The Mystery Behind Chuck E. Cheese's Pizza Shape

Chuck E. Cheese's pizza has been the subject of a conspiracy theory that went viral in 2019, sparked by YouTuber Shane Dawson's video, which questioned the shape of the pizza served at the restaurant chain. Dawson's video claimed that the misshapen pizzas were evidence that Chuck E. Cheese's was reusing leftover slices from customers' tables to create new pizzas, which were then reheated and served to other customers. The video prompted a response from Chuck E. Cheese's, who denied the claims, stating that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough, which may result in non-uniform shapes. Employees also offered explanations for the misshapen pizzas, including difficulties in cutting the pizza and the process of sliding it from the cutting board to a tray. Despite the company's denial and the lack of evidence, the conspiracy theory gained traction on social media, with some users demanding an explanation from the restaurant chain.

Shane Dawson's conspiracy theory about Chuck E. Cheese's recycled pizzas

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", in which he discussed a conspiracy theory about Chuck E. Cheese's pizza being recycled from leftover slices. In the video, Dawson recalled memories from his childhood visits to the restaurant and his confusion over the misshapen pizza slices, which should have been round and even. He hypothesized that employees gathered uneaten pizza, consolidated the leftovers, and served them to new customers.

To test this theory, Dawson analysed photos of Chuck E. Cheese pizzas, visited the restaurant to observe the pizzas firsthand, and even took a pizza home to examine how it was sliced. He pointed out the jagged crusts and misaligned pepperonis, claiming that the uneven slices were evidence of the recycling process. Dawson's video gained widespread attention, with many viewers taking his theory as fact and demanding explanations from the restaurant chain.

However, Dawson's theory had several flaws. Firstly, a misaligned crust does not necessarily indicate that the pizza was made from different pies. Additionally, it is unlikely that enough untouched pizza slices would be left behind by customers to routinely form new pizzas. Despite these shortcomings, the conspiracy theory sparked intense online discussions and prompted Chuck E. Cheese to issue a public statement refuting the claims:

> The claims made in this video about Chuck E. Cheese’s and our pizza are unequivocally false. No conspiracies here – our pizzas are made to order and we prepare our dough fresh in the restaurant, which means that they’re not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious.

An ex-employee of Chuck E. Cheese also explained that uneven slices could result from kitchen staff cutting mistakes or realising they were a slice short and randomly cutting an extra slice, which would make the pizza look "funky" and further throw off the alignment.

While Chuck E. Cheese denied Dawson's claims, they did not sue him over the conspiracy theory. The incident sparked a broader conversation about the belief in conspiracy theories and the role of online platforms in disseminating such theories.

Chuck E. Cheese's official response to the conspiracy theory

We at Chuck E. Cheese's take the quality of our food and the satisfaction of our customers very seriously. We are aware of the recent conspiracy theory regarding our pizza, which claims that we recycle leftover slices to create new pizzas to serve to our customers. We want to assure our valued customers that these claims are unequivocally false.

Our pizzas are made to order, and we prepare our dough fresh in our restaurants, which means that they may not always be perfectly uniform in shape, but they are always delicious. Each pizza is handmade by our talented team of pizza pros, ensuring that every 'za is unique and made with care. The amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings may vary, but we guarantee that every slice is fresh and never recycled.

We understand that sometimes the shape of our pizzas may look a bit misshapen, but we can assure you that this is due to the handmade nature of our pizzas. Our kitchen staff does their best to ensure each pizza is cut and prepared perfectly, but sometimes things may look a little "funky." Rest assured, this does not affect the taste or quality of our pizzas.

We take food safety and sanitation very seriously, and we would never serve leftover or uneaten food to our customers. Our employees are trained to follow strict food handling and safety protocols, and we have robust procedures in place to ensure the freshness and quality of our ingredients. The idea that we would reuse uneaten pizza slices is simply untrue and goes against our commitment to providing our customers with a safe and enjoyable dining experience.

We invite our customers to come and see the magic happen in our kitchens and watch as our talented pizza pros create their pizzas from scratch. We are proud of our food and our commitment to freshness, and we welcome anyone who wants to see firsthand the care and dedication that goes into every pizza we make.

Thank you for your continued support, and we look forward to serving you and your families for many years to come.

The role of social media in spreading the theory

Social media played a pivotal role in spreading the theory that Chuck E. Cheese's pizzas are misshapen because the restaurant chain reuses leftover slices to create new pizzas. This conspiracy theory first emerged on Yahoo! Answers in 2009, but it gained traction a decade later when YouTuber Shane Dawson, with over 20 million subscribers, posted a 94-minute "investigative" video in 2019. The video, titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson," included footage of Dawson and his friends ordering and examining Chuck E. Cheese pizzas with misaligned crusts and toppings.

The video sparked widespread discussion and speculation on social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and Reddit. Users shared photos of misshapen pizzas from the chain, demanding explanations and fuelling the conspiracy. Dawson's substantial online following and the engaging visual content of his video were key factors in the rapid spread of the theory. The use of hashtags, retweets, and shares on Twitter, for instance, enabled the idea to reach a vast audience in a short period.

