Bushra Griffith
Tillamook Extra Sharp White Cheddar is widely considered to be one of the best extra sharp white cheddars available. It is available almost everywhere in the US and won 1st place in the cheddar category at the American Cheese Society 2023 conference. Other popular extra sharp white cheddars include CROC Extra Sharp Cheddar, Coastal White Cheddar from Costco, and Cracker Barrel Extra Sharp Cheddar.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Brand | Tillamook, Pearl Valley Cheese, Cabot Creamery, Wisconsin Cheese Mart, Keystone Farms Cheese |
| Price | $4.99 (8oz), $15.41 (2lb) |
| Weight | 8oz, 2lb, 32oz |
| Flavor | Nutty, crisp, sharp, bold, rich, mature |
| Texture | Smooth, dry, crumbly |
| Aging | Minimum 9 months, 2 years, 3 years, 5 years |
| Pairs well with | Fruit, crackers, salty meats, wine, mac and cheese |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Extra-sharp white cheddar cheese pairs well with wine, crackers, and fresh fruit
- The cheese is aged for at least 3 years, giving it a nutty, crisp flavour
- Tillamook Vintage White Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese is a popular choice, with a strong flavour and no need for refrigeration
- Cheddar cheese is usually known for its yellow colour, but white cheddar does not contain colour additives
- White cheddar is smooth, bold, rich, and creamy, making it perfect for snacking and melting
Extra-sharp white cheddar cheese pairs well with wine, crackers, and fresh fruit
Extra-sharp white cheddar cheese is a versatile and popular choice for any cheese board, offering a familiar flavour that acts as a great anchor when trying other cheeses. Its bold, sharp flavour pairs well with a variety of wines, crackers, and fresh fruits.
When it comes to wine, extra-sharp cheddar can be a good match for intensely fruity Chilean Cabernet Sauvignons or similarly fruity Cabernets from other regions, such as South Australia. These wines complement the sharpness of the cheese. However, it's important to note that the tannins in red wine can sometimes struggle with sharp, well-matured cheddars, so a bottle with a few years of age tends to work better than a young one. For those who prefer white wine, a South African old vine Chenin Blanc or a rich Cape White blend can also pair well with the sharpness of cheddar. Chardonnay is another option that can add a delicious layer of complexity to the pairing.
As for crackers, black pepper crackers can bring a hint of spice to complement the sharpness of the cheese. Sweet and fragrant raisin bread can also heighten the complexity of extra-sharp cheddar, providing a delightful contrast of flavours.
When it comes to fresh fruit, apples are a classic pairing with cheddar cheese, and this combination can be taken to the next level with the addition of walnuts and cinnamon sugar. Strawberries are also a fantastic choice, adding a burst of freshness to the mix. Pineapple provides a lively contrast to the sharpness of the cheese, while honey adds a touch of sweetness. For a more sophisticated pairing, try roasted figs or fresh-cut apples with golden honey.
When preparing a cheese board, it's recommended to include at least three cheeses to provide a good range of flavours. Extra-sharp cheddar can be paired with complementary flavours, such as a soft cheese like Brie or a blue cheese. Alternatively, try alternative milk cheeses like sheep ricotta, buffalo mozzarella, or goat Gouda for a unique twist.
Gluten-Free Diets: Tillamook Medium Cheddar Cheese's Safety
You may want to see also
The cheese is aged for at least 3 years, giving it a nutty, crisp flavour
When it comes to the best extra sharp white cheddar cheese, several options are available. One popular choice is Tillamook Extra Sharp, which is aged for 15 to 24 months and has a slight hint of funkiness along with notes of candied pecans. It's a favourite among many and easily available in grocery stores across the US. However, some have expressed disappointment with its lack of sharpness.
For those seeking a sharper option, CROC Extra Sharp Cheddar is a strong and sharp cheese sold in most big stores. Another option is the Balderson 6-year cheddar, which is also available at Costco and is considered the "best white cheddar out there" by some.
If you're looking for a well-rounded flavour with depth and a crumbly texture, the Shop Rite house brand's extra sharp cheddar delivers a sharp punch and a smooth finish. Cabot, a popular brand, also offers a 3-year-aged cheddar that can be found at Costco, providing a sharp and tasty option at a great price.
When it comes to ageing, extra sharp cheddars are typically aged for around two years. However, the ageing process can vary, and some cheddars are aged for longer periods, such as the Balderson 6-year cheddar. Ageing contributes to the development of a nutty flavour, a characteristic that is sought after in extra sharp cheddars.
Cheddar Cheese: Understanding Exchange System Benefits
You may want to see also
Tillamook Vintage White Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese is a popular choice, with a strong flavour and no need for refrigeration
When it comes to the best extra sharp white cheddar cheese, Tillamook Vintage White Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese is a popular choice. This award-winning cheese has a strong, mature flavour that is sure to satisfy those who enjoy a sharp bite. It is aged for over two years, the longest of all Tillamook cheddars, giving it a distinctively bold taste. The cheese has a slightly crumbly texture, making it perfect to pair with fruit and wine.
One of the standout features of this cheese is that it does not necessarily require refrigeration. This aspect makes it an excellent option for camping or other outdoor activities where refrigeration may not be readily available. The ability to maintain its quality without refrigeration sets it apart from other cheeses and adds to its appeal for those with active lifestyles or limited storage space.
Tillamook Vintage White Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese is available in 32-ounce blocks, providing ample quantity for gatherings or simply to enjoy over time. It is crafted from rBST-free cow's milk, ensuring a natural product. The cheese's sharp flavour can enhance various dishes, from grilled creations to casseroles and macaroni and cheese.
