Shane Dawson's Chuck E. Cheese Scandal: What's The Deal?

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video to his 'Investigating Conspiracies' channel, in which he claimed that Chuck E. Cheese recycles its uneaten pizza slices. The video, which has garnered millions of views, sparked a feud between Dawson and the pizza company, with Chuck E. Cheese refuting the claims and stating that their pizzas are made to order and always delicious. Dawson's theory is based on his observation of unevenly cut and placed slices, which he claims is a result of the company piecing together leftover slices to serve as fresh pizzas. This controversy has led to a debate among viewers, with some supporting the conspiracy and others denying it.

Shane Dawson's Chuck E. Cheese conspiracy theory video

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson" in which he discussed a conspiracy theory about Chuck E. Cheese's pizza. The theory, which Dawson did not create, speculated that the restaurant chain recycles uneaten pizza slices from customers and uses them to create new pizzas. Dawson and his friends tested this theory by ordering several pizzas at a Chuck E. Cheese's restaurant. They noticed that the pizzas were misshapen, with the crusts misaligned and failing to form a perfect circle. Dawson also pointed out the jagged crusts and misaligned pepperonis, expressing awe and disbelief throughout the video.

Dawson further investigated the theory by taking a pizza home and attempting to figure out how it was sliced. He claimed that he "definitely proven" that the pizza halves weren't originally together and questioned why a piece seemed to be missing. He suggested that there was a reason for the misshapen pizzas but stated that he couldn't "legally" say what it was, implying that it was related to the conspiracy theory.

The video garnered a lot of attention, amassing 14 million views in two days. Many social media users took the theory as fact, demanding an explanation from the franchise. Chuck E. Cheese was forced to address the conspiracy, releasing an official statement refuting the claims. They stated that their "pizzas are made to order and we prepare our dough fresh in our restaurant, which means that they’re not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious." Despite this denial, Chuck E. Cheese did not sue Dawson over the conspiracy theory.

The theory has continued to circulate, with a recent video uploaded in 2024 claiming that Chuck E. Cheese sued Dawson for the conspiracy theory. This video, which has over 6 million views, sparked renewed interest in the topic. While some have pointed out flaws in Dawson's theory, others have conducted their own investigations, finding similar evidence of mismatched pizza slices.

Chuck E. Cheese's response to the conspiracy theory

Chuck E. Cheese has denied the conspiracy theory popularized by YouTuber Shane Dawson in 2019. The theory, which has gained traction on social media, alleges that the restaurant chain recycles uneaten pizza slices from customers to create new pizzas. Dawson's video, which has amassed millions of views, shows a photo of a pizza with differing slice sizes and includes an account of his visit to a Chuck E. Cheese restaurant, where he and his friends ordered a pizza that appeared deformed and misshapen.

In response to Dawson's video, a spokesperson for Chuck E. Cheese refuted the claims, stating that they are "unequivocally false." The spokesperson added, "No conspiracies here—our pizzas are made to order and we prepare our dough fresh in the restaurant, which means that they're not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious." The company emphasized that their pizzas are made fresh and that any variations in shape are due to the handmade nature of their dough preparation.

In addition to the official statement, several past and present employees of Chuck E. Cheese have spoken out against the speculation. One former employee explained that the kitchen staff often cut the pizzas quickly and may not pay close attention to the dimensions of the slices. Another current employee confirmed on Twitter that they do not recycle pizza slices and that leftover pizza is always discarded.

It is important to note that while Dawson's video sparked a widespread discussion and raised concerns among customers, his theory has not been proven. Chuck E. Cheese's response, along with testimonies from employees, suggests that the uneven slices are more likely due to the handmade nature of their pizza preparation rather than any malicious intent or recycling practice.

The company's swift and transparent response to the conspiracy theory demonstrates their commitment to addressing customer concerns and maintaining the integrity of their brand. By refuting the claims directly and providing an explanation for the uneven pizza slices, Chuck E. Cheese aimed to reassure customers and protect their reputation as a family-friendly restaurant chain.

The theory's popularity and impact on social media

YouTuber Shane Dawson's conspiracy theory about Chuck E. Cheese's pizza gained immense popularity when he posted a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson" in 2019. The video, which has garnered over 49 million views, discusses the theory that Chuck E. Cheese recycles leftover pizza slices from customers' tables and uses them to create new pizzas to serve. Dawson and his friends ordered pizzas from the restaurant and were shocked to find that the slices seemed to be mismatched, with the crusts misaligned and failing to form a perfect circle. This observation, combined with the fact that the theory had been floating around on the internet since 2009, fuelled the conspiracy's popularity.

