Cheddar Cheese's Sweet Companion: Exploring Jam Pairings

The combination of cheese and jam may seem unconventional, but it is a classic dish in Italian culture. The pairing of these two foods dates back to the Middle Ages, when cheese was considered a meal ender used to cleanse the palate before dessert. Today, pairing cheese with jam remains a staple of European dinner tables and party platters. The key to a successful pairing is finding flavours that complement each other without overpowering one another. When it comes to cheddar cheese, a sharp or mature cheddar pairs well with sweeter jams like strawberry, while a softer cheddar may go better with a more subtly flavoured jam.

Strawberry jam and cheddar

The pairing of cheese and jam dates back to the Middle Ages, when cheese was considered a "meal ender", used to cleanse the palate before dessert. The custom is especially popular in Italy and France, where bold colours and flavours are used to bring out the best in even the simplest ingredients.

Combining sweet jam with savoury cheese creates a complementary flavour profile, enhancing subtler undertones and adding complexity. When pairing jam and cheese, it's important to consider the intensity of the cheese, which is largely determined by the type of milk used and its consistency. Fresh and soft cheeses tend to be sweeter, while semi-mature and mature cheeses have a stronger flavour.

Mature and savoury cheeses pair well with sweeter jams, and strawberry jam is a classic choice. Strawberry jam tends to be on the sweeter side, so it's best to avoid milder cheeses. Here are some suggestions for pairing strawberry jam with cheddar cheese:

Cheddar and Strawberry Jam Pairing

Cheddar, a classic "meal ender" cheese, pairs well with the sweetness of strawberry jam. When creating this pairing, it's important to remember that the jam should not overpower the cheese. The key is to find a balance between the two flavours. Here are some tips to create a sophisticated flavour combination:

• Chill the jam: To maintain its firm texture and fresh appearance, chill the strawberry jam before serving. This will also help to prolong its shelf life.
• Serve separately: Instead of mixing the jam and cheese together, serve them separately on a platter. This allows your guests to enjoy the unique flavours of each ingredient and combine them according to their preference.
• Consider portion size: The ratio of jam to cheese is crucial. Use a small dollop of jam per slice of cheese to avoid drowning out the cheese flavour or reducing the jam to a mere seasoning.
• Accompaniments: Offer crackers or bread on the side, such as Melba rounds or Triscuits. These neutral bases will allow the flavours of the jam and cheese to shine.
• Experiment with variations: Try different types of cheddar, such as sharp or mild, to find the intensity that best complements the strawberry jam. You can also experiment with other classic cheeses, such as Gouda or Emmental.

Recipe Ideas

• Cheese ball or spread: Mix grated sharp cheddar cheese with chopped pecans, light mayonnaise, minced onion and garlic, Tabasco sauce, and strawberry preserves. Chill the mixture for 2-3 hours. Shape it into a ball or spread it on a serving dish. Surround it with strawberry preserves or serve them on the side.
• Dip: Combine the same ingredients as above, omitting the strawberry preserves. Chill and shape the mixture into a ball or spread. Serve with crackers and a side of strawberry preserves for dipping.
• Mold: Follow the dip recipe and press the mixture into a lightly greased ring mold. Fill the centre with strawberry preserves for a visually appealing and tasty treat.

Fig jam and cheddar

A popular way to serve this combination is in a grilled cheese sandwich. The sharpness of cheddar, the sweetness of fig jam, and the buttery toast create a delightful symphony of flavours. To make this sandwich, butter the outside of two slices of bread and spread fig jam on the inside of one slice. Add grated or sliced cheddar, then top with the other slice of bread. Toast the sandwich in a panini press or a skillet until the bread is golden brown and the cheese is melted.

For a more sophisticated take on this combination, try a charcuterie board with sliced cheddar, fig jam, and accompaniments like nuts, bread, and cured meats. When creating a charcuterie board, it is important to consider the balance of flavours and textures. The sharpness of cheddar and the sweetness of fig jam can be enhanced by the addition of salty, crunchy, or savoury elements.

When choosing a cheddar to pair with fig jam, consider the intensity of the cheese. Mature, sharp cheddars will stand up to the sweetness of the jam, while milder cheddars may be overpowered. The same principle applies when creating a charcuterie board—offer a variety of cheeses, jams, and accompaniments to create a well-rounded and balanced tasting experience.

