Cheese And Cancer: What's The Link?

There is conflicting evidence on the link between cheese consumption and breast cancer risk. Some studies suggest that a high intake of certain cheeses, such as cheddar and cream cheese, may increase women's risk of breast cancer, while others indicate no increased risk. The conflicting evidence may be due to the complexity of dairy foods, which contain a mix of nutrients and non-nutrient substances that can have varying effects on cancer etiology. While the specific compounds responsible for the potential increase in risk have not been conclusively identified, some researchers speculate that it could be due to the high-fat content of certain cheeses or the presence of growth hormones in milk, which becomes more concentrated during the process of making cheese.

High-fat cheese and breast cancer risk

Breast cancer is the most common cancer among women in the United States, and diet is known to play a key role in influencing the risk of developing the disease. Dairy products, such as cheese, are under scrutiny as a factor that may be linked to an increased risk of breast cancer. While some studies have found a positive correlation between high-fat cheese consumption and breast cancer risk, others have found no link between the two.

The Link Between High-Fat Cheese and Breast Cancer Risk

Some researchers suggest that the high-fat content of certain cheeses, such as cheddar and cream cheese, may be a factor in increasing women's risk of developing breast cancer. A 2017 study funded by the National Cancer Institute found that women who consumed the most American, cheddar, and cream cheeses had a 53% higher risk of developing breast cancer. The authors of the study attributed this increased risk to components in dairy, such as insulin-like growth factor (IGF-1) and other growth hormones, which may promote cell growth and division and increase breast cancer risk.

Additionally, dairy products contain traces of estrogens from cows, and the concentration of these hormones increases during the process of making cheese. While the amounts are small, they appear to be biologically active in humans and may contribute to an increased risk of breast cancer mortality. The Life After Cancer Epidemiology study found that among women previously diagnosed with breast cancer, those who consumed one or more servings of high-fat dairy products, such as cheese, daily had a 49% higher breast cancer mortality rate compared to those who consumed less than half a serving daily.

Conflicting Evidence and Other Factors

It is important to note that the research on the link between cheese consumption and breast cancer risk is mixed. Some studies have found no increased risk associated with cheese intake. For example, a pooled analysis of data from over 20 studies found no link between dairy product intake, including cheese, and breast cancer risk. Additionally, fermented dairy products, such as yogurt and cheese, did not increase breast cancer risk in two separate studies. This may be because yogurt and cheese do not increase IGF1 levels in the body, as the IGF1-stimulating factors present in milk may be lost during the fermentation process.

Furthermore, other lifestyle factors, such as alcohol consumption, obesity, and physical activity, also play a significant role in influencing breast cancer risk. Obesity, for example, raises levels of both IGF1 and oestrogen in post-menopausal women, increasing their risk of developing breast cancer. Therefore, it is important to consider multiple risk factors and not solely focus on cheese consumption when assessing breast cancer risk.

While some studies suggest a link between high-fat cheese consumption and an increased risk of breast cancer, particularly due to the presence of hormones and growth factors, the evidence is not conclusive. More research is needed to fully understand the complex relationship between diet and breast cancer risk, and it is important to consider multiple lifestyle factors when assessing an individual's risk.

Cheddar and cream cheese

The Link Between Cheddar and Cream Cheese and Breast Cancer

Several studies have indicated a positive association between the consumption of cheddar and cream cheese and the risk of breast cancer in women. One particular study, published in 2017 by Susan McCann and colleagues, found that a high intake of these cheeses was linked to a 53% increased risk of breast cancer. This study, which included data from 1,941 women with breast cancer and 1,237 women without the disease, adjusted for various confounding factors such as age, body mass index (BMI), and family history of breast cancer.

Potential Reasons for the Increased Risk

The reasons behind the elevated risk of breast cancer associated with cheddar and cream cheese consumption are multifaceted. Firstly, these cheeses have a high-fat content, particularly saturated fats, which have been linked to increased breast cancer risk in various epidemiological studies. Additionally, the milk used to make cheese often comes from pregnant cows with elevated estrogen and progesterone levels, resulting in higher concentrations of these hormones in the cheese. Estrogen exposure is a well-known risk factor for breast cancer.

Other Dairy Products and Breast Cancer Risk

It is important to note that not all dairy products are associated with increased breast cancer risk. For example, yogurt consumption has been linked to a reduced risk of breast cancer. Additionally, some studies suggest that low-fat cheeses may not carry the same risks as their full-fat counterparts. Further research is needed to fully understand the complex relationship between dairy consumption and breast cancer risk.

In conclusion, current evidence suggests that a high intake of cheddar and cream cheese may increase the risk of breast cancer in women. However, more studies are required to confirm these findings and elucidate the underlying mechanisms. While dairy products provide essential nutrients like calcium and vitamin D, it is advisable to opt for low-fat or non-fat alternatives and include other calcium-rich foods in the diet.

Dairy and breast cancer research

Dairy products are under study as a factor that may be linked to an increased or decreased risk of breast cancer. While some researchers suggest that the high fat content of many dairy products or traces of growth hormones in milk may be linked to an increased risk, others argue that the calcium and vitamin D in dairy products may be linked to a decreased risk.

The Link to Increased Risk

Some researchers have suggested that the high fat content of many dairy products may be linked to an increased risk of breast cancer. For example, a 2017 study funded by the National Cancer Institute found that women who consumed the most American, cheddar, and cream cheeses had a 53% higher risk of breast cancer. The authors of the study suggested that components in dairy such as insulin-like growth factor (IGF-1) and other growth hormones may be among the reasons for the increased risk. Additionally, dairy products contain traces of estrogens from cows, and as milk is converted to cheese, the estrogens become more concentrated. While they are only traces, they appear to be biologically active in humans, increasing breast cancer mortality.

