Colby Cheese Or Cheddar: Which Has Less Grease?

Cheddar and Colby are two popular varieties of cheese that are often confused for one another due to their similar appearance. While both cheeses are semi-hard and yellow in colour, they differ in terms of taste, texture, and origin. This article will explore the differences between the two cheeses and answer the question: which has less grease, Colby or Cheddar?

Colby Cheese vs Cheddar Cheese

Explore related products

365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Low Fat Cottage Cheese, 16 oz

$4.29

Good Culture Organic 2% Low Fat Classic Cottage Cheese, 5 Oz

$2.39

365 By Whole Foods Market, Cheddar Mild Reduced Fat Sliced, 8 Ounce

$3.69

Horizon Organic American Cheese Slices, 8 oz. Pack, 12 Slices

$6.29

Farmers Market, Gluten Free, Keto, Paleo, Low Sodium, Zero Sugar, Wisconsin Cheese, 1-Pack, Vermont Extra Sharp Cheddar

$11.99

Organic Valley Organic Cream Cheese Spread

$4.29

Taste

Colby and Cheddar cheese differ in taste, texture, and history. While both cheeses are semi-hard, firm, and often orange, they come from different places and use distinct techniques.

Colby cheese is a semi-hard cheese made from cow's milk. It is named after the city of Colby, Wisconsin, USA, where it was first developed in 1885 and quickly became popular. It has a fat content of ~31–32% and a moisture content of 40%. It is made with pasteurized milk and has a short aging process. It is typically consumed within three months. It is popular among US citizens and is used in snacks, sandwiches, and salads. It can also be grated and combined with other cheeses for use on pizza.

Colby has a mild buttery and slightly sweet flavor. It also has a mild, tangy aftertaste and is known for being creamier than cheddar. It has a smooth, open texture with small holes called "eyes" throughout the cheese. This texture is due to the way the cheese is made as it doesn't follow the signature "cheddaring" process of cheddar cheese. Instead, Colby cheese is made by washing the curds with warm or cold water, which removes some lactose and reduces acidity, resulting in a milder, slightly sweet flavor. It is then gently stirred and kept moist, which preserves its softer texture and creamy consistency.

Cheddar cheese, on the other hand, is a semi-hard cheese made from cow, goat, sheep, or buffalo milk that is typically raw, pasteurized, or thermized. It originated in the village of Cheddar in Somerset, England, and has been produced since at least the 12th century. It has a fat content of at least 50% fat and a moisture content of 40%. Cheddar's texture can be described as "varies (rubbery to friable and crystalline)". It has a more pronounced, sharper flavor that intensifies with aging. It ranges from mild to extra sharp, with aging times extending from a few months to several years. The aging process deepens the flavor and gives the cheese a crumbly texture.

Cheddar cheese goes through the unique "cheddaring" process, which further acidifies the curds and draws more whey out, resulting in its dense texture and flavor differences. After the cheddaring process, the curds are salted, milled, and pressed into molds to form wheels or blocks. The cheese is then aged, and the length of aging produces a range of flavors, from mild to earthy.

Texture

While Colby and Cheddar cheeses may look similar, they differ in texture. Cheddar is a semi-hard cheese with a firm texture that ranges from rubbery to friable and crystalline. Its texture becomes crumbly as it ages. On the other hand, Colby is a semi-hard cheese with a softer, moister, and milder texture. It has a slightly elastic texture with a creamy, mild flavour.

Colby cheese is made with a "washed-curd" process, where the curds are washed with cold water, reducing the acidity of the curd and resulting in a milder, sweeter, and less sharp flavour. This process also gives Colby its softer and more open texture. The curds are then gently stirred and kept moist, preserving the soft texture and creamy consistency. The cheese is then pressed into moulds, which further contributes to its softer texture.

In contrast, Cheddar cheese undergoes a unique process known as "cheddaring". After milk is heated and cultures are added, rennet is introduced to form curds. The curds are then cut, heated, and stacked to release and drain the whey. This process gives Cheddar its dense texture and contributes to its sharper flavour. The curds are then salted, milled, and pressed into moulds, which affects the final texture of the cheese.

The difference in texture between Colby and Cheddar is also due to their moisture content. Colby has a higher moisture content, which makes it creamier and more excellent for melting. However, this higher moisture content also leads to a weaker body, and Colby does not retain its quality for as long as Cheddar. It is typically recommended to be consumed within three months, as it can become extremely soft and develop a bitter taste after 100 days.

In terms of colour, both cheeses can range from white to deep orange. The orange hue is typically achieved by adding annatto, a natural colourant, and does not affect the taste. However, the colour can also be influenced by the type of milk used and the manufacturing process.

Origin

Colby and Cheddar cheese are similar in appearance, but their origins, flavours, and textures differ significantly. While Cheddar is an English cheese, Colby is an American cheese.

Cheddar cheese originated in the village of Cheddar in Somerset, England, and has been produced since at least the 12th century. The region's climate and rich grazing pastures made it ideal for dairy farming, and its limestone caves provided the perfect conditions for ageing cheese. Cheddar's popularity spread quickly across Britain and Europe, eventually making its way to North America with English settlers.

