Brie Alternatives: Exploring Similar Cheeses For Your Palate

Brie is a soft-ripened French cheese with a rich, buttery flavour and creamy texture. It's a versatile cheese that can be enjoyed in a variety of ways, from cheese plates to sandwiches, burgers, frittatas, and even desserts. However, you may want to try a substitute for brie due to its strong flavour, price, or availability. Here are some similar cheeses that you can use as alternatives to brie:

- Camembert: This French cheese is made in a similar style to brie but is aged longer, resulting in a stronger, slightly sour, and slightly sweet flavour. It has a silky texture and a distinctive edible rind.

- Hermelin: Nicknamed the Brie of the Czech Republic, this cheese is likely hard to find outside the region but makes an excellent replacement for brie.

- Mozzarella: A popular and easily accessible cheese, mozzarella melts easily and has a similar oozy, stretchy texture to brie. However, it is fairly bland compared to brie, so you may want to add stronger flavours when using it as a substitute.

- Chevré (French Goat Cheese): Made from goat's milk, Chevré has a similar texture, colour, and taste to brie. However, it is drier and more solid, with an earthier flavour profile.

- Cream Cheese or Vegan Cream Cheese: Cream cheese has a similar creamy spreadability to brie but is milder in flavour. It's perfect for spreading on pastries, and it melts into a liquid cream when cooked, making it ideal for pasta sauces and fillings.

- Saint-André Cheese: This super-fatty cheese is sometimes referred to as Brie on steroids. It has an intense flavour and is best suited for cheese platters or recipes that call for a strong cheese.

Camembert: a French cheese with a similar taste, texture and appearance to Brie

Camembert: A French Cheese with a Similar Taste, Texture, and Appearance to Brie

Camembert is a French cheese that is very similar to Brie in terms of taste, texture, and appearance. Like Brie, it is a soft-ripened, bloomy rind cheese that originated in northern France. It is typically made in a small format, no larger than eight ounces, and has a soft white rind created by microbes like Penicillium camemberti. The interior of Camembert has a soft yet solid paste that becomes an oozy, liquid cream as the cheese matures. Its flavours range from milky and buttery to earthy, mushroomy, or vegetal.

Camembert and Brie have a lot in common, and to the untrained eye, they may look like the same cheese. However, there are some key differences between the two. Camembert is typically made in a smaller format than Brie, and its production process, geography, and format are slightly different. While both cheeses are soft-ripened and have bloomy rinds, the specific bacteria, moulds, and yeasts used to ripen them are not identical.

In terms of taste, Camembert is known for its intense, slightly sour, slightly sweet, rich, and creamy flavour. Its flavour profile is often described as earthy and vegetal, with notes of savoury umami. The rind is edible, and the texture of the cheese itself is sometimes described as chalky or pasty.

Camembert is a popular cheese in France, even more so than Brie, and it has stood the test of time. It can be used as a substitute for Brie on a cheese plate or in most recipes. However, it is important to note that Camembert has a stronger flavour than Brie, so adjustments may need to be made when using it as a substitute.

Brillat-Savarin: a triple-cream cheese with a higher fat content than Brie

Brillat-Savarin is a triple-cream cheese with a fat content of at least 72%. This means it has a higher fat content than double-cream Brie, which has a fat content of at least 60%. Brillat-Savarin is a popular alternative to Brie, as it has a similar appearance and can be consumed in the same way. It is a creamy, elegant, and indulgent cheese.

Triple-cream cheeses, like Brillat-Savarin, are made by adding extra cream to the milk during the production process. This gives them an incredibly rich, buttery flavour and a thick, spreadable texture. They are sold in small wheels, typically one to two inches wide, and have a slightly thicker rind than Brie.

If you're looking for a cheese to substitute for Brie, Brillat-Savarin is a great option. It will add a touch of luxury to any dish or cheeseboard. However, it may be more challenging to find in stores and could be more expensive.

Other similar cheeses include Camembert, a French cheese with a stronger flavour than Brie, and Saint-André, a super-rich and intense cheese sometimes referred to as "Brie on steroids". For a more affordable and accessible option, mozzarella is a good alternative, though it is milder in flavour and may need additional seasoning.

Mozzarella: a soft cheese with a smooth texture, often used as a substitute for Brie in baking

Mozzarella is a soft cheese with a smooth texture that can be used as a substitute for brie in baking. It is a popular and easily accessible cheese that can be found in most markets and is also simple to make at home. Mozzarella is a good alternative to brie for those who are pregnant or unable to consume dairy, as it is a very safe cheese. It melts easily and has a similar oozy, stretchy texture to brie, making it ideal for baked dishes. However, compared to brie, mozzarella has a milder flavour profile, so you may want to add stronger flavours such as salt, pepper, lemon zest, dried fruit, honey or balsamic vinegar to enhance its taste.

Mozzarella is made from a variety of different milks, including buffalo, cow, sheep and goat milk. It is a versatile cheese that can be used in sandwiches, pizzas, burgers, frittatas and omelettes, as well as sweet dishes such as pastries and desserts. It pairs well with fresh French bread and can be served with fruits, berries, grapes and walnuts. Mozzarella is also a good option for those who are looking for a cheaper alternative to brie, as it is usually more affordable.

Chevré (French Goat Cheese): similar to Brie in texture, colour and taste, but with a drier and more solid mouthfeel

Chevré, or French Goat Cheese, is a great alternative to brie. Chevré is made from goat's milk and has a similar texture, colour, and taste to brie. However, the main difference lies in its mouthfeel and consistency. Chevré has a drier and more solid mouthfeel compared to the creamy texture of brie. While brie can be quite viscous when served at room temperature, Chevré remains spreadable yet firm.

Goat's cheese, or Chevré, develops a stronger flavour and a more pungent smell as it ages. When young and soft, it serves as an excellent substitute for brie in sandwiches and casseroles, closely mimicking the texture of brie. As it ages, Chevré becomes harder and develops a stronger flavour, making it less similar to brie.

Both Chevré and brie are versatile cheeses that can enhance various dishes. They are delicious in salads and sandwiches and are sure to impress on a cheese plate. However, when considering baked brie recipes, keep in mind that Chevré's firmer texture may yield different results.

Saint-André Cheese: a super fatty cheese, sometimes referred to as Brie on steroids

Saint-André cheese is a French triple cream cow's milk cheese with a fat content of about 75%. It is produced in the form of a 200g cylinder, 6cm in diameter and 5cm high. It has a soft, buttery texture, a tangy edible rind, and tastes like an intense version of Brie. The high fat content of Saint-André can make white wine taste sour and metallic, so it is recommended to pair it with a crust of baguette, a light beer, or a slice of pear.

A Similar Alternative to Brie

Saint-André is an excellent alternative to Brie due to its similar taste, texture, and appearance, including an edible rind. It can be baked and enjoyed with bread, fruits, and other dipping foods, just like Brie.

Other Cheeses Similar to Brie

Other cheeses that are similar to Brie include Brillat-Savarin, Delice de Bourgogne, St. Angel, St. Felicien, and Explorateur. These cheeses are often referred to as "triple-crème" cheeses, known for their high fat content and creamy texture.

A Healthier Alternative to Brie

If you're looking for a healthier alternative to Brie, Sweet Grass Dairy Green Hill is an excellent option. It's an award-winning American Brie-style cheese made from pasture-fed Jersey cow's milk. It's silky, creamy, and has delightful notes of buttered popcorn.

Frequently asked questions