Juicy Lucy: The Perfect Cheese Filling

The Juicy Lucy is a Minnesota classic, a unique burger with molten cheese inside its beef patty. The best cheese for a Juicy Lucy is one that will create an extra gooey and melty centre. While some people prefer blue cheese, pepper jack, or gouda, American cheese is the classic choice for its soft, smooth texture and ability to melt almost entirely.

American cheese is the best for a smooth melt

When it comes to creating the perfect Juicy Lucy, a smooth melt is essential. While there are many types of cheese that can be used, American cheese stands out as the best option for achieving this desired consistency.

American cheese is renowned for its soft and smooth texture, making it ideal for a Juicy Lucy. Its melting properties are superior to other varieties, transforming into a liquid-like state when heated. This characteristic is crucial for the signature oozing effect that defines a well-crafted Juicy Lucy. The cheese should be extra gooey and melty, and American cheese delivers on this front.

The traditional Juicy Lucy, as purportedly invented by Matt's Bar in Minneapolis, is filled with American cheese. This classic version has earned its reputation for a reason, and American cheese is central to its success. While other cheeses can be used, they may not provide the same level of meltability and flavour.

American cheese also offers versatility in its preparation. It can be purchased pre-sliced or shredded, or for an even smoother melt, one can take the extra step of making their own "American" cheese using sodium citrate. This homemade version guarantees an exceptionally creamy texture and enhances the flavour of the burger's cheesy core.

Additionally, American cheese's mild flavour complements the beef without overwhelming the other ingredients. It strikes the perfect balance, allowing the savouriness of the meat and toppings to shine through while still delivering that indulgent, cheesy experience.

In conclusion, American cheese is the ideal choice for a Juicy Lucy due to its exceptional meltability, smooth texture, and versatility. It is a key component in achieving the signature oozing cheese and creamy mouthfeel that makes this burger a favourite among cheese lovers.

Blue cheese is a good alternative for a poignant flavour

A Juicy Lucy is a unique burger that features molten cheese held inside its beef patty. The cheese is the star of the burger, so getting the right kind is essential. You need a cheese that will be extra gooey and melty. While American cheese is the classic choice, blue cheese is a good alternative for a poignant flavour.

Blue cheese has a strong, pungent flavour that can add a tangy twist to your Juicy Lucy. It is often paired with minced garlic, as in the flagship Blucy at the Blue Door Pub in the Twin Cities. If you're looking for a cheesier option, you can even add extra cheese on top of your burger.

When selecting a cheese for a Juicy Lucy, consider the melt potential. Cheeses with higher fat and moisture content are more likely to lose their form when heated, resulting in a gooey, liquid-like centre. Younger cheeses also tend to melt better than older cheeses.

To make your Juicy Lucy, start by forming your ground beef into a patty. Place a slice of blue cheese in the centre, or use shredded cheese for easier melting. Fold the edges of the meat towards the centre to completely cover the cheese, forming a thick patty.

Cook your burger on a grill or stovetop over medium heat. The cooking time will depend on your desired doneness, but be aware that the cheese may not melt fully if you cook it for too short a time. Let the burger rest for a minute or two before serving to prevent the cheese from exploding out.

Now you know how to make a Juicy Lucy with blue cheese, you can enjoy a poignant flavour twist on this classic Minnesota burger.

Cheddar is not ideal for a juicy lucy as it doesn't melt well

Cheddar cheese is not the best option for a Juicy Lucy as it doesn't melt well, especially if it's well-aged. The ideal cheese for a Juicy Lucy should be extra gooey and melty, with a smooth texture.

A Juicy Lucy is a unique burger that features molten cheese held inside its beef patty. It is said to have originated in Minneapolis, Minnesota, with two restaurants, Matt's Bar and the 5-8 Club, claiming ownership. The burger is cooked in such a way that the cheese melts while the patty cooks, resulting in a melty, gooey, cheesy mouthful when bitten into.

To achieve this signature oozing cheese effect, the cheese used should have a high melt potential. This is determined by the moisture and fat content of the cheese, with higher values resulting in a better melt. Younger cheeses also tend to melt better than older cheeses.

Cheddar cheese, especially if it's well-aged, doesn't meet these criteria as effectively as other cheeses. It has a lower moisture and fat content, which makes it less likely to lose its form when heated. Therefore, it may not melt sufficiently within the cooking time of the burger patty, resulting in a less gooey and less juicy Juicy Lucy.

If one insists on using cheddar cheese for a Juicy Lucy, it is recommended to use shredded cheddar instead of a block of cheese. Shredded cheddar has a larger surface area, which can enhance melting. Additionally, shredding your own cheese from a block is preferable to using pre-shredded bagged cheese, as the latter is often coated with anti-caking agents that can hinder proper melting.

However, even with these adjustments, cheddar cheese may still not provide the desired meltiness compared to other cheese options. For a classic, authentic Juicy Lucy, American cheese is the top choice due to its soft, smooth texture and easy meltability. When melted, it becomes almost like liquid, oozing out of the beef patty with every bite. Other suitable options include Fontina, Gruyere, Emmental, and Gouda cheeses, which offer milder flavors and good melt potential.

Younger cheeses melt better than older cheeses

Juicy Lucys are cheeseburgers with molten cheese held inside their beef patties. The best kind of cheese for a Juicy Lucy is one that will be extra gooey and melty, like American cheese. This is because American cheese is soft and smooth, and when melted, it becomes almost like liquid.

Younger cheeses tend to melt more easily than older ones. This is because aged cheeses have less moisture, making them prone to clumping. However, the state of the protein—specifically, its network of casein protein—affects meltability the most. In freshly made cheeses, casein proteins are in tightly wound clusters, allowing for little interaction with one another. As cheese ages, it goes through a process called proteolysis, in which bonds between individual casein molecules are “snipped,” allowing the clusters to unwind and bind with other casein molecules, forming a matrix. Early in this process, the matrix is flexible, allowing young cheeses to melt smoothly. With time, the proteins bond together tighter, forming a stronger network that requires more heat to melt and is less flexible when melted. This can result in more separated fat and clumps, as seen in older cheeses.

Therefore, when making a Juicy Lucy, it is best to use a younger cheese, as it will melt more easily and create the desired gooey and liquid centre.

Shredded cheese melts better than sliced cheese

Juicy Lucys are stuffed with molten, bubbly, waterfalling cheese. To achieve this, the cheese must be extra gooey and melty. While some people prefer blue cheese, pepper jack, or cheddar, American cheese is the best option for a smooth melt. It is soft, easy to melt, and becomes almost liquid-like when heated.

Frequently asked questions