Colby cheese, on the other hand, is an American cheese that was first made in 1885 in Colby, Wisconsin, by a young cheesemaker named Joseph Steinwand. It is said that while experimenting with traditional cheesemaking methods, Steinwand tried washing the curds in cold water to reduce the acidity, creating a milder, sweeter, and softer cheese than Cheddar. The new cheese was named after the town of Colby, and soon became popular across the United States.

The difference in the production processes of these two cheeses is what sets them apart. Cheddar cheese undergoes a unique process known as "cheddaring", which involves further acidifying the curds and drawing out more whey, resulting in its dense texture and flavour. Colby cheese, on the other hand, skips the cheddaring step and instead washes the curds in cold water, reducing the acidity and leading to a milder, slightly sweet flavour and a softer, more open texture.

Explore related products

Farmers Market, Gluten Free, Keto, Paleo, Low Sodium, Zero Sugar, Wisconsin Cheese Gift Sets, 3-Pack, Garlic Herb White Cheddar

$19.99

Borden American Fat Free Singles Cheese 3/4 oz, 16 Slices - Pack of 4

$52.9

Farmers Market, Gluten Free, Keto, Paleo, Low Sodium, Zero Sugar, Wisconsin Cheese Gift Sets, 8 Count

$44.99

The Laughing Light Creamy Swiss Spreadable Cheese Wedges, 0.75 oz, 24 count

$25.99

365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Sliced Mild Cheddar Cheese, 6 Ounce

$4.99

Farmers Market, Gluten Free, Keto, Paleo, Low Sodium, Zero Sugar, Wisconsin Cheese Gift Sets, 3-Pack, Classic Italian Cheese Blend

$19.99

Manufacturing process

Colby and cheddar cheese differ in their manufacturing processes, which results in differences in their taste and texture. Here is a detailed overview of the manufacturing process for each:

Colby Cheese Manufacturing Process:

Colby cheese was created by altering one small step in the usual cheddar production process. The key difference lies in the omission of the "cheddaring" process, which is a unique step in making cheddar cheese. Instead of cheddaring, Colby cheese is made by partially draining the whey after the curd is cooked, and then adding cold water to decrease the mixture's temperature. This results in a moister, softer, and milder cheese.

The manufacturing process for Colby cheese includes the following steps:

• Milk is heated, and a starter culture is added.
• Rennet is added to help separate the curds from the whey.
• Instead of fully draining the whey, only about two-thirds of it is drained, and cold water is added to reduce the temperature.
• The mixture is washed with cold water for 15 minutes, and then fully drained.
• Salt is added to the curd.
• The curd is placed into molds and pressed.
• The cheese is then packaged and ripened for 2 to 3 months at a controlled temperature.

Cheddar Cheese Manufacturing Process:

Cheddar cheese has a more complex manufacturing process that includes the cheddaring step. Here is an overview of the process:

• Milk is heated, and a starter culture is added.
• Rennet is added to separate the curds from the whey.
• The curds are cut into pieces and heated to release more whey.
• The curds are then stacked and pressed to remove excess moisture.
• The curds are salted, milled, and pressed into molds.
• Cheddar cheese undergoes an extended aging process, ranging from a few months to several years, which deepens its flavour and texture.

Nutritional value

Cheddar cheese is a rich source of protein, calcium, and vitamins A and B12. However, it is also high in fat and sodium, with one ounce (28 grams) containing around 10 grams of fat and 180 to 190 milligrams of sodium. Cheddar is made from whole milk and is aged for a minimum of three months, contributing to its strong flavour. The longer ageing process also results in a denser texture compared to Colby cheese.

Colby cheese, on the other hand, is known for its milder taste and creamy texture. It is also a good source of protein and calcium, but it may have slightly more carbohydrates. It is moister, softer, and less dry than cheddar, with a higher moisture level that makes it excellent for melting. Colby is produced by washing the curds with warm water to remove lactose, resulting in a milder flavour. It is typically aged for a shorter period of one to three months.

In terms of nutritional value, both cheeses are quite similar. Cheddar may have slightly more calories, but both are high in protein and fat while being low in carbohydrates. According to one source, a serving of 100 grams of cheddar cheese contains 404 calories, 22.87 grams of protein, 33.31 grams of fat, 3.09 grams of carbohydrates, and zero grams of fibre and sugar. Another source provides values for a 132-gram serving, with 533.28 calories, 30.19 grams of protein, 43.97 grams of fat, 4.08 grams of carbohydrates, zero grams of fibre, and 0.63 grams of sugar.

Colby cheese, according to one source, has 112 calories per serving, with 24% coming from protein, 73% from fat, and 3% from carbohydrates. Another breakdown of Colby's nutritional content shows 39.5% water, 24.6% protein, 33.2% fat, 2.7% carbohydrates, and zero alcohol.

While both cheeses offer nutritional benefits, it is important to consume them in moderation due to their high-fat content. Excessive consumption of high-fat dairy products has been linked to potential health risks, particularly for heart and cardiovascular health. To enjoy cheddar or Colby cheese as part of a balanced diet, it is recommended to regulate portion sizes and opt for lower-fat or reduced-sodium versions when possible.

Frequently asked questions