The impact of Dawson's theory was such that it forced Chuck E. Cheese to respond. The company denied the claims, stating that their pizzas are made to order with fresh dough, which sometimes results in uneven slices. However, their explanation did little to dispel the theory, and many people, including other YouTubers and social media users, continued to speculate and share their own experiences with the restaurant's pizzas. The theory even led to online discussions about other conspiracy theories surrounding the Chuck E. Cheese franchise, such as claims that the horror video game series "Five Nights at Freddy's" is based on the pizza chain.

The popularity of Dawson's theory can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, Dawson had a large online following, with his YouTube channel boasting over 20 million subscribers at the time. Secondly, the theory tapped into existing concerns and suspicions about the restaurant chain, with some people finding the place "a little suspect". Additionally, the visual evidence presented by Dawson in his video was compelling to many viewers, even if it did not definitively prove the theory. Finally, the theory played on people's fears of germ contamination, which is especially relevant for a restaurant that caters to young children.

The impact of the theory on social media was significant and long-lasting. It sparked numerous online discussions and even led to a resurgence of the theory in 2024, five years after Dawson's initial video. It also prompted responses from former and current Chuck E. Cheese employees, who denied the claims and provided alternative explanations for the uneven pizza slices. The theory's popularity highlights the power of social media and the internet in spreading information, regardless of its accuracy. It also demonstrates how conspiracy theories, once they take hold, can be challenging to dispel, even with official denials and refutations.

Evidence for and against the theory

In 2019, YouTuber Shane Dawson posted a video titled "Investigating Conspiracies with Shane Dawson", in which he claimed that Chuck E. Cheese recycles uneaten pizza slices from customers and uses them to create new pizzas. The video, which amassed 14 million views in two days, showed Dawson and his friends visiting a Chuck E. Cheese restaurant and ordering several pizzas that appeared to have mismatched slices. Dawson claimed that this was evidence that the pizzas were made from recycled slices, and that he had first noticed this as a child.

Evidence for the theory

Firstly, there is the visual evidence of the pizzas with uneven edges and misaligned crusts and toppings. This suggests that the pizzas are not made from a single dough base, as one would expect, but from multiple, differently-sized pieces. Additionally, the fact that Chuck E. Cheese cuts their pizzas earlier in the process than most pizzerias could explain why the slices appear to be of different sizes and shapes.

Evidence against the theory

Chuck E. Cheese has denied the claims, stating that their "pizzas are made to order and we prepare our dough fresh in [the] restaurant, which means that they’re not always perfectly uniform in shape, but always delicious." This explanation is supported by several former employees, who have stated that the uneven slices are due to kitchen staff cutting the pizzas too quickly or too early in the cooking process. One former employee claimed that they had "never in my time working there ever put a pizza together that was a pizza from a table that didn’t eat it. Never.". Additionally, a Chuck E. Cheese manager explained that the slices may look disproportionate simply because they are cut earlier in the process and have time to move around and settle before being served.

While the visual evidence of the mismatched pizza slices is compelling, the statements from former employees and Chuck E. Cheese's official denial of the theory suggest that there may be other explanations for the uneven slices.

Other Chuck E. Cheese conspiracy theories

Chuck E. Cheese has been the subject of various conspiracy theories over the years, including the following:

• Recycled Pizzas: One of the most well-known Chuck E. Cheese conspiracy theories is that the restaurant chain recycles its uneaten pizzas by combining leftover slices to create new pies. This theory gained widespread attention in 2019 when YouTuber Shane Dawson dedicated an episode of his "Conspiracy Series" to the topic. Dawson presented evidence, including photos of pizzas with mismatched slices, and recounted his own experiences of noticing "misplaced pizzas" as a child. He also claimed that a friend who worked at Chuck E. Cheese had confirmed the theory. However, the company has vehemently denied these allegations, stating that their pizzas are "made to order" and that any inconsistencies in shape are due to the dough being "prepared fresh" in the restaurant. Despite the company's refutation, the theory persists, with many customers expressing skepticism about the uniformity of their pizza slices.
• Promoting Child Gambling: Chuck E. Cheese has faced multiple lawsuits alleging that it promotes gambling to young children. This theory gained traction due to the presence of arcade games and other entertainment offerings within the restaurant chain. Concerns have been raised about the potential negative impact on children's wellbeing and financial habits.
• Animatronics and Entertainment: The use of animatronics and entertainment shows at Chuck E. Cheese has sparked speculation and theories about the company's intentions. Some have suggested that the animatronics are used as a form of cost-cutting, while others have found them entertaining or nostalgic. The company's evolution in entertainment offerings, from animatronics to video screens and interactive features, has also sparked debates and comparisons with competitors like ShowBiz Pizza.

These conspiracy theories surrounding Chuck E. Cheese have sparked intense debates, with some customers and analysts defending the company while others remain skeptical and critical of their practices.

Frequently asked questions