Social media users also actively participated in investigating and debating the theory. Some conducted their own experiments, visiting Chuck E. Cheese restaurants to observe the pizzas and dining experiences firsthand. Others shared their personal experiences as customers or employees of the chain, offering alternative explanations for the misshapen pizzas, such as errors in the dough preparation or cutting processes.

The intense online discussion prompted an official response from Chuck E. Cheese, who denied the accusations. They issued statements on Twitter and to news outlets, emphasising that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough, which can result in variations in shape. The franchise also received support from health officials, who deemed the idea of pizza slice recycling highly unlikely.

While the theory was ultimately debunked, the incident demonstrates the power of social media in disseminating information, engaging audiences, and holding businesses accountable. It also highlights the potential pitfalls of online discourse, where misinformation can spread rapidly and cause significant reputational damage, even when the claims are baseless.

The impact of the conspiracy theory on the public's perception of the brand

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson, who has over 20 million subscribers, released a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson". In it, he discussed and seemingly supported a long-standing conspiracy theory that Chuck E. Cheese's recycled leftover pizza slices to create new pizzas to serve. The video, which has been viewed tens of millions of times, caused a significant stir, with many social media users taking the theory as fact and demanding explanations from the company.

The impact of this conspiracy theory on the public's perception of the brand was notable. Despite Chuck E. Cheese's official denial of the claims and explanations for misshapen pizzas, including the use of fresh dough and handmade preparation, the theory still had a lasting effect on brand perception. The incident caused a significant number of people to question the hygiene and sanitation practices of the company, with some even conducting their own investigations into the claims. The conspiracy theory also contributed to a broader narrative of "unsanitary conditions" within the restaurants, further damaging the brand's reputation.

The conspiracy theory's popularity and impact highlight the potential for negative publicity to influence public opinion and brand perception. While Chuck E. Cheese's denied the allegations and provided explanations for the misshapen pizzas, the incident likely left a lasting impression on consumers, potentially affecting their trust in the brand and their willingness to dine at the restaurant. This is particularly true for parents, who are responsible for the safety and well-being of their children and may have heightened concerns about hygiene and sanitation.

Furthermore, the conspiracy theory's focus on pizza, a core product of the brand, made the allegations especially damaging. Pizza is a signature offering of Chuck E. Cheese's, and the suggestion that the company engages in unsanitary practices or false advertising could have a direct impact on sales and revenue. The incident may have caused a decline in pizza orders and could have led to a broader loss of trust in the brand, affecting sales across other product categories as well.

To mitigate the impact of the conspiracy theory, Chuck E. Cheese's took several steps, including official denials, employee testimonials, and explanations for misshapen pizzas. They emphasised the use of fresh dough and handmade preparation, addressing the concerns of those who believed the theory. Additionally, the company introduced other changes, such as a retooled pizza recipe, the removal of animatronics, and the addition of trampolines, to revitalise the brand and attract a new generation of customers. These efforts appear to have been successful, with the company reporting eight straight months of same-store sales growth.

Overall, the impact of the conspiracy theory on the public's perception of the brand was significant. Despite official denials and explanations, the incident likely left a lasting impression on consumers, affecting their trust and willingness to dine at the restaurant. However, through a combination of direct responses and broader brand revitalisation efforts, Chuck E. Cheese's has been able to make a comeback and reconnect with its customers.

The potential reasons for misshapen pizzas, such as handmade dough or cutting errors

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", in which he discussed a conspiracy theory that Chuck E. Cheese's recycled leftover pizza slices to create new pizzas. The video sparked widespread attention, with many social media users taking the theory as fact and demanding explanations from the pizza chain.

In response to the speculation, Chuck E. Cheese's issued an official statement denying the claims:

> "The claims made about Chuck E. Cheese's and our pizza are unequivocally false. No conspiracies here — our pizzas are made to order and we prepare our dough fresh in our restaurant, which means that they're not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious."

The company attributed the misshapen pizzas to the fact that each pizza is handmade, which can result in variations in the amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings, as well as the shape of the dough. Additionally, an ex-employee of Chuck E. Cheese's explained that the uneven slices could also be a result of cutting errors during the preparation process. Sometimes, after realizing they were a slice short, staff would randomly cut an extra slice, making the pizza look "funky" and further throwing off the alignment.

Another Reddit user, claiming to be a current employee of the restaurant, provided a more detailed explanation:

> "It's just when the pizza comes out of the oven, they place it on a cutting board in order to slice it. The slicer is very large and kind of heavy, so some people have a lot of difficulty trying to cut the pizza perfectly... After the pizza is done being cut, the cook slides it onto a tray to carry out to the guests. It's when the pizza is being slid off of the cutting board and onto the tray where it gets kind of wonky looking."

Thus, there are several potential reasons for the misshapen pizzas at Chuck E. Cheese's, including variations in handmade dough preparation and cutting errors during the pizza-making process.

Frequently asked questions