The Perfect Cheese For A Club Sandwich

The club sandwich is a sacred sandwich. But what cheese goes on it? There is much debate about the ingredients of a traditional club sandwich, and while some people argue that there should be no cheese on a classic club, others suggest that Cheddar, Colby Jack, Swiss, or American cheese are all suitable options. One source even suggests that Pepper Jack, Provolone, or Mozzarella are acceptable alternatives. So, while there may be no definitive answer, it seems that a range of cheeses could work on a club sandwich, depending on your preference.

Cheddar cheese is a popular choice

Cheddar cheese is a great option for a club sandwich as it has a strong and sharp flavour that pairs well with the other ingredients. It also has a firm texture, which adds a nice contrast to the softness of the bread and the other fillings.

When making a club sandwich with cheddar cheese, it is important to consider the quality and freshness of the ingredients. The bread should be toasted but not too dry, and the lettuce and tomatoes should be crisp and fresh. The cheddar cheese should be sliced thinly so that it melts easily and creates a nice, creamy texture when combined with the mayonnaise.

To assemble the sandwich, spread mayonnaise on one side of each slice of bread. Layer the turkey, tomato slices, and cheddar cheese on one slice of bread. Place another slice of bread on top, mayonnaise side up, and layer with ham, bacon, and lettuce. Finally, top with the last slice of bread, mayonnaise side down, and secure the sandwich with toothpicks.

The club sandwich is a classic for a reason, and the addition of cheddar cheese only enhances its flavour and appeal. It is a hearty and satisfying sandwich that is perfect for a quick lunch or a casual dinner.

Swiss cheese is also a common option

When constructing a club sandwich with Swiss cheese, it's important to consider the order of the layers. A classic approach is to start with Swiss cheese, followed by thinly sliced turkey, tomato, lettuce, and bacon. This combination creates a balance of flavours and textures that complement each other. The Swiss cheese adds a creamy texture and a subtle tang that enhances the overall taste experience.

Swiss cheese also has the advantage of melting well, which can be utilised in a club sandwich. By placing the Swiss cheese near a warm ingredient, such as freshly cooked bacon, it can become slightly melted, adding a delightful gooeyness to the sandwich. This can be especially appealing to those who enjoy their sandwiches warm or toasted.

Additionally, Swiss cheese is known for its versatility and ability to pair well with a variety of other cheeses. For those who enjoy a more complex flavour profile, combining Swiss cheese with other cheese varieties such as cheddar or Colby Jack can create an intriguing blend of tastes and textures. This combination can elevate the club sandwich experience, making it even more indulgent and satisfying.

When selecting Swiss cheese for a club sandwich, it's important to choose a high-quality variety. Look for Swiss cheese that is smooth, creamy, and has a slightly sweet and nutty aroma. Avoid Swiss cheese that appears dry or cracked, as this may indicate that it has dried out or is past its prime.

You can use Colby Jack cheese

When assembling your club sandwich, spread mayonnaise on one side of a slice of toasted bread. You can add lettuce and tomato to this first slice, and season the tomatoes with salt and pepper if desired. Place a second slice of bread, mayo side down, on top of the first slice. Then, start stacking your layers of meat and Colby Jack cheese. Finally, top with a third slice of bread, mayo side down, and secure the sandwich with toothpicks.

Using Colby Jack cheese in your club sandwich can add a nice creamy texture and a subtle tanginess that complements the other flavours in the sandwich. It's a versatile cheese that melts easily and won't overwhelm the other ingredients.

You can also get creative and experiment with different types of Colby Jack cheese. For example, you could try a Colby Jack cheese with jalapenos for a spicy kick, or a smoked variety for a more intense flavour. Additionally, feel free to adjust the amount of cheese to your preference. If you're a cheese lover, you might want to add an extra slice or two of Colby Jack to your club sandwich.

So, if you're looking for a delicious and versatile cheese option for your club sandwich, Colby Jack is an excellent choice. It adds a nice creamy texture, melts well, and its mild flavour pairs perfectly with the other ingredients in this classic sandwich.

Monterey Jack cheese is another alternative

A club sandwich is a classic, and there are many ways to make it your own. While some people prefer to stick to the traditional club sandwich, others like to experiment with different ingredients.

A classic club sandwich is made with three slices of toasted bread, with one slice used as a separator in the middle. It is typically made with sliced cooked turkey, ham or fried bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise. However, you can switch up the ingredients to suit your preference. For example, you can use different types of bread such as whole grain, white, sourdough, rye, or pumpernickel. You can also add extra ingredients such as thin-sliced red onion, avocado, or arugula.

If you're looking for a cheese to add to your club sandwich, Monterey Jack cheese is another alternative. Monterey Jack is a semi-hard cheese with a creamy texture and a mild flavour. It is an excellent melting cheese, which makes it a perfect choice for a grilled club sandwich. The mild flavour of Monterey Jack also means it won't overpower the other ingredients in the sandwich.

When assembling your club sandwich, spread mayonnaise on one side of a slice of toast. Then, add a layer of Monterey Jack cheese, followed by ham, sliced tomato, and lettuce. You can season the tomatoes with salt and pepper, if desired. Place another slice of toast on top, with the mayonnaise side facing down. Add more mayonnaise to this slice, and then stack your layers of meat and cheese. Finally, top it off with the last slice of bread, with the mayonnaise side facing down.

To add an extra kick to your club sandwich, try using Pepper Jack cheese instead of plain Monterey Jack. Pepper Jack cheese has a similar creamy texture but includes spicy peppers for an added kick of heat. This can be a great way to add some extra flavour to your sandwich.

So, if you're looking for a new twist on the classic club sandwich, consider using Monterey Jack cheese. It's a mild, melting cheese that will complement the other ingredients perfectly. Get creative and make your ultimate club sandwich!

American cheese is a further option

American cheese is a good option for those who like a more subtle cheese flavour, as it will complement the other ingredients without being too dominant. It is also a good choice if you are making a larger batch of club sandwiches, as it is a popular and well-known variety that will likely appeal to a wide range of people.

When choosing American cheese for your club sandwich, look for a good quality variety that is sliced to the perfect thickness for your sandwich. You want the cheese to be thick enough to provide a good amount of flavour and texture, but not so thick that it overpowers the other ingredients or makes the sandwich difficult to eat.

To assemble your club sandwich with American cheese, start by toasting your bread of choice. You can use white, whole wheat, sourdough, rye, or any other variety that you prefer. Spread a layer of mayonnaise on one side of each slice of toast, and then begin stacking your ingredients. A classic club sandwich typically includes layers of meat, such as turkey, ham, or bacon, as well as lettuce, tomato, and cheese.

For a club sandwich with American cheese, you can layer the meat and cheese together, or create separate layers for each. For example, you could stack turkey, tomato, and American cheese on one layer, and then add a slice of toast, followed by ham, bacon, lettuce, and another slice of American cheese. This will create a delicious combination of flavours and textures.

Finally, top it off with the last slice of toast, spread with mayonnaise, and secure the sandwich with toothpicks or cocktail sticks. Cut the sandwich into triangles or quarters, and serve with your favourite sides, such as potato chips, French fries, or a pickle spear. Enjoy your club sandwich with American cheese!

Frequently asked questions