Wine And Cheddar: The Perfect Pairing Guide

Wine and cheese is a classic combination that has evolved from a simple pleasure to a culinary culture. While it may seem daunting to choose the right pairing, there are some tried-and-true principles to guide your selection. The ideal wine pairing for cheddar depends on how mature the cheese is. A mild to medium block cheddar will be much easier to match than an aged clothbound cheddar that’s been ageing for 18 months or more. In this article, we will explore some of the best wine varieties to pair with cheddar cheese.

Cabernet Sauvignon and aged cheddar

Cabernet Sauvignon is one of the most well-known red wine varieties, with bold fruit flavours like black cherry and blackcurrant, as well as robust tannins. When it comes to selecting a cheese to pair with this wine, you'll want to choose a strong, salty, and firm cheese. This is where aged cheddar comes in.

Aged cheddars have a sharpness and saltiness that develops with time, along with a crumbly texture that provides a nice contrast to the wine. The full body of the Cabernet Sauvignon helps to enhance the bold flavour profile of the aged cheddar. The wine's mouth-drying tannins are balanced by the fattiness of the cheese, resulting in a delightful sensory experience.

When selecting a Cabernet Sauvignon to pair with aged cheddar, look for one with subtle hints of dark fruits and herbs. These flavours will complement the strong characteristics of the cheese. Additionally, wines with a bit of bottle age tend to work better than younger ones, as the tannins can be a bit overpowering in a young wine.

For a unique twist, consider trying a Shiraz or Syrah with your aged cheddar. The tobacco notes in these wines can add an intriguing depth of flavour to the pairing. The charcoal cheddar, in particular, is a great match for Shiraz due to its smoky and earthy flavours.

When creating a wine and cheese pairing, it's important to remember that the wine and cheese should complement each other, with neither one overpowering the other. The combination of Cabernet Sauvignon and aged cheddar achieves this balance beautifully, making it a classic and popular pairing for wine and cheese enthusiasts to enjoy.

Chardonnay and mild cheddar

Chardonnay is a versatile wine that can be clean, crisp, and light-bodied, or oaky, rich, and full-bodied. When pairing Chardonnay with cheese, it's important to consider the wine's oak content. For a mild cheddar, a crisp, high-acid unoaked Chardonnay is the perfect pairing. The acidity of the wine cuts through the richness of the cheese, making it less overwhelming on the palate. The creamy texture of the mild cheddar also blends well with the fruity undertones of the Chardonnay, creating a harmonious and balanced taste.

The buttery flavour of mild cheddar complements the fruity notes of the Chardonnay, resulting in a delightful contrast of flavours. The sweetness of the cheese accentuates the crisp acidity of the wine, while the mildness of the cheese allows the fruitiness of the Chardonnay to shine through. This pairing is ideal for an afternoon snack or a pre-dinner appetiser, as it is refreshing and pleasant on the palate.

When selecting a Chardonnay to pair with mild cheddar, look for unoaked or lightly oaked options. The crisp, high-acid nature of unoaked Chardonnay will enhance the mild cheddar's flavour without overwhelming it. Alternatively, a lightly oaked Chardonnay can add a touch of richness and depth to the pairing, creating a more complex flavour profile.

It's worth noting that Chardonnay also pairs well with other semi-hard cheeses such as Colby Jack, Havarti, and even a buttery cheddar with more depth of flavour. The versatility of Chardonnay allows it to complement a range of cheese options, making it a great choice for cheese platters or snacking.

For a slightly more intense flavour experience, consider pairing an oaked Chardonnay with a sharp cheddar. The oak ageing process adds depth and complexity to the wine, enhancing its ability to stand up to the bold and sophisticated flavours of sharp cheddar. This pairing brings out the fruitiness of the wine and the mellowness of the cheese, creating a delightful contrast that showcases the best of both the wine and the cheese.

Merlot and garlic herb cheddar

The perfect wine and cheese pairing depends on the type of cheese and its maturity. A mild to medium block cheddar is much easier to match than an aged clothbound cheddar that's been ageing for 18 months or more. Aged cheddars are saltier, sharper, and crumbly, making them the perfect pairing for wine.

