Cannoli Conundrum: Which Cheeses Complement This Sicilian Treat?

The traditional filling for cannoli, a Sicilian dessert, is made from ricotta cheese. This soft, white cheese is made from whey, a protein that is left over when making other types of cheese. It is low-fat and slightly grainy, similar to cottage cheese. However, some recipes use a mixture of ricotta and mascarpone, or mascarpone on its own, as the filling.

Characteristics of cheese used in Cannoli

Ricotta is the traditional filling

Cannoli is a traditional Italian dessert, originating on the island of Sicily. It consists of a tube-shaped, fried pastry shell with a creamy, sweet filling.

The traditional filling for cannoli is made from ricotta cheese. This soft, white cheese is made from whey, which is the protein left over when processing dairy to make other types of cheese. It is low in fat and has a slightly grainy texture, similar to cottage cheese.

When making cannoli, it is important to drain the ricotta cheese overnight to remove excess moisture. This ensures that the filling is not too runny, which can cause the pastry shell to become soggy. The drained ricotta is then mixed with other ingredients, such as sugar, vanilla, and chocolate chips, to create the sweet, creamy filling.

Using ricotta cheese for the filling is not only traditional but also ensures a healthier dessert, as ricotta is lower in fat than other cheeses sometimes used in cannoli, such as mascarpone or cream cheese.

While ricotta is the traditional filling, some variations exist, and it is not uncommon to find cannoli filled with other cheeses or even custard or ice cream. Ultimately, the choice of filling depends on personal preference, and experimenting with different fillings can be enjoyable.

Mascarpone is a popular alternative

Mascarpone is thicker and denser than ricotta, which means you're less likely to end up with a runny filling and soggy pastry. This is because mascarpone has a lower moisture content than ricotta, which is softer and more liquid in texture. Ricotta is made from whey, a protein that's left over when processing dairy to make other cheeses. On the other hand, mascarpone is made from cow's milk and has a texture more like butter or custard.

If you want to make a cannoli filling that's true to the traditional Italian dessert, then ricotta is the best choice. However, if you're looking for a filling that's thicker, higher in fat, and easier to control, then mascarpone is a great alternative.

You can also use a blend of ricotta and mascarpone, which offers a flavour similar to traditional ricotta with the added creaminess of mascarpone. This blend gives you the best of both worlds and can be a good option if you want to stick closer to the traditional recipe while still enjoying the benefits of mascarpone.

Ricotta should be strained before use

Ricotta is a soft, white cheese made from whey—a protein that's left over when processing dairy to make other types of cheese. It is low in fat and has a slightly grainy texture. It is the traditional filling for cannoli, a sweet Italian pastry.

Because of its soft, liquidy texture, ricotta should be strained before it's used in pastry filling. If you don't drain the cheese, your filling will be wet and grainy, and your cannoli shells will become soggy. Ricotta can be strained by placing it in a fine mesh strainer and covering it with a piece of plastic wrap. Place something heavy on top, like pie weights or dry beans, and put the strainer over a bowl. Leave it in the fridge to drain for at least six hours, but preferably overnight. You'll be surprised at how much liquid comes out!

Straining ricotta is necessary for creamy Italian desserts like cannoli because it keeps the recipe from becoming watery. It also helps to create a smooth consistency. If you're in a hurry, you can drain ricotta by placing it in a cheesecloth and squeezing out the excess moisture. However, this method may not remove all the moisture and is not ideal for pastries, which require drier, crumbly ricotta.

Mascarpone is thicker and less likely to make shells soggy

Mascarpone is a soft cheese, similar to cream cheese in texture, and is often used as a filling for cannoli in the US. It has a thick, high-fat, triple-cream consistency, more like butter or custard than the slightly grainy texture of ricotta. Mascarpone is made from cow's milk, whereas ricotta is traditionally made from sheep's milk.

Mascarpone is a good choice for cannoli filling because of its thickness and lower moisture content. If ricotta is not drained properly before use, it can make the filling runny and the shells soggy. Even if you do drain the ricotta, your filling may still be too moist. Mascarpone, on the other hand, is less likely to cause these issues. It has a dense consistency and is thicker than most ricotta brands, so it won't turn your cannoli shells soggy.

To ensure your cannoli filling is thick, you can use a brand of mascarpone that is known to be thicker, such as BelGioioso. If you are set on using ricotta, be sure to drain it well. Place the ricotta in a fine-mesh strainer or cheesecloth and let it drain in the fridge for at least six hours, or preferably overnight.

If you want the best of both worlds, you can blend ricotta and mascarpone. This will give you a flavour similar to traditional ricotta with the added creaminess of mascarpone.

Ricotta is healthier

Cannoli is a traditional Italian dessert that consists of a tube-shaped, fried pastry dough shell with a sweet, creamy cheese filling. The filling is traditionally made from ricotta cheese, but some variations include a blend of ricotta and mascarpone, or even cream cheese, custard, or ice cream.

Ricotta is the healthier option for cannoli filling when compared to other cheeses. It is a soft, white cheese made from whey—a protein that is left over when processing dairy to make other types of cheese. Ricotta is low in fat and has a milder taste compared to other cheeses used in cannoli. It is also lighter and less fat-filled than mascarpone, which is similar to cream cheese in terms of fat content.

To make cannoli with ricotta filling, it is important to drain the ricotta cheese overnight to remove excess moisture and ensure a thick, creamy filling. The filling is then piped into the cannoli shells, which are served immediately to maintain a crisp texture.

Some common additions to the ricotta filling include powdered sugar, vanilla extract, and mini chocolate chips. The classic flavor of ricotta filling also includes a touch of orange zest, and some feature chopped pistachios.

Frequently asked questions