The Mystery Of Disappearing Cheese: A Culinary Extinction

The idea of cheese going extinct may sound bizarre, but it's a very real possibility. In fact, some beloved French cheeses like Camembert, Brie, and blue cheese are already at risk of disappearing due to a decline in microbial diversity. This loss of microbial diversity is a result of the cheese industry's shift towards standardization and consistency, which has led to a loss of genetic diversity in the fungi strains used to make these cheeses. While this transition initially occurred in the 20th century, the effects are now being felt, with cheesemakers finding it increasingly difficult to produce these iconic cheeses.

Decline in microbial diversity

The microbial diversity of cheese is a complex and dynamic ecosystem, with a variety of biotic and abiotic factors influencing the development and succession of microbial populations. The cheese microbiota is composed of prokaryotic, eukaryotic, and viral populations, with lactic acid bacteria (LAB) being the most common and playing a crucial role in the manufacturing and ripening processes.

The microbial interactions within the cheese ecosystem are essential for the final composition and diversity of the cheese microbiota, as well as its functionality. These interactions include competition, amensalism, commensalism, and mutualism. For instance, some microbes produce siderophores to aid in the uptake of essential trace elements like iron and zinc, while others have molecular systems to "steal" these siderophores. Understanding these interactions is crucial for selecting starter species and improving cheese quality and safety.

The cheese-making process, milk type, manufacturing practices, ripening environment, duration of ripening, and the type and activity of microorganisms all influence the sensorial properties of cheese, such as texture and flavor. The microbial diversity and number of species present in ripened cheese can be vast, with bacteria, yeasts, and filamentous fungi all playing a role.

The dynamics of microbial communities in cheese are shaped by microbial interactions, which can have technological and sensorial implications. These interactions are influenced by both intrinsic and extrinsic factors, such as substrate availability, pH, redox potential, temperature, salt content, and relative humidity.

Overall, the microbial diversity and interactions within the cheese ecosystem are critical for the development, dynamics, and functionality of the cheese microbiota, ultimately influencing the unique characteristics and quality of each cheese variety.

Loss of unique aromas, colours and flavours

The potential extinction of cheeses like Camembert, Brie, and blue cheese is a concern for cheese lovers and the French. This is due to the decline of microbial diversity in the bacteria and fungi that play a crucial role in the cheese-making process.

Cheeses like Camembert, Brie, and blue cheese are at risk of disappearing due to a loss of microbial diversity. Specifically, the strains of fungi that impart their unique characteristics are in danger. Each strain of fungus used in cheesemaking contributes to the distinct aroma, colour, and flavour of the final product.

Historically, cheesemakers employed various strains of the fungus Penicillium biforme for Camembert. This resulted in each batch of cheese having its own unique characteristics. However, about a century ago, cheesemakers began exclusively using a specific albino strain known as Penicillium camemberti. This strain produced the perfect white rind desired by consumers and soon became the standard for Brie and Camembert production globally.

The shift towards using only Penicillium camemberti has led to a loss of genetic diversity in the fungi. This fungus is unable to reproduce sexually, so it must be cloned by cheesemakers. Over time, this process has caused mutations in the genome of the fungus, including the loss of its ability to produce asexual spores. As a result, the cheese industry is facing challenges in acquiring sufficient spores to inoculate their cheeses.

The loss of microbial diversity in the cheese-making process has led to a decrease in the variety of aromas, colours, and flavours that were once possible. While it is unlikely that cheese as a food group will disappear, the potential loss of specific cheeses like Camembert and Brie is a concern for those who appreciate their distinctive characteristics.

Inability to reproduce sexually

While it may seem odd to think of cheese going extinct, it is a real possibility, and one that has many people, especially the French, worried. This is because cheese is more than just a food in France; it is a cultural symbol and a core component of the country's culinary history.

One of the ways in which a cheese can go extinct is through the inability to reproduce sexually. For example, the fungus strain Penicillium camemberti, which is used to make Camembert and Brie cheeses, cannot reproduce sexually and must be cloned by cheesemakers. This process, however, eliminates genetic diversity in the fungus strain and has resulted in mutations, including the loss of its ability to produce asexual spores. Without these spores, the fungus strain supporting these culturally significant cheeses could disappear.

The decline of Penicillium camemberti can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, cheesemakers preferentially chose to use this strain due to its desirable taste and appearance, leading to its overuse and the disappearance of other strains such as Penicillium biforme. Secondly, in the 1950s, manufacturers began to opt for cloned strains of the fungus rather than naturally occurring ones, as they grew faster and produced a more uniform cheese. This further reduced the genetic diversity of the strain.

The loss of Penicillium camemberti would be a significant blow to the cheese industry, as it is a key ingredient in Camembert and Brie cheeses. These cheeses are beloved by many and hold cultural and historical value, especially in France. The potential extinction of these cheeses highlights the intricate balance between nature and human intervention in the food industry and serves as a reminder of the importance of preserving microbial diversity.

Mutations in the genome

The process of cheese-making involves the use of specific fungi, such as Penicillium camemberti and Penicillium roqueforti, which play a critical role in giving cheese its distinctive characteristics. However, over time, these fungi are losing their ability to reproduce naturally, and scientists are now growing them through asexual reproduction, which is more difficult and may have implications for the future of cheese production.

In the specific case of Camembert, the use of an albino strain of Penicillium camemberti, which produces the perfect white rind, has become standard among cheesemakers globally. This strain was isolated and selected for its desirable characteristics, but it is now losing some of its ability to reproduce naturally. This means that scientists are increasingly relying on asexual reproduction techniques to grow the fungus, which is a challenging process.

Additionally, the reliance on a single or a limited number of strains of an organism leaves them vulnerable to diseases or pathogens. If a disease emerges that the remaining strain is susceptible to, it could wipe out the entire population. This is a similar threat faced by other popular foods due to declining global biodiversity and the impacts of climate change.

To address these challenges, scientists have started working to restore some of the genetic diversity to the fungi used in cheese-making. This involves studying the genome sequences of these fungi and identifying ways to improve their adaptability and resistance to diseases. However, it is a complex process that requires a deep understanding of fungal biology and genetics.

Lack of genetic diversity

The French cheeses Camembert and Brie are reportedly "on the verge of extinction" due to a decline in the strains of fungi that give them their unique taste, smell, colour, and texture. This is due to a lack of genetic diversity in cheese cultures, specifically, the over-reliance on the asexual strains of fungi that give these cheeses their distinctive characteristics.

The fungi in question are called Penicillium camemberti and Penicillium roqueforti. They are used to make Camembert and blue cheeses, respectively. The problem is that these fungi populations have become increasingly less diverse. Some domesticated populations even consist of only a single clonal lineage. This is because the industry relied primarily on the asexual method, producing clonal lineages to perpetuate the moulds. As a result, they can no longer reproduce with other strains that could provide them with new genetic material. Over time, this induces the degeneration of the strain in question.

However, it is important to note that this does not mean that soft French cheeses made with these less-vigorous fungi strains will suddenly become "extinct". Other microflora can be used to make soft cheese, but the texture and flavour might be different from what is expected of these varieties of cheese.

Additionally, specialty cheesemakers are less likely to be affected by the lack of cheese culture diversity because they don't make cheese on an industrial scale. Experimental studies indicate that it might be possible to adapt wild Penicillium strains into strains appropriate for Camembert production.

Frequently asked questions