
Pizza lovers are often curious about why their pizza cheese turns yellow when cooked. The answer lies in the type of cheese used, the cooking temperature, and the presence of oil or moisture. While some people prefer the familiar yellow pizza cheese, others opt for white cheese, which is commonly used in artisanal or brick oven pizzas. The yellow colour in cheese was historically an indicator of quality, stemming from higher levels of carotenoids in milk produced by grass-fed cows. Today, the colour of pizza cheese can vary depending on factors such as moisture content, fat content, and cooking temperature, all of which influence the melting and browning of the cheese.
Characteristics of Pizza Cheese Turning Yellow When Cooked
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Type of Cheese | Mozzarella, Gruyere, Fontina |
| Colour of Cheese | Yellow, White |
| Temperature | 420°F, 425°F-450°F, 475°F, 600°F |
| Bake Time | 7:30-8:00 minutes, 5:00 minutes, 8 minutes, 15 minutes |
| Cheese Characteristics | Oil content, melting point, stretchiness, taste, reheating |
| Browning | High temperatures, broiler setting, grill setting |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Pizza ovens cook at extreme temperatures, causing cheese to brown
- Using a broiler or grill setting can help brown cheese
- Cooking at a lower temperature can prevent cheese from browning
- Cooking at a high temperature can cause cheese to release orange grease
- Yellow cheese indicates higher quality, so some companies add colouring

Pizza ovens cook at extreme temperatures, causing cheese to brown
Pizza ovens cook at extremely high temperatures, which can cause cheese to brown. The high heat of a pizza oven is necessary for the oven spring and to produce the cornicione (egg shell crust). However, it is not the heat alone that browns the cheese. The type of cheese used also plays a significant role in how it cooks and whether it browns.
Mozzarella is a commonly used cheese on pizzas, and it comes in various forms, including whole milk, low-moisture, and fresh. The fat content and moisture level of the cheese can affect how it cooks and whether it browns. For example, low-moisture mozzarella is more prone to browning and burning than whole milk or fresh mozzarella.
Additionally, the quality of the cheese can impact its cooking characteristics. Older cheese may require different baking temperatures and times to avoid browning or burning. The processing and pack dates of the cheese should be regularly checked to ensure it is not over-ripened.
The heat of the oven and the cooking time can also affect how the cheese cooks. Cooking at a higher temperature for a shorter time may result in a pizza with a hard crust and caramelized cheese on top, while a lower temperature and longer cook time can produce a softer, chewier pizza with a more evenly melted cheese.
To prevent the cheese from browning, one can cook the crust and sauce first and then add the cheese and other toppings towards the end of the cooking process. Additionally, cooking at a lower temperature or using a different type of cheese with lower moisture content can help avoid browning.
Cheese Pizza: New York's Signature Slice
You may want to see also

Using a broiler or grill setting can help brown cheese
If you're looking for that perfect, golden-brown crust on your pizza, using a broiler or grill setting can be a game-changer. Here are some tips to achieve that desired colour:
First, let's talk about the broiler setting. This is a great option for getting your cheese to brown nicely. Simply turn on the broiler towards the end of your bake time. Place the rack as high as possible, so the top of your pizza gets hot enough to brown the cheese. Keep a close eye on it, as you don't want your cheese to go from golden to charred! You can also experiment with par-baking your pizza first and then finishing it off under the broiler to get that perfect crust.
If your oven has a grill setting, this too can give you those desirable brown cheese crusts. Turn on the grill setting and place the pizza close to the top element. The heat transfer in this case is by radiation, so don't be misled by the temperature; your pizza will still brown nicely.
Another trick is to use a combination of steel and stone. Preheat a thick Cordierite stone to a high temperature, and if you want to take it up a notch, get two stones – one for the pizza to sit on and another to place above the pizza for that extra boost of heat from the top.
If you're feeling adventurous, try using a gas torch on your pizza after removing it from the oven. This will give you that browned cheese effect, but be careful not to overdo it!
So, the next time you're making pizza, don't be afraid to experiment with these techniques to achieve that perfect, golden-brown cheese crust!
Cheese Pizza Halal Status: Pizza Pizza Edition
You may want to see also

