Cheese Vs Pepperoni: Which Pizza Rules The World?

Pepperoni and cheese are two of the most popular pizza toppings, with pepperoni often considered a quintessential American topping. While cheese pizza is seen as a safer option, especially for children, pepperoni is a beloved classic that is hard to beat. So, which is more popular? A YouGov survey revealed that 51% of Americans love extra cheese on their pizza, while 50% love pepperoni, making it a close call. However, a survey by Hormel Foods found that 79% of Americans believe pizza is better with pepperoni, suggesting that pepperoni might edge out cheese in the battle of the toppings.

Explore related products

The Elements of Pizza: Unlocking the Secrets to World-Class Pies at Home [A Cookbook]

$16.96 $32.99

Hillshire Snacking All Natural Uncured Pepperoni Deli Lunch Meat with Natural White Cheddar Cheese, 2.76 Oz

$2.78

Hormel Snacktray/Pep/Cheese/Crk, 14.7 oz

$7.97

Hormel Gatherings, Hard Salami & Pepperoni Party Tray, 28 oz

$11.99

COLUMBUS Pepperoni Panino, 3.9 Oz

$6.99

COLUMBUS Salami Deli Meat Panino, Genoa Salame & Mozzarella Cheese, Charcuterie Food Items, Gluten Free, 3.9 Oz Pack

$6.99

Pepperoni is a popular pizza topping worldwide, especially in the US

Pepperoni is a popular pizza topping worldwide, with a strong following in the United States. It has been described as a "quintessential American pizza topping", alongside cheese and tomato sauce. Its popularity is such that most pizza restaurants offer it as a standard option, and it is often viewed as a classic, beloved choice.

In the US, pepperoni is more than just a topping; it is a cultural icon. For many Americans, curling up on the couch with a pepperoni pizza is a source of comfort and a sense of normalcy, especially during challenging times like the COVID-19 pandemic. Nearly four in five Americans (79%) believe that pizza is better with pepperoni on it, and it is often the first pizza to be devoured at parties.

The allure of pepperoni as a topping is multi-faceted. Firstly, it is a versatile meat that can be sliced thin or thick, piled high, or baked into the crust. Different regions of the US have their own unique preferences for preparing and enjoying pepperoni on their pizzas. For example, in New York, thin slices of pepperoni are often piled high, while in Chicago, deep-dish pizzas feature thick slices of pepperoni baked into the crust.

Additionally, pepperoni has an irresistible taste that keeps people coming back for more. It is often described as "delicious" and is considered a perfect match for pizza, akin to peanut butter and jelly. This popularity is not limited to the US, as pepperoni is enjoyed by people all over the world.

While pepperoni may not be the healthiest option, it continues to be a beloved favorite that shows no signs of losing its popularity anytime soon. Whether it's the classic combination of pepperoni and cheese or a unique custom creation, pepperoni remains a topping that satisfies pizza lovers around the globe.

Cheese pizza is seen as the new plain due to the rise of the meatless movement

While pepperoni is a beloved classic pizza topping, cheese pizza is gaining popularity due to the rise of the meatless movement. Cheese pizza is now considered the new "plain" option that anyone can eat, and its popularity is growing.

In the past, pepperoni was the go-to choice for those who wanted a simple, no-frills pizza. However, with the increasing number of people reducing their meat consumption or adopting vegetarian and vegan diets, cheese pizza has become the new default option. This shift can be attributed to the growing meatless movement, which has led to a higher demand for meat-free options.

The popularity of cheese pizza can also be influenced by personal preferences and health considerations. Some people may prefer the taste and texture of cheese pizza, finding it less greasy and more flavourful than pepperoni pizza. Additionally, cheese pizza can be a safer option for those who are squeamish about toppings or have dietary restrictions.

According to a YouGov survey, while pepperoni is still America's favourite pizza topping, extra cheese is a close second. The survey revealed that 51% of Americans love extra cheese, while 50% love pepperoni. This indicates that cheese pizza is becoming a strong contender to the once-dominant pepperoni.

The rise of the meatless movement has significant implications for the pizza industry. Pizza restaurants and brands are now offering more meat-free options to cater to the growing demand. This includes not only cheese pizzas but also innovative vegetarian and vegan pizzas, such as those featuring vegetables, plant-based meats, or other creative combinations.

