Wine And Sharp Cheddar: A Perfect Pairing Guide

Wine and cheese is a classic combination that has evolved from a simple pleasure to a culinary culture. The protein in cheese softens the tannins in wine, and the right combination can result in a harmonious medley of delicious flavours. When selecting a wine to pair with sharp cheddar cheese, it is important to consider the maturity of the cheese, as a mild cheddar will be easier to match than an aged, sharp cheddar. For instance, a mild cheddar pairs well with a Chardonnay, while an aged, sharp cheddar pairs well with a Cabernet Sauvignon, Shiraz, or Pinot Noir.

Cabernet Sauvignon and sharp cheddar

When it comes to pairing wine and cheese, it's important to consider the maturity of the cheese. A mild to medium block cheddar will be much easier to match than an aged clothbound cheddar that's been maturing for 18 months or more. The aging process brings out saltier, sharper, and crumbly characteristics in cheddar, making it the perfect pairing for a wine like Cabernet Sauvignon.

When pairing Cabernet Sauvignon with cheddar, opt for a semi-hard cheese with some age to it. These cheeses can help enhance the flavour of the wine while balancing out the tannins that can leave your mouth feeling dry. Aged and sharp cheddars have just the right amount of flavour and fat content to balance the tannins while bringing out the citrus notes in the wine.

While Cabernet Sauvignon is a great pairing for sharp cheddar, there are a few other wines that can also complement this cheese. Syrah/Shiraz with tobacco notes pairs well with smoked and aged cheddar, as the intense and dry flavours of the wine match the concentrated savoury flavours of the cheese. For a cheese like Vermont sharp cheddar, a wine with earthy notes like Pinot Noir is a good choice. The boldness of the cheese is complemented by the wine's earthy notes, creating a harmonious pairing.

Shiraz and smoked cheddar

The ideal wine to pair with cheddar depends on its maturity. A mild to medium block cheddar is easier to match than a well-aged, crumbly, and sharp cheddar.

Shiraz, with its tobacco notes, is a perfect wine varietal for smoked and aged cheddar cheese. The wine's tobacco notes are influenced by the oak barrels in which it is crafted. The resulting spicy complexity and tobacco-like flavours complement the smokiness of the aged cheddar.

Syrah, another name for Shiraz, is an ideal choice for its intense and dry flavours of herbs and dark fruits. The savoury, concentrated flavours of aged cheddar are balanced by the intense, dry flavours of Syrah.

When pairing wine with cheddar, it is important to consider the cheese's maturity and intensity of flavour. Aged cheddars are saltier, sharper, and crumbly, making them a perfect match for wines with intense flavours like Shiraz.

For a harmonious pairing, consider the balance of flavours and intensity. The bold, savoury flavours of aged cheddar require a wine that can complement and enhance its taste without being overwhelmed. Shiraz, with its tobacco notes and spicy complexity, is an excellent choice to create a delightful sensory experience.

Chardonnay and mild cheddar

Chardonnay is a versatile wine that can be clean, crisp, and light-bodied, or oaky, rich, and full-bodied. When selecting a cheese to pair with Chardonnay, consider the wine's oak content. For oaked Chardonnays, a sharp cheddar cheese is a great option, as the pairing brings out the fruitiness of the wine and the mellowness of the cheese. However, for this discussion, we will focus on Chardonnay and mild cheddar.

Chardonnay, a white wine with a crisp and fruity flavor, pairs exceptionally well with mild cheddar cheese. The acidity of the wine cuts through the richness of the cheese, making it less overwhelming on the palate. The creamy texture of mild cheddar blends harmoniously with the fruitiness of the Chardonnay, resulting in a balanced and delightful contrast of flavors. The sweetness of the cheese complements the crisp acidity of the wine, creating a refreshing taste experience. This pairing is perfect for an afternoon snack or a pre-dinner appetizer.