While some customers rave about the flavour and convenience of this cheese, others have expressed disappointment with the shipping costs and packaging when ordering online. However, the ability to find this cheese in stores and the overall positive reviews make it a recommended option for those seeking a sharp, flavourful cheddar cheese with the convenience of limited refrigeration requirements.
In summary, Tillamook Vintage White Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese is a popular choice for those seeking a strong-flavoured cheese that doesn't need constant refrigeration. Its versatility in pairing options, ability to enhance various dishes, and longer ageing process contribute to its popularity. While shipping and packaging experiences may vary, the overall positive sentiment surrounding this cheese makes it a worthwhile option for extra sharp white cheddar enthusiasts.
Cheddar Cheese: Processed or Natural?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Cheddar cheese is usually known for its yellow colour, but white cheddar does not contain colour additives
Cheddar cheese is a popular variety of cheese, especially in the US. It is often associated with the yellow or orange hue that is produced by adding annatto, a colour additive derived from the seeds of the achiote tree. While some consumers prefer the deeper yellow or orange colour, others find it unappealing. Interestingly, the practice of colouring cheese originated in the 16th or 17th century when cheesemakers noticed that consumers preferred cheese with a more intense yellow colour, which occurred naturally when cows grazed on grass with higher levels of beta-carotene during certain seasons.
However, not all cheddar cheese is yellow or orange; there is also white cheddar cheese, which does not contain any added colour additives. White cheddar cheese is made in a similar way to its yellow counterpart, but without the addition of annatto or other colourings. It has the same sharp, tangy, or nutty taste profiles that cheddar enthusiasts know and love, and it melts admirably, making it perfect for grilled cheese sandwiches or macaroni and cheese.
When it comes to the best extra-sharp white cheddar cheese, several brands stand out. Tillamook, a well-known dairy company, offers an extra-sharp white cheddar that is widely available in the US and has a great flavour. Their cheese won 1st place in the cheddar category at the American Cheese Society 2023 Conference, proving its excellence. Cabot, another popular brand, produces a sharp cheddar that is aged for three years, resulting in a delicious, strong, and sharp flavour.
Other noteworthy mentions include the CROC Extra Sharp Cheddar, which is widely available in major stores and is known for its intense sharpness and strong flavour. For those seeking an artisanal option, the Balderson 6-year extra-aged cheddar is a fantastic choice, offering a unique taste experience. Additionally, the Trader Joe's "Coastal English Cheddar" is a sharp variety with lactic acid crystals that add a delightful texture and flavour.
Cheddar Cheese and Fatty Liver: A Safe Snack?
You may want to see also
White cheddar is smooth, bold, rich, and creamy, making it perfect for snacking and melting
White cheddar is a versatile cheese, perfect for snacking and melting. Its smooth, bold, rich, and creamy characteristics make it a popular choice for cheese lovers.
When it comes to extra sharp white cheddar, there are several options available that stand out for their exceptional quality and flavour. One of the most renowned brands is Tillamook, which has garnered acclaim for its extra sharp white cheddar. Tillamook's cheese is widely available across the United States, making it a convenient choice for many. Their cheese is aged between 15 to 24 months, resulting in a unique texture and flavour profile. It has notes of candied pecans and a subtle hint of funk, adding a layer of complexity to its taste. In 2023, Tillamook also took first place in the cheddar category at the American Cheese Society Conference, solidifying its reputation for producing exceptional cheddar.
Another highly regarded extra sharp white cheddar is the Cabot 3-year cheddar. Available at Costco, this cheese delivers a sharp and tangy flavour that is sure to please those seeking a more intense cheese experience. It has a well-rounded flavour and a slightly crumbly texture, contributing to its overall appeal.
For those seeking a more unique option, the Balderson 6-year cheddar is a top choice. This cheese, available on the East Coast, is described as the "best white cheddar out there" by some enthusiasts. Its extended ageing process contributes to a more intense and complex flavour profile.
Additionally, the Collier Welsh Cheddar, available at Costco, is a popular choice for those seeking a sharp white cheddar. Originating from the UK, this cheese is easily accessible in Canada, making it a go-to option for those in that region.
Extra sharp white cheddars, such as those mentioned above, offer a more intense flavour and a unique texture compared to milder cheddars. Their longer ageing process contributes to their bold and rich characteristics, making them ideal for snacking or incorporating into recipes where melting is required. The smooth and creamy nature of white cheddar makes it a versatile cheese that can elevate any dish or be enjoyed on its own.
Sharp Cheddar Cheese: Why the Pungent Aroma?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
There are several extra sharp white cheddar cheeses available, each with its own unique characteristics. Some popular options include Pearl Valley, Tillamook Vintage, and Cabot Creamery.
Extra sharp white cheddar has a nutty, crisp, and bold flavor. It is known for its sharp and bitey taste, adding a wonderful burst of flavor to any dish.
Most extra sharp white cheddar cheeses are aged for at least 3 years. However, some, like Tillamook Vintage, are aged for over 2 years, contributing to their sharp and mature flavor.
Extra sharp white cheddar pairs well with a variety of drinks. For wine, it complements both red and white wines. It also goes well with beers like Saison ale, cider, and Belgian ales, and spirits like bourbon and single malt scotch.
Extra sharp white cheddar is a versatile cheese that can be used in various dishes. It can be melted into recipes like mac and cheese, adding a burst of flavor. It's also great for snacking and is perfect on a meat and cheese board, pairing well with fresh fruit, crackers, and salty meats.