The Link to Decreased Risk

On the other hand, some researchers have studied whether the calcium and vitamin D in dairy products may be linked to a decreased risk of breast cancer. For example, a pooled analysis of data from more than 20 studies found no link between dairy product intake (including milk, cheese, and yogurt) and breast cancer risk. Additionally, a study that reviewed 2003-2014 data from the Roswell Park Data Bank and BioRepository found that a high total dairy intake was associated with a 15% lower breast cancer risk, primarily due to a high yogurt intake.

While the research on the link between dairy and breast cancer is mixed, it is important to note that dietary studies are challenging to conduct, and it is difficult to isolate one food as the factor contributing to cancer risk. Additionally, many other factors influence breast cancer risk, such as genetics, alcohol consumption, and obesity. As such, it is recommended to take an "everything-in-moderation" approach when it comes to dairy consumption and to prioritize a more plant-based diet for cancer risk reduction.

Dairy hormones and breast cancer

Dairy products are under study as a factor that may be linked to increased or decreased breast cancer risk. While genetics can increase the risk of breast cancer, for most women, lifestyle factors such as diet, alcohol consumption, and obesity are bigger influences on the development of the disease.

Some researchers have suggested that the high-fat content of many dairy products or traces of growth hormones in milk may be linked to an increased risk of breast cancer. Dairy products contain traces of estrogens from cows, and as milk is converted to cheese, the estrogens are more concentrated. While they are only traces, they appear to be biologically active in humans, increasing breast cancer mortality. The components in dairy products such as insulin-like growth factor (IGF-1) and other growth hormones may be among the reasons for the increased risk of cancer. Obesity raises levels of both IGF-1 and oestrogen in post-menopausal women, and an early menarche, a late menopause, and drinking alcohol all increase the duration and amount of breast cells' exposure to oestrogen.

On the other hand, other researchers have studied whether the calcium and vitamin D in dairy products may be linked to a decreased risk of breast cancer. Yogurt and cheese do not increase IGF-1 levels in the body, possibly because the IGF-1-stimulating factors present in milk are lost during the making of cheese and yogurt. A pooled analysis of data from more than 20 studies found no link between dairy product intake (including milk, cheese, and yogurt) and breast cancer risk. Further, a recent study found that women who consumed 2-3 cups of cow's milk per day had an 80% increased chance of breast cancer, but replacing dairy milk with soy milk was associated with a 32% reduced risk of breast cancer.

While diet is thought to be responsible for 30% of all cancers, more research is needed to understand how dairy foods affect breast cancer risk.

Yogurt and breast cancer risk

Yogurt is a dairy product that has been the subject of several studies investigating its potential link to breast cancer risk. While some studies suggest a reduced risk of breast cancer with higher yogurt consumption, others indicate conflicting results. Here is a detailed overview of the current research and understanding of the relationship between yogurt intake and breast cancer risk:

Potential Benefits of Yogurt Consumption

Several studies have found an inverse association between yogurt consumption and breast cancer risk. This means that women who consumed higher amounts of yogurt had a lower risk of developing certain types of breast cancer. Specifically:

• A study by Susan McCann and colleagues, published in the journal Current Developments in Nutrition, found that a high intake of yogurt was associated with a 39% lower risk of developing breast cancer. This study analysed data from 1,941 women with breast cancer and 1,237 women without the disease.
• The Diet and Cancer Pooling Project (DCPP), an international consortium including the American Cancer Society's Cancer Prevention Study II (CPS II), analysed data from over 1 million women. They found that women who consumed higher amounts of yogurt and cottage/ricotta cheese had a moderately lower risk of developing ER-negative breast cancer.
• A meta-analysis by Lu Chen et al. examined the relationship between dairy food intake and breast cancer risk using data from eight publications. They found that higher yogurt intake was associated with a reduced risk of breast cancer, although the overall evidence did not support a strong association.

Conflicting Evidence and Uncertainties

While some studies suggest a protective effect of yogurt consumption against breast cancer, other research has produced conflicting results:

• The Roswell Park Cancer Institute Data Bank and BioRepository study found that while higher yogurt intake was associated with a reduced risk of breast cancer, the association was not significant in women from Canada or the US. The reduced risk was observed only in cohort studies from Australia, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, and Sweden.
• The DCPP study also noted that the protective effect of yogurt and cottage/ricotta cheese consumption against ER-negative breast cancer was not observed in studies including women from the US.
• A pooled analysis of data from more than 20 studies found no link between dairy product intake (including yogurt) and breast cancer risk.
• The Nurses' Health Study II found that women who consumed 2 or more servings of high-fat dairy products (such as whole milk or butter) per day had a higher risk of premenopausal breast cancer compared to women who consumed fewer servings.

Mechanisms and Further Research

The potential mechanisms underlying the relationship between yogurt consumption and breast cancer risk are not yet fully understood. Yogurt contains several nutrients and compounds that could influence cancer risk. For example:

• Yogurt is a source of calcium and vitamin D, which have been hypothesised to reduce breast cancer risk.
• Yogurt contains probiotics and prebiotics that can promote a healthy gut bacterial community, which may positively affect immune function and reduce cancer risk.

However, it is important to note that dairy products also contain substances such as insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) and other growth hormones that may adversely affect cancer risk. More research is needed to fully understand the complex relationship between yogurt consumption and breast cancer risk, including the potential benefits and risks associated with specific types of dairy products.

Frequently asked questions