When selecting a Chardonnay to pair with mild cheddar, consider the oak content of the wine. Un-oaked Chardonnays, also known as naked or steel-fermented Chardonnays, tend to have a lighter, crisper style with bright fruit flavors and little to no oak influence. On the other hand, oaked Chardonnays are aged in oak barrels, which impart vanilla, spice, and butterscotch flavors to the wine. While oaked Chardonnays can still be crisp and fruity, they often have a richer, more full-bodied style.

For a mild cheddar and Chardonnay pairing, consider a crisp, unoaked Chardonnay to complement the mildness of the cheese. Look for Chardonnays from cooler climates, such as those from the Chablis region in France or the Old World styles from Australia and New Zealand. These Chardonnays tend to have higher acidity and more citrus and green apple flavors, which will refreshingly cut through the creamy texture of the mild cheddar.

Alternatively, if you prefer a bolder Chardonnay with more oak influence, look for Chardonnays from warmer regions, such as California, Chile, or South Africa. These Chardonnays will have more tropical fruit flavors like pineapple and mango, as well as notes of butter and vanilla from the oak aging. When paired with mild cheddar, the wine's richness will be balanced by the cheese's smooth, buttery flavor, resulting in a harmonious and nuanced taste experience.

In conclusion, Chardonnay and mild cheddar is an excellent pairing for those who appreciate a balanced and nuanced taste experience. The crisp, fruity flavors of the Chardonnay complement the creamy texture and mild flavor of the cheese, creating a delightful contrast. Whether you choose an unoaked or oaked Chardonnay, the combination of the wine's acidity and fruitiness with the cheese's sweetness and richness will surely please your palate.

Merlot and garlic herb cheddar

Garlic herb cheddar has a rich and bold flavour that complements the complex notes of Merlot. The sharpness of the cheese is enhanced by the wine, and the garlic and herb flavours add an extra layer of flavour that pairs well with the fruitiness of the Merlot. The herbal garlic flavours are more heavily emphasised due to the Merlot's dry fruitiness, creating a harmonious balance of flavours.

The best Merlot wines to pair with garlic herb cheddar come from the Bordeaux region in France and the Napa Valley in California. These wines have luscious black fruit aromas and underlying green herbaceous notes, making them a bold and confident choice for this pairing. The tannins present in Merlot also help to cut through the fat in the cheese, making the combination even more pleasing to the palate.

When creating a cheeseboard, it is important to consider the maturity of the cheese, as this will impact the best wine pairings. A mild to medium block cheddar will be much easier to match than an aged clothbound cheddar that has been maturing for 18 months or more. For a successful pairing, the wine should complement the cheese without overpowering it, and vice versa.

In addition to Merlot, other wine options that pair well with sharp cheddar cheese include Cabernet Sauvignon, Shiraz, and Pinot Noir. These wines have the intensity and dryness to stand up to the strong, sharp flavours of aged cheddar.

Moscato and pepper jack

Moscato is a sweet, light, and fruity wine, typically made from Muscat grapes. It has a lower alcohol content compared to other wines. The wine's sweetness can complement the spiciness of Pepper Jack cheese, as the sugar in the wine helps balance the heat in the cheese and enhances its creamy texture. The fruity notes of Moscato also bring out the flavours of the cheese, creating a harmonious pairing.

Pepper Jack cheese is a semi-soft, cow's milk cheese with an open texture and a spicy taste. This spicy kick comes from the addition of jalapeño peppers, which are studded throughout the cheese. It has a buttery flavour similar to Monterey Jack, but with added spice. Pepper Jack cheese is incredibly versatile and can be used in sandwiches, burgers, salads, and soups. Its bold flavour and adaptability make it a must-have ingredient for cooking and snacking.

When serving Moscato and Pepper Jack, consider adding some crackers or bread on the side. The crispness of crackers or the softness of bread can provide a textural contrast to the creamy cheese and the sweetness of the wine. Additionally, you can offer some fresh fruits, such as apples or pears, to complement the fruity notes in the Moscato.

Overall, the pairing of Moscato and Pepper Jack is a delightful combination that showcases the balance of sweet and spicy flavours. The wine's sweetness and fruity notes complement and enhance the cheese's spiciness, creating a unique and enjoyable sensory experience.

Frequently asked questions