Merlot is a versatile red wine that goes well with various types of cheese, including Garlic Herb Cheddar. The wine is known for its dry fruitiness, which makes it a great match for sharp or tangy cheeses. The rich and bold flavour of the Garlic Herb Cheddar enhances the complex notes of the Merlot, creating a harmonious balance of flavours. The sharpness of the cheese, along with the garlic and herb flavours, adds an extra layer of flavour that complements the fruitiness of the Merlot. The soft tannins in Merlot also help to cut through the fat in the cheese, making the pairing pleasant on the palate.

When creating a wine and cheese pairing, it is important to consider the texture and flavour profiles of both components. Fresh, lighter cheeses pair well with crisp, lighter wines, while heavier, denser cheeses are better suited for bigger and bolder wines. Additionally, tasting the wine before the cheese can enhance the overall experience.

For those who enjoy exploring different wine and cheese combinations, experimenting with other semi-hard, aged cheeses with higher fat content can lead to exciting discoveries. The goal is to find a cheese that complements the wine without overpowering it and vice versa.

In conclusion, the pairing of Merlot and Garlic Herb Cheddar cheese is an excellent choice for wine and cheese enthusiasts seeking a delightful and memorable flavour combination.

Shiraz and smoked cheddar

When it comes to wine and cheese, the general rule is that the wine should complement the cheese without overpowering it, and vice versa. The acidity and tannins in wine cut through the fat in cheese, making for a delicious and balanced pairing.

A Shiraz wine is a bold, full-bodied wine with a high alcohol content and intense flavours. It is a good match for smoked cheddar, a semi-hard cheese with a strong flavour and a crumbly texture. The boldness of the Shiraz will complement the smokiness of the cheese, creating a harmonious flavour profile. The wine's high alcohol content will also help to accentuate the cheese's rich, artisanal flavour.

When pairing Shiraz with smoked cheddar, it is important to consider the strength and quality of the cheese. A mild to medium-strength smoked cheddar will pair better with a Shiraz than a sharp or extra-aged cheddar, as the intense flavours of the cheese could overpower the wine. Additionally, allowing the smoked cheddar to mature for a couple of weeks before consumption will result in a more mellow smoke flavour that will complement the Shiraz better.

To enhance the experience, consider serving the smoked cheddar at room temperature, as this will allow its full range of flavours to come through. Accompanying the cheese with crackers or bread can also provide a textural contrast and showcase the smoothness of the Shiraz.

Overall, the combination of Shiraz and smoked cheddar is a delightful pairing that showcases the magic of matching wine and cheese. The bold flavours of both elements will create a memorable sensory experience, making it a perfect choice for wine and cheese enthusiasts.

Pinot Noir and Vermont sharp cheddar

If you love the boldness of Vermont sharp cheddar, consider pairing it with a wine with earthy notes like Pinot Noir. Cheddar lovers enjoy pairing Vermont cheddar with sweet and tart fruits like apples and pears, softening it in dips and sauces, or making it the centrepiece of a fabulous cheese and crackers platter.

Pinot Noir is a light to medium-bodied red wine with dry characteristics and ripe red fruit flavours. It is usually a good choice for pairing with both cheese and charcuterie. Its earthy and strawberry flavours make it a good match for a nutty, medium-firm cheese like Gruyere.

When pairing wine and cheese, it is important to consider the maturity of the cheese. A mild to medium block cheddar will be much easier to match than an aged clothbound cheddar that has been ageing for 18 months or more. The best wine to pair with cheddar depends on how mature it is.

Pinot Noir's ripe red fruit flavours complement the boldness of Vermont sharp cheddar. The dryness of the wine also helps to balance the sharpness of the cheese. The earthiness of the wine is a good match for the nuttiness of the cheese.

For a successful pairing, it is also important to taste the wine before the cheese for the optimum effect. Like some wines, many cheeses taste better at room temperature instead of being served straight from the fridge.

Frequently asked questions