Cooking at a lower temperature can prevent cheese from browning
Cooking pizza at a lower temperature can prevent the cheese from browning. While pizza ovens can reach temperatures of 425°F to 600°F, cooking pizza at home at such high temperatures can result in burnt cheese. To avoid this, it is recommended to cook the pizza at a lower temperature for a longer period.
For example, one source suggests cooking pizza at 240°C to achieve nice patchy browning in a thicker-style pizza. Another source recommends cooking at 350°F for pizzas with various toppings, as higher temperatures would shorten the baking time too much to cook the toppings thoroughly.
Additionally, it is suggested to cook the crust and sauce first and then add the cheese and other toppings towards the end of the cooking process. This way, the crust and toppings are cooked properly without burning the cheese.
The type of cheese used also plays a role in browning. For instance, low-moisture cheeses tend to brown and burn faster than whole milk cheeses. Therefore, choosing a cheese with a higher moisture content can help prevent browning.
Furthermore, the amount of oil in the cheese can impact browning. Cooking at high temperatures can cause the cheese's proteins to seize, pressing out the oil and resulting in orange grease. By cooking at a lower temperature, the cheese's oil is retained, inhibiting the browning process.
Vegan Options at Pizza Studio: Does it Include Cheese?
You may want to see also
Explore related products

Cooking at a high temperature can cause cheese to release orange grease
The browning of pizza cheese is a common issue that pizza makers face. While some people like the browning on the cheese, others prefer it to be just melted. The browning of pizza cheese is caused by cooking at a high temperature, which can cause the cheese to release orange grease. This can be prevented by cooking at a lower temperature or by using a different type of cheese.
Cooking pizza at a high temperature can cause the cheese to release orange grease, which can affect the appearance and taste of the pizza. This is because the proteins in the cheese seize up, pressing the oil out. This is more likely to happen with whole milk mozzarella, which has a higher fat content than part-skim mozzarella. To prevent this from happening, it is recommended to cook pizza at a lower temperature for a longer period of time. This will allow the pizza to cook thoroughly without burning or releasing excess grease.
The type of cheese used can also affect the amount of grease released. For example, older cheese may need to be handled differently, with slower baking temperatures and times. The processing and pack dates of the cheese should be checked regularly to ensure that it is not over-ripened, as this can affect its melting point and how it releases oil. Different types of cheese have different melting points and grease release rates, so experimenting with different cheeses can help to find the one that works best for your pizza.
Additionally, the moisture content of the cheese can impact how it cooks. Low-moisture cheeses, such as low-moisture mozzarella, are more prone to browning and burning than fresh mozzarella, which has a higher moisture content. Using a cheese with the perfect amount of moisture and fat will allow the amino acids to do their job and give the desired melt. Cooking methods and equipment can also play a role in how the cheese cooks. For example, cooking pizza in a pan or on a screen can affect the cooking time and the amount of grease released.
To prevent the cheese from browning or burning, it is recommended to cook the crust and sauce first and then add the cheese and other toppings towards the end of the cooking process. This will allow the cheese to melt without burning. Additionally, cooking the pizza at a lower temperature and then finishing it with a blast of high heat can help to achieve the desired melt without burning.
Cheese Sticks Galore: Double the Order, Double the Fun!
You may want to see also

Yellow cheese indicates higher quality, so some companies add colouring
The colour of cheese on pizza is influenced by a variety of factors, including the type of cheese, temperature, and cooking time. One notable observation is that pizza cheese often turns yellow or orange during the cooking process. While this colour change may be expected and even desirable in some cases, it is intriguing to explore the underlying reasons.
One factor that contributes to the yellowing of pizza cheese is the presence of colouring agents. Historically, before food regulations were established, cheese makers would add colouring to their cheese to make it appear more yellow. This practice was driven by the perception that yellow cheese indicated higher quality. The reasoning behind this belief was that cows that grazed on abundant grass produced milk with higher levels of carotenoids, resulting in a yellow hue. By extension, cheese made from this milk would also exhibit a yellow colour.
Today, despite regulations, some companies continue to add colouring to their cheese. This practice is influenced by consumer expectations, as people have become accustomed to certain cheeses being yellow. As a result, companies may add colouring to their cheese to maintain consistency and meet customer preferences.
It is worth noting that the cooking temperature and time can also impact the colour of pizza cheese. Cooking pizza at extremely high temperatures or for extended periods can cause the cheese to brown or even burn. Additionally, the type of cheese used, such as whole milk or low-moisture mozzarella, will affect how it melts, stretches, and browns during cooking.
In summary, the yellowing of pizza cheese can be attributed to a combination of factors, including the addition of colouring agents, consumer expectations, cooking temperatures, and the specific type of cheese used. Each of these factors plays a role in determining the final appearance and quality of the pizza.
Hot Pocket Mystery: Are Four Cheese Pizzas Vegetarian?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
Pizza cheese, usually mozzarella, turns yellow when cooked due to the heat. The cheese may also release orange grease, which is more likely to happen when the pizza is cooked at a high temperature.
The release of orange grease is likely due to the cheese oiling out. This can happen when cooking at a high temperature, causing the proteins to seize and press out the oil.
To prevent pizza cheese from turning yellow, cook the pizza at a lower temperature. You can also try using a different type of cheese that is less prone to browning, such as Gruyere or Fontina.

























