recycling of slices. Chuck E. Cheese's response also included input from alleged employees, who took to social media platforms like Twitter and Reddit to refute the claims. One self-identified employee, Jade, expressed their scepticism about the theory, stating that it was "grasping at straws".

Additionally, an ex-employee, YouTuber Payden, provided insight into the pizza-making process, explaining that uneven slices could result from kitchen staff errors during the cutting process. This explanation aligns with another theory offered by employees, who attributed the uneven slices to the use of a bulky pizza slicer that is challenging to handle, causing slices to shift and resulting in irregular shapes and cut marks.

While Chuck E. Cheese has vehemently denied the conspiracy theories, they have not taken legal action against Shane Dawson or other proponents of these claims. The company's response focused on refuting the allegations, emphasising the freshness and quality of their pizzas, and providing explanations for the occasional uneven shapes of their slices.

Alleged employees' opinions

Alleged employees of Chuck E. Cheese's have taken to social media to refute Shane Dawson's theory that the restaurant recycles old, uneaten slices of pizza. They claim that the pizzas are made-to-order and that any abnormalities in the shape are the result of this process. One Reddit user, identified as Jade, a cashier at Chuck E. Cheese's, wrote, "I'm a cashier and hate my job anyway, but [Dawson’s] theory is just grasping at straws". YouTuber Payden, an ex-Chuck E. Cheese employee, explained that the uneven slices resulted from kitchen staff errors during the cutting process. For example, after cutting, if they realized they were a slice short, they would randomly cut an extra slice in the pizza, making it look "funky" and throwing off the alignment.

Other alleged employees have explained that the misshapen pizzas are a result of a heavy, bulky pizza slicer that is hard to handle. As they are cutting the pizza, the slices move around on the tray, creating uneven shapes and strange cut marks. However, critics of this theory point out that it doesn't explain why some pizza slices look shrunken compared to others and why the crust doesn't line up all the way around. While some find this theory entertaining, they don't believe it, as it seems like a high-risk, low-reward situation for the company.

It's important to note that Chuck E. Cheese's has denied Dawson's claims and released an official statement to several news outlets: "The claims made in this video about Chuck E. Cheese’s and our pizza are unequivocally false. No conspiracies here — our pizzas are made to order, and we prepare our dough fresh in our restaurant, which means that they’re not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious."

Explore related products

365 by Whole Foods Market, Thin Crust Uncured Pepperoni Pizza, 13.3 Ounce

$4.59

365 By Whole Foods Market, Pizza, Cheese Two Pack, Frozen, 25 Ounce

$8.49

Amy's Frozen Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Made With Organic Flour and Tomatoes, Frozen Meals, 13.0 Oz

$10.49

Rao's Made for Home Frozen Pizza - Uncured Pepperoni, Brick Oven Crust, Premium Quality, Fresh Shredded Whole Milk Mozzarella Cheese

$12.29

Whole Foods Market, Italian Cheeseboard Pizza, Frozen Wood-Fired, 13.7 Ounce

$6.49

365 By Whole Foods Market, Pizza, Rising Crust Four Cheese, 28.6 Ounce

$6.49

The made-to-order process

Chuck E. Cheese's pizza-making process involves preparing dough fresh in the restaurant, which can result in slight variations in the shape and size of the pizza base. This made-to-order approach ensures that each pizza is prepared from scratch, contributing to the unique characteristics of each pie. While some may perceive these irregularities as a negative aspect, Chuck E. Cheese's emphasizes that their pizzas, though not perfectly uniform, are consistently delicious.

The process of making a pizza from scratch involves various steps, each contributing to the final product's distinctiveness. Firstly, the dough is prepared and rolled out to form the base. At Chuck E. Cheese, the dough is made fresh, which means that each batch may have slight differences in texture and consistency, impacting the overall shape of the pizza base.

After adding the sauce, cheese, and desired toppings, the pizza is ready for baking. The oven's temperature and timing play a crucial role in determining the pizza's doneness and crispness. Once baked, the pizza is removed from the oven and prepared for slicing.

The slicing process is where the made-to-order nature of Chuck E. Cheese's pizzas becomes even more evident. As each pizza is freshly prepared, the slicing may not always result in perfectly symmetrical slices. The weight and bulkiness of the pizza slicer, combined with the softness of the fresh dough, can cause the slices to shift slightly during cutting, resulting in uneven shapes and slight misalignments in the crust.

While some critics have attributed the uneven slices to cost-cutting measures, such as reusing leftover pizza slices, these claims have been refuted by the company and former employees. The more plausible explanation lies in the inherent variability of the made-to-order process, where each pizza is crafted individually, leading to minor inconsistencies in shape and size. Ultimately, Chuck E. Cheese's maintains that their pizzas are freshly made and that any irregularities in shape do not compromise the taste or quality of their product.

The bulky pizza slicer

Shane Dawson, one of YouTube's biggest stars, has sparked a conspiracy theory about Chuck E. Cheese's pizza, specifically regarding the uneven slices and misshapen crusts. In his video "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson," Dawson and his friends discuss the theory that Chuck E. Cheese's employees recycle leftover pizza slices to create new pizzas. They are shocked by the misshapen pizzas they receive, with crusts that do not form a perfect circle.

While Chuck E. Cheese has denied Dawson's claims, employees and those claiming to work there have offered explanations for the uneven pizza slices. One such explanation is the use of a bulky pizza slicer. Allegedly, the weight of the slicer makes it difficult to handle, causing the pizza slices to shift on the tray during the cutting process, resulting in uneven shapes and strange cut marks.

However, critics of this theory point out that it does not explain why some slices appear shrunken compared to others and why the crusts do not always line up. They argue that reusing pizzas to save money seems like a high-risk, low-reward situation, as any potential savings could be outweighed by lawsuits if customers found out. Additionally, they question the likelihood of employees keeping such a secret for an extended period.

Despite the criticism, the bulky pizza slicer theory has gained attention as a potential explanation for the uneven pizzas at Chuck E. Cheese. While the truth behind the misshapen pizzas remains a mystery, it has sparked interesting discussions and reactions from people, with some finding entertainment in the various theories proposed.

Frequently asked questions