Whether served in a grilled cheese sandwich or as part of a charcuterie board, the combination of fig jam and cheddar is a delightful pairing that showcases the interplay of sweet and savoury flavours.

Apricot jam and cheddar

The combination of apricot jam and cheddar cheese is a match made in heaven. This sweet and salty duo is a classic flavour pairing that is perfect for any occasion. The sweetness of the jam pairs perfectly with the sharpness of the cheddar cheese, making it a delightful snack or appetizer.

How to Serve

There are several ways to serve apricot jam and cheddar, from simple tea sandwiches to elegant crostini. Here are some ideas to get you started:

• Tea Sandwiches: These bite-sized sandwiches are easy to make and perfect for tea time or party appetizers. Simply spread apricot jam on slices of bread, add cheddar cheese, and top with another slice of bread. For the best flavour, use aged cheddar and soft white bread.
• Crostini: For a quick and elegant appetizer, try topping toasted baguette slices with apricot jam and sharp cheddar cheese. You can also garnish with micro greens for added colour and flavour.
• Fruit and Cheese Plate: Create a beautiful platter with apricot jam, cheddar cheese, and fresh fruits such as apricots, plums, or pears. This option is perfect for a summer picnic or a winter comfort food meal.
• Grilled Cheese: For a fun twist on a classic, spread apricot jam on one side of a grilled cheese sandwich and add sliced cheddar cheese to the other side. Grill until the cheese is melted and enjoy!
• Dipping Sauce: Apricot jam also works well as a dipping sauce for cheddar cheese. Cut the cheese into small pieces and serve with the jam on the side for a simple and tasty snack.

Pairing Tips

When pairing jam and cheese, it's important to consider the balance of flavours. Here are a few tips to keep in mind:

• Sharp cheeses pair well with sweeter jams. The sharpness of cheddar cheese is complemented by the sweetness of apricot jam.
• The ratio of jam to cheese is crucial. Use just enough jam to enhance the flavour of the cheese without overwhelming it.
• Chilling the jam can help it stay firm and fresh, especially when serving it with cheese at room temperature.
• When serving jam and cheese together, avoid mixing them directly. Instead, enjoy them side by side or layered so that each ingredient can be appreciated.

Blackberry jam and cheddar

Blackberry jam is a sweet yet tangy preserve with a slight bite. It is a classic option that goes best with milder, softer cheeses, such as Camembert, Taleggio, or a milder, sweeter mouldy cheese like Blue Stilton.

When creating a blackberry jam and cheddar pairing, it is essential to consider the quality of both ingredients. Opting for high-quality, sophisticated options will elevate the experience. Additionally, the ratio of jam to cheese is crucial. A small dollop of jam per slice of cheese is ideal, allowing the flavours to meld without one dominating the other.

To enhance the experience further, consider serving the blackberry jam and cheddar with accompaniments such as wine, artisan bread, or smoked almonds. Presenting the jam and cheese separately allows guests to customise their pairings according to their preferences.

For a unique culinary adventure, explore the combination of blackberry jam and cheddar. Experiment with different types of cheddar, from mild to sharp, to discover the nuances that each variety brings to the pairing. Remember to chill the jam and serving dishes to maintain freshness and firmness during your culinary journey.

Peach jam and cheddar

Combining savoury cheese with sweet fruit and fruit preserves is a pairing that dates back to the Middle Ages. The custom is especially popular in Italy and France, where bold flavours and colours are used to bring out the best in even the simplest of ingredients.

Peach jam is a highly sweet option that goes well with sharp, aged cheeses. It is therefore an ideal pairing for stronger blue cheeses like Roquefort or Gorgonzola. If blue cheese isn't for you, cheddar is a good alternative—look for a variety with a well-pronounced nuttiness, like Moliterno.

When serving jam and cheese, it is best to chill the jam and serving dish beforehand. This will help to keep the jam firm and fresh in appearance and flavour. It is also wise to avoid double-dipping, as this can introduce bacteria from the cheese into your jam jar. Instead, serve the jam in a separate dish.

The ratio of jam to cheese is also important. A small dollop per slice is best, so as not to overwhelm the flavour of the cheese.

Frequently asked questions