Four in five Americans believe pepperoni is a perfect match for pizza

While cheese pizza is often regarded as a classic, it is safe to say that pepperoni has stolen the hearts of Americans. A survey conducted by The Harris Poll revealed that four in five Americans believe pepperoni is a perfect match for pizza, with 80% of respondents stating that pepperoni and pizza go together like "peanut butter and jelly." This sentiment is reflected in the pizza emoji, which features pepperoni as the chosen topping.

The popularity of pepperoni as a pizza topping is deeply ingrained in American culture, with many fond memories of pizza nights and parties involving this beloved combination. In fact, during the COVID-19 pandemic, pizza was a comfort food for 73% of Americans, and pepperoni pizza provided a sense of normalcy during challenging times. This preference for pepperoni is also evident in the way people order pizza. While some may prefer a simple cheese pizza, many opt for a classic pepperoni or even add pepperoni to their custom creations.

The allure of pepperoni pizza extends beyond its delicious taste. Pepperoni is a versatile topping that can be tailored to regional preferences. In New York, thin slices of pepperoni piled high atop a pizza are common, while Chicago-style deep-dish pizza features thick slices of pepperoni baked into the crust. This adaptability has contributed to its widespread appeal across the country.

However, it is worth noting that while pepperoni reigns supreme, cheese is a close contender. According to a YouGov survey, 51% of Americans love extra cheese on their pizza, while 50% expressed their love for pepperoni. This slight difference in preference highlights the ongoing debate between cheese and pepperoni enthusiasts. Nevertheless, the combination of cheese and pepperoni is also a classic choice, satisfying those who want the best of both worlds.

Explore related products

Hormel, Pepperoni Original, 6 Ounce

$3.97

Hillshire Snacking Small Plates, Italian Dry Salami and Gouda Cheese, Single Serve

$2.78

FrigoCheese Heads, Sharp Cheddar Cheese Sticks and Beef Sticks, 8 ct

$3.99

Tillamook Country Smoker Real Hardwood Smoked Sausages, Pepperoni, 15.2 Ounce Tall Jar, 20 Count

$16.99

Naturalissima, Uncured Pepperoni Panino, 6 oz

$7.49

Dietz & Watson Sliced Pepperoni, 6 oz

$4.29

Cheese is the best ingredient on pizza as it brings the most texture and flavour

While pepperoni is a beloved classic, cheese is the best ingredient to put on a pizza as it brings the most texture and flavour. Cheese is a quintessential pizza topping, and extra cheese is the most-beloved pizza topping according to a YouGov survey, with 51% of Americans saying they love it and 33% liking it.

Cheese is a versatile topping, and a good melting cheese can bring a pizza together. It is a safe option for those who are squeamish about toppings and is a popular choice for children. Cheese is also a great option for those who don't eat meat, and with the meatless movement growing, cheese pizza is the new 'plain'.

Cheese is a popular topping worldwide, and while pepperoni is a favourite in the United States, it is not as popular in other countries. Cheese is a simple, effective, and classic choice for a pizza topping. It is a staple for a reason, and while some may prefer to add extra toppings, cheese is a reliable and tasty option.

In addition, cheese is a healthier option than pepperoni. Pepperoni is high in fat and calories and can contribute to weight gain and health issues if consumed in large amounts. Cheese, on the other hand, provides protein and calcium and can be a good source of vitamins and minerals.

Finally, cheese is a comforting and nostalgic food for many people. It is a familiar and enjoyable taste that can evoke happy memories, especially for millennials who grew up with pizza nights and pizza parties.

Pepperoni is a beloved classic that has been around for decades

In the US, pepperoni is a favourite topping, with nearly four in five Americans (79%) believing that pizza is better with pepperoni on it. This preference for pepperoni is so strong that Americans are more than twice as likely to choose it over other popular options, such as sausage (38% vs 15%). The popularity of pepperoni is not limited to a specific region or style of pizza; instead, it is enjoyed across different variations, such as the thin-crust New York-style pizza and the deep-dish Chicago-style pizza.

The allure of pepperoni is not just limited to its taste but also to the memories and emotions associated with it. Many Americans, especially millennials (81%), have nostalgic memories of eating pepperoni pizza with their families as children, making it a beloved classic. This emotional connection is one of the reasons why pepperoni remains a popular choice for pizza nights and gatherings with friends and family.

While pepperoni may not be the healthiest option, it continues to be a favourite among pizza enthusiasts. Its widespread popularity has ensured that most pizza restaurants offer pepperoni as a topping, making it easily accessible for those who crave it.

Despite the growing popularity of cheese pizzas, particularly due to dietary preferences and the meatless movement, pepperoni remains a classic choice that is hard to beat for many pizza lovers.

